Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To let my 11yo sit in the front seat on a long motorway journey?

135 replies

Amarette · 07/10/2022 13:17

I have to take my DD on a long motorway journey this weekend. I have a one-year old car with excellent safety ratings for the passenger seat, with air bags etc. In fact, the safety ratings look like its safer to be in the front than the back, although they only seem to have tested child's car seats in the back so it's hard to compare.

Anyway, my friend said that she would never let her DC travel in the front seat on the motorway as its always safer for them to be in the back. Starting to question myself now as would never forgive myself if something happened to her and I had made a decision that contributed to it.

Curious what other people think? She is tall for an 11yo and an athlete so not a delicate child!

OP posts:
lanthanum · 07/10/2022 17:42

If you want to take the safety issue to extremes, going by rail is safer - I suspect by a larger margin than the difference between front and back seat.

Reallyreallyborednow · 07/10/2022 17:41

To those saying the front seat is more dangerous than the back.
What happens if the traffic sudddnly comes to a standstill and the HGV behind you fails to notice and slams straight through the back of your car? And your rear seats are crushed but the two front seats are still intact? This has happened before and rear seat passengers killed when the front ones survive.
The front seat is no more dangerous than the back.
You can never prepare for all eventualities

statistically, the back seat is safer. As with everything, like you say you can’t cover all eventualities. But in a crash, your child is more likely to survive in the rear seat.

you can put them in the front seat and hope that if you crash it’s the scenario you describe, but realistically that is less likely.

www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC2564455/

“On average, the risk of death was 21% lower among passengers in the rear seat compared with front seat passengers. This apparent protection varied with age, restraint use, and airbag presence. The rear seat seemed to offer the greatest protection to children 0–12 years”

JS87 · 07/10/2022 17:39

bingotime · 07/10/2022 17:30

Presumably it's based on statistics from accidents.

I think the statistics though might include head on collisions on single carriageway roads. The most dangerous crashes are usually head on crashes as some impatient knob one decides to overtake when it isn't safe to do so. The PP may be correct that on a motorway it isn't necessarily the back seats which are safer.

Amarette · 07/10/2022 17:39

ShoeTheDoor · 07/10/2022 16:43

Also I know you are saying she is an athlete so strong etc but have you watched a body get flung around a car in the ENCAP crash tests? Not even adults could brace for it.

I believe this is your car www.euroncap.com/en/results/toyota/c-hr/26309 click the video tab half way down the page. I have recently bought a new car hence all the ENCAP watching.

Yes that's the stats I looked at. Adult 95% safety rating in front seats, child 77% rating in back seats.

Car also has automatic braking so I would suspect there is more chance of a side or rear crash than front on.

OP posts:
Beginningless · 07/10/2022 17:33

I don’t know a lot about this but OP I would listen to @BertieBotts who has posted upthread and given me and many other posters lots of advice about car seats, she appears to have expertise.

bingotime · 07/10/2022 17:30

lisaJN1986 · 07/10/2022 17:27

To those saying the front seat is more dangerous than the back.
What happens if the traffic sudddnly comes to a standstill and the HGV behind you fails to notice and slams straight through the back of your car? And your rear seats are crushed but the two front seats are still intact? This has happened before and rear seat passengers killed when the front ones survive.
The front seat is no more dangerous than the back.
You can never prepare for all eventualities.
Let your child travel in the front if you want to OP.

Presumably it's based on statistics from accidents.

lisaJN1986 · 07/10/2022 17:27

To those saying the front seat is more dangerous than the back.
What happens if the traffic sudddnly comes to a standstill and the HGV behind you fails to notice and slams straight through the back of your car? And your rear seats are crushed but the two front seats are still intact? This has happened before and rear seat passengers killed when the front ones survive.
The front seat is no more dangerous than the back.
You can never prepare for all eventualities.
Let your child travel in the front if you want to OP.

AWOL66 · 07/10/2022 17:22

RewildingAmbridge · 07/10/2022 13:22

How tall is she? My mum is 5'1 I wouldn't make her sit in the back

🤣Imagine if you did!😂

Bunnycat101 · 07/10/2022 17:22

I’m also interested in the airbag question. I’ve never been 100% sure if the airbag should be on or off with a forward facing car seat in the car. It’s not something that happens very often- mainly just lifts to parties and the like

Clymene · 07/10/2022 17:20

Yes of course you do @TheOrigRights but I'm just a bit bemused that car safety seems to be less of a priority for children once they're out of car seats.

There are lots of things that children want to do that they don't get to make the decisions on because they're children. This is just another one of those being a boring parent things as far as I'm concerned.

bloodywhitecat · 07/10/2022 17:19

This reply has been deleted

Post withdrawn at author's request

If it was there wouldn't be cars with front seat isofix, my SEAT can have an isofix seat on the front passenger seat.

TattiePants · 07/10/2022 17:17

My DD was 5ft 6 when she turned 11 and taller than many adults. Of course it’s ok.

CoveredInCobwebs · 07/10/2022 16:52

I’m also interested in the answer to the airbag question. My 8yo quite often goes in the front but I haven’t been turning off the airbag, now wondering if I should?

ShoeTheDoor · 07/10/2022 16:43

Also I know you are saying she is an athlete so strong etc but have you watched a body get flung around a car in the ENCAP crash tests? Not even adults could brace for it.

I believe this is your car www.euroncap.com/en/results/toyota/c-hr/26309 click the video tab half way down the page. I have recently bought a new car hence all the ENCAP watching.

ShoeTheDoor · 07/10/2022 16:40

"According to The Royal Society for the Prevention of Accidents (RoSPA), ‘If the middle rear seat has a three-point (lap and diagonal) seat belt, this is the safest place to put a child restraint (unless the manufacturer’s instructions say it fits better in one of the other seats) because it is the furthest away from the sides of the car."

I think I overthink things anyway as I watch a lot of car dash cam videos on YouTube. The motorway ones are terrifying.

TheOrigRights · 07/10/2022 16:37

Clymene · 07/10/2022 16:29

@TheOrigRights - what an odd response. Pretty much everyone puts their babies and young children in rear facing car seats nowadays because they're safer. When my teens were young, they were a rarity.

I prefer my children to be as safe as possible, no matter what their age.

Well, yes I was being slightly facetious, but my point is that you risk injury just getting in the car in the first place. You're implying that people who put their 11 year in the front have lost sight of their safety ("safety goes out the window when they're older").

TokyoSushi · 07/10/2022 16:32

Gosh, it wouldn't even occur to me to have similar age DS in the back if it was just to two of us!

Clymene · 07/10/2022 16:31

Amarette · 07/10/2022 15:02

As I said she's an athlete so muscular and strong. Probably stronger than a lot of adult women.

Car is a Toyota ChR Hybrid. I looked up the safety stays and unless I'm reading it wrong the front seats are safer than the back.

The centre of the back seat is the safest place to sit in any car.

Magenta82 · 07/10/2022 16:29

BringOnAutumn · 07/10/2022 16:23

What is the actual safe height for an airbag, though? I don’t think I've seen an answer for this. The other height examples don’t seem to say when the airbag is safe for.

From what I understand it is several inches taller than me! They were designed for an average man and so, along with seat belts and the seats themselves, are often a danger to women, especially short ones.

Clymene · 07/10/2022 16:29

@TheOrigRights - what an odd response. Pretty much everyone puts their babies and young children in rear facing car seats nowadays because they're safer. When my teens were young, they were a rarity.

I prefer my children to be as safe as possible, no matter what their age.

BringOnAutumn · 07/10/2022 16:23

What is the actual safe height for an airbag, though? I don’t think I've seen an answer for this. The other height examples don’t seem to say when the airbag is safe for.

dementedpixie · 07/10/2022 15:47

fleurdelee · 07/10/2022 15:46

Is it?
I didn't know this

No its not illegal for an under 12 to sit in the front seat

fleurdelee · 07/10/2022 15:46

This reply has been deleted

Post withdrawn at author's request

Is it?
I didn't know this

FrodisCapering · 07/10/2022 15:45

This reply has been withdrawn

Post withdrawn at author's request

TheOrigRights · 07/10/2022 15:21

DotDotaDash · 07/10/2022 13:33

😂

I have offered my tall as me 12 year old to sit in the front but he is worried that he’d end up involved in having to chat and look at the world out the windows and far prefers to play games on his phone in the back 🙁

So if she wanted to and was tall enough then I would let her. Any statistical safety difference is surely marginal and not a prediction for your specific journey circumstances.

Grin Same! My 13 yo now often chooses to sit in the back so he can use his AirPods and not engage with me. Suits me - I can listen to The Top 100 Power Ballads Ever the radio.