Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To let my 11yo sit in the front seat on a long motorway journey?

135 replies

Amarette · 07/10/2022 13:17

I have to take my DD on a long motorway journey this weekend. I have a one-year old car with excellent safety ratings for the passenger seat, with air bags etc. In fact, the safety ratings look like its safer to be in the front than the back, although they only seem to have tested child's car seats in the back so it's hard to compare.

Anyway, my friend said that she would never let her DC travel in the front seat on the motorway as its always safer for them to be in the back. Starting to question myself now as would never forgive myself if something happened to her and I had made a decision that contributed to it.

Curious what other people think? She is tall for an 11yo and an athlete so not a delicate child!

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
thecatsthecats · 18/05/2023 14:51

Well, those things also go on my husband's offence list - it's a miracle I haven't killed him. But as a non driver he is so much worse!

Don't get me started on him getting arsey when I shush him when he yaks on over the sat nav... Apparently I'm supposed to wait until he pauses breath, say, "sorry dear, I just need to listen to the directions". At 70mph when I need to lane change.

I think I'd prefer a 11yo to be honest.

GertrudePerkinsPaperyThing · 18/05/2023 13:57

I would be so angry if a husband of mine interfered with my driving in that way!

I hate having adults in the front of my car now (usual only drive with my dc present - 14 and 9). They do things like - spread a bit of leg or coat into the driving area (where the gearstick is), sit forward at junctions “to see”, thereby blocking the driver’s view, rather than keeping their head back as they should, natter to you at important points like at tricky junctions, tell you “it’s clear” or point out parking spaces that you’ve already either seen or dismissed for reasons.

Any way that’s all irrelevant- it makes me look like a nervous driver but I’m not at all, I’m just a misery guts!

Ive let my dc go in the front from a younger age, OP, because particularly the youngest gets sick in the back.

thecatsthecats · 18/05/2023 13:34

My immediate thought wasn't about safety but about behaviour.

My 34yo husband isn't mature enough to sit in the front seat some days!

He's a non-driver, and I had to give him a serious bollocking the other day for his habit of "helpfully" using my hazards to thank another driver. A) I had already done a little hand raised wave, b) not always possible to thank people and that's fine, c) it was a very bad spot to give a potentially confused signal, and it DID confuse them.

Countless other small bits of behaviour that are a much worse distraction when he's next to me that a non-driver wouldn't do.

So does your daughter know how to behave in the front?

Wenfy · 18/05/2023 13:23

My kids were both in the front seat for the first 2-3 mths of their lives as it was easier to reach for them. This is a non-issue

Madamecastafiore · 21/02/2023 15:24

The safest seat in the car is the middle seat in the back due to being as far away from impact zones.

Totally up to you to judge risk and deem what you think is appropriate.

All my kids have sat in the back until they were in secondary school and they're all quite tall. DC3 is still in an isofix booster at 9 and I've a spare one for her friends who all balk at having to sit in one.

I've been in a fatal car accident though so am rather adverse to any risk.

SVRT19674 · 21/02/2023 14:32

parsniiips · 08/10/2022 17:38

@Clymene

Really? You didn't know that it's much safer in the back and that airbags can snap children's necks?


Is it still safer in the back if a double decker bus pounds into the back of the car, or side of the back end of the car?

As long as everyone is sitting in a carseat appropriate for their weight and age/size, and airbags are switched off for those that it could be dangerous to, everything else is dependent on the impact and location of any potential accident.

Well...the passenger seat isn´t called the death seat for nothing, you know.

SVRT19674 · 21/02/2023 14:30

This reply has been deleted

Post withdrawn at author's request

@FrodisCapering it is as you say in Spain where I live. The child has to be 12 years old and at least 1.35 metres tall to sit in the front. Not complying is 200 euros fine and 4 points off your licence. The only exceptions are when the car has no back seats, the back seats are occupied by other minors in seats and one other I can´t recall. Maybe you´ve travelled in mainland Europe and that´s why you thought it was so in Britain.

parsniiips · 08/10/2022 17:38

@Clymene

Really? You didn't know that it's much safer in the back and that airbags can snap children's necks?


Is it still safer in the back if a double decker bus pounds into the back of the car, or side of the back end of the car?

As long as everyone is sitting in a carseat appropriate for their weight and age/size, and airbags are switched off for those that it could be dangerous to, everything else is dependent on the impact and location of any potential accident.

Abraxan · 08/10/2022 10:29

paintitallover · 07/10/2022 14:51

It's illegal so YABU

No it isn't.
Not in England anyway.
May be in other countries.

Reallyreallyborednow · 08/10/2022 10:22

In other news, it's also much safer never to cross a road than to cross one. Have you ever seen someone who's been flattened by a bus?

presumably though you take measures to avoid being hit by a vehicle crossing the road? Use crossings, look left, cross when it’s clear..

same thing, yes there’s a risk but you take steps to minimise it.

I’ve literally never given this a thought

have you also never given a thought to any other risks? Lay on back as infants, researched the safest car seat, avoided smokers? Why think about one risk but not another?

NotLovingWFH · 08/10/2022 09:29

I’ve literally never given this a thought. As soon my DC were tall enough to use the seatbelt they could sit in the front and we’d chat about all sorts. Had some of our best conversations in the car.

BertieBotts · 08/10/2022 08:47

EfficientDynamics · 08/10/2022 08:24

I saw a friend recently who has bought an Audi TT. For those that don't know, that's a small three door car with literally no leg room for anybody sitting in the back unless it's a baby

The back of the front seat practically makes contact with the rear bench so no leg room in the back

I was told that their six year old DD sits in the front seat when she goes in the car with her dad. I've always wondered about whether this was legal, I'm pretty sure they said there's ISOFIX on the front passenger seat

It's probably actually safer in that case if the front seats almost make contact with the back. You need 55cm distance from the crease of the back seat to the back of the front seat for any child seat to be considered safe, because they allow for 55cm movement tolerance. 50cm if it's a new regulation one. 55cm is usually about the depth of the seat, so if the front seat hovers over the back seat then it's usually too small. Anything within that 55cm space is a hazard for a child to hit their head (e.g. tablet holders that stick out backwards are a safety problem). I don't really know how the car manufacturers get away with it, because those back seats are essentially unsafe to use any child seat on (and I can't imagine that an adult passenger would move any less than 55cm in a crash either!)

crackofdoom · 08/10/2022 08:42

12 year old DS has insisted on sitting in the front seat for several years, to get away from his brother 😆. It does alleviate the risk of me having to turn around and bellow "STOP BLOODY ARGUING!" on a regular basis, which is a highly distracting manoeuvre (any stats on that? 😬)

Getoff · 08/10/2022 08:32

Clymene · 07/10/2022 14:07

Really? You didn't know that it's much safer in the back and that airbags can snap children's necks?

In other news, it's also much safer never to cross a road than to cross one. Have you ever seen someone who's been flattened by a bus?

High5InALowRide · 08/10/2022 08:29

Amarette · 07/10/2022 14:16

A bit of a mixed bag of responses but the votes suggest IANBU. I don't know her exact height but it's definitely above 150cm.

If airbags are so dangerous at that height then surely a lot of shorter women are being put at risk? I suppose another one or the ways that things are designed for men's needs and not women's.

She is much happier in the front and loves to chat. And maybe that will be safer as it will keep me awake and alert!

I will put her seat back as far as possible. That seems like a good compromise.

Just spotted this. As a 150cm driver I agree she's fine!

High5InALowRide · 08/10/2022 08:27

My 7 and 9yo regularly sit at the front. 9yono longer needs a booster and does seem really small sat in the front so i avoid on long journeys but sometimes needs must and it massively helps with car sickness as now he's not in a booster he struggles in the back.

EfficientDynamics · 08/10/2022 08:24

I saw a friend recently who has bought an Audi TT. For those that don't know, that's a small three door car with literally no leg room for anybody sitting in the back unless it's a baby

The back of the front seat practically makes contact with the rear bench so no leg room in the back

I was told that their six year old DD sits in the front seat when she goes in the car with her dad. I've always wondered about whether this was legal, I'm pretty sure they said there's ISOFIX on the front passenger seat

PanPacificBallroomChampion · 08/10/2022 07:52

If you have an accident depending upon the circumstances you have no way of knowing which seat would be best. If you rear ended someone at speed the front seat would have been a bad idea but conversely if you’re queuing and a hgv crashes into the back of you then the front seat would probably be safer. As long as you’re using the correct booster (if she’s under 135cm) it doesn’t really matter where she sits especially if the trip passes, as I’m sure it will, without any incidents.

Lunar270 · 08/10/2022 07:45

Amarette · 08/10/2022 07:27

@BertieBotts thank you so much for your wise and informative post. Everything you say makes complete sense and is really reassuring, thanks. I will tell DD about the smartphone thing too!

Bertie has probably mentioned all you need to consider really. Although I've told my kids never to put their feet up on the dash on long journeys. I see it from time to time and whilst tempting, the airbag could put you in an uncompromising position Hmm

Anyway, in all seriousness, the C-HR is a great car. My eldest has one and it's fine front or back. At 11 and 150cm, I certainly wouldn't stick her in the back. She'll be fine. IMO the brace thing is nonsense. Crash test dummies don't brace and neither does everyone in a crash, simply because you're not always aware of a crash happening. There's also theory that bracing is worse for injury and the ideal is to yield. Most of us don't have the luxury of deciding.

Going back to a pp, cars are mostly designed for men so many women are at a disadvantage. Sorry about that but it is changing. However, despite this cars are safer than ever and motorway driving safer than all other roads.

Hope you have a safe journey and most importantly enjoy it. Try not to think about this thread!

NeedSleepNow · 08/10/2022 07:44

My just turned 12 tray old always sits in the front. I have 3 children and my car won't fit them all across the back seats, so my eldest always sits in the front whatever route of journey. He is legally tall enough not to use a booster but he does still use a backless booster as otherwise the seatbelt doesn't seem to sit in the right place on him and he slouches in the seat too much without it.

BertieBotts · 08/10/2022 07:39

Sorry I left a sentence half finished

*It might be that the back seat/front seat thing is out of date too but to be honest I don't really know.

sanityisamyth · 08/10/2022 07:30

Make sure they're on a booster seat if they're not yet 135cms, and turn off the air bag for that seat, and push the seat back as far as possible.

Amarette · 08/10/2022 07:27

@BertieBotts thank you so much for your wise and informative post. Everything you say makes complete sense and is really reassuring, thanks. I will tell DD about the smartphone thing too!

OP posts:
BertieBotts · 08/10/2022 07:22

I think the PP was talking about the 4yo who sits in the front. Probably they are sitting on a booster seat, which is perfectly legal.

Yes I think it's illegal to put children in the front in some countries, but it's not illegal in the UK.

"Bracing" definitely a myth but that screenshot somebody sent mentioning bracing didn't look like it came from a reputable site so I would ignore it. The reason they generally say airbags are dangerous for kids under 12 is the same as why we say you need to use booster seats for kids under 12 - it's to do with height and at 150cm this child wouldn't need a booster seat anywhere in the world. Seatbelts are designed for people 150cm+ (which does indeed pose a problem for women who are shorter. If you're shorter, wear a seatbelt anyway. It will still do something.) Nothing magical is going to happen on the eve of her 12th birthday that makes her better at withstanding airbags. It's just an easier message to say "over 12 vs under 12" - rather than complicating it with things like if your child is 150cm or not. There is going to be higher risk for younger children and lower risk for older ones on a sliding scale. There's really not that much difference between an 11yo and 13yo for example, but an 8yo would be at more risk and a 6yo even more so. But age is an easy metric - you don't always know your child's exact height or weight but you tend to know their age in years.

The middle seat thing is out of date, it used to be the case that the middle seat was safest because side impact protection in cars has only been a thing for approx the last 25 years, so 10-15 years ago anyone driving a car older than about 10 years was at high risk from side impact crashes and the middle seat is the furthest point from that type of crash. Nowadays that is less relevant because cars have side impact protection built in so the sides are less risky, and very few people are driving around in 20+ year old cars. If you're linking/reading studies and they are based on crashes that occurred in the 90s, bear this in mind too. Modern cars have completely unrecognisable safety features compared with cars from the 80s and 90s. It might be that the back seat/front seat

I don't know if you can extrapolate NCAP data because they don't put adult dummies in the back and test them so they aren't judging by the same criteria and the score may reflect that. For instance they get marked down for not having a built in booster seat in the back even though a separate high backed booster gives better crash protection in lab tests. But certainly several experts in Sweden seem to think the front seat is safe (note here they are talking about deactivated airbags because they are discussing use with rear facing child seats and not adult sized children) www.carseat.se/rearfacing/position-in-vehicle/front-seat-safety/
And if your car has a good NCAP rating for front seat occupants, it's not a bad place to put an adult-sized person.

I’m also interested in the answer to the airbag question. My 8yo quite often goes in the front but I haven’t been turning off the airbag, now wondering if I should?

Check the car's manual. For forward facing children in car seats you will have an instruction in there. Some cars say not at all, some cars say airbag on, some say airbag off. All say seat back as far as it can go, I believe. If your 8yo is not on a booster seat you'd be best off using at least a backless booster if not a full high back until 150cm or until the belt fits over the hips when he's bending his knees over the seat edge - for most 8yos, bending their knees over the seat edge (as is comfortable) tends to bring their bum and hips forward, which puts the lap belt higher over their tummy.

One issue that hasn't been mentioned in the thread is the smartphone problem - recently more head injuries seen in children who pre-crash were positioned bent over looking at a smartphone. When they're in this position they are at risk from the airbag as their head is more in the place that it's likely to explode. But if you want her in the front so you can chat, then this is less likely.

Sorry OP, I bet you wish you'd never asked Grin

WindyKnickers · 07/10/2022 22:38

My 11 yo sits up front as standard unless she has a friend in the car in which case the 7 yo gets a turn. Never really gave it much thought.

I think in some countries (France possibly) it is illegal under the age of 12 so maybe that poster isn't from the UK?