Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to think that beauty advent calendars agave become a horrible representation of this who ‘have’ and those who ‘don’t’

137 replies

ThisOrTha · 07/10/2022 12:53

The price of some of these calendars is crazy! I think everyone should have the right to buy what they want, but with the current state of things it feels like a really horrible waste of money. Yet built up to be a ‘must have’ etc etc.

Im probably being a grump and I do love beauty products/fashion, I just think some of these companies could donate some of the cover price to other causes as I’m sure the price markup is substantial.

AIBU to think that beauty advent calendars agave become a horrible representation of this who ‘have’ and those who ‘don’t’
OP posts:
ReedOfFate · 07/10/2022 14:26

OP it must be to do with your particular sphere that they are a “must have” - in my sphere they very much aren’t and I can’t think of a single conversation I’ve had about them (have seen them in MN year on year; would like the Diptyque one maybe but I often get a couple of candles for Christmas and I don’t need or want more than that)

Some of them sound like good value if you use a lot of products, and opportunity to try new things is a good idea. I use my very old Playmobil calendar - the old style one with the reusable boxes - and keep my money for stollen, amaretti biscuits, ginger bread and Bailey’s throughout December. We’re all different!

LuciaPopp · 07/10/2022 14:17

I've always assumed that these calendars are marketing for the products- basically 24 big samples.

I love beauty products and fall for all sorts of "buy two get this bag of things you don't want free" all the time. I've never bought a beauty Advent calendar however as they don't really fit with my approach to Advent- it sometimes feels like Christmas starts on 1 December and finishes on 26 December, whereas I try to keep Advent distinct at least to some extent and then celebrate Christmas for the 12 days. Having a present every day in Advent doesn't really fit with that- I do have a paper one though.

Mooda · 07/10/2022 14:16

Nasty things, so much packaging and waste for minute amounts of product. I always look at them and just think 'landfill' - just a load of disposable crap. What percentage of the materials/chemicals used are in the bin before Christmas? I know many things we consume are pointless and wasteful but these are right at the top of the scale.

bellsbuss · 07/10/2022 14:16

DH bought me my first one Christmas 2020 to cheer me up and I loved it so he bought me another one last year. I used about 90% of what was in there and the rest I gave to my daughters.

3WildOnes · 07/10/2022 14:11

This is so bizarre. I love beauty but have never bought one because I don't want to spend £200 on an advent calendar.
I don't begrudge other people paying £200 on one. We are all free to spend our money how we wish.

PeloFondo · 07/10/2022 14:10

I got the net a Porter one last year in the sale which made it great value. Loved 95% of the products. I wouldn't have bought it full price and haven't got one this year hut would definitely get a sale one again. It was full size products, no sample sizes

KimmySchmitt · 07/10/2022 14:10

I'm not sure the price mark-up is substantial actually, or that they're poor value for money. Like anything, it's only worth it to people who like and will use the products. Some of the higher end calendars this year have very good contents. Take the John Lewis calendar, there are 27 products in there. The cost of the calendar is lower than the cost of 3 of the (full size) products. If you were planning to buy those three products anyway, the rest is a bonus. I'm not saying the shops make a loss or anything, I'm sure the calendars do cost them less than the sale price, but it would still cost me a lot more to buy the contents individually. They're not all full of tiny samples and plastic waste (yes, some are but you can choose carefully).

StopFeckingFaffing · 07/10/2022 14:07

I've never had one and do not feel under any pressure whatsoever to buy one or expect someone else to buy me one

There is all sorts of frivolous crap available to separate people from their hard earned cash but I don't see these as being any worse than other luxury items which we all have a choice whether to but or not

Hadjab · 07/10/2022 14:02

I buy one every year. I put a lot of research into which one, based on what's in it that I will actually use, and the brands that I'd like to try, and what I will give away. If I were to buy a full size version of every product in a calendar, and not like/use 50% of them, then I'd definitely be far more out of pocket than buying an £150 advent calendar. Would I consider myself to be a have not? Nope - I've just opted to spend what little spare cash I have on something I like, like most people would on various hobbies.

VeridicalVagabond · 07/10/2022 14:00

I make advent calendars for my DH, DD and myself because they really are such a rip off to buy. I just enjoy the fun of having a little door to open every day.

I remember when it used to just be a piece of cardboard with a little picture behind each door, of angels and shepherds and wise men and such! So hundreds of pounds is mad.

bingbummy · 07/10/2022 13:57

This one is £20 and cruelty-free, and their stuff is nice. I like expensive stuff because... it's your face, but this stuff is genuinely good.

I'll be getting my mum and some others this for xmas. It was always the superdrug one, which was also good and cruelty-free, but I can't find it this year, but found this other cheap one that looks nice lbworld.co.uk/product/sunkissed-25-days-of-beauty-advent-calendar-2021-25-pieces/?gclid=Cj0KCQjwnP-ZBhDiARIsAH3FSRcktdpXr6pSyWX3IFN0at3SqtY9_edmUBKvbOxwZn51VaFSQcw6-awaAoAAEALw_wcB

The thing with trends is there will always be a high end that the price is inflated on, and an affordable end, which is often just as pleasing.

clopper · 07/10/2022 13:57

I always get one and enjoy trying out new things. Sometimes I have gone on to buy larger bottles of certain creams and lotions if I like the sample. However, I have an old banger of a car and never have foreign holidays, so it’s my little treat to myself. People can spend their money on what they’d like, be it wine, BT sports channels, holidays and cars. I’m not interested in any of those things but I don’t begrudge others spending their money how they choose. I always buy the cheap ones but would love one of those expensive ones to try.

SummerInSun · 07/10/2022 13:54

Wouldn't everyone rather just have one with a nice bit of chocolate every day?!?

JenniferBarkley · 07/10/2022 13:53

I bought one the year I was on maternity leave and due to go back to work in Jan. I was feeling very flat and had lost a bit of myself and thought it would be nice to have a little lift. It was, it was nice to get a wee moment just for me each day and there's a couple of products I still buy. I haven't bought one since as they're not great value for money and quite wasteful - but that year it was a nice pick me up.

I've also bought one for a friend from her favourite brand as a birthday present which went down well.

I don't think anyone views them as a must have. There's loads of things that are expensive, that most of us couldn't afford or wouldn't think are good enough value to shell out on. It's just another one for the list.

Not a big deal.

PrincessButtercupToo · 07/10/2022 13:51

AgentJohnson · 07/10/2022 13:50

If people in your friendship group are wanting them, that says a lot about them and why you consider them friends. May I suggest you do a SM detox and the best it is it won’t cost you.

What does it say about them?

AgentJohnson · 07/10/2022 13:50

If people in your friendship group are wanting them, that says a lot about them and why you consider them friends. May I suggest you do a SM detox and the best it is it won’t cost you.

Nidan2Sandan · 07/10/2022 13:47

I've always wanted one, just for the novelty but refuse to pay that kind of money (even the £50 ones) just for the novelty factor.

Kids have always just had chocolate ones, one year I paid extra for the haribo ones but that isnt the norm.

I do think the expense of some of the calendars are bonkers.

MangoBiscuit · 07/10/2022 13:46

Some years I get the M&S one just as a treat for myself, but only with the offer, when I'm buying Christmas presents for family, so spending enough anway. A couple of times I've sold a few of the bits I won't use, on ebay. So all in, it doesn't actually cost me much. Like others have said, I do a lot for Christmas for others, so this bit is for me.

RealBecca · 07/10/2022 13:45

Ffs they are a luxury product business not a charity. There are plenty of charitable things out there to support if you choose to. The problem is that you are put to g pressurenon yourself to buy into the crap that xmas is a time for making dreams come true with loads of materialistic crap.

When did one present and a £1 advent calendar for fun turn into the fiasco of beauty calendars, December boxes, personalised xmas eve pjs and xmas eve boxes and piles and pike of presents become the norm? Who really benefits?

Young kids dont care and teenagers love the environment. Dont attach thought and love with materialistic crap.

Noviembre · 07/10/2022 13:45

Cheap samples for idiots. Why even give this any thought?

Alltheshoes74 · 07/10/2022 13:44

i’ve bought one this year for the first time in ages - I’m running low on a few bits and they have things I’d like to try. Usually I steer clear to avoid getting bits I don’t need but not this year that said I usually pass the things I don't want to my friends to avoid waste/clutter

CaptainThe95thRifles · 07/10/2022 13:42

If folk want to presume I'm on the breadline because I don't buy overpriced, gimmicky make up advent calendars, it's only their own ignorance they're showing 😂

Surely these things are just a representation of those who don't give a toss about this shit, and those who do (or, conceivably, actually want something that's only available in these things - who knows?!).

saltinesandcoffeecups · 07/10/2022 13:42

I quite like the whisky 🥃 ones, and have bought one each for myself and DH for the past 3 or 4 years. For us we get to sit down together during December in front of the fire and have drink together. It’s our way of building up to the holidays and enjoying our time together.

Yes you are being a grump
Yes, I think some of them are overpriced and silly
No, I’m not going to judge how someone else chooses to spend their money
No, I’m not going begrudge anyone for finding a little fun in their life

FamilyTreeBuilder · 07/10/2022 13:41

They are all poor value for money, over packaged, plastic fantastic consumer tat.