Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be involved with my year 8 exam revision?

112 replies

Doingprettywellthanks · 07/10/2022 11:17

Just wondering how much others get involved in their year 7/8/9 child’s revision?

I was a complete swot at school / uni - and study skills is something that I really do appreciate makes a huge difference. Consequently - every evening I am structuring a plan with my DS, re what he will learn that evening and then testing him on it.

His classmate’s mother, who is also my friend! And I were chatting and I mentioned how I would be relieved to get my evenings back post exams and saw looked quizzically at me. Transpires she leaves her year 8 entirely to his own devices, which is obviously completely fair enough! But it did prick my interest. Am i the minority or majority?

OP posts:
ErinAoife · 07/10/2022 13:34

Really depend of your kids. My eldest did not need any input from me in secondary school, my middle one need supervision as doing the bare minimum. I don't set up a plan but I make sure his work his done

MermaidEyes · 07/10/2022 13:32

outtheshowernow · 07/10/2022 13:12

I do t think it's necessary for an 8 year old to revise for anything other than learning spellings or tables. And if they were not doing it off their own back I would not help. Let kids be kids

Year 8, so age 12/13

MermaidEyes · 07/10/2022 13:31

Half the exams in year 8 are pointless because they won't be doing all those subjects at GCSE level anyway. I left mine to figure out their own study plans, as the way I work may not be the same as the way they work. But I did help with revision for GCSEs and A Levels if they asked me to.

outtheshowernow · 07/10/2022 13:12

I do t think it's necessary for an 8 year old to revise for anything other than learning spellings or tables. And if they were not doing it off their own back I would not help. Let kids be kids

justasoul · 07/10/2022 13:06

DD is in Y9 and my input is limited to asking if she has any homework due or any assessments coming up. She will ask if she needs help, we will often discuss topics she’s learning but no formal timetable or anything.

chesirecat99 · 07/10/2022 13:04

It's unusual but I don't think it is a bad thing. It's important to learn independence and be self motivated but it's also important to learn how to do that and acquire study skills. We micromanaged Year 7 exams to encourage good habits and teach them revision skills, then left them to it with minimal involvement afterwards. My logic was at 11 they will probably listen to advice from parents but by the time it matters at GCSE, not a chance!

conkercollector · 07/10/2022 12:58

After DD1 did nothing at all for her first year 7 assessments, I did start to help her structure a revision timetable and showed her how to make revision notes (they don't seem to teach this at school). I would ask her a few test questions or look at some online together. Now she's Year 8 I hope I can just help her with a timetable and ask a few questions to check she has actually done the revision. I think it's a big jump in expectations between primary, where all revision work is done in class (and my DD was a year when they didn't take SATS because of Covid so probably didn't even do in-class revision) and secondary where you are expected to do a lot independently.

PugInTheHouse · 07/10/2022 12:56

Absolutely not in Y8 or 9, IMO there is little point to these exams. My DCs are at private school and have had end of year exams every year from Y3 but they are kept low key, they are given a revision booklet each year to show the potential topics and the most I have ever done is ask if they are doing it, have done it etc. Obviously always there to support them if required. DS2 has autism and ADHD so sometimes needs me to chat to him first and help him get in the right frame of mind to study.

Personally in Y10 and 11 I would expect them to be able to study alone, plan what they need to do and make decisions on how long is appropriate for them, some DCs of course will need more help but overall for a NT child I would expect self regulation from them.

In RL I have never heard of anyone sitting down for a couple of hours for Y8 exams with their DCs, or even GCSEs for that matter (but there are a couple of astonishing threads on here about the hot housing/micromanaging that goes on). Independence in studying (and all aspects of growing up) is really important. I have always felt I wanted to know what my DCs true ability is, if I am having to sit with them for a couple of hours a night and they are unable to do this independently then this isn't going to be sustainable, I have seen situations play out in RL a couple of times where a child is pushed further than their real capabilities, they then believe they will achieve much higher and are left very disappointed.

LottiesHook · 07/10/2022 12:53

Luckycatt · 07/10/2022 12:46

Yes - ex teacher and I help my own ks3 kids with revision. It's much like what I'd be reaching my Ks3 classes when I taught. Strategies to revise, ideas to memorise things, helping retention. So I show my kids things like mind maps - we might draw one together for a science test for example. I don't know how much of that sort of skill teaching goes on in their school. I suspect very little.

I am intrigued by mind maps for science. You wouldn't be able to upload a picture as an example? My ds flat out refuses to make mind maps (or flashcards). Sad He is very bright but has no idea how to revise and does not get the concept of study skills.

Malbecfan · 07/10/2022 12:51

A "friend" is like this with her DC. She micromanages every aspect of their lives. Her DC are now 18 and 16 and cannot get their own breakfast or pack their bags for school without mother checking them. Her DH has a learned helplessness too - probably makes for a quiet life, but he lived alone before they got together and seemed to manage fine. The lads are actually nice and quite bright, just emotionally immature. Mother is jealous of my slightly older DDs and their independence. Mine didn't wake up like that, it took a lot of effort to get them there.

At year 8, a NT child should be perfectly capable of managing their own revision. If they mess up, there is lots of time to help them sort it out before public exams kick in.

Orangesarenottheonlyfruit · 07/10/2022 12:47

I think you're setting your kid up for future failure.
I have various friends who pushed their kids like this and the kids did well, until university and then they were lost without their parents help.

I have 2 DDs. One extremely academic, one with ADHD and a bit more creative. The academic one had worked like a Trojan, got a great scholarship etc all under her own steam. The second child did less work but found her own happy medium. I let her do as much as she wanted but all her results were her own. She fluffed a few exams but learnt from it and has actually gone on to do good things.

You have to let kids learn it themselves, learn to fail and learn resilience. By pushing this hard, you are creating future problems.

Luckycatt · 07/10/2022 12:46

Yes - ex teacher and I help my own ks3 kids with revision. It's much like what I'd be reaching my Ks3 classes when I taught. Strategies to revise, ideas to memorise things, helping retention. So I show my kids things like mind maps - we might draw one together for a science test for example. I don't know how much of that sort of skill teaching goes on in their school. I suspect very little.

Testina · 07/10/2022 12:46

My Y8 doesn’t have exams that you can revise for in the same way. They tend to be end of unit tests, and they don’t get given anything to take home - even their own school exercise books live in class. So I’m less involved than I naturally would be!

But I would say that every French vocab test list that comes home, she asks me to test her - whereas the other mums would look at me blankly and not even know there was a test. And no, their kids aren’t independently testing themselves!

ChicCroissant · 07/10/2022 12:42

Alaimo · 07/10/2022 12:12

Do what works for your DC, but I'd highly recommend reducing your involvement in the coming years. I'm a university lecturer, and it's the kids who have had this hand holding approach who often really struggle in first year when suddenly there is no one checking in with them on a daily basis.

This was my first thought tbh! If you are looking forward to getting your evenings back then you're not hands off OP!

My DD's school help them with the revision plan prior to exams, so they already have that - we provide encouragement to stick to it. She knows we expect her to revise and luckily for us, she is willing to do so. She doesn't revise as much as I used to, but a lot more than her dad!

Raidcandle · 07/10/2022 12:40

KrisAkabusi · 07/10/2022 11:27

I think there's a happy medium between doing nothing and what you are doing. If you keep doing all the planning for your son he'll never learn to do it himself.

I agree totally with this.

FWIW, I did absolutely no revision throughout high school and successful obtained all A grades. Not ever child needs to revise.

Probably being a bit thick here, but what exams are there before year 9?

GabriellaMontez · 07/10/2022 12:37

I did this with my youngest. She needed some guidance. Just didn’t appreciate how to structure and plan. It needed to be spelled out to her.

My eldest just did it herself.

They're all different.

junebirthdaygirl · 07/10/2022 12:37

My dd studied away by her self..totally motivated. One ds wouldn't let me next nor near his books. But second ds liked me to hear him out stuff. He found it easier to learn knowing l would check so learnt really well. I never minded and it was handy in the car as l could shoot questions at him and it helped him to keep it in his memory.
We gradually stopped as he got older and maturity helped him become quite good at studying. Whatvr works and especially when he is on for it.

StillNotWarm · 07/10/2022 12:33

I help if asked (and have helped create a whole Geography book from the scraps that were legible) and check the homework app at least weekly to keep an eye out for revision homework, and double check revision has been done. But I wouldn't structure his revision.

Plumbear2 · 07/10/2022 12:25

My now year 10 always revised independently but will sometimes ask me to ask him questions. This has helped to produce a study plan that HE is happy with and works for himself. I couldn't stand to be micromanaging him. It works because he got mostly 6s and 7s in the end of year report for year 9. You may need to back off and let him decide how and what he studies.

SomeUnspokenThing · 07/10/2022 12:17

The main thing is whether your son is happy with how things are. If he is, then there's no reason to greatly change things. Though I would pick up on a PP's comment about how he has to learn to study too. Knowing how to study and plan things for himself will be useful as he progresses through his education, be that school or HEI.

I'm fairly hands-off with my DD but realise I'm fortunate in that she's self-motivated and wants to do well so she plans her own study around which tests are coming up (we're in Scotland so she's in Y10 equivalent). I get summaries from the school wrt what homework is due and I check in with her to make sure it's done, and she comes to me when she's stuck on things. If she wasn't doing so well at school then I would have more input.

Sounds like your son is doing well, OP.

CeeceeBloomingdale · 07/10/2022 12:14

I have a Y7 and a Y11. They both self manage. I’m there if they need support but they both prefer to do it their own way.

Alaimo · 07/10/2022 12:12

Do what works for your DC, but I'd highly recommend reducing your involvement in the coming years. I'm a university lecturer, and it's the kids who have had this hand holding approach who often really struggle in first year when suddenly there is no one checking in with them on a daily basis.

Doingprettywellthanks · 07/10/2022 12:08

Wailywailywaily · 07/10/2022 12:02

I sort of manage him from afar. He has his own revision plan that the school helped them to establish, but without me prompting him he would forget and procrastinate for the evening. He is a very motivated learner but also has strong ADHD tendencies so I try to stay hands off so that he can be independent while checking in with him along the way. If that makes sense?!

Mine too adhd tendencies.

so I spent a couple of hours with him before we started going through all his files and ordering them as it was… carnage!

OP posts:
Doingprettywellthanks · 07/10/2022 12:07

rageapplied · 07/10/2022 11:50

What if he doesn't learn like you do and your plan doesn't work for him?

It seems to. He came in top 10% in all exams bar french last term and he seems pretty content with the status quo

OP posts:
Wailywailywaily · 07/10/2022 12:02

I sort of manage him from afar. He has his own revision plan that the school helped them to establish, but without me prompting him he would forget and procrastinate for the evening. He is a very motivated learner but also has strong ADHD tendencies so I try to stay hands off so that he can be independent while checking in with him along the way. If that makes sense?!

Swipe left for the next trending thread