Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To have my 2 yo watch 5 hours of TV?

137 replies

Cbeebiesismybestfriend · 07/10/2022 06:05

God that sounds so bad written down.

He goes through stages of waking at 5 and it usually lasts around a week then reverts to half six again, not sure why.

I don’t know what to do with him at this time other than let him watch TV! Then he has another hour or so at the end of the day Blush

Do others do the same?

OP posts:
FiveMins · 07/10/2022 08:26

Tbh it's pretty shit. Even as an adult that's a lot of screentime. At that age we had a "magic light" that meant they weren't allowed to leave their bed until it came on. We put toys at the end of the bed and books and they have to stay in bed until 6am. You have to be strict with it and make it fun (we said it was the morning fairies,). It worked with all three of ours Having the TV first thing makes them much more likely to wake up I reckon.
Then you could give him an hour of telly which means by then it's 7 a.m. you can get up at a reasonable hour. And you can then let him play by himself.

ReeseWitherfork · 07/10/2022 08:24

Cbeebiesismybestfriend · 07/10/2022 08:19

We’ve never watched cocomelon. He hates it, thankfully.

It is generally Mr Tumble (pre 6am) then CBeebies where there are things he likes (teletubbies, Chuggingtons - annoying talking trains - has started to get into Hey Duggee) and things he’s not bothered about he wanders off and engages in meaningful play (trashing the house …) 😂

It’s easy to overlook how little they’re actually watching the screen. I’m not a morning person so always stuck the TV on for DS when he woke for a couple of hours but I reckon he watched all of ten minutes of it until he turned about 2.5 when he could start requesting what he wanted. He’d sit glued to Paw Patrol until I had enough and banned it 😅

Cbeebiesismybestfriend · 07/10/2022 08:19

We’ve never watched cocomelon. He hates it, thankfully.

It is generally Mr Tumble (pre 6am) then CBeebies where there are things he likes (teletubbies, Chuggingtons - annoying talking trains - has started to get into Hey Duggee) and things he’s not bothered about he wanders off and engages in meaningful play (trashing the house …) 😂

OP posts:
mynameiscalypso · 07/10/2022 08:17

I have to admit laughing a little at some of the ideas of what to do at 5am with a two year old. I think TV then is fine.

ReeseWitherfork · 07/10/2022 08:17

ReeseWitherfork · 07/10/2022 08:07

As with PP, this suggests screen time has an impact on ADHD-related behaviours not ADHD. Following to the study that it is citing, they seem to be suggesting that these behaviours can be reversed by lowering the amount of screen time. They also talk significantly about the type of TV, which I think is something often overlooked in these conversations. The woman who rips apart CocoMelon adds an interesting take where she talks about the quality of the TV. I’ll be back once I’ve found her. Worth reading OP!

Check out this lady OP: raisewildflowers.com/screen-time

She’s qualified in child development and has taken a particular interest in screen time. She talks heavily about the importance of choosing better quality TV for your kids and not putting on the high dopamine stuff like CocoMelon. You can tell the folks at CBeebies are concerned with actually putting on high quality educational shows for kids. Whereas anything that originated on YouTube is just trying to create addictive shows so they get more plays and more ad revenue. So four hours of CBeebies is better than two hours of CocoMelon in my book! Even though the latter meets the WHO recommendation and the former does not.

SleeplessInEngland · 07/10/2022 08:08

I don’t see the big deal. I grew up watching tv and I turned out tv.

marvellousmaple · 07/10/2022 08:08

No criticism from me. I'm a TV on in the background type person and all 4 of mine have watched heaps of kids tv. Obviously all kids are different but mine are very capable and successful ( 3 being grown adults with very responsible jobs). 4th is in an accelerated learning programme through state school. Try not to stress.
One thing I would do is make sure I went out everyday if I was home with them. You don't seem to be but maybe even a little wander in the garden with a cup of "tea" each if you have 5 minutes spare in the morning. Otherwise just give your little one a big cuddle when you come home. I would be astounded if any actual teacher could pick the amount of tv each child had watched when they start school.

Cbeebiesismybestfriend · 07/10/2022 08:07

I meant 8-9 in the morning, not evening!

I honestly don’t think it’s affecting behaviour or sleep … if I did might have to rethink. Bear in mind we’re talking maybe two mornings a month where it’s that much.

OP posts:
Brighteyedtriangle · 07/10/2022 08:07

Honestly I would try and avoid this.

Im usually the camp of do anything to get through the day but when my 6 year old watches too much tv she is so ignorant and honestly her whole persona changes.

BTW She watches plenty of Tv so its not dont do it at all its limit it as much as you can. We have a no morning before school rule and if she turns cheeky it goes off and she cant watch it for the rest of the day.

Bizarly once it goes off shes happy as larry and entertains herself with other stuff.

ReeseWitherfork · 07/10/2022 08:07

As with PP, this suggests screen time has an impact on ADHD-related behaviours not ADHD. Following to the study that it is citing, they seem to be suggesting that these behaviours can be reversed by lowering the amount of screen time. They also talk significantly about the type of TV, which I think is something often overlooked in these conversations. The woman who rips apart CocoMelon adds an interesting take where she talks about the quality of the TV. I’ll be back once I’ve found her. Worth reading OP!

RIPQueen · 07/10/2022 08:03

i think no tv until 6am is reasonable then 6-7 is reasonable. 8-9pm is way too late for tv as well it’s overstimulating can’t you do an hour 4-5 whilst you make dinner or whatever. 2 hours is over the amount recommended but I think probably fine. More than that every day is too much - it’s different on a one off rainy Sunday or when you or they are sick but that’s really a lot!

ChronicOverthinkr · 07/10/2022 08:01

watching TV 5-730 and 8-9ish and then presumably the hour before bed too?

I’m pretty lax but I feel like that’s too much. If you remove the TV as an option entirely, he will entertain himself with toys. It’s a process he’ll need to learn because imaginative play is a skill, so yes - he will likely need input to begin with to make sure he’s not destroying the house. But you will reap the rewards of persevering and positive reinforcement during the day too. Mine used to watch a lot of TV before I realised what a negative impact it was having on their behaviour and sleep patterns. It was a rough couple of months when we decided no more than an hour of TV a day but now they get up and play with Brio, Duplo, marble runs, cars etc (they’re 2 and 4).

grey12 · 07/10/2022 07:59

My trick is to put boring tv after a while and my kids always end up playing 😉 like in the mornings ITV changes from cartoons to boring adult tv and I keep the tv on. If I turn it off they'll come to annoy me

Cbeebiesismybestfriend · 07/10/2022 07:55

If only @Romeoalpha … you know when they have something they are allowed and it totally loses its appeal … 😂

he’s just been in the shower with me and his favourite game is throwing an empty bottle of shampoo into the bath, I have no idea why, but he was happy.

So when I analyse it it probably isn’t that awful as in my OP, it’s probably more like watching TV 5-730 and 8-9ish, which still isn’t great but not as bad.

OP posts:
violetcuriosity · 07/10/2022 07:51

OP just do what you need to do, if he'll sit there and it means that you get to have a rest then just do it. He won't sit still forever. Don't be so hard on yourself I'm sure he plays alongside watching the tv x

Romeoalpha · 07/10/2022 07:48

KatieKat88 · 07/10/2022 07:39

Only reading the first page of that link - it is focused on mobile screens, the impact of exposure to violent scenes too young and has a case study of a 9 year old who has been potentially wrongly diagnosed with ADHD whereas his behaviour is presenting like ADHD due to watching screens as above.

So I don't think OP's 2yo watching Cbeebies is quite the same thing really!

True, but I chose that because it’s the first hit of hundreds and is a literature review so it does demonstrate a lot of research into adverse impact of screen time.

Also, if the OP’s toddler is getting 5 hours of TV at age 2 because she finds it convenient to keep him occupied, she is very likely to end up giving him screen time on other devices for the same reasons as he grows up. She needs to know the dangers, and so do other parents on here.

Bridgeth29 · 07/10/2022 07:45

Do what you need to do. The TV is NOT the devil.

lannistunut · 07/10/2022 07:44

Or give him a toilet roll of his own and move the one from the bathroom to a higher shelf.

A lot of kids actually have very boring toys, when you analyse them they are all essentially the same thing in different colours.

Romeoalpha · 07/10/2022 07:42

Cbeebiesismybestfriend · 07/10/2022 07:28

And I’m certainly not trying in any way to be awkward, if anyone has any good suggestions I’m all ears as I wouldn’t dream of putting CBeebies on for 5 hours between 2 and 7 but somehow so early in the morning it barely seems to count.

The problem is like most children this age his attention span is very short, he does play for a bit but for anything meaningful it needs adult interaction and that’s quite hard at 5am Smile

How about giving him a box of sensory toys like squishy balls, strings of pasta, sealed clear bottles of dried lentils, rice and peas to shake or fill them with coloured water oil and glitter, hand bells and other small instruments. If he’s going after the toilet roll and cat litter I expect giving him things like this that he is ‘allowed’ to play with will help keep him occupied. (Dry stuff only for the early morning, then when you wake up properly you can get out stuff like playdough or waterbeads)

KatieKat88 · 07/10/2022 07:39

Only reading the first page of that link - it is focused on mobile screens, the impact of exposure to violent scenes too young and has a case study of a 9 year old who has been potentially wrongly diagnosed with ADHD whereas his behaviour is presenting like ADHD due to watching screens as above.

So I don't think OP's 2yo watching Cbeebies is quite the same thing really!

chillipopcorn · 07/10/2022 07:37

Hjgfer · 07/10/2022 07:08

If your happy with it it’s fine. My daughters changed this week and is now having 3 hour binges watching YouTube videos of little girls play with their dolls. She then role plays what she’s watched on her iPad.

in winter we’ve usually have CBeebies on in the background all day.

Jesus. I mean the evidence is pretty clear regarding impact of screen time on small brains. All of us make decisions sometimes to make our lives easier but the fact that OP has asked this question means she knows it's not OK. It's not good for them (definitely not having the TV on all day!).

TheRubyRedshoes · 07/10/2022 07:36

Op is acutely aware of his TV time though.

She is a conscious aware parent who wondering about the impact.

Some DC very sadly would spend those hours in the day watching TV when they should be doing other things.thats the difference surely?
Child wakes up and then sends their day on the TV?
Solidly?
Again when parents are ill... spending the day in front of the TV is necessary.
In a usually balanced full life it's fine.

Whinge · 07/10/2022 07:36

As for why not switch it off I think because he does flit and out and most programmes are so short that if I turned it off entirely he’d flit in and out of his toys but start pulling the toilet roll off the wall or emptying the cats litter tray over the floor!

Have you tried, or are you just assuming the worst?

There's nothing stopping him from pulling toilet paper off the wall or emptying the litter tray even if the TV is on, especially as you say he isn't usually interested in it.

Mylittlesandwich · 07/10/2022 07:36

There may be a link between screen time and ADHD. It has been basically impossible to show a causal link between screen time and ADHD. Screen time is also known to reduce depression so it's hardly the devil.

OP I have the tv on in the background most of the time. It's how I was brought up so normal to me. At that time in the morning I would do exactly the same. Make sure you're engaging plenty later in the day and are present. Doing all the "right" things.

Rinatinabina · 07/10/2022 07:34

Thats way too early, does he like books?tbh when DD did this I just got up with her and got her to u load dishwasher etc. BUT I wasn’t working. I would try to delay the start a bit, see if he’ll sit in your bed with some stickers or books.

It’s incredibly hard though at 2, DD is almost 3 and can only now occupy herself for ten minutes. You have all my sympathy and absolutely no judgement!