Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think getting any job is really tough?

107 replies

Bluey124 · 06/10/2022 22:21

Even just getting through the initial process of applying. It's never just applying quickly. It's often a long application form often followed by another test such as numeracy or literacy. It's a wonder anyone gets employed at all.
Years ago it used to be much easier. I got jobs in my teens and twenties just by filling out a short paper application form, now, it's a different story....

OP posts:
Secretboringsister · 08/10/2022 12:04

After 50 as a woman is an additional issue I am facing. It’s pretty disheartening

Secretboringsister · 08/10/2022 12:02

TrickorTreacle · 07/10/2022 00:27

Agreed OP. It was easy(ish) back in the early 2000s. It was a 1-interview stage then you were told if you succeeded or not.

In 2010, 2 interviews became the norm. Took me a good few months to find work.

In 2022, a 3-interview process is now the norm. It has become elitist. Although this is for a different thread, I'm also finding that dates want a "2nd interview" and a "3rd interview" before finding love.

Life is too short.

I agree! I’m right now in the midst of a 6 interview loop! Including a presentation! I wish I could say this is the only company I am in interviews with using 5+ interviews plus a presentation. It’s exhausting on candidates.

FannyCann · 08/10/2022 11:46

I agree OP. Depending on the job obv but even quite basic jobs can be a pita.
DD1 has just got her first serious post graduation job, a 2 1/2 year training scheme. For the level of job I suppose it was fairly reasonable, an online interview, followed by in person when she had to do a presentation which she put a lot of work into.

When she was first graduating she applied to the Office for National Statistics, (just before coronavirus hit) and they were advertising for new graduates whilst claiming to be inclusive and accepting of other educational routes eg apprenticeships.
The application was time consuming. Then there was a maths test. Fair enough you might say, given the nature of the employer/job.
She said there were questions on things she had never covered and failed and that was the end of that application.
But her degree was joint honours, 30% statistics, she got a 1st from a top university. A* a levels. She's never failed a maths test before.
It seemed ridiculous to weed people out this way and I'm sure others, approaching from other educational pathways would also have been confounded. Surely the whole point is they would expect to train up new employees, especially the graduate intake?

Doing this will inevitably mean missing out on good candidates.

Phineyj · 08/10/2022 11:09

Basically if you are getting no or crappy applications, while simultaneously deterring good ones, you need to look at your processes.

One major issue with schools is it's near impossible to get important information about the job before applying unless you have an insider contact (such as what typical starting and finishing times are and how many compulsory things happen before and after the school day). As that hugely affects commute and childcare, this deters candidates from even applying (because in teaching your current employer knows you are looking).

Phineyj · 08/10/2022 11:01

YA so NBU. I'm an experienced teacher of a subject in which there is a big shortage of teachers. I am reliable, punctual, up to date in my subject, have great references etc. I was job hunting in a vague kind of way this spring (tbh I was so fed up of the working conditions, I was considering quitting entirely till the cost of living crisis hit).

Through networking, four schools expressed an interest in hiring me. One made me prepare a day's teaching and interview on something entirely separate to my main subject; one was not willing to consider anything less than full time even though I'd been upfront about not being in the market for full time; the third wanted part time but basically wanted more than full time work done in it and the fourth made me spend an interview justifying why they should hire me, despite having begged me to apply!

I just don't think a lot of organisations really understand the barriers they are putting in the way. They have not accepted it's a sellers' market for anyone with skills and experience.

Employers should not be requiring so much of applicants up front.

EnglishGirlApproximately · 08/10/2022 10:55

If that was the travel industry i probably know who you mean haha 😄

Oddsocks12 · 08/10/2022 10:52

Haha @EnglishGirlApproximately in my last role the industry had award ceremonies and the man who owned the awarding company, also owned the business that received the most awards.

😂 he was literally awarding himself.

EnglishGirlApproximately · 08/10/2022 10:49

@Oddsocks12 my industry is full of awards ceremonies its nuts. Half the year has us all patting each other on our backs for doing our jobs 😁

SarahAndQuack · 08/10/2022 10:49

Mmm, I'm torn on this one. A lot of what people describe as difficult job application processes sound very simple compared to what is standard in my former career, where you often submit pages and pages of work (including original documents and plans) before longlisting. I found it really ground me down, and it took an awful lot of time, too. I'd have much preferred a long application form and a couple of tests!

But it's not true that entry-level and low-paid jobs have all moved over to complicated application systems. I'm currently a bit over minimum wage doing semi-skilled manual work, and I got the job simply by walking in, asking if there was work, discussing the hours I wanted, and my boss said I could have a paid trial for a week then see where we were. That's how he employs pretty much everyone, and most people got their jobs by word of mouth.

Rhekdifn · 08/10/2022 10:44

Yeah, the employment process of graduate schemes has put me off from applying, and I am just over 25. I'm used to just doing an application form + interview. In contrast, these are wanting behavioural tests, then having to go to an assessment centre etc... which puts me off when I am probably not the worse candidate for the industry I want to go into.

Oddsocks12 · 08/10/2022 10:42

There's a lot of #bossbabes & #workingmum on mine too. Women getting awards at ceremonies that nobody has ever heard of or selfies at a work girls night out.

🥂 always a prosecco emoji in there too.... (must be a Cornwall thing!)

I love celebrating real promotions and real awards. Or the woman or man who has held down a job while studying only to graduate with a degree in architecture / law / teaching (especially if they also have caring responsibilities!)

Those are impressive! And I love those.

I'm definitely giving that Twitter account a follow 😂

2pinkginsplease · 08/10/2022 10:40

I think it depends on what field of employment you are looking for.

I’ve had 3 interviews in he last 20 months and got each job I interviewed for however I have heard of people having 2 interviews and a “test” to sit and they work in a different area .it’s as though some employers are wanting their candidates to jump hurdles hoping that only the strongest manages it.

my first application I had to send a video of me answering some questions they had set and hen I got an interview,

the second two jobs were for the same company and the application form was quite long aswell as the dreaded interview questions!

EnglishGirlApproximately · 08/10/2022 10:32

@Oddsocks12 @SudocremOnEverything don't forget the oh so original stories of hiring someone with no skills because they're such an empathetic and forward thinking boss 🙄 If you don't already follow The State of LinkedIn on twitter you really should!

SudocremOnEverything · 08/10/2022 10:14

Oddsocks12 · 08/10/2022 09:51

I agree here @Asparagoose my LinkedIn feed is full of cyber security, marketing and digital marketing people due to contacts I made at work and at University.

Every other photo on my feed is a golf selfie. Basically, men brown nosing with other men doing their fake LinkedIn business 😂

That sounds depressing.

My linked in feed is full of people demonstrating the worthy values and good work to make everything accessible to everyone and to care about all sorts of important stuff. I look at it and think: eurgh.

no golf though. Luckily.

Oddsocks12 · 08/10/2022 09:51

I agree here @Asparagoose my LinkedIn feed is full of cyber security, marketing and digital marketing people due to contacts I made at work and at University.

Every other photo on my feed is a golf selfie. Basically, men brown nosing with other men doing their fake LinkedIn business 😂

SudocremOnEverything · 08/10/2022 09:18

Aprilx · 08/10/2022 08:41

When could you ever do that? I have worked for nearly forty years and never found this to be the case. I started a new job in the summer after a bit of time off, I did some online applications but they were no more onerous than ever, generally uploaded a CV and attached a cover letter. In the end I walked into an agency on the high street, handed in my CV and I was working within a week.

You appear to have been able to do in scooby doo episodes made in the 70s.

however, I’m not sure that’s the most reliable source for understanding the labour market. Or anything really. Even sandwich making in scooby doo is not really an accurate representation of what’s possible
in real life. 🤣

SudocremOnEverything · 08/10/2022 09:16

When you are on the other side of the recruitment stuff, you do really see why there are different parts to the process though. Loads of the people you interview really won’t have the skills, experience or disposition for the job. And they’re the ones that got through a screening process to interview!

I’ve interviewed people who cannot outline the headline findings of the PhD they literally just finished (which matters a great deal for a job which listed the ability to communicate complex issues to non-expert audiences), people who genuinely don’t know some absolutely basic stuff (pretty alarmingly so in some cases) and in some cases people whose personal values are pretty terrifying (we’re talking in the realms of expressing actual racism and stuff 🤦🏻‍♀️).

Equally, we’ve all worked with people who most definitely should have been weeded out and not offered a job too. So that helps to underline why the processes do need to be fairly rigorous. And sometimes why the cultural fit stuff is especially important. I’ve interviewed at companies where I knew I wouldn’t consider taking the job because it became apparent that I would most definitely not be a good cultural fit there.

I’ve also left jobs because, frankly, they were awful places to work and the culture was just horrendous (right from the top!). I feel lucky that I’m in a position now
where professionally I can make these kind of choices because I’m beyond the needing to take any job I can stage.

My eldest son is at the trying to get started phase of jobs and it’s definitely really tough. There are loads of candidates for every job and he’s had some pretty dismal
experiences. He did have to quit a job because he genuinely felt unsafe working there - being expected to work with unsafe electrical equipment and to deal with aggressive, drunk customers without any security support. His employer won’t have improved anything - there are enough people who desperately need the work and don’t have the ability to quit and look
for something else.

The other issue is underemployment at that end of the market. Even when you get a job, they just don’t seem to offer full time hours. So many employers, it seems, would rather employ loads of people and give them too few hours than actually offer proper, full time jobs. The government unemployment figures like to hide this though by focusing on how many people have any kind of employment.

Aprilx · 08/10/2022 08:41

Bluey124 · 07/10/2022 15:01

And people who don't work anymore express surprise when you can't just walk into somewhere or have a quick interview and off you go kind of thing. Gets on my nerves. The job market and process of getting a job is so much more in depth now instead of in some of the cases mentioned.

When could you ever do that? I have worked for nearly forty years and never found this to be the case. I started a new job in the summer after a bit of time off, I did some online applications but they were no more onerous than ever, generally uploaded a CV and attached a cover letter. In the end I walked into an agency on the high street, handed in my CV and I was working within a week.

FlimFlam2 · 08/10/2022 08:38

Oddsocks12 · 08/10/2022 07:31

Try living in Cornwall where there's 100+ applicants per role and the role itself is £19500...

Especially for marketing / design / IT and digital marketing roles

People can bang on about the skills gap as much as they want. But if there's a skill gap in London or Leeds, it doesn't mean there's an abundance of vacancies and roles in places like Devon and Cornwall.

These threads come up again and again, and people always come on to say it's piss easy to get a job. But it seriously depends on where you are.

1 vacancy in Cornwall will be more difficult to get than the 1000 vacancies in London 😂 for example....

Very true. The job market in London is totally different to the rest of the country - people are constantly changing jobs/coming and going, so there is lots to apply for. Elsewhere, there are fewer employers to begin with and opportunities are further reduced because people stay in the same roles for longer.

makingmiracles · 08/10/2022 08:37

Depends on what you’re going for. I signed up with an agency, took a temp to perm job, so easy a child could do it, although 8hrs on feet, £12.20 ph, more in fact as we’ve just had a raise. No interview, no cv.

Asparagoose · 08/10/2022 08:33

PimmsOfCourse · 07/10/2022 00:37

I think networking is key and LinkedIn

And this increasingly excludes neurodiverse people from the workplace because their disability prevents them from networking effectively. Being qualified and competent at the job is no longer sufficient, it’s all about who the employer wants to eat lunch with for the next five years.

EnglishGirlApproximately · 08/10/2022 08:25

Its really industry dependent i think. I've had two interviews this week and neither have asked for my CV and both very informal, but I'm known in my industry and have a good reputation.
I think its much harder at entry level, NMW type jobs. A friend applied for an online order pickers job at Tesco and the interview turned out to be two hours long involving team building, shop floor demonstrations etc. Sainsbury's online application form is crazy unless they've changed it recently.
Then there's the lack of flexibility around interviews. I find it odd that interviewers are happy to employ people that would have to call in sick to their current job to attend. I'm interviewing for roles but luckily both interviewers have understood that I'm not willing to cancel appointments and seem unprofessional in my current role so have worked with me to find suitable times.

SudocremOnEverything · 08/10/2022 08:20

You will still probably need to go through some ridiculously convoluted process to get one of them: recruiter screen, initial interview, competency interview, cultural fit, 85 stages of presentation and portfolio review, a visit to the Aztec zone for a strength challenge, and so on.

But you won’t be limited to Cornwall’s local job market.

SudocremOnEverything · 08/10/2022 08:13

Oddsocks12 · 08/10/2022 07:31

Try living in Cornwall where there's 100+ applicants per role and the role itself is £19500...

Especially for marketing / design / IT and digital marketing roles

People can bang on about the skills gap as much as they want. But if there's a skill gap in London or Leeds, it doesn't mean there's an abundance of vacancies and roles in places like Devon and Cornwall.

These threads come up again and again, and people always come on to say it's piss easy to get a job. But it seriously depends on where you are.

1 vacancy in Cornwall will be more difficult to get than the 1000 vacancies in London 😂 for example....

There are loads of totally remote jobs in marketing / design / IT though. Paid at far more then £20k.

I absolutely agree that there are regional
issues. But honestly I don’t think digital stuff is the sector where that’s a problem.

Iheartmykyndle · 08/10/2022 08:11

Im finding this hard the moment. I find an application form takes about 4-5 hours to complete, then if you get an interview there's all the prep (1-4 hours depending on what they need). I interviewed for a role last month and had to do a presentation, write a "business plan" and a 4 person interview panel. For a £26k senior admin job. That they gave to an internal candidate. Fuck off.

I applied for another one that said to apply via indeed so I did. Then they sent me an email asking me to complete their own application asking for the same information. I declined.