Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think it odd my doctor won't give me a blood test

139 replies

ImStillMe · 06/10/2022 22:18

I did an e-comsult asking for a blood test for two things. Firstly I have been taking OTC vitamin D as I read this may be beneficial if you catch Covid (although I have also read this is debunked). I wanted my vitamin D level checked so I know whether or not to continue with this.

And secondly my hair has become very dry so I wondered if I am deficient in anything, or if it ok to try OTC biotin or zinc.

The surgery replied to say it's up to me if I want to continue with vitamin D supplements or not as they are OTC, and that I should talk to a pharmacist about my dry hair.

So no blood tests for me.

OP posts:
tigger1001 · 07/10/2022 09:02

Sorry I agree with the majority. That's not a medically required blood tests and you could pay to have that done privately.

paintitallover · 07/10/2022 08:52

Wasting NHS time on frivolities. People are dying and not getting enough attention out there. The NHS is on its knees.

Iamthewombat · 07/10/2022 08:41

Maybe if there was a national mentality that people should be encouraged to test regularly, just maybe, we could prevent some types of illness that are currently utilising NHS resources

There are more important tweaks to the ‘national mentality’ than everyone getting blood tests all the time for vitamin D, vanadium, boron etc. Like eating less sugar, junk food and similar crap and walking more instead of driving everywhere. The after effects of those things consume more NHS resources than lack of vitamin D. See how effectively the advice on diet and exercise has been absorbed by the ‘national mentality’. Unpopular opinion coming up: I suspect that most of the people demanding regular blood tests, if they were available on the NHS, would be like a PP’s Aussie mate: they’ve put weight on and are determined to ascribe it to a hormone or vitamin deficiency rather than crisps.

LouisCatorze · 07/10/2022 08:32

It's this type of 'entitled' approach to (mis)using the NHS that has helped tip it into the crisis its currently in. Honestly, OP, listen to yourself and get a grip.

Lauraa7 · 07/10/2022 08:07

Branster · 06/10/2022 22:51

Maybe if there was a national mentality that people should be encouraged to test regularly, just maybe, we could prevent some types of illness that are currently utilising NHS resources.

And can we stop with this attitude that the NHS is only there for grave illness or you must be on your death bed before you have the right to access any NHS services.

I do hope one day we'll get a government with the guts to get rid of the NHS.

OP, in the UK, I'd definitely get the tests done but find a private clinic. I wouldn't dismiss what you describe. You want to know if you are deficient in anything, you should find out. All may be well or perhaps you could do with some additional vitamins as recommended by a doctor. Better to know.
I know a few countries where blood tests and other tests are offered as a preventive health measure through national health care or easily accessible private care. The difference is, in quite a few other countries, people are used to the idea of spending more money on their health. And on good quality food for example. It's the way it is. They'd rather not but are accepting of this. And although not great for their pockets, maybe it's better for their health.

I totally agree with you. I’m in Australia and went to see a doctor who worked in the UK. He said the NHS is great for cancer and if you’re dying.
it is just too reactive, and if there were more preventive checks in place, might help to alleviate the stress on the system.

CrunchyCarrot · 07/10/2022 07:57

If you've been taking OTC Vit D then it's probably a very small dose, am I right? 800 i.u. possibly? This may be insufficient but you do need to do a blood test to see where you are at with levels. I highly recommend getting hold of a self-test kit:

www.vitamindtest.org.uk/?gclid=Cj0KCQjw-fmZBhDtARIsAH6H8qjsbf8vyZ47LxD6NJE9AZjRw-fz9z-mFoExLDQ_QLfII14DIlnAOrYaAiTUEALw_wcB

This will give you the info you need so you can decide whether to up supplementation or not.

The dry hair thing - honestly it's just too vague and could be any number of reasons why your hair is dry. NHS ain't going to test for that.

Cheeseandcrackers86 · 07/10/2022 07:52

Vitamin D is low in most people in this country especially this time of the year and you're unlikely to overdose yourself taking OTC supplements so just keep going of you want. Zinc /biotin levels aren't routinely checked as they are really significant enough. Again just take suplements if you're worried. I am a GP and don't think the advice was unreasonable. Just see the pharmacist as advised. I don't think your symptoms warrant the discomfort and cost of a blood test tbh x

olympicsrock · 07/10/2022 07:50

Totally unreasonable

Bpdqueen · 07/10/2022 07:49

Taking vitamin D daily is completely safe in this country and on the rare chance you took to much you would know about it as you would be ill. As for your hair try a different shampoo and conditioner

Changechangychange · 07/10/2022 07:47

Pac35 · 07/10/2022 06:38

A viitamin d tests costs £60 in the nhs. Nhs advises everyone takes vit d during autumn/ winter

Vitamin D costs £249 in our trust (it flashes up on the system when we order it).

And actually a full panel of every vitamin and trace metal known to man, which is what OP apparently asked for, would probably cost a few grand. Maybe not £8k, but closer to £8k than £1k. Selenium, zinc, manganese etc are send-away tests to a reference lab - definitely not something a GP could authorise, and definitely not indicated for dry hair.

DillDanding · 07/10/2022 07:46

My son had to have a full set of blood tests but as he was seeing a consultant privately, the cost was an eye watering 1k. This was just at the regular path lab at the local nhs hospital. Luckily, the consultant arranged them on the quiet for me under the NHS.

Anyway, this made me realise that blood tests are probably pretty expensive, even on the NHS. So I’m not surprised your GP was reluctant to refer you for a triviality.

Blowyourowntrumpet · 07/10/2022 07:36

The NHS is not there to pander to your whims. Stop wasting their time and grow up

Sniffypete · 07/10/2022 07:31

Good. You aren't ill. The GP is right. You need a hairdresser not a blood test.

NotAHouse · 07/10/2022 07:28

I was initially denied a blood test for feeling tired, dizzy and nauseated. So you and your bad hair day don't stand much of a chance.

mumda · 07/10/2022 07:25

Impressive you got an appointment.Gives me hope to try ringing again.

Lopilo · 07/10/2022 07:24

AllLopsided · 07/10/2022 07:14

This is a bit misleading - it's only €25 and you can claim most of it back from CPAM, and the rest from your mutuel if you have one. You only pay in full if you're not in the system yet, in which case you should have PHI to cover it.

In France healthcare is funded through 'social contributions' as part of your taxes. I believe it's 8% of your salary. The state then pays approx 70% of your costs unless you see a super-expensive doctor who charges more than the government-agreed fees. The other 30% comes from your mutuel (top-up insurance), which is optional and costs around €100 a month (variable according to age and how much cover you want). So it can be more complicated in terms of getting reimbursed but is not dissimilar to the NHS, though a little more expensive overall.

I was really making the point that if you have to pay/claim back it reduces the number of time wasters and also reminds people that health care, even seeing a gp for 10mins, had to be paid for by someone.

Splutteramo · 07/10/2022 07:19

You don’t need one that’s why! They aren’t going to wait time and resources when you might need a better shampoo!
get a private one done if your so fussed….

Lalliella · 07/10/2022 07:17

Have you actually read anything at all about the state of the NHS? People with actual things wrong with them can’t get treatment. Stop wasting their time and resources.

NoNotHimTheOtherOne · 07/10/2022 07:15

Maybe if there was a national mentality that people should be encouraged to test regularly, just maybe, we could prevent some types of illness that are currently utilising NHS resources.

Test what, though? There are thousands of things that can be measured in blood samples. If you do all of them for every patient, apart from the massive cost, there is also an almost 100% probability of at least one false positive result, resulting in patients' potentially being treated for conditions they don't have. This is one of the biggest causes of medical error leading to patient harm in private insurance-based healthcare systems.

Natsku · 07/10/2022 07:14

YABU to ask for those blood tests for those reasons. If you showed ill health symptoms of deficiencies then yeah, but not for dry hair and wondering if you're supplementing enough (just keep supplementing, everyone should be taking vit D).

But it would be ideal if people could get regular (e.g. yearly or every few years) basic blood screens and health check ups done for preventative health reasons but there's no way the NHS can afford that when its been under-funded for so long. I'm glad I moved to a country where I get regular health check ups with my occupational healthcare (including vision and hearing tests, picked up my anaemia returning) and the unemployed are entitled to free check ups on the public system (I had one once, was good) but the public system is better funded and occupational healthcare is commonplace (I think required by law maybe).

AllLopsided · 07/10/2022 07:14

Lopilo · 07/10/2022 06:49

In France, you generally have to pay a fee to see a GP. Posts like this make me realise why.

This is a bit misleading - it's only €25 and you can claim most of it back from CPAM, and the rest from your mutuel if you have one. You only pay in full if you're not in the system yet, in which case you should have PHI to cover it.

In France healthcare is funded through 'social contributions' as part of your taxes. I believe it's 8% of your salary. The state then pays approx 70% of your costs unless you see a super-expensive doctor who charges more than the government-agreed fees. The other 30% comes from your mutuel (top-up insurance), which is optional and costs around €100 a month (variable according to age and how much cover you want). So it can be more complicated in terms of getting reimbursed but is not dissimilar to the NHS, though a little more expensive overall.

womaninatightspot · 07/10/2022 07:12

isthismylifenow · 07/10/2022 06:19

To the PP re the 8000 pound test...

How did you come up with that figure?

(I think that person has been watching Chicago Med as if anyone goes there they get every test from the alphabet, plus an mri and cat scan. I could understand that figure then, yes)

And for the OP, a hair mask and hair and nails vitamins will most likely help.

It is crazy money but they do throw tests at you if they can’t figure out what’s wrong. I was ill last year had a lumbar puncture, ct scan, mri and so, so many blood tests.

sadly my hair is still frizzy.

ducktape · 07/10/2022 07:08

I had similar concerns and paid for a thriva test to test levels of vitamin d, b vitamins and iron. All were very low, but very low iron / ferritin was why my hair was not just dry, but falling out. I started taking supplements and have retested at 6-12 month intervals. Thriva showed the previous results and the trend which i found very helpful. Other tests are available, but this is the only one I've used. I would definitely recommend it if you can afford it (about £60 for them all, I think)

womaninatightspot · 07/10/2022 07:07

AlmostAJillSandwich · 06/10/2022 22:37

It costs the NHS £8000 to do a blood panel, and you want them to do that for dry hair?!

No really? I was hospitalised last year and thought I must be properly ill as they gave me so many blood tests. Trying to figure what the problem was.

PortalooSunset · 07/10/2022 07:05

Mine refused to do a clinically indicated test requested by my consultant. They said it was because it was a specialist test and they're generalists so wouldn't be able to interpret the results (though I suspect there was at least a little of 'if the consultant wants it then it shouldn't have to come out of our budget').
The tests were requested to see if one of my medications needed changing. Despite being generalists they were happy to make that change without the test 🤔