Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

These women don’t have the right to complain

140 replies

Cheeseplants · 06/10/2022 21:54

That their baby’s father is a deadbeat, when they told them from the start they didn’t want a child with them.

Like what did they expect?
I’m all for women having the right to choose, but when you choose to give birth to a child that’s dad does not want him/her… are you justified in complaining about that man when the child is born and isn’t playing daddy?

YABU- yes they have the right to complain
YANBU- no they shouldn’t complain

OP posts:
Ponoka7 · 08/10/2022 13:22

Velvian · 08/10/2022 10:12

@Anniefrenchfry , I'd be intrigued to know how many men present themselves as losers with no concept of responsibility as a seduction technique. I'm not sure if the scenario suggested exists at all.

Have a watch of the old Jeremy Kyle's (no I wasn't a fan) but I've lived among people who live like his guests do. I look at the beautiful teen girls who do the full makeup/hair/lashes and who go with the lads who wear black north face head to toe and ride the Peds/smoke weed and just think wtf!. Theres loser dads who have 2-10 (no exaggeration) who land woman after woman and these are working women, not just those living on benefits etc.

Chonfox · 08/10/2022 12:22

Silly comment. Of course they have a right. If a man has sex with a woman without precautions he runs the risk of becoming a father. He then has a responsibility to step up. He had the option of condoms or a vasectomy to f he really doesn't want to become a dad.

BeautifulDragon · 08/10/2022 11:44

Some people just make very poor choices.

If a man promises the world and suddenly changed when you get pregnant (it happens!) YABU. But if he's always been aggressive/lazy/unmotivated/whatever, then choosing to have a baby with him and being shocked he continues to behave as previously mentioned then...YANBU

However, I see lots of people like this through work and they almost always have issues/ past trauma themselves. It's hardly ever a simple situation.

The same as people who have more children then they can comfortably care for etc.

chocolatemademefat · 08/10/2022 11:33

Oooh you’re brave! Although secretly I agree with you. Some women always think they’ll be the one to change a man - oh he’ll love the baby sooo much that we’ll live happily ever after. Em - no you won’t. You’ll be left bringing up a child on your own and possibly struggling to get by.

And where will the prize specimen of manhood be? Cozying down with the next woman willing to be with someone like him. And I know he didn’t choose to have a baby but he obviously didn’t take any precautions either.

Mumoblue · 08/10/2022 11:19

@Cheeseplants

Can I ask, are you a single parent yourself?

Because my point was kind of that I didn’t get lied to (at least not about that) - he did want our son. He still admits he wanted our son, but if he thinks it’ll get him sympathy, he’ll lie to others about it.

Being a single parent, our society judges you guilty before they find out why anyway. You’re automatically treated like you did something wrong and have something to apologise for. I’m not really sure what the point is of making a thread about an already shit-on demographic just to point out that you don’t feel sorry for a portion of them. It seems pretty mean spirited.

KosherDill · 08/10/2022 11:18

Women that choose to get pregnant to men they know will be useless fathers and partners or to claim benefits are on the scale of few to mythical.

This just isn't true.

On Mumsnet alone we constantly have OPs along the likes of "he has 4 kids from 3 other women, hasn't seen two of them in a year.. but he said it would be different with ours..now he's gone and left me and our newborn .."

Or the ever popular "My partner has no job, no friends, games all night long and ignores me unless he wants sex or food; we've been together six months and when i fell pregnant five months ago he promised to find work but now gets angry when i mention it.."

The examples are endless!

Sorry but the OP is right; women who are willing to hook up with any old loser do not have a right to complain or play victim when the predictable outcome ensues.

Velvian · 08/10/2022 11:17

@Cheeseplants , I don't understand how you know which women's are the ones that you want to discriminate against and which are not. That is why I say you only have the choice of all or none. No situation is black and white, which is precisely why I don't understand how you make your judgement.

Ilovemycatalot · 08/10/2022 11:07

Men can and do lie. My dd dad told me he would support me and wanted her as much as I did. Yet he left me as soon as she was born. Together 6 yrs married….

Ponoka7 · 08/10/2022 11:07

@Keyansier , you can have unprotected sex when you are HIV positive. Generally when you are medicated and your viral load is under a certain amount. We now know more about transmission and most women don't carry the virus in intimate body fluids.

It's correct that women do pick the father of their children. If a man states that he doesn't want to be a father, it's upto you if you have sex with him without protection. If you are having casual sex and don't want to be a LP, use double protection. He will still be financially responsible. If you are in a relationship with that man, then you make your decision to be a LP or not. It must be galling when they want to know once the child is an adult, though. Women have the right to give their children up for adoption, they don't have to inform the father.

No-one can get themselves into a situation that they knew would happen beforehand and then legitimately complain.

bingbummy · 08/10/2022 11:07

Cheeseplants · 06/10/2022 22:17

I shouldn’t have said ‘right’ to complain. That wasn’t accurate because everyone has a right to complain, but I struggle to feel sympathy for the women that do this.

She didn't do it, they did.

Velvian · 08/10/2022 11:04

I haven't seen you present any facts @Anniefrenchfry . I told you the facts of my own situation and pointed out that I was subject to the views you promote.

As I said, you can only really choose to tar all women with that brush or none of them. Women that choose to get pregnant to men they know will be useless fathers and partners or to claim benefits are on the scale of few to mythical.

It is far safer to avoid judgement than to rush to it. You never know when your own circumstances may change to tip you into the unacceptable bracket.

KosherDill · 08/10/2022 10:49

Kendodd · 08/10/2022 10:36

Ok, let's say the women don't have a right to complain.
Does the child have a right to complain about deadbeat dad?
And if the child does have a right to complain, does the childs mother have a right to advocate for her childs needs?

The child's mother chooses the dad, always.

The best way to advocate for the child's needs is to be very, very discriminating in the choice of its father. Before conception.

WhileMyGuitarGentlyWeeps · 08/10/2022 10:49

I find this hard to answer, as I don't know any women who deliberately and purposely got pregnant, when their DH/DP stated categorically that he didn't want a baby. Do women really do that?

I suppose if it DOES happen, then no, they can't complain if the man/father of the baby doesn't want anything to do with the baby. Then again, why are men having sex with women without a condom if they DEFINITELY don't want children? He can say he wants nothing to do with the baby, but he should be forced to pay up for its keep. Takes two to Tango and all that!

Anniefrenchfry · 08/10/2022 10:48

Velvian · 08/10/2022 10:28

Personally, I don't think I'm the one the naive view. @Anniefrenchfry I'm a very cynical, middle aged mother of 3. Sexually abused in my adolescence and teens, teenage pregnancies, former single mother.

Do you think I was exempt from the attitudes you mention, due to the fact that I was a groomed child, insufficiently protected by my parents and other adults?

Do you suppose that I have not been subject to character assassination and verbal abuse for my DC's lifetime by the man that abused me and his family? He didn't stop to think, 'hang on a minute, this woman has single handedly brought up my child, with zero financial contribution from me'

I also internalised this to my mid thirties, carrying 'the shame' of being a teenage mother. Far harder than that was when I realised that it wasn't actually my shame to carry. It was quite easy to live with it all being 'my fault'.

Eh what? I don’t know you and make no assumptions about you as a random onhere, what an odd question. You stated men don’t present themselves as losers with no concept of responsibility and I responded telling you factually that they do. And quite a lot of them.

Cheeseplants · 08/10/2022 10:47

@Velvian Why can I only choose all or none? That’s very black and white and the topics surrounding this are not.
I’ve made it clear in my posts which women I’m talking about and it’s definitely not every woman who has a deadbeat dad. Because some deadbeats don’t look like deadbeats when you first meet them, and they tell you they want kids with you blah blah and then you are, rightfully, shocked and disappointed when you find out it was all a facade and that he’s a deadbeat.
I’m only talking of the women who saw a deadbeat, knew he was one, shagged him and then suddenly they’re shocked when he continues acting the same way he was when they met him.

OP posts:
Velvian · 08/10/2022 10:39

@Cheeseplants How do you know which mothers to unleash your judgement upon? You can only really choose all or none.

Angelinflipflops · 08/10/2022 10:38

*on here

Angelinflipflops · 08/10/2022 10:37

Doggydoos- completely agree, the judgement are here is from the dark ages, it seems women must remain chaste until marriage, and if you have a contraception failure, you are to blame

olivehater · 08/10/2022 10:37

It’s one thing telling a woman you want her to have and abortion. It’s quite another thing to go through the act of getting an abortion. Can you not see how that might weigh more heavily on a person.
Not to mention that it is technically illegal in this country to have an abortion for social reasons. It is only allowed on the pretense that it is to protect the woman's mental health.

Kendodd · 08/10/2022 10:36

Ok, let's say the women don't have a right to complain.
Does the child have a right to complain about deadbeat dad?
And if the child does have a right to complain, does the childs mother have a right to advocate for her childs needs?

Cheeseplants · 08/10/2022 10:32

@Mumoblue I’m not talking about your case at all. I feel for women in these scenarios and can understand your outrage because you were LIED to.
However plenty of women were not lied to. They knew he didn’t want kids and still chose to risk pregnancy, give birth and then be annoyed he didn’t step up.

OP posts:
OlympicProcrastinator · 08/10/2022 10:31

Kosherdill, so in the early stages of dating, when you might not know all the guys flaws, you're not meant to have sex with them

Well there is a school of thought that, as pregnancy often results in pregnancy, whether you use contraception or not, it is indeed better to refrain from casual sex and be in a serious relationship before doing so. Because that would be an awful lot better on the whole for children and society.

But that is considered very old fashioned I know.

Toomanysleepycats · 08/10/2022 10:31

I would have thought the number of men who make it loud and clear they don’t/won’t be a ‘dad’ before they have unprotected sex must be very small.

If they are the sort to be very upfront about it, then I bet they have protected sex.

Its the other ones I think a lot of women fall foul of. They don’t declare their position, not only about being a father, but also wether they are even going to be a long term partner. I have seen so many posts where a partner, a husband, has walked out during pregnancy. The woman will often say that this is a planned pregnancy.

So YABU, I think a lot of these women are the victim to duplicitous males.

I will always feel sorry for them.

Johnnysgirl · 08/10/2022 10:30

JulesCobb · 06/10/2022 22:01

I dont know who you are talking about, but why cant hey not complain about deadbeat fathers? How hard is it to wear a condom?

Probably no harder than insisting he wears a condom, to be completely fair.

Velvian · 08/10/2022 10:28

Personally, I don't think I'm the one the naive view. @Anniefrenchfry I'm a very cynical, middle aged mother of 3. Sexually abused in my adolescence and teens, teenage pregnancies, former single mother.

Do you think I was exempt from the attitudes you mention, due to the fact that I was a groomed child, insufficiently protected by my parents and other adults?

Do you suppose that I have not been subject to character assassination and verbal abuse for my DC's lifetime by the man that abused me and his family? He didn't stop to think, 'hang on a minute, this woman has single handedly brought up my child, with zero financial contribution from me'

I also internalised this to my mid thirties, carrying 'the shame' of being a teenage mother. Far harder than that was when I realised that it wasn't actually my shame to carry. It was quite easy to live with it all being 'my fault'.