Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To expect to keep my full car allowance even though I'm part time?

95 replies

PoppyBlunt · 06/10/2022 20:52

I know most companies pro rata car allowance for PT employees.

I went PT (4 days a week) 4 years ago. When I did so my car allowance remained in full and was not pro rata.

I have recently been promoted and with the grade change have an increased car allowance. The grade I was at has an allowance of 5.5k pa and the new grade allowance is 7.5k pa.

HR have taken an age to send my contract and I was paid before receiving it. I was paid the 7k car allowance in full rather than pro rata.

My contract (yet to sign) is saying it is pro rata i.e. 6k.

AIBU to push back on my contract and state there is a precedent (as I was paid it in full for 4 years) and also that I've been paid for the full amount with my new package?

Anyone got any HR insight on this?

OP posts:
rwalker · 07/10/2022 10:27

Why not go ok the full way and ask for full wages on pt hours while your at it

PurpleBananas22 · 07/10/2022 10:24

WireSkills · 07/10/2022 10:13

I can see both sides of this as, as an employee, it's not like you can lease a car for 3/5 days per week.

On the other hand, if you had 2 people job sharing over a 5 day week, if the employer paid for all of the car, they would be funding 2 car allowances, so that's not fair on them either.

Ultimately there is no regulation or requirement to do it one way or the other - it just comes down to negotiation.

But this isn't about a job share so that doesn't apply here.

It's a fact that part time employees do cost an employer more than full time... the employer has to pay full car allowance, full health insurance, life insurance premiums and other benefits like training courses etc at the full rate, for 2 people.

So 2 part timers at 50% will cost the employer more than 1 full timer.

To most organisations this is just factored in to the budget.

WireSkills · 07/10/2022 10:13

I can see both sides of this as, as an employee, it's not like you can lease a car for 3/5 days per week.

On the other hand, if you had 2 people job sharing over a 5 day week, if the employer paid for all of the car, they would be funding 2 car allowances, so that's not fair on them either.

Ultimately there is no regulation or requirement to do it one way or the other - it just comes down to negotiation.

PurpleBananas22 · 07/10/2022 09:41

The over payment is at their discretion. They can either let it go , claw the difference back or you own them a days pay but playing the barrack room lawyer never goes down well. No one is indispensable. Just be careful.

This is so disappointing and sad to read. 'Just be careful'?? Why? Would you even think about saying that to a man? OP has gained a promotion because she is good at her job. They're not going to demote her because she asks a question about her employment contract! Good grief.

It wasn't an overpayment - it was a term of OP's previous contract.

They can't claw back the difference as there is nothing to claw back.

And she certainty doesn't owe them a days pay! Honestly this advice would be funny if it wasn't such a serious issue.

for those of you struggling to understand why OP should receive the full car allowance... the easiest way is to think of it as a car. Can you get half a car? No. She would get a whole car.

For those of you saying 'but it's not a car it's an allowance'.... yes, but the allowance is in lieu of the car, so again, she could ask for a car instead of the allowance and they would give her a full car

Same with other benefits. You get a whole laptop and mobile phone. You get the same level of health insurance, dental insurance etc. these are paid for by the company and don't get reduced to a lower or less funding from the employer.

The other part of this conversation is that part time workers are overwhelmingly female. So reducing part timers car allowance is potentially discrimination.

A car allowance is not treated the same way as salary, pension and annual leave. The PP who had a snipe at OP about asking for more annual leave clearly doesn't understand the issue here.

dolorsit · 07/10/2022 09:33

I used to deal with setting up company car usage (more on dealing with organising the lease side)

The email we would send to the employee would tell them the value of the car they were entitled to or the car allowance they could receive.

This was based on job role or employee grade (eg some got it as they needed the vehicle to do their job, others because it was a management perk)

The number of hours they worked was irrelevant in both cases.

Weirdlynormal · 07/10/2022 09:17

UnderCoverFieldAgent · 07/10/2022 09:09

You CFer!! I dare you to ask for full holiday entitlement too…go on, I bet you would 😂

Staggering

Mademoiselle14 · 07/10/2022 09:15

YANBU its a benefit in kind so you should get the full allowance, if you had a company car you would still be allowed to drive it on the day you didn’t work.

ShipwreckSunset · 07/10/2022 09:14

Genuinely amazed by some of the posts on here saying OP is ‘lucky’ and entitled… women can be their own worst advocates sometimes.

Good luck with the negotiation OP, there are plenty of examples where PT are paid full car allowance and rightly so. If they make a fuss I’d be tempted to take the car instead. The whole car that is 😉

UnderCoverFieldAgent · 07/10/2022 09:09

You CFer!! I dare you to ask for full holiday entitlement too…go on, I bet you would 😂

TheStoop · 07/10/2022 09:06

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

Zilla1 · 07/10/2022 08:56

I wouldn't expect FT pension or salary if PT but would expect a full company car or car allowance if essential for the role, an entire laptop and mobile phone and all the tools of the job not to be pro rata. Am genuinely surprised by the 'entitled' PPs and those who would expect to be grateful for a promotion. The employer would only offer a promotion if it were in their interests.

Jackienory · 07/10/2022 08:39

boogiejive · 06/10/2022 21:30

While it's delightful reading some of this drivel, you should expect the full car allowance. As PP says a company car would be wholly yours. The cash allowance is to provide you for a car - the garage won't charge you 90% of the value because you work 90%.

Raise it with them.

But it’s a car allowance, that’s the point. And the value of that “allowance” is specified in the new contract. If you want the reduced hours then thems the terms of the contract. If you don’t sign the contract then, presumably, you are back to your original job/hours or possibly redundant. The over payment is at their discretion. They can either let it go , claw the difference back or you own them a days pay but playing the barrack room lawyer never goes down well. No one is indispensable. Just be careful.

Weirdlynormal · 07/10/2022 08:37

@PoppyBlunt if it’s male dominated I’d put good money on you already earning less than many of the men.

All of this is a conversation.

Brunonono · 07/10/2022 08:35

*lower salary that should say

Brunonono · 07/10/2022 08:35

You should definitely bring it up and I'm amazed how many people are saying not to!

In my view, this is a benefit of employment not a salary for hours worked. Part time staff should get the same benefits of employment. If it were private health cover, would everyone say a part time member of staff should get lesser cover or top it up? Either it's a benefit for people at a certain grade or it's not. Similarly benefits continue during periods of salary (e.g. maternity) as the benefits are separated from salary and salary is linked to hours worked.

As others said - what would a man do?!

PoppyBlunt · 07/10/2022 08:29

Thank you for all the comments and input. It's genuinely really helpful to get lots of different thoughts and experiences. I'm going to negotiate and see what they say.

I work in a very male dominated industry and the significant majority of us that are PT are women. So hopefully I'll be advocate for others too.

I'll report back...

OP posts:
massistar · 07/10/2022 08:27

Mine was pro rated when I was PT. Always seemed a bit unfair to me. I'd push back if I was you. You've nothing to lose by questioning it?

PoppyBlunt · 07/10/2022 08:22

Subaru4336 · 06/10/2022 22:13

I'd be careful, my employer mistakenly paid me full car allowance, despite being p/t...and then noticed and I had to pay it back. Somewhat naively, I hadn't actually noticed, so hadn't been trying to get one over on them or anything.

I'll be doing everything above board.

OP posts:
countrygirl99 · 07/10/2022 08:20

It really depends on why you get a car allowance. If you need one to do your job absolutely you should get the full allowance. But most "car allowances" are a hangover from.when it was a tax efficient way of paying someone and nothing to do with need. These days it's mostly a way of not having part of the salary included in redundancy/pension contribution calculations. So then you needy to look at it as partof the overall benefit package that you would usually expect to be pro-rata for part time.

PoppyBlunt · 07/10/2022 08:19

Hotandbothereds · 06/10/2022 23:29

If you accept they made a mistake why on earth do you think they’ll go back to continuing to make it now it’s been corrected?

I think you're missing the point. I'm assuming it was a mistake based on the fact that my new contract sets out pro rata and the old one didn't.

I'm hoping they'll amend new contract on the basis of what most other posters are saying here.

OP posts:
daisymoo2 · 07/10/2022 08:12

I’m really surprised so many of you think it’s reasonable to expect benefits to be paid in full when working a PT contract. It’s a car ‘allowance’ that’s being offered, not a car itself. I’ve never known the car allowance not to be pro rated and I’ve been part time for 15 years.

Does everyone expect to receive full time employer pension contributions too?

Glittertwins · 07/10/2022 08:09

But I don't need my car for work, it's a bit of an old policy and new people to my grade no longer get the car or allowance

Glittertwins · 07/10/2022 08:05

We can only have pro-rata car allowance if we are part time, not the car for this kind of issue.

NightmareSlashDelightful · 07/10/2022 07:57

I think you certainly have a legitimate reason to push back; a precedent has been created for them paying you a full car allowance on a pro rated salary for four years. It’s not like they did it for two months and then rectified.

However, they’re not necessarily obliged to continue to give you the full allowance. So you might have to accept it.

It’s certainly worth a conversation though.

Weirdlynormal · 07/10/2022 07:57

LimboLass · 07/10/2022 00:07

Entitled thread of the year is now closed.

We have a winner right here.

@LimboLass I assume you're low paid if you accept what they 'give you' for your time, labour, IP, and skills?

What a crazy attitude. I'm genuinely quite shocked. What's entitled about negotiating the best deal you can for your services.