Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Does this financially ring true?

434 replies

ManyBooksLittleTime · 06/10/2022 19:48

We bought our house nearly 20 years ago for 245k. Now, 19 years later, we still have 203k left on the mortgage. I know the first years is basically paying interest , but only 42k in 19 years??? We have had good interest rates too.Also, my husband reckons it will go down to 181k by August next year. Please can soneone more astute with finance let me know if these numbers can be right?

OP posts:
whereeverilaymycat · 07/10/2022 12:33

ChickenyChick · 07/10/2022 11:15

your husband writing things down means nothing

He's not necessarily deceitful

But from what you said earlier, he does not understand what compound interest is.

Do either of you understand this concept? Because to be fair most people don't, and then you get these shocks.

Long term borrowing is hugely costly, basically

Plus turning unsecured debt to a secured debt is always best avoided if possible.

TheSheerCheekOfSomePeople · 07/10/2022 12:27

I agree with @Pheefifofuckthisshit that perhaps you need to get to the bottom of this with an accountant or IFA first. Depends on what you know about your relationship and how things tend to go. And whether you are on the mortgage and can get your own copies or not.

I was going to say anyway OP, more generally, that I suggest you check your credit file as a matter of urgency. Because even if you are not on this mortgage if you are linked financially in any way ie you have a joint account or joint bill then this and any other debts he has could be causing you problems. And if you are on this mortgage then his trouble is yours too in terms of being personally responsible for this very large debt. Although it is anyway considering you live there and contribute but in a different sense.

Also OP you can talk to an IFA or Citizen's Advice or Debt Service (a charitable one, not a for-profit one) at any time regarding your own situation and I think you should. Likewise a solicitor. You don't need his permission or to take him along or to tell him. There is also a lot of financial education information on websites such as Which? and MoneySavingExpert and ThisIsMoney (from the Daily Mail - yes, I know, but it's good) so it would be a good idea to educate yourself about finances more generally as knowledge is power.

CosyDarkNights · 07/10/2022 12:24

You've not only paid back 42k, you've borrowed more on more than 1 occasion. You aren't going to see the amount you owe go down massively if you keep adding to the debt! How much have you actually borrowed in total?

TheSheerCheekOfSomePeople · 07/10/2022 12:19

hope he can remember how much we borrowed.

If he can't remember, "can't remember" or even if he apparently can, the best thing to do is to check the paperwork. If you can't find it he can request replacement documentation from the provider(s). If you are also on those mortgages you can yourself without his permission.

You need to have a tough talk with your husband about finances and how from now on today you are going to be fully involved. Maybe you have just been letting him get on with it and he's not very good with figures and thinks that you agreed and completely understood each time you borrowed more what the consequences were in which case that is your mistake for not taking joint responsibility and perhaps being too trusting in which case you need to tell him your concerns without blaming him alone. But maybe he is financially abusing you by making it difficult for you to know what is going on while he controls the money however poorly. I don't know. Deep down you will know. Are there any other red flags in his behaviour other than a potential financial mess looming? How he responds to this conversation will be very telling.

CoffeeHousePot · 07/10/2022 12:18

Your husband is lying to you. You’ve either borrowed lots more. Or you have gone onto interest only for long periods.

We had a mortgage for 515K 7 years ago. 25 year mortgage. Our balance is 375 k now.

HoneyAndMonsters · 07/10/2022 12:14

Also, his comments about “paying the difference” between the purchase price and the value including interest makes it sound like it has been an interest only mortgage from the start. What was your deposit? Did the deposit take the outstanding initial debt down to £203K??
He would have to have ALSO taken out some sort of method to repay the bricks at the end of the interest only term. Otherwise, in effect, you will have been renting for 19 years and in another 8 years the bank will take back the house.

tiredofthiisshit21 · 07/10/2022 12:10

I think your husband is lying to you.

HoneyAndMonsters · 07/10/2022 12:09

Nothing adds up here. If you or your husband borrowed more against the mortgage, surely the borrowing period and repayment amounts would have been reviewed each time and a new statement produced. No way are you currently “overpaying” at £1.9k on a £203k repayment mortgage over 8 years. You are massively underpaying. If that is the repayment amount then the period must be much longer than 8 years. If he is secretly paying off a huge chunk in addition each month (to hide the fact he borrow ~£100k without your knowledge) then it might be plausible. The bank won’t lend unless the repayments over the term (8 years) will clear the debt.

Pheefifofuckthisshit · 07/10/2022 12:06

This sounds extremely dodgy. I'd be getting everything in writing, all statements and records and going over them yourself with independent help eg a forensic accountant or financial advisor.

Sorry but I'd be removing the husband from this conversation for now until I'd got to the bottom of things.

TimeForMeToF1y · 07/10/2022 12:04

Given that the OP is rather hazy on the details I think it's only fair to wait and see what the mortgage statements say before condeming the husband as having some kind of secret addiction

Dishwashersaurous · 07/10/2022 11:45

So how much have you actually borrowed in total?

what is the total mortgage?

Then you can work out how much you've actually paid off

Thelittleweasel · 07/10/2022 11:45

@ManyBooksLittleTime

If you are "overpaying" and hope to pay off your £200000 odd in 8 years you must be paying in the region of £25000+ per year or £2000+ per month.

Does that seem feasible? Is it on your bank statements as a regular outgoing?

Tigofigo · 07/10/2022 11:25

We've paid off about £60k of our similar sized mortgage, without overpaying, in 10 years, so I would expect in 20 years you would have paid off well over £100k. But you've only paid £40k...

ChickenyChick · 07/10/2022 11:15

your husband writing things down means nothing

He's not necessarily deceitful

But from what you said earlier, he does not understand what compound interest is.

Do either of you understand this concept? Because to be fair most people don't, and then you get these shocks.

Long term borrowing is hugely costly, basically

fromdownwest · 07/10/2022 11:12

pattihews · 07/10/2022 10:17

I'd be interested to know who/ what this company advising you and apparently managing your mortgage applications is? Is it some self-proclaimed financial advisor mate of your husband's? Is it someone who's making a percentage of every new mortgage contract you sign — so will steer your husband to a product that suits the advisor rather than you, the clients?

Back in the 1980s a friend introduced me to someone they thought was a qualified accountant do some work for me. He subsequently 'advised' me on my mortgage. It was only five years later, when I remortgaged, that I discovered that he wasn't a qualified accountant, I was paying a ridiculously high rate and that my 'accountant'/ advisor had had an £2k introduction fee from my mortgage provider and was getting £50 from my mortgage payment each month — and would have done for the whole 25 years if I hadn't remortgaged. That a**ehole made £5k from me. Is that where all your money's going too?

Mortgage Advisors no longer make a % of the mortgage as a payment. and have done so for some time. They receive payment from the lender which is for the work invovled in arranging it.
This does not get paid by the client, and does not increased the rate charged.

Anniefrenchfry · 07/10/2022 10:59

Tessasanderson · 07/10/2022 10:43

Where has it been proven that the husband has lied to the OP? She has little understanding of whats going on, is very vague discussing actual figures and at no point has she stated that he has refused to tell her any details over the 20yrs.

Is that lying?

did You not read all her posts? His explanation of why they have so much left is a clear lie. The man has borrowed between 100-140 grand extra and probably moved to interest only as well. There is no other way they still owe so much

mewkins · 07/10/2022 10:56

You don't have to get him to explain anything. You can simply look at all the mortgage statements. I would guess he has remortgaged several times without you knowing and used the money for stuff he wishes to hide from you.

Kennykenkencat · 07/10/2022 10:50

uiyo7987 · 06/10/2022 23:19

Also surely you must have switched mortgage provider over 20 years. I understand that a lot of people dont switch every two years but you must have moved your mortgage onto lower rates over that time?

I think the million pound house was in response to me. However, I think your house would have to be 1mil by now if it was 240 in 2002. I mean i just checked local houses here in London and any house that cost that much back in 2002 is worth at least 850k right now. And where other than London would you have bought a house for 245k back in 2002. That was a lot of money back then - that got you a nice three bed house in what is now considered to be very desirable parts of SW and North London.

Not all places go up uniformly

I had a similar priced property in 2004 on the outskirts of London which I sold last year. No where near the £1million or £850,000 mark
And we didn’t overpay in the beginning. It was considered a bit of a bargain.

Tessasanderson · 07/10/2022 10:43

Anniefrenchfry · 07/10/2022 10:29

Because he’s lying to her. Clearly.

I agree that she’s went through live unawares and let him deal with it, it’s mind boggling the extreme of it , I grant you, but he’s lying.

now he may have done it for good reason ie they have been living well above their means, but he has likely borrowed 100-140 grand extra.

Where has it been proven that the husband has lied to the OP? She has little understanding of whats going on, is very vague discussing actual figures and at no point has she stated that he has refused to tell her any details over the 20yrs.

Is that lying?

chesirecat99 · 07/10/2022 10:41

Your husband is right that borrowing £245k at 4% interest will cost you about £388k in total on a 25 year mortgage. Your mortgage statement wouldn't say £388k, it will state the amount owed without interest ie £245k at the start, the outstanding balance excluding interest (ie how much you would have to pay the bank if you settled the mortgage in full in one payment) thereafter.

At the beginning of the term, most of your monthly payments are paying the interest on £245k so only a small amount is paid off. The next year, you are paying interest on, say £240k, so the interest payments are a bit less, and more gets paid off. The MSE calculator linked below shows you how the it works in a graph. You should owe close to £100k with 8 years to go.

www.moneysavingexpert.com/mortgages/mortgage-rate-calculator/

Two things don't add up about your DH's story:

  1. You should owe less than £200k now, even with additional borrowing of 2 x £7k
  2. If you have 8 years left on your 25 year term, and pay £1.9k per month, you will only pay £182k in total in that time. That isn't enough to cover the outstanding £203k, let alone the £203k plus interest. The bank wouldn't allow there to be an outstanding balance at the end of the term. Your DH must have extended the term.

I don't think just extending the term fully explains why you still owe so much after 20 years, unless he extended it by a long time. Either he has borrowed more than the 2 x £7k or he has taken a mortgage holiday at some point or changed to interest only.

EmmaH2022 · 07/10/2022 10:33

Annie "Because he’s lying to her. Clearly."

but if OP is named on the mortgage, surely she will have had to read and sign paperwork each time a change was made?

Anniefrenchfry · 07/10/2022 10:29

Tessasanderson · 07/10/2022 10:08

Why is everyone trying to make out the husband is evil here?

It happens in lots of relationships even though we dont like to admit it. DH assumes the role of breadwinner and controller of funds and DW enjoys life blissfully unaware or interested in how the money is used.

I have read this thread and the OP comes across exactly this way. She has little knowledge of the past 20yrs finances. She has taken little interest in them and talks about 'extras' and 'credit card debt' as though they are of little importance. I am not sure she can account for any of the extra spending over the last 20yrs. It could be just getting by. I had a work collegue who found his wife £40k in debt and she hadnt purchased a single 'luxury item'. It was all family meals out, socializing and kids stuff.

So you have a DH making sure everything ticks over. Making decisions that effect the whole family and at a guess very open to discussing them with the OP who isnt really interested. Are you really telling me in 20yrs she hasnt had opportunities to raise this question multiple times.

If the DH is trying to clear £1900 per month off the mortgage then congratulations. He is doing something to sort the problem out. My guess is he is trying his best to let the OP know that things cant carry on the way they are and they probably need to reign it in a bit, especially seeing what interest rates are doing.

Because he’s lying to her. Clearly.

I agree that she’s went through live unawares and let him deal with it, it’s mind boggling the extreme of it , I grant you, but he’s lying.

now he may have done it for good reason ie they have been living well above their means, but he has likely borrowed 100-140 grand extra.

pattihews · 07/10/2022 10:17

I'd be interested to know who/ what this company advising you and apparently managing your mortgage applications is? Is it some self-proclaimed financial advisor mate of your husband's? Is it someone who's making a percentage of every new mortgage contract you sign — so will steer your husband to a product that suits the advisor rather than you, the clients?

Back in the 1980s a friend introduced me to someone they thought was a qualified accountant do some work for me. He subsequently 'advised' me on my mortgage. It was only five years later, when I remortgaged, that I discovered that he wasn't a qualified accountant, I was paying a ridiculously high rate and that my 'accountant'/ advisor had had an £2k introduction fee from my mortgage provider and was getting £50 from my mortgage payment each month — and would have done for the whole 25 years if I hadn't remortgaged. That a**ehole made £5k from me. Is that where all your money's going too?

Tessasanderson · 07/10/2022 10:08

Why is everyone trying to make out the husband is evil here?

It happens in lots of relationships even though we dont like to admit it. DH assumes the role of breadwinner and controller of funds and DW enjoys life blissfully unaware or interested in how the money is used.

I have read this thread and the OP comes across exactly this way. She has little knowledge of the past 20yrs finances. She has taken little interest in them and talks about 'extras' and 'credit card debt' as though they are of little importance. I am not sure she can account for any of the extra spending over the last 20yrs. It could be just getting by. I had a work collegue who found his wife £40k in debt and she hadnt purchased a single 'luxury item'. It was all family meals out, socializing and kids stuff.

So you have a DH making sure everything ticks over. Making decisions that effect the whole family and at a guess very open to discussing them with the OP who isnt really interested. Are you really telling me in 20yrs she hasnt had opportunities to raise this question multiple times.

If the DH is trying to clear £1900 per month off the mortgage then congratulations. He is doing something to sort the problem out. My guess is he is trying his best to let the OP know that things cant carry on the way they are and they probably need to reign it in a bit, especially seeing what interest rates are doing.

WireSkills · 07/10/2022 10:03

Bunce1 · 07/10/2022 09:45

Each time you reply op it’s clear you don’t understand the figures and I’m not saying that to put the boot in but you MUST take your statements and go see your provider or an independent financial provider and get some one to break it down for you.

there is no way you’ll be able to pay off £203k in 8 years unless you have some sort of windfall. The numbers do not stack up.

It is feasible, but the calculator shows £203,000 at 5.11% over 8 years as being £2,581 per month, which is a large amount.

If OP's husband is telling her they can pay it off at a lower amount in the same period, then he's either being mislead or he's misleading.

OP - The other thing I didn't mention is that if it transpires you've had bad deals because of your husband's (or your) lack of understanding, you may have a case for being mis-sold a product.

I remember years ago, when I was young and naïve, a mortgage broker (not independent, again in hindsight) convinced me and my ex to get an interest only mortgage with a separate endowment policy to cover the capital element.

It was all the rage back in the mid-90's, and they'd sold it to us on the basis that it was pretty much guaranteed that our endowment policy would end up way more than the capital element, so we'd actually be much better off.

A quick google will tell you how that ended up...

I never sought any compensation from the mis-selling because a) we only had the mortgage a couple of years and won't really have been massively financially disadvantaged; and b) it would probably mean having to contact me ex as we'd have to share any compensation - not appealing!

Swipe left for the next trending thread