Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Does this financially ring true?

434 replies

ManyBooksLittleTime · 06/10/2022 19:48

We bought our house nearly 20 years ago for 245k. Now, 19 years later, we still have 203k left on the mortgage. I know the first years is basically paying interest , but only 42k in 19 years??? We have had good interest rates too.Also, my husband reckons it will go down to 181k by August next year. Please can soneone more astute with finance let me know if these numbers can be right?

OP posts:
nomdegrrr1 · 07/10/2022 14:50

We got a mortgage in the early 1990s, endowment (interest only) never switched or remortgaged. I'm not incredibly clued up about mortgages. I'm posting this to see if anyone more knowledgeable of the markets then will have their memory jogged.

I knew at least one person who had this type of mortgage. You borrowed to buy a house and got the mortgage. As the value of the house rose, you could draw on the increase in value via the mortgage without a remortgage or revaluation. So if you bought a house worth 100k, got a mortgage for 95k, then house price inflation meant the house was supposedly now worth £150k, you could draw on or borrow the extra 55k at mortgage rates rather than personal loan or credit card rates.

When someone tried to persuade me to get this type of mortgage, I think I visibly recoiled and this type disappeared quite quickly. I think it was with the Woolwich, but my memory is rubbish these days. However, could it be something like this, where the money just bleeds out drip by drip?

There were other types from, I think, Virgin where the interest rate was linked to how much savings you had and that sort of thing could perhaps have also had an impact. And there were the 105% mortgages around as well at one point, which I thought was a disaster waiting to happen.

OP - I don't know if my ramblings are useful, but I think you need to get copies of absolutely everything and sit down with someone. You need to find a clear starting point and track from there. I hope that it's all sorted out soon.

TheSheerCheekOfSomePeople · 07/10/2022 14:49

I do think it is important at this point to be careful not to indicate to the lender that there might be problems arising. Make an excuse why you need the paperwork again or get an IFA to do it for you.

EstellaRijnveld · 07/10/2022 14:48

You need to switch to a repayment only mortgage op. You can switch brokers to see if you can get a better deal. I used London and Country, on recommendation from many here. I got a really good 5 Yr fixed rate mortgage with Nationwide via L&C.

www.landc.co.uk/

HideTheCroissants · 07/10/2022 14:34

ZealAndArdour · 07/10/2022 01:13

They won’t have any equity if they’ve been on an interest only mortgage all that time?

Yes they would! Paid £70,000 for my house with a £66,500 pound interest only mortgage. 25 years later the house was worth £350,000 - that’s equity of £283,000. We could have sold our four bedroom house, paid the mortgage off and bought something smaller for £250,000 outright. As it was we paid off the mortgage with SOME of the proceeds of an endowment policy and stayed in this house.

Clockwatching54321 · 07/10/2022 14:22

We had around the same a few years ago and in 5 years ours is down to 210k on a 35 year mortgage. There is something very suspicious going on. Big red alarm bells for me

2bazookas · 07/10/2022 14:12

uiyo7987 · 07/10/2022 13:24

My point about house prices is that rather than try and pay all of this off - i.e. quite a large mortgage at a time when interest rates are rising and now they've hit middle age is perhaps to downsize. I mean yes they can spend the next 10/20 years paying 2000 plus on the house and be stressed about. Or they can just downsize. That wasnt simply a comment on house prices but also on a way out of the problem without having to spend all their spare cash on paying off the house in their latter years

Their debt is close to maturity.

Note, the OP's DH is looking for NEW mortgage lenders to bail him out. Maybe he's as economical to them with his payment history, as he is to OP.

Every other mortgage lender is frantically backpedalling away from risky new borrowers. I'd have thought DH is well and truly in the "not with a bargepole" category.

IamtheDevilsAvocado · 07/10/2022 14:03

ManyBooksLittleTime · 06/10/2022 20:18

Thanks for all of your advice. The mortgage is definitely in my name too. I just think we have borrowed far more than I thought. So I think that when I've come to sign, I must have been looking at new monthly figures and interest rates rather than how much we were borrowing and the complete figure. Our interest rate is great at under 1 per cent, but DH wondering about changing now as we have this fixed term until August. He is worried that in August the interest rates will be through the roof. At least in 8 years it sounds as though the bulk of it will be paid off.

What he thinks he's borrowed is immaterial.

Please contact the company direct and ask for a full statement to be sent to your email only.

Continuing to believe what he tells you /or beleives... Is putting you in a risky position!

IamtheDevilsAvocado · 07/10/2022 13:55

ManyBooksLittleTime · 06/10/2022 19:58

Definitely 203k left. Paying 1.9 k a month now

I'd be really concerned if this was me.

How did you not have sight of any of the statements over this time?

Why is your husband being quiet (shifty?) about this?

Hasnhe been borrowing more money without your knowledge.

These figures just don't make sense.!

Anniefrenchfry · 07/10/2022 13:51

Actually I was just rereading rhe ops posts and the husband might not be lying it might be she’s just no clue and paid no attention.

what makes me think it is these statements..

He said that if we bought a house for 245 at 4 per cent it's the same as buying a house for 356k and that we have been paying off the difference

this tells me it’s interest only, he’s trying to explain to her the interest was what took it to 356 and that’s what they have being paying, that it wasn’t a repayment mortgage.

we started getting into debt 20 years ago paying for childcare for me to work.

I suspect they had a lot more debt that]n she knew and he’s increased rhe mortgage to pay for it as they have been living above their means. So when the debt became too much they remortgaged and added to the mortgage and used the money to pay the debt off.

reigatecastle · 07/10/2022 13:35

Something has gone on. We had a mortgage of about £185K over 20 years and after 13 years there was £65Kish left on it to pay off. So you should have paid off a lot more than you have. It does look like there have been extra borrowings but why do you not know about them, you must have had to sign for it. Or is it only in your DH's name?

Itstheeconomystupid · 07/10/2022 13:27

Are you able to use Excel?

It's very easy to work out mortgage interest and capital repayment with a simple Excel function.

Use the PMT function

For example
=PMT(3%/12, 120,100000,1)
gives you the monthly payment required to pay off a 100k debt, over 10 years, at 3% interest, assuming monthly payments (12 per year, 120 in total over 10 years)

Set up your worksheet so you can play around with the interest rate, number of years to pay off, etc. Once you get comfortable with the basics you can add in effects of overpayments etc.

You do need to be all over this, to be honest. It sounds like you have increased the debt capital rather than reducing it over the many years.

L0bstersLass · 07/10/2022 13:26

HangerLaneGyratorySystem · 07/10/2022 13:21

Does anyone know what “the company” is that OP refers to - seems as if “they” have an overview of mortgages? 🤔

I suspect she means their mortgage broker.
If the same one has been used all along they may be able to be very helpful in unpicking this, so long as they themselves have not been negligent of course.

uiyo7987 · 07/10/2022 13:24

My point about house prices is that rather than try and pay all of this off - i.e. quite a large mortgage at a time when interest rates are rising and now they've hit middle age is perhaps to downsize. I mean yes they can spend the next 10/20 years paying 2000 plus on the house and be stressed about. Or they can just downsize. That wasnt simply a comment on house prices but also on a way out of the problem without having to spend all their spare cash on paying off the house in their latter years

ivykaty44 · 07/10/2022 13:24

there is something wrong here, the calculations are not correct

I can find a calculator that does 30 year loan, so slightly different....but close

If you are on year 19 then you should have paid £110k of principal loan (over 27 years this would be slightly more) Interest at 5% £183k, loan balance £125k

www.bankrate.com/mortgages/amortization-calculator/

I did the loan start day as October 2003 to keep it simply 19 years ago - have a play and ignore the $ sign as it makes no difference.

www.calculator.net/mortgage-calculator-uk.html?chouseprice=245000&cdownpayment=0&cloanterm=27&cinterestrate=5&cpropertytaxes=0&chomeins=0&cpmi=0&cothercost=0&cstartmonth=10&cstartyear=2003&printit=0&x=64&y=15#ukmortgage

this calculator - input the figures and then scroll down to the table that shows you all the figures for each and every year - this one is £108.961 with a 27 year loan at 5% borrowing 245k with no deposit

HangerLaneGyratorySystem · 07/10/2022 13:21

Does anyone know what “the company” is that OP refers to - seems as if “they” have an overview of mortgages? 🤔

ThanksItHasPockets · 07/10/2022 13:18

And where other than London would you have bought a house for 245k back in 2002.

PILs' 4-bed family house in need of a bit of work in a nice part of rural North Wales cost £245,000 in 2002. Then as now the stamp duty threshold was £250k but because your money went further there was a lot of bunching in the market around £240-250k for a family home in many affluent areas.

L0bstersLass · 07/10/2022 13:17

@uiyo7987 It doesnt add up but on the other hand if you had a house that cost that much 20 years ago, it would be at least 1million now....so it's not all bad.

No it wouldn't. Depends where in the country it is. You do realise the housing market moves differntly in other parts of the country?

@uiyo7987 And where other than London would you have bought a house for 245k back in 2002

Is this a joke? What a ridiculous comment. I bought a house for more than that then, in North Wales. 4 bed detached.

You're having a howler with your contributions in this thread.

kirinm · 07/10/2022 13:17

We've paid off £50k in 6 years so something is definitely not right.

2bazookas · 07/10/2022 13:00

@uiyo7978
And where other than London would you have bought a house for 245k back in 2002.

What ridiculous naivety. The answer is, any desirable/affluent area in Scotland or the North of England; and I'm talking family detached, not castles.

OP is in this mess after 20 years of ignorance. Please don't mislead her. further.

ohthehorrorthehorror · 07/10/2022 12:44

You need to see the statements urgently. This sounds very ominous.

TheSheerCheekOfSomePeople · 07/10/2022 12:41

Amazing you have been so passive about this OP.

It has been in the past, and still is quite common for one person to take the lead in finances and the other person to find out too late that they have been too trusting or passive about family finances. Especially when being influenced by a partner who really doesn't want you to be interested for their own reasons and especially if you are also not confident with money or maths. At the time it can feel like a fair division of labour if the 'non-finances' partner plays to their strengths in other ways.

Don't beat her when she's down.

Yes this is a warning to others not to get to this point but OP needs help what to do next and moral support should she suffer any great shocks when she gets to the bottom of it.

sheepdogdelight · 07/10/2022 12:40

EmmaH2022 · 07/10/2022 10:33

Annie "Because he’s lying to her. Clearly."

but if OP is named on the mortgage, surely she will have had to read and sign paperwork each time a change was made?

I can't see how he's lied?
OP has buried her head in the sand (and would have continued to do so if she hadn't been sent a letter).
I wonder how much knowledge she has of their finances in general? Does she know if they are living to their means, for example? Putting credit card debt onto a mortgage is generally a bad idea (although not so bad if interest rate was below 1%) for example, and they (both) did something to create it.

She admits to agreeing to the original mortgage and to the re-mortgages (she can't even remember how many). I suspect at one of these points (or maybe even the original mortgage) they switched to interest only. As she seems perfectly happy for her husband to deal with this stuff, he might have switched without her knowing. Or he may even have discussed it with her as she seems vague and unsure about other details. None of this "clearly" suggests lying.

sponsabillaries · 07/10/2022 12:37

uiyo7987 · 06/10/2022 23:19

Also surely you must have switched mortgage provider over 20 years. I understand that a lot of people dont switch every two years but you must have moved your mortgage onto lower rates over that time?

I think the million pound house was in response to me. However, I think your house would have to be 1mil by now if it was 240 in 2002. I mean i just checked local houses here in London and any house that cost that much back in 2002 is worth at least 850k right now. And where other than London would you have bought a house for 245k back in 2002. That was a lot of money back then - that got you a nice three bed house in what is now considered to be very desirable parts of SW and North London.

This is an ignorant comment. London prices only took two years to recover after the crash in 2008. Durham and Hartlepool only recovered to pre-2008 prices in January of this year, meaning that someone who bought at the top of the market in 2007 in Hartlepool has had to wait all this time for the value of their house to return to what they paid for it (just in time for it all to crash again).

www.standard.co.uk/homesandproperty/property-news/house-prices-durham-hartlepool-pre-2008-north-south-property-uk-b976592.html

Anniefrenchfry · 07/10/2022 12:33

Can you imagine thinking you’re paying Your 245k mortgage off for twenty years and then finding out you still owe 203k ? And not even knowing if it’s right?

it is astonishing how some folks live.

Even adding 7 grand to your mortgage to pay off credit card debt shows a complete inability to manage money and an issue with debt.

I suspect op the debt was higher than you know and you have been paying interest only for a long time.

2bazookas · 07/10/2022 12:33

You may need to think more radically like downsizing. Hopefully you have decent equity

Highly unlikely, from what she's said.

I suspect the only reason DH has opened a discussion on their debt, is because of the lenders intention to foreclose and sell the house. That is the ONLY feasible option to repay the outstanding loan.