Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Does this financially ring true?

434 replies

ManyBooksLittleTime · 06/10/2022 19:48

We bought our house nearly 20 years ago for 245k. Now, 19 years later, we still have 203k left on the mortgage. I know the first years is basically paying interest , but only 42k in 19 years??? We have had good interest rates too.Also, my husband reckons it will go down to 181k by August next year. Please can soneone more astute with finance let me know if these numbers can be right?

OP posts:
Jobear2797 · 08/10/2022 00:06

nomdegrrr1 · 07/10/2022 23:47

@Jobear2797 I worked at a County Court back in the late eighties & early nineties, and there used to be literally hundreds of repossession hearings every month. It was horrific and made me incredibly risk averse with mortgages and loans.

I won't ignore the Official Secrets Act, even after all this time, and give details, but there were so many sad stories where people lost their homes because of the actions of others. Sometimes it was gambling, or drink, or just bad luck. Sometimes people tried to play the system and lost. Someone lost their home as a result of 'proving a point' and 'having their day in court' and being stuck with spiralling court costs trying to show that the rules didn't apply to them.

I'm not up to speed on mortgages now (or even then) but there seems to be some gaps and I hope that the OP can make sense. I hope that everything can be explained and sorted out. The OP must feel that they are trying to keep their feet in a landslide.

Absolutely 100% agree, it was horrific and I hated that back in the day I had to turn up to repossess a house as the banks representative, it was horrible, especially if the wife or husband didn’t know or if there were children involved, did get a knife pulled on me once by one particular husband who didn’t have a clue, and plenty of times I’d cry my way home, especially as I was only 21 at the time, just like you it made me very very risk adverse.
I’m just praying that in this case it’s not as bad as it first appears and perhaps there’s some logical explanation, but it must be very worrying and not a little scary for the op, let’s just hope and pray that whatever the reason it can get sorted.

Jobear2797 · 07/10/2022 23:55

Vapeyvapevape · 07/10/2022 23:25

Trusting her husband seems to be what's got the op into this mess .

Yes but it’s not the OP’s fault IF he is untrustworthy, seems to me a lot of people are criticising the OP, when did we become a people who blame/shame the victim, that’ feels very unfair to me. Surely we should be supporting the op to find out the facts about her situation and if it’s as bad as it first looks support the op to find ways to rectify the situation. All the rest is her business and not ours.
Also how do we know that there is not a perfectly good reason for the mortgage being the size it is still, perhaps he swapped part of it to an endowment mortgage and has a huge junk of money he’s about to pay off it, or used it to invest in something that’s making a huge profit while borrowing was so cheap, everyone has jumped to the worst possible conclusion and I realise that’s because of the secrecy but I do know other couples that don’t discuss their finances at all, even ones that don’t know what each other earn and although that’s not how I would want to be with my husband I’m an each to their own type of person.

nomdegrrr1 · 07/10/2022 23:47

@Jobear2797 I worked at a County Court back in the late eighties & early nineties, and there used to be literally hundreds of repossession hearings every month. It was horrific and made me incredibly risk averse with mortgages and loans.

I won't ignore the Official Secrets Act, even after all this time, and give details, but there were so many sad stories where people lost their homes because of the actions of others. Sometimes it was gambling, or drink, or just bad luck. Sometimes people tried to play the system and lost. Someone lost their home as a result of 'proving a point' and 'having their day in court' and being stuck with spiralling court costs trying to show that the rules didn't apply to them.

I'm not up to speed on mortgages now (or even then) but there seems to be some gaps and I hope that the OP can make sense. I hope that everything can be explained and sorted out. The OP must feel that they are trying to keep their feet in a landslide.

Vapeyvapevape · 07/10/2022 23:25

Jobear2797 · 07/10/2022 23:16

Hi
As an ex bank manager those numbers don’t sound right I’m very sorry to say, but it’s not your fault, not at all, you trusted your partner and it seems that he either froze the mortgage for a period of time on interest only or borrowed more. It happens all the time sadly and you’d be amazed at how many houses in the 80’s that I had to go to repossess, a job I hated, where either the husband or wife didn’t know that the mortgage was even in arrears, let alone that they were supposed to move out that day. It happens all the time.
I’d do my research if I were you, ring the bank and ask them to talk you through exactly what has been going on and then sit down with your husband and explain that you know there is a problem and ask him why , (there can be so many reasons from losing his job and not wanting to worry you, through to an addiction, gambling etc,depression, to business reasons that might make sense once you talk about it, because borrowing on a mortgage is much cheaper than a business loan. He may have a plan of how he is going to repay it, if he has and it is sound then it’s all down to how you feel about him not telling you the truth, if you’re happy with his explanation and feel nothing dodgy is going on, then it’s all about addressing the issue of why he has not been open and honest, that would be what worries me most, yes money is important especially when it comes to your home but trust is far more important, in my opinion, for what little that is worth. If he hasn’t a plan try not to panic there will be options hopefully, you can look at extending the term of the mortgage or repaying more or even downsizing if you have to. I’m so so sorry that you are in this position and truly hope it’s not as bad as you think, but please do not listen to people who say you should have done this or that, you have been a trusting person who loves their husband and that makes you a nice person in my book. There’s plenty of men out there who haven’t a clue about their mortgages too and how much there wife is really spending on that handbag or shoes. Yes I do think that it’s better if both partners are equally involved in the finances but some have absolutely no interest what so ever, like my husband, he honestly hasn’t a clue and when I try to talk to him about it his eyes just glaze over, it isn’t his thing, but then he’s good at tons of things I’m not so he concentrates on what he is good at and I do the same, we run everything by each other but don’t check up on each other as we trust each other implicitly.
I so hope that it all works out for you and your husband and if you need any general advice I would be happy to try to help but only from personal experience as I left that world behind a long time ago!!! Good luck

Trusting her husband seems to be what's got the op into this mess .

Jobear2797 · 07/10/2022 23:16

Hi
As an ex bank manager those numbers don’t sound right I’m very sorry to say, but it’s not your fault, not at all, you trusted your partner and it seems that he either froze the mortgage for a period of time on interest only or borrowed more. It happens all the time sadly and you’d be amazed at how many houses in the 80’s that I had to go to repossess, a job I hated, where either the husband or wife didn’t know that the mortgage was even in arrears, let alone that they were supposed to move out that day. It happens all the time.
I’d do my research if I were you, ring the bank and ask them to talk you through exactly what has been going on and then sit down with your husband and explain that you know there is a problem and ask him why , (there can be so many reasons from losing his job and not wanting to worry you, through to an addiction, gambling etc,depression, to business reasons that might make sense once you talk about it, because borrowing on a mortgage is much cheaper than a business loan. He may have a plan of how he is going to repay it, if he has and it is sound then it’s all down to how you feel about him not telling you the truth, if you’re happy with his explanation and feel nothing dodgy is going on, then it’s all about addressing the issue of why he has not been open and honest, that would be what worries me most, yes money is important especially when it comes to your home but trust is far more important, in my opinion, for what little that is worth. If he hasn’t a plan try not to panic there will be options hopefully, you can look at extending the term of the mortgage or repaying more or even downsizing if you have to. I’m so so sorry that you are in this position and truly hope it’s not as bad as you think, but please do not listen to people who say you should have done this or that, you have been a trusting person who loves their husband and that makes you a nice person in my book. There’s plenty of men out there who haven’t a clue about their mortgages too and how much there wife is really spending on that handbag or shoes. Yes I do think that it’s better if both partners are equally involved in the finances but some have absolutely no interest what so ever, like my husband, he honestly hasn’t a clue and when I try to talk to him about it his eyes just glaze over, it isn’t his thing, but then he’s good at tons of things I’m not so he concentrates on what he is good at and I do the same, we run everything by each other but don’t check up on each other as we trust each other implicitly.
I so hope that it all works out for you and your husband and if you need any general advice I would be happy to try to help but only from personal experience as I left that world behind a long time ago!!! Good luck

CountessWindyBottom · 07/10/2022 23:16

Do you have a person you can trust working in accounting or law? I'd advise you to bring the statements to a professional third party to establish exactly what is going on as it sounds like you're being fleeced. The discrepancy is huge and given that it is all in your name you need to assess liability and exactly where you stand. There is a substantial sum of money unaccounted for it seems so you need to take control of this stat.

Allmyarseandpeggymartin · 07/10/2022 23:10

@Andypandy799 If the mortgage is in her name then she should have read the paperwork and known roughly what was happening

ChazsBrilliantAttitude · 07/10/2022 22:03

Andypandy799 · 07/10/2022 16:42

I think pp need to stop criticising @ManyBooksLittleTime as many couples have one partner trusted to take care of the finances and nothing wrong with that.

Why people jump to the conclusion that her do has been doing something deceitful or malicious is just plain projecting and goes
with the many misandry posts on here.

Some men are wankers yes and some women can also be horrible but to generalise when you only know 1% of the story on here is disturbing and can’t be helpful to people who genuinely need help and advice.

Why don’t more MN not just give the benefit of the doubt, it’s not like he’s being accused of having an affair.

For example how do you know the DH isn’t self employed and used the equity in the home at times to support there business which in turn provides the finances for the family? May not be the case but who knows when on forums like this you only get a tiny bit of the story.

@ManyBooksLittleTime good luck putting your mind at rest and I’m sure you will all be fine, or as best as you can be as most of us are I’m the same boat now worrying about mortgages

It's hardly unreasonable point out that a £100K shortfall in where the mortgage should be at time when we are moving from historically low interest rates to rapid rate rises is worrisome.

I manage the finances rather than DH and I am the main earner, but he still knows how much is owed on the mortgage. We've always made the decision that we would not use the family home to fund any business ventures etc. as you face the risk of losing both your home and your income stream at the same time if the business goes wrong.

There is a big question mark over what has happened with the OP's mortgage and both she and her DH have been lax. If he has borrowed more without her consent then he has potentially been fraudulent, on the other hand if he has been trying to involve her and she hasn't taken an interest then she bears some responsibility.

Each adult in a relationship has a responsibility to understand the financial side of things.

cheshirebloke · 07/10/2022 21:37

Andypandy799 · 07/10/2022 16:42

I think pp need to stop criticising @ManyBooksLittleTime as many couples have one partner trusted to take care of the finances and nothing wrong with that.

Why people jump to the conclusion that her do has been doing something deceitful or malicious is just plain projecting and goes
with the many misandry posts on here.

Some men are wankers yes and some women can also be horrible but to generalise when you only know 1% of the story on here is disturbing and can’t be helpful to people who genuinely need help and advice.

Why don’t more MN not just give the benefit of the doubt, it’s not like he’s being accused of having an affair.

For example how do you know the DH isn’t self employed and used the equity in the home at times to support there business which in turn provides the finances for the family? May not be the case but who knows when on forums like this you only get a tiny bit of the story.

@ManyBooksLittleTime good luck putting your mind at rest and I’m sure you will all be fine, or as best as you can be as most of us are I’m the same boat now worrying about mortgages

But the numbers that the OP has posted do not add up, there's about 100k 'missing' somewhere. Either she's missed something (like being on IO mortgage for substantial period), or there's something else gone on.

Extending the house mortgage to subsidise a business is a tragic move, most lenders would ditch you tomorrow if they got wind of that. And you certainly shouldn't do something so serious without discussing it with a joint mortgage holder.

Realitysucks · 07/10/2022 20:29

Op this sounds awful! You need to look at the statements! I have a 380k mortgage have overpaid by only £150 a month from the start and we’ve paid 50k off in 3 years! Our interest rate is 1.92 and we haven’t borrowed more!

Ellyess · 07/10/2022 20:25

nomdegrrr1 We had a mortgage in the late 1980s like that. My, now deceased, husband was borrowing money from it behind my back. I have no idea on what he spent it. It was a sorry tale and I don't want to frighten ManyBooksLittleTime ·with my story, but please, do check on what is happening and find out about what was borrowed each time you switched Provider. Then follow the mortgage account monthly and make sure no more is borrowed against the house unless it is used to improve the value of the house.

Jaxxy · 07/10/2022 20:08

ManyBooksLittleTime · 06/10/2022 19:53

It was taken out for 27 years. 8 left on it. We have borrowed a bit more each time we' ve changed mortgage provider- husband v quiet about this

If you have been borrowing more when you remortgage the. you have cleared down more than £42k capital as you have been borrowing more money.

are you on a fixed interest rate, if so when does it finish, I don’t think you are paying enough to clear the mortgage on 8 years, UNLESS you are on a very low fixed rate for the rest of the term.

call you mortgage provider and ask them how much was borrowed, and also what they think you need to pay to clear the mortgage in 8 years.

Isthisexpected · 07/10/2022 20:01

I have this sinking feeling you've signed paperwork not understanding it and he's actually taken huge amounts of extra debt on the mortgage and blown it all.

Merryoldgoat · 07/10/2022 19:34

@Solonge

Have you read the thread?

Solonge · 07/10/2022 19:28

ManyBooksLittleTime · 06/10/2022 19:48

We bought our house nearly 20 years ago for 245k. Now, 19 years later, we still have 203k left on the mortgage. I know the first years is basically paying interest , but only 42k in 19 years??? We have had good interest rates too.Also, my husband reckons it will go down to 181k by August next year. Please can soneone more astute with finance let me know if these numbers can be right?

Yes....scarey isnt it.? dont worry....the actual capital amount begins to get smaller in the last few years. Right now...its mainly interest.

LikeTearsInRain · 07/10/2022 19:18

I would guess you’ve been interest only or potentially you’ve been on an endowment mortgage. Would explain why your DP says a big lump sum will come off at some point, endowment matures?

pollymere · 07/10/2022 19:00

Sorry you're finding this out now. The low interest rates over the past 20 years makes me think you should've paid most of it by now. We've got less than ten grand left to pay on ours after twenty years.

LeilaRose777 · 07/10/2022 18:54

If you kept upping your borrowing when you remortgaged then you're not paying off a 245k mortgage anymore. What's the actual amount? None of the numbers you've given add up. This is incredibly important and you and your OH need to sit down and go through everything together. The fact that you haven't seen any statments is ringing big alarm bells for me. You usually get them once or twice a year.

SwitchedOnMum · 07/10/2022 18:54

Sounds to me like you've inadvertently switched to an interest only mortgage, and not fully understood what that meant financially.

Scottishskifun · 07/10/2022 18:51

This definitely isn't right unless your husband has been taking out larger amounts when remortgaging or you were on interest only for a while!

In comparison our mortgage has reduced by 60k in 8 years with 1 lump sum payment of 10k in that time so 50k. Interest rate of 3.8% for first 4 years, 1.2% after that.

neighboursmustliveon · 07/10/2022 18:48

It doesn't feel right to me.

Our current home we had a mortgage of £151,000 in Dec 2016z we currently owe £124,000. We are not over paying to bring it down. So 6 years we have paid off £27,000.

Our last house we bought for £46,500 in 2003, in 2005 we remortgaged (stupidly) taking it up to I think £70. We sold it in 2016 and owed £34,000. So in 11 years we paid off £26,000.

MissPinkCakeyBun · 07/10/2022 18:44

I'm really hoping that this is not terrible news on a large amount you didn't know about. 😞 my ex husband did a similar thing and after the divorce I was left with very little as the debts were in both names

ThistleTits · 07/10/2022 18:42

ManyBooksLittleTime · 06/10/2022 19:56

Mortgage statements must be electronic. I haven't seen them. Dh does seem to think it will all get paid off in 8 years as we are over paying. I saw the balance today as he is investigating the best interest rate and Mortgage lender to switch to and they emailed me a copy of findings

My mortgage statement has never been electronically delivered. Always a hard copy, whatever provider I have had.

AmberMcAmber · 07/10/2022 18:41

So we have just remortgaged & borrowed extra on top for windows & roof repair…. The term of our mortgage has reduced slightly so it’s 25years now instead of about 32 (which is what our old one would have been) our payments are the same as before & when the 25yrs are up we would have repaid it all

my point being, even if you’ve borrowed extra, providing you’ve not gone to interest only the balance would be settled at the end of the term - otherwise the money isn’t accounted for

sounds like you’ve gone to interest only maybe 😬

Toomuchtrouble4me · 07/10/2022 18:39

Hearthnhome · 06/10/2022 19:54

Ffs ‘a bit more?’

Ffs - she meant ‘bit’ How much is a ‘bit’ more - very relevant!