Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Does this financially ring true?

434 replies

ManyBooksLittleTime · 06/10/2022 19:48

We bought our house nearly 20 years ago for 245k. Now, 19 years later, we still have 203k left on the mortgage. I know the first years is basically paying interest , but only 42k in 19 years??? We have had good interest rates too.Also, my husband reckons it will go down to 181k by August next year. Please can soneone more astute with finance let me know if these numbers can be right?

OP posts:
somebodycutmygrass · 06/10/2022 22:56

Given what you paid for your home all those years ago, I expect it's quite sizeable and worth several millions now.
The running costs, ie heating, council tax ,insurance must be sky high.
Do you think you DH isn't particularly money savvy and been rather naive about the true cost of living?
Not every high earning educated person has a grip on personal finances, we're not all geniuses in every field.
The high flyers/ earners often lack common sense and just dont get the obvious.
I am guessing he called the mortgage broker/ provider and presented them with the cashflow situation and of course they would suggest they loan the additional funds for whatever debt.
However. ...there is an issue with the fact you were not asked to agree to this transaction .... Do you think your DH is a trusting soul?

Hotandbothereds · 06/10/2022 22:55

ManyBooksLittleTime · 06/10/2022 22:36

Thank you all so much for your answers. I have been incredibly stupid not looking at statements and I'm surprised even more of you haven't told me so.Most of you have been really kind and explained things to me.

I have started to talk about this with my husband and the rest will be discussed tomorrow.

The good news is that we are going to pay 2.4k a month and the mortgage will be paid off in 8 years. He will pay 2/3 of it. Many of you have indicated this will clear it. It will be hard to manage though. But we need to do it.

I have also realised that I think , even better than the mortgage repayments, ( although I will definitely be looking at these) is that I can contact the company that secure the mortgage providers. They will have all the details for each time we have swapped and all of the financial details. I'll do this from work tomorrow .

The bad news is that I don't think my husband is explaining it accurately. He said that if we bought a house for 245 at 4 per cent it's the same as buying a house for 356k and that we have been paying off the difference. This sounds like bollocks because you have all been explaining to me how your mortgages have been steadily decreasing over time.

I had my own property years ago. I paid the mortgage and it decreased from the original amount.

He is going to put figures on paper to show me tomorrow evening!

We are both shit with money. Ironically we started getting into debt 20 years ago paying for childcare for me to work. Some of you are talking about a discrepancy of 100k though????

I guess I'll be busy tomorrow. I am really grateful for all the advice.

Is he trying to say the mortgage was interest only all along? I still don’t think those figures add up.

Dont let him try and baffle you with what he thinks OP, look at all the statements yourself.

I’m sure even if you’ve moved mortgage companies the previous ones will send you copies of their records if you contact them.

And I’d also get your house valued, so you know where you stand if you were to sell up.

sponsabillaries · 06/10/2022 22:52

When an explanation is that confusing it’s either because the explainer doesn’t understand the situation themselves or because they are deliberately trying to obfuscate the truth. I honestly don’t know which would be worse in this situation.

saltinesandcoffeecups · 06/10/2022 22:52

No your DH isn’t explaining or understanding it correctly… you bought the house for 245K and financed that amount at 4% interest (compound). That 365K does not come into the equation at all. (Unless you borrowed an additional 120K)

I’ve seen things on the internet where people are trying to do mental gymnastics to make the rising interest rates into a good thing…but it’s all crap. That 365K looks really familiar so maybe he got that from some bad information floating around?

Please go find a mortgage calculator and plug in your numbers and find out what you added to the original loan amount. Also look into compound interest and how it differs from simple interest.

I really say this in the most helpful way possible and not snarky at all. We’ve all made bad financial decisions (OMG, have I made some doozies), the smart ones learn from them.

CapMarvel · 06/10/2022 22:50

You need to get copies of the mortgage statements going back the full history of the loan.

But your husband is lying out his arse. At some point he has added a significant amount onto the loan and not told you.

PyongyangKipperbang · 06/10/2022 22:50

All he will do is write down stuff he knows you dont get to keep you in the dark.

DO NOT TRUST HIM

I dont even know why I am wasting my fingers typing this because you will anyway.....

luxxlisbon · 06/10/2022 22:49

ManyBooksLittleTime · 06/10/2022 22:36

Thank you all so much for your answers. I have been incredibly stupid not looking at statements and I'm surprised even more of you haven't told me so.Most of you have been really kind and explained things to me.

I have started to talk about this with my husband and the rest will be discussed tomorrow.

The good news is that we are going to pay 2.4k a month and the mortgage will be paid off in 8 years. He will pay 2/3 of it. Many of you have indicated this will clear it. It will be hard to manage though. But we need to do it.

I have also realised that I think , even better than the mortgage repayments, ( although I will definitely be looking at these) is that I can contact the company that secure the mortgage providers. They will have all the details for each time we have swapped and all of the financial details. I'll do this from work tomorrow .

The bad news is that I don't think my husband is explaining it accurately. He said that if we bought a house for 245 at 4 per cent it's the same as buying a house for 356k and that we have been paying off the difference. This sounds like bollocks because you have all been explaining to me how your mortgages have been steadily decreasing over time.

I had my own property years ago. I paid the mortgage and it decreased from the original amount.

He is going to put figures on paper to show me tomorrow evening!

We are both shit with money. Ironically we started getting into debt 20 years ago paying for childcare for me to work. Some of you are talking about a discrepancy of 100k though????

I guess I'll be busy tomorrow. I am really grateful for all the advice.

Your mortgage will likely not be paid off in 8 years, you are barely factoring in interest. If you are remortgaging next august your rate will be significantly higher than your current rate.
And you don’t state what your actual repayment is compared to 1.9k and now 2.4k. Can you even increase your monthly payment to that without incurring a fee?

He’s taking shite. How can he ‘show you the figures?’
The interest rate is irrelevant in a way, your repayment considers your interest rate, the total loan and the length of the loan so you should be well under 200k with only 8 years “left”.
A large sum, possibly several times, has been added to your mortgage.
The term may also have been lengthened.
This is all quite important and needs to be dealt with immediately as you have a huge amount left to pay of your mortgage given you bought 20 years ago.

Chanttotheprince · 06/10/2022 22:49

My mortgage is £390 and has 25 years left to pay off at a rate of 1.99% and £1600 a month. Your husband has stolen a significant amount of money and there’s no way in hell that will be paid off in 8 years at £2k per month

WiddlinDiddlin · 06/10/2022 22:46

Sorry OP, I don't fully understand how all the interest works (and thats fine as I don't have a mortgage!)... but even I can see how fishy this all looks.

I'd not accept his maths, on paper or otherwise. I would want to see the actual hard evidence from the mortgage co's and details of each change to what you originally had.

He's done something significant without your consent and he is still trying to bamboozle you.

SarahSissions · 06/10/2022 22:45

Before you sign or agree to anything I would get your husband to email you all the mortgage statements and docs and then go by yourself to a financial advisor to go through them. This all sounds as shady as fuck.

if I were taking out. New mortgage tomorrow id clear it with 2.4k payments in 10years- you seem to have made no inroads at all. Where has all the extra borrowing gone and why weren’t you aware of it? 2.4k a month payments aren’t solving the problem, it’s masking some serious earlier mismanagement

ChazsBrilliantAttitude · 06/10/2022 22:44

In fact you should be further ahead because interest rates have been below 4% for a long time.

ChazsBrilliantAttitude · 06/10/2022 22:43

Plug your numbers into this and it will show you where you should be
www.moneysavingexpert.com/mortgages/mortgage-rate-calculator/

Here is £245K at 4% over 27 years
Remaining Debt
0 £245,000
1 £239,850
2 £234,490
3 £228,913
4 £223,108
5 £217,067
6 £210,780
7 £204,237
8 £197,428
9 £190,342
10 £182,968
11 £175,293
12 £167,306
13 £158,994
14 £150,344
15 £141,341
16 £131,972
17 £122,222
18 £112,075
19 £101,515
20 £90,525
21 £79,088
22 £67,185
23 £54,798
24 £41,907
25 £28,491
26 £14,529
27 £0

It looks to me like you are about £100K short of where you should be after 19 years - £100K!

Parishcouncil · 06/10/2022 22:42

Thankyou for letting us know that for tonight OP you are ok 💐 Hope tomorrow proves to be productive xx

uiyo7987 · 06/10/2022 22:42

@ManyBooksLittleTime by now you shouldnt have a mortgage seeing as rates have been so low since 2008. However, if your house is now worth that much - then frankly you can sell up rather than try and pay it off

ManyBooksLittleTime · 06/10/2022 22:36

Thank you all so much for your answers. I have been incredibly stupid not looking at statements and I'm surprised even more of you haven't told me so.Most of you have been really kind and explained things to me.

I have started to talk about this with my husband and the rest will be discussed tomorrow.

The good news is that we are going to pay 2.4k a month and the mortgage will be paid off in 8 years. He will pay 2/3 of it. Many of you have indicated this will clear it. It will be hard to manage though. But we need to do it.

I have also realised that I think , even better than the mortgage repayments, ( although I will definitely be looking at these) is that I can contact the company that secure the mortgage providers. They will have all the details for each time we have swapped and all of the financial details. I'll do this from work tomorrow .

The bad news is that I don't think my husband is explaining it accurately. He said that if we bought a house for 245 at 4 per cent it's the same as buying a house for 356k and that we have been paying off the difference. This sounds like bollocks because you have all been explaining to me how your mortgages have been steadily decreasing over time.

I had my own property years ago. I paid the mortgage and it decreased from the original amount.

He is going to put figures on paper to show me tomorrow evening!

We are both shit with money. Ironically we started getting into debt 20 years ago paying for childcare for me to work. Some of you are talking about a discrepancy of 100k though????

I guess I'll be busy tomorrow. I am really grateful for all the advice.

OP posts:
ChazsBrilliantAttitude · 06/10/2022 22:36

In 2003 Base Rate was 3.5% so even if your mortgage was at 4% interest in your first year would have been under £10K. At the peak in 2007 Base Rate went up to 5.75% before dropping back due to the financial crisis to historically low levels. From 2008 onwards interest rates have been exceptionally low. You should have been able to pay down significant amounts of capital.

saltinesandcoffeecups · 06/10/2022 22:33

OP, I’ve paid about the same off of my mortgage in 1/2 the time and only been paying about 2/3rds of your monthly payment. So there is your sniff test to see if your situation is reasonable. Something is going on and I wouldn’t let it rest until you see all of the statements.

Xenia · 06/10/2022 22:31

It sounds like the husband may have committed mortgage fraud if he remortgaged without the wife's consent. If I were the wife I would request every mortgage statement (or online access) from the lender immediately and start by printing them all out for the file and take over organising all this as the husband seems to have been sneaky.

Hotandbothereds · 06/10/2022 22:30

uiyo7987 · 06/10/2022 22:21

It doesnt add up but on the other hand if you had a house that cost that much 20 years ago, it would be at least 1million now....so it's not all bad

True, best bet might be sell up, pay off the mortgage and take your half of the equity OP once you get to the bottom of what your DH has actually been up to.

Ledwood85 · 06/10/2022 22:28

Bunnyfuller · 06/10/2022 22:21

This screams gambling. I’m sorry op.

100% this.

The lack of progress paying down the mortgage gives the first hint.

The disconnected-from-reality sudden acceleration of paying it down in the next few years suggests a hopeless gambler deluding themselves that a big win to cover it all up is waiting any day now.

ChazsBrilliantAttitude · 06/10/2022 22:26

The numbers are way off especially with interest rates as low as they have been. If your mortgage was 250K at 1.5% the total annual interest bill would be £3750pa. so how can you have paid off so little in the last 19 years.

Just how much more have you added to the mortgage or have you been on interest only for a while.

I have been tracking my mortgage monthly for years on a spreadsheet as I am actively paying it off early and your numbers are not credible. You need to see what has really been happening and ask why you still have so much outstanding.

To put it in context over 10 years I have paid off more than half of my mortgage which was bigger than your original amount.

Subaru4336 · 06/10/2022 22:24

ManyBooksLittleTime · 06/10/2022 20:18

Thanks for all of your advice. The mortgage is definitely in my name too. I just think we have borrowed far more than I thought. So I think that when I've come to sign, I must have been looking at new monthly figures and interest rates rather than how much we were borrowing and the complete figure. Our interest rate is great at under 1 per cent, but DH wondering about changing now as we have this fixed term until August. He is worried that in August the interest rates will be through the roof. At least in 8 years it sounds as though the bulk of it will be paid off.

If your mortgage payments are £1.9k now on a rate <1%, they're going to increase by a fairly hefty chunk @ManyBooksLittleTime. Unfortunately you're unlikely to get a rate <4%, even now. Also means less of your payments will be reducing the capital.
I'm baffled as to how you have so much left after so long, the statements should have the answers though.

Calmdown14 · 06/10/2022 22:22

How old are you OP?

As others have said, there's no way to pay that off in eight years at £1900 a month and certainly not if he switches now as the interest rate will be around 5%.

You say you added to the mortgage to pay off credit card debt so it sounds like your finances have not been adding up for many years and just kicking the can down the road.

You may need to think more radically like downsizing. Hopefully you have decent equity

uiyo7987 · 06/10/2022 22:21

It doesnt add up but on the other hand if you had a house that cost that much 20 years ago, it would be at least 1million now....so it's not all bad

Bunnyfuller · 06/10/2022 22:21

This screams gambling. I’m sorry op.

Swipe left for the next trending thread