Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Does this financially ring true?

434 replies

ManyBooksLittleTime · 06/10/2022 19:48

We bought our house nearly 20 years ago for 245k. Now, 19 years later, we still have 203k left on the mortgage. I know the first years is basically paying interest , but only 42k in 19 years??? We have had good interest rates too.Also, my husband reckons it will go down to 181k by August next year. Please can soneone more astute with finance let me know if these numbers can be right?

OP posts:
mackthepony · 07/10/2022 02:04

@itsasadworldneverforget

Thanks

Harrystylestutu · 07/10/2022 01:51

I know absolutely nothing about mortgages op.
I still live with my parents, husband and children, I'm 33, it's not the best lol, I just pay rent, utilities and everyone's food etc, But I know when a family member bought this house for a family members specific needs in 2001, it was 95k..lovely area and four bed, three bath with garden. West mids area.

did you buy somewhere expensive? I think something must have got muddled up perhaps? Because that can't really be right can it?. Do a credit check on yourself is my only advice now 💐

ZealAndArdour · 07/10/2022 01:13

itsasadworldneverforget · 06/10/2022 21:35

Because some people want a very large house to live in, hold it for many years and then downsize and use the equity to buy outright.

They won’t have any equity if they’ve been on an interest only mortgage all that time?

PigletJohn · 07/10/2022 01:03

I can't make out the numbers, but "you" have been borrowing extra money over the years, so the balance is bigger than if you had just been paying off a repayment mortgage.

Whether the money has been spent on home improvements, new cars, holidays or gambling is a different matter.

It is concerning that you have not seen the mortgage statements and do not know what has happened.

It will not be paid off as quickly as you were expecting. When do you hope to retire?

HollyGoLoudly1 · 07/10/2022 00:52

Your husband is lying to you. Call the mortgage company and ask them to explain the figures so you know the exact situation before you speak to him.

altmember · 07/10/2022 00:51

Something certainly doesn't add up, going by the figures you've stated.

To repay the 203k over the next 8 years would be £2115 a month before adding any interest at all, i.e. 0% interest. Your current rate is very low, so if you had the benefit of that for the next 8yrs £2200 a month would cover it. But current rates are about 5% at best, which would need £2570 a month to repay it. You've had the advantage of exceptionally low rates over the 14 years, but somehow not reduced the balance. Now rates are jumping up, you're going to take a spanking unfortunately.

Not sure what rates and deal you've had over the past 19 years. Or how much you've been paying per month (inc any over payments). But assuming an average 4% and no overpayments, you'd have been paying £1240 a month. But crucially, by now, year 19, your remaining balance should have been down to about 100k. You should have got down past 200k at least 10 years ago (by year 7).

I agree with the others that there's about 100k unaccounted for somewhere in all this. 5k credit card consolidation on a couple of occasions does not explain this at all.

As for what to do now - if you refix now, you'll be straight up to 5% immediately, and you'll probably have to pay an ERC (at best that'll be 2k, could be a lot more). So you'll be speculating on the current offers of 5% being better than what's available by next August, which yes, could well be even higher. But to change now would cost you around an extra £10k for certain (8k interest, 2k ERC).

I'm in a similar situation with my current fix ending later next year. Your choices are either to pay that 10k penalty up front to lock in 5% rate for an extra 4 years, or to take a chance on rates not going up much higher/coming down again towards the end of next year and keep your current fix for the remaining 10 months. If you've got savings, or ability to overpay regularly, I'd be inclined to chuck everything you can at it over the next 10 months and then take stock.

If mortgage rates are up to 7% next August then you'll be about 6k worse off overall, than taking 5.1% now. If they only go up to 6%, then you'll be 3k better to wait til then rather than jumping for 5.1% now. You should probably check all these calculations out for yourself though. Plenty of online mortgage calculators (I used the Money Saving Expert one for these estimates).

Check what your overpayment allowance is (typically 10% of the balance), and when it's annual anniversary is. If you're lucky you might be able to use two years worth of overpayment allowance between now and next Aug. Also bear in mind that at the end of your current fix, you should have the option to pay off lump sum of any amount without no penalty. Not sure exactly how that works if you've already pre arranged a new fixed rate to take over though?

perenniallymessy · 07/10/2022 00:49

Whenever we have remortgaged (if changing the amount or the term) the lender has insisted on speaking to both of us on the phone before going ahead. They have wanted to know we both understand the amount and the term agreed to.

Surely you have had something similar? To be fair my DH is probably a bit daft and just goes with what I say (high level finance job but trusts me, thank goodness I'm honest!). I always make sure I show him the paperwork and statements though and we can both see it on our banking app.

1245J · 07/10/2022 00:44

Assuming worst case, ie 100% loan, 5% average mortgage rates, the broad position would be:

  • At 19 years a balance outstanding of £108,124
  • Annual payments of £16,782 (ie £1,395 a month)
  • Total payments over 19 years of £317,908
  • Of which interest is £181,302
But the key issue is that even at 5% interest rates, the balance would be £108k.

You took out smallish extra loans to pay off credit cards, but these would not affect the above too much. If the mortgage was interest only, the balance would not go down, but you have confirmed you understood the mortgage to be capital repayment.

As you say, the interest is higher in the first year (£12k of the £16k) and by year 19 it would be lower (£5k of the £16k).

Either you have been on interest only and paying peanuts each month for several years, or the mortgage has been increased materially and that money has been used for something else without your knowledge, or the lender has made a colossal mistake. My guess is your husband has either taken remortgage money for something else or debited payments from your joint current account to another accounts, split off some of the payment to pay interest only and retained some of each monthly payment without telling you.

RunnerDown · 07/10/2022 00:33

uiyo7987 · 06/10/2022 23:19

Also surely you must have switched mortgage provider over 20 years. I understand that a lot of people dont switch every two years but you must have moved your mortgage onto lower rates over that time?

I think the million pound house was in response to me. However, I think your house would have to be 1mil by now if it was 240 in 2002. I mean i just checked local houses here in London and any house that cost that much back in 2002 is worth at least 850k right now. And where other than London would you have bought a house for 245k back in 2002. That was a lot of money back then - that got you a nice three bed house in what is now considered to be very desirable parts of SW and North London.

I live near Glasgow. I bought a house for just over £200k in 1999 which would be worth around £500k now. And there were many houses and even flats for sale at that time which would have sold for far more than that . How can you possibly believe that there were no houses costing over £245 k outside London in 2002. How Londoncentric

ThorsBedazzler · 07/10/2022 00:32

It's clear he either doesn't understand mortgages himself or is trying to make sure you don't.

You bought the house for a certain amount.
Mortgage was £245k
There must have been a cash deposit as mortgage isn't for 100% of cost of house, it would have been 95% max, or 90% or less.

You pay off the mortgage, the money borrowed from the bank. So that at the end of the term you owe the bank £0 and the whole house is yours.

The mortgage payments each month pay off interest and some of the capital (the mortgage money you borrowed). At the start of when you borrowed, say it would be something like 98% interest and 2% capital. Your monthly payments will stay the same but the proportion that goes to pay off interest and proportion that pays off capital will change.

By the end of 15 years your payments (assuming no extra money is borrowed) will be maybe 70% interest and 30% capital, so the longer you have the mortgage the more capital you pay off each month, so that by the end of the term, your last few payments are nearly all just chunks off the capital.

What your husband has said makes no sense.

Plus the capital, the amount you owe the bank, should have reduced a lot more. If you've only got 8 years left of the mortgage you should have a significant amount less owing.

Anyway. Get the facts from the paperwork, not your husband.

Dotcheck · 07/10/2022 00:19

Given what you paid for your home all those years ago, I expect it's quite sizeable and worth several millions now

millions? I bought my house around the same time, it’s gone from 88 to 200.

OP I think your husband has some explaining to do

genuinelyaskingforafriend · 07/10/2022 00:05

On top of this, why has he lied to you? Gambler? Affair?

LakieLady · 06/10/2022 23:49

Xenia · 06/10/2022 22:31

It sounds like the husband may have committed mortgage fraud if he remortgaged without the wife's consent. If I were the wife I would request every mortgage statement (or online access) from the lender immediately and start by printing them all out for the file and take over organising all this as the husband seems to have been sneaky.

That happened to a client of mine a few years ago.

He'd remortgaged several times without her consent, and when we got a copy of the forms from the last mortgage, the signature was nothing like hers.

I changed jobs before it was resolved, so never found out what happened about it.

OneFootintheRave · 06/10/2022 23:38

Manchester1990 · 06/10/2022 20:30

He’s easily borrowed a 100k on it that’s unaccounted for. It could be way more if he did it online without your wet signature.

hes basically stolen from you. Gambling addiction would be my best guess.

Sadly, this could be right.

YourUserNameMustBeAtLeast3Characters · 06/10/2022 23:27

uiyo7987 · 06/10/2022 23:19

Also surely you must have switched mortgage provider over 20 years. I understand that a lot of people dont switch every two years but you must have moved your mortgage onto lower rates over that time?

I think the million pound house was in response to me. However, I think your house would have to be 1mil by now if it was 240 in 2002. I mean i just checked local houses here in London and any house that cost that much back in 2002 is worth at least 850k right now. And where other than London would you have bought a house for 245k back in 2002. That was a lot of money back then - that got you a nice three bed house in what is now considered to be very desirable parts of SW and North London.

I bought a £267k house in 2004. Not London. 3 bed detached. It’s worth less than £500k now, maybe £450k. London prices increased at an exceptional rate.

uiyo7987 · 06/10/2022 23:19

Also surely you must have switched mortgage provider over 20 years. I understand that a lot of people dont switch every two years but you must have moved your mortgage onto lower rates over that time?

I think the million pound house was in response to me. However, I think your house would have to be 1mil by now if it was 240 in 2002. I mean i just checked local houses here in London and any house that cost that much back in 2002 is worth at least 850k right now. And where other than London would you have bought a house for 245k back in 2002. That was a lot of money back then - that got you a nice three bed house in what is now considered to be very desirable parts of SW and North London.

MadeForThis · 06/10/2022 23:19

Either your DH added to the debt or he didn't pay the debt (interest only or mortgage holiday)

ChazsBrilliantAttitude · 06/10/2022 23:13

I really would try to get to the bottom of this yourself. The discrepancy is huge and I would want to understand for myself why you are so far from where you should be at this stage.
Don't let anyone blind you with numbers - mortgages are a simple concept. You start off with the amount you borrow and the lender works out the total amount of interest due over the life of the mortgage at the original rate then calculates how much you need to pay each month to get to zero at the end of the term. If interest rates go up from the original rate -your monthly payments go up (or you have to push out the end date) and if interest rates go down from your original rate - you pay less each month or you end up paying off the mortgage sooner.

What you need to know is
Original amount borrowed + original interest rate + term
What amounts were added to the mortgage and when?
Did you agree to that additional borrowing?
Have monthly payments been made in full in accordance with the agreed repayment schedule?
Was the mortgage always a capital reduction mortgage or did it go interest only at any point?
Have any payment holidays been taken?
Are the mortgage payments up to date now?

As Xenia pointed out up thread - if there additional borrowing that you haven't agreed to then this is serious and you should be raising it with your lender (not with your DH).

saltinesandcoffeecups · 06/10/2022 23:06

OP, are there any organizations that can help explain all of this to you when you get all of the statements? I’m not in the UK, so I don’t know of any local orgs, but in my country there are different groups that offer classes for financial matters such as understanding mortgages and financing, Before you make any decisions you really need to arm yourself with solid knowledge.

luxxlisbon · 06/10/2022 23:05

*Looking at how it's laid out by the company though it's like this.

203 over 8 years at 5.11 interest is 253k to pay back in total.*

What company?
To pay 203k off on a 5.11% interest mortgage you would need to pay £2,581 per month, excluding remortgage fees.

Looking to get to the bottom of it all tomorrow.
But you know what the answer, you already admitted you have borrowed extra multiple times when you remortgaged. So the question is how much, what did that money go on, and why do you have such little knowledge on your own loan?
You know extra money was borrowed so your husband hasn’t done it fully behind your back.

endofthelinefinally · 06/10/2022 23:05

If you have been releasing equity/increasing the size of the mortgage there will be correspondence relating to that.
If you have switched to interest only, at the very least you should be paying into a life insurance policy or have some other agreement with the lender as to how you are going to pay the full amount at the end of the term.
Has your husband made some sort of arrangement with the lender?
You had better get all the paperwork out and check.

ManyBooksLittleTime · 06/10/2022 23:03

Thank you so much for taking the time to do this. I'll be printing it out for tomorrow

OP posts:
StClare101 · 06/10/2022 23:02

You need to go and see the bank by yourself. Make an appointment and do not take your husband. They have specialist teams to help you if your own husband has misled you.

ManyBooksLittleTime · 06/10/2022 23:00

Looking at how it's laid out by the company though it's like this.

203 over 8 years at 5.11 interest is 253k to pay back in total.

We are not doing this and the company have advised not to switch mortgage provider, but to see how things pan out.

That figure would be horrific. But we do pay back so much more than we borrow.

Looking to get to the bottom of it all tomorrow.
And my house isn't worth anywhere near 1 Mill unfortunately

OP posts:
AprilShowers23 · 06/10/2022 22:56

Don't let him "explain the figures to you" on paper. He will try to make it sound like what he's done is legit and can falsify amounts etc, making it look like you're the one who just doesn't get it. I would get all the figures and statements directly from the bank and mortgage provider - take them to a financial advisor or someone in your family/friends who you can trust and is good with finances and see if they can help you with it. Or even post on here with the private info blanked out. There are lots of people on here who can help - just don't let your DH convince you it's all ok. You will not be paying that off in 8 years.