Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

What car seat can you use on planes for a 1yo?

110 replies

OriginalUsername3 · 06/10/2022 16:38

Using aibu for traffic. Does anyone have a car seat they use on planes? I cannot for the life of me actually find one. Googling "car seat for planes" just brings up loads that aren't actually suitable. Driving me mad! Would like one that's actually pretty safe, and preferably rear facing, in cars aswell as being suitable for planes.

OP posts:
Neurotic90 · 07/10/2022 04:02

I think the main benefit is having a car seat you know is safe for car journeys on the other side, and hasn't been mishandled or crashing about in the hold during transit. There's no way my 1 year old child would be forward facing, or travelling in a rented seat you have no idea of the crash history of or expiration date just to make going on holiday easier for myself. I imagine the OP has similar concerns and all the bewilderment is due to the complete lack of car seat knowledge in this country due to our disgustingly lax laws.

Your best to phone the airline OP, they should be able to advise. Jet2 don't need seats to be TUV approved, so the Joie Steadi is a good budget seat if your airline also allows it.

Notsoglamanymore · 07/10/2022 03:33

cooolio · 07/10/2022 02:54

"A child strapped in their car seat on the plane would have the same space they’d have in the car"

No, there's more space in the average car.

"the car seat is very helpful when it comes to turbulence. Holding a child is not that safe. I have flown through storms where we dropped enough the oxygen masks were deployed. People who didn’t have a seat belt on were seriously injured as their heads hit the ceiling with force."

You'd cover the baby with your own body in this situation if you were holding them. You don't have the chance to if they're buckled into a car seat. Items crashing round the cabin etc, you have no way of shielding them from that in a car seat. There is zero safety benefit to a car seat on a plane.

This is a ridiculous comment, it’s fair enough if you personally don’t want to use a car seat on a plane but to say there’s zero safety benefit to it is like saying there’s no safety benefit to using a car seat in a car🤦🏼‍♀️ Of course there’s a benefit.
I know that you can’t seriously be suggesting that it would be safer in the event of extreme turbulence to cover your unrestrained child with your own body than to have them securely strapped into a car seat where they basically won’t move? I mean come on, that stretches reason a bit.
This is no different than saying your child would be safer in your lap and being held by you than in a car seat in a car crash.

Decide for yourself the amount of risk you’re happy to take regarding your kids but let’s not throw reason and fact straight out the window and pretend that no car seat is safer.

Notsoglamanymore · 07/10/2022 03:23

cooolio · 07/10/2022 02:34

"Also that I must admit to being a little reluctant to paying nearly £1000 for a seat for DS when I don’t technically have to yet but the safety aspect still nags at me."

How do you think a car seat will help him in a plane crash?

I’m not that daft😂I know that in the event of a plane crash we can all pretty much kiss our arses goodbye, it’s for safety in the event of turbulence and takeoff/landing. I would’ve thought that would be obvious.

allboysherebutme · 07/10/2022 03:06

John Lewis do a baby car seat for £60. That's quite slim and it's good for the price. X

JustLyra · 07/10/2022 03:02

cooolio · 07/10/2022 03:00

"Or your qualifications to contradict the likes of Lufthansa and Maxi Cosi?"

The people who want to sell flights to families and car seats? 😂 erm, of course they'll encourage buying one.

It's useless on a flight.

So that’ll be no links and no qualifications. Thought not.

cooolio · 07/10/2022 03:00

"Or your qualifications to contradict the likes of Lufthansa and Maxi Cosi?"

The people who want to sell flights to families and car seats? 😂 erm, of course they'll encourage buying one.

It's useless on a flight.

JustLyra · 07/10/2022 02:58

No, there's more space in the average car.

The seat is the size that it is. Doesn’t change on a plane so they’re no more confined.

There is zero safety benefit to a car seat on a plane.

Given that everything I’ve ever read contradicts that do you have a link to your evidence for that statement? Or your qualifications to contradict the likes of Lufthansa and Maxi Cosi?

cooolio · 07/10/2022 02:54

"A child strapped in their car seat on the plane would have the same space they’d have in the car"

No, there's more space in the average car.

"the car seat is very helpful when it comes to turbulence. Holding a child is not that safe. I have flown through storms where we dropped enough the oxygen masks were deployed. People who didn’t have a seat belt on were seriously injured as their heads hit the ceiling with force."

You'd cover the baby with your own body in this situation if you were holding them. You don't have the chance to if they're buckled into a car seat. Items crashing round the cabin etc, you have no way of shielding them from that in a car seat. There is zero safety benefit to a car seat on a plane.

Betsyboo87 · 07/10/2022 02:54

I know it’s not the point of the thread but am I the only person reading this and thinking that there is no way in hell that my child would tolerate sitting in a car seat for the duration of a flight? Short or long haul. Maybe I just have a difficult one. We’ve paid for an extra seat before and had him on our laps for take off and landing.

Aintnosupermum · 07/10/2022 02:48

@cooolio

the car seat is very helpful when it comes to turbulence. Holding a child is not that safe. I have flown through storms where we dropped enough the oxygen masks were deployed. People who didn’t have a seat belt on were seriously injured as their heads hit the ceiling with force.

Aintnosupermum · 07/10/2022 02:44

I flew all over the place with 3 children ages 5 and under. My children were in a car seat until they were 4. So much easier, especially for my son who has sensory issues linked to his autism.

I was US based and flew back and forth to Europe as well as in and around North America. I used the cosco scencera car seat because it’s so light and easy to handle. Crew tried to complain but I asked the pilot for permission, explaining the child being in a car seat was probably safer as it was just me with 3 children. The pilots always let me use the car seat.

JustLyra · 07/10/2022 02:39

The child must have so little space in this situation. You reduce their space after paying for a seat for them, just so you can strap them down and reduce wriggling on your knee? Why?

A child strapped in their car seat on the plane would have the same space they’d have in the car

cooolio · 07/10/2022 02:37

"I think the main points are it has to be forward facing, slim enough to fit in the seat and be a 5 point harness

The 5 point harness refers to the car seat itself, so a pretty standard UK FF car seat.

Once on the plane, the seatbelt is used to fasten the car seat to the plane seat, a bit like you would in a car using the lap belt."

The child must have so little space in this situation. You reduce their space after paying for a seat for them, just so you can strap them down and reduce wriggling on your knee? Why?

cooolio · 07/10/2022 02:34

"Also that I must admit to being a little reluctant to paying nearly £1000 for a seat for DS when I don’t technically have to yet but the safety aspect still nags at me."

How do you think a car seat will help him in a plane crash?

Notsoglamanymore · 07/10/2022 02:16

I have this same problem as flying long haul in January with DS who will be 20 months but then. I just wanted one for the safety aspect. However from my research is seems like although it is the norm in the US it’s incredibly rare in the UK and most folk just have babies on their laps.
It’s incredibly difficult to find an airline approved car seat in the UK and there are only maybe two options. So I’ve decided to go with having him on my lap for the flight (night flight so praying he’ll sleep) and buying a Joie Tilt or Joie Steadi (both rear facing up to 18kg and under £100) to go in the hold for use when we get to our destination.

Also that I must admit to being a little reluctant to paying nearly £1000 for a seat for DS when I don’t technically have to yet but the safety aspect still nags at me.

JustLyra · 06/10/2022 23:48

Shmithecat2 · 06/10/2022 23:10

It can't be installed with a lap belt though, it needs 3 points.

Some can be secured on a plane with the lapbelt, even though that wouldn’t be acceptable in the car.

it’s why the OP needs to check with their actual airline.

Some infant carriers for example can be fitted forward-facing with the lap belt only on a plane, yet you couldn’t do that in a car.

JustLyra · 06/10/2022 23:18

Most airlines have a list - your car seat will have a label telling you if it’s approved as well.

you could also Google the name/make of your car seat and plane.

The seats don’t have to be rear facing on a plane - it just needs to be able to be secured by the belt

GreenCereal · 06/10/2022 23:14

Yes it’s a very American thing to do. They also do not use the infant lap belts that are common in the rest of the world.

Shmithecat2 · 06/10/2022 23:10

Thumberline · 06/10/2022 20:32

Joie steadi is only 42.5cm wide and rear facing until 18kg. I think it’s one of the slimmest on the market so could be a suitable option.

It can't be installed with a lap belt though, it needs 3 points.

stormelf · 06/10/2022 23:07

I'm pretty certain the britax twe is approved for use on a plane but please double check in case I am wrong. It has to be forward facing on the plane but can be rearward facing when used in a car. It may not be suitable for your child depending on their size though, my son was only big enough for it at around 18 months but he is small for his age.

The Facebook group car seat advice UK or extended rear facing may be able to help you

FettleOfKish · 06/10/2022 23:05

Ps.. depending on the type of transfer you've booked you may not be able to use it. A private car almost certainly, but a coach likely not.

Taytotots · 06/10/2022 23:04

The seat will have to be airline approved. Not many uk ones are.

Taytotots · 06/10/2022 23:02

As @PurpleBananas22 check the airline website and print out and take a copy with you. I had to take a car seat when I flew with my twins on my own when they were under one. One had to be in s car seat as too small for adult belt. We used a britax two way elite. It wasn't great trying to get two babies and a plane set off the plane though as they sent my buggy through to the baggage hall. Luckily someone took pity on me and helped me carry them.

FettleOfKish · 06/10/2022 23:01

DoubleDuvetDay · 06/10/2022 17:08

Lots of people who clearly never fly on these threads
If you have a baby in their own seat then you can fit a car seat, it depends by airline and you need to check. It is very common.
Some seem to also be mini pull along wheel seats that then go into the plane seat.

You say that, but I've been selling flights for nigh on 20 years and I have never, ever, had anyone want to take a car seat on to use on the plane. I've travelled extensively myself and never witnessed it.

It's very rare, in Europe at least.

OP I would package it well and check it in. I've had plenty of people do that over the years and don't ever remember a damage complaint. A few buggies and myriad suitcases but never a car seat.

PurpleBananas22 · 06/10/2022 22:53

Apparently I am in the minority but I have done this several times! It's not a massive deal but it's been great.

I bought a second hand Britax car seat especially for this purpose and have flown short haul and long haul with it. Each airline has slightly different requirements but it will say somewhere on their website what their criteria is.

I think the main points are it has to be forward facing, slim enough to fit in the seat and be a 5 point harness

The 5 point harness refers to the car seat itself, so a pretty standard UK FF car seat.

Once on the plane, the seatbelt is used to fasten the car seat to the plane seat, a bit like you would in a car using the lap belt.

I have always printed off the airlines own instructions and take a copy on the flight with me just in case the Cabin crew weren't sure how to use it.