Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to be wondering if we should be leaving London too?

156 replies

KarokeandGin · 06/10/2022 13:34

We currently live in east London with 3 young children in a 3 bed house. Very happy with our house and whilst the younger two share a room hopefully we will be able to afford to do a loft conversion in a few years so by 7/8 the younger two won’t have to share.

lots of our friends are leaving London and moving to Kent and Essex for the grammar system and more space. Our local secondary school is fine, nothing special but not awful.

AIBU to not really have considered if we should be leaving London too? We are happy here but I do wonder if the extra space and countryside living would benefit the DC. My main concern is moving and not being happy personally (both myself and DH grew up in London) even if it was a better life for my DC. Should I be putting their happiness and potential for a better education first?

YABU - consider going and put your children first
YANBU - continue enjoying the life you have and your children will likely do just as well

OP posts:
TedMullins · 06/10/2022 14:25

Stay! My parents moved out of London before I was born to a picturesque but boring town in the midlands and I always used to berate them and say I wish I’d grown up in London instead. There was plenty of underage drinking and drugs in the town because teenagers are so bored. I now live in London myself and love it.

CharBart · 06/10/2022 14:23

It depends. What would your day to day life be like? We stayed, partly because we both would have had to commute , making it more expensive and logistically harder with childcare etc.

If you’re from London do you have family there? One downside of staying for us is that it takes a long time to travel to family but sounds like that’s not an issue for you?

Now kids are getting older they definitely have more independence than if we lived somewhere remote and plenty to do, but you could have that in a decent sized town in Kent or Essex!

applecharlotte12 · 06/10/2022 14:21

We are in East London and so pleased we stayed put. DS has just started year 7 at an outstanding state secondary that is 15 mins walk away and on the edge of a huge park.

There's so much to do for teens here - whatever DS ends up wanting to do work wise or hobby wise he'll have access too. Plus now covid restrictions are over I'm loving doing galleries/museums, theatre and visits into central london. I'm so grateful to live in this city despite the pollution/crime. I grew up in a beautiful part of rural Yorkshire and love to visit but wouldn't want to move there.

Thepeopleversuswork · 06/10/2022 14:21

I can see the schools thing is a consideration.

FWIW though I think people hugely exaggerate the value of living outside cities for young families.

The only real window when you get any value out of it is when kids are primary age and below and can play outside etc. For teenagers living in a big city will always be preferable to a small town. Small towns have far more dangers than big cities due to boredom, lack of facilities and drugs and teenagers loathe living a car journey away from their mates.

Personally I would be inclined to stay put in your shoes.

unicornflakegirl · 06/10/2022 14:20

Living in London is amazing, so much to do and children growing up with confidence. I live in a different European capital city, I wouldn't swap for a rural setting for any amount of garden.
Do what makes you happy but as a teen I'd much rather be in town.

KarokeandGin · 06/10/2022 14:19

Oh and yes we have family nearby. My husbands mum helps with post school pick up once a week.

OP posts:
KarokeandGin · 06/10/2022 14:17

Thank you all. We live in Snaresbrook for those asking where in east London. I grew up with a small garden and we have a small garden so that would be a pull for the kids. Interesting to hear from those of you who are glad you stayed. My parents had moved from London by the time I graduated and I like the idea of still living here so the kids could return post Uni to save them on rental costs

OP posts:
Buckland123 · 06/10/2022 14:12

Stay. We live about 45 mins from London on the train and it’s crap - best of no worlds! Not rural enough, not city enough. If we could afford it I’d go back to London asap, as would my teens who travel in as much as they can. London offers so much in terms of things to go, culture, diversity. It’s wonderful!

reigatecastle · 06/10/2022 14:09

Tiredalwaystired · 06/10/2022 13:54

Not sure where you live in London but you could just move to a different borough.

Harrow has a huge amount of outstanding secondary schools and you can still get three bed with a garden for around £600 a £650

only 35 mins to Baker St too. I’m always amazed it’s so affordable.

£600K affordable!

I know, relatively speaking it is. But still!

SleeplessInEngland · 06/10/2022 14:07

Don't leave just because you see others doing it and think you 'should'. If you're happy then you're happy.

Mardyface · 06/10/2022 14:06

London is some people's version of the best life! Do what you want.

I grew up in the countryside and enjoyed romping around the fields as a young kid but it didn't give me practice at socialising and when I was a teenager recreation was all driving really fast in boys' cars down country lanes and drinking cider in bus shelters. I'm bringing my kids up in London. My 13 year old loves it and is able to catch a train into Central London herself to do some activities. We visit galleries and museums and other stuff most weeks. My 11 year old says she would rather be in the countryside but she does like being able to walk to the corner shop and the library independently which I couldn't at 11 without a lift or a v long bus journey.

It's not for everyone but it doesn't have to be - it's for you!

Ithoughtthiswastherehearsal · 06/10/2022 14:05

Depends where you live and how safe the area is, plus if you have family nearby.

I did not feel safe living in East London but perhaps you’ve found a nicer bit than my area!

Growing up in London does kinda suck yes. I did it and I didn’t want it for DC.

Enko · 06/10/2022 14:04

We moved. Really happy we did. Close friends didn't move really happy they did.

Other friends moved back and forth 4 times and now live in Devon... work out what will make you happy

BIWI · 06/10/2022 14:04

You're making a very dangerous assumption that your children will pass the 11+ to actually get into a grammar school though. What would you do/how would you feel if they didn't?

London secondary education - non-grammar - is generally very good. I'd focus on looking at boroughs where the schools are particularly good and house-hunt there. (I'd also be seriously checking out the schools near you to find out what they're actually like).

Polimolly · 06/10/2022 14:04

I moved to a rural town when DS was 3, and by the time he was 12, I moved back to a city. Best move ever. I find rural places extremely boring.

In your case, I might move to a smaller town but don't go somewhere rural. There's nothing to do!

Jackiebrambles · 06/10/2022 14:04

We have had the same thought process and dilemma as you, we've seen a fair few people leave as well. My dh often looks at the space we could get outside of London wistfully!

But we're staying. Partly because we've been here so long and the kids are so well settled and happy/doing so well at school, to disrupt that seems mad. Also because I think the opportunities for study/work/hobbies and brilliant public transport is great for teens.

We do worry about violence/crime though.

CruCru · 06/10/2022 14:03

The thing is, there's this weird assumption (on here and elsewhere) that the only really acceptable childhood is one spent in an affluent suburb. It really is fine to have children and live in London. When they are older, they'll be able to get around without needing endless lifts.

Not everyone has to live like the Inbetweeners.

ThrowingSomeCrumbs · 06/10/2022 14:00

I am in a very similar position, though kids older than yours. East London, house is perfectly fine and have a really lovely group of close friends. Kids are very happy at their great schools with some fantastic friends. But I think I have reached my London limit. Yes, we have some great parks and some great forest, but I want more!

NCHammer2022 · 06/10/2022 13:57

I definitely wouldn’t move for the grammar system. That’s just inflicting a rat race on your children and imo negates the quality of life benefits they would get from e.g. having a bigger garden.

Scarecrowrowboat · 06/10/2022 13:57

We've decided to stay put for the kids and just be more cramped. There are just more opportunities, more jobs, more activities here and we are just far enough out that there is lots and lots of green space.
I lived in Zone 6 growing up and it seemed incredibly far out of London which seems funny to me now. I think my kids will likely want to be close to London too as nice as it would be for us not to have a huge mortgage and to have a bigger house.

Tiredalwaystired · 06/10/2022 13:54

Not sure where you live in London but you could just move to a different borough.

Harrow has a huge amount of outstanding secondary schools and you can still get three bed with a garden for around £600 a £650

only 35 mins to Baker St too. I’m always amazed it’s so affordable.

FinanceLPlates · 06/10/2022 13:51

And for those who have some sort of idealised vision of an idyllic, innocent life in the country - it very much depends. There’s plenty of alcohol and drugs around if they fall in with the wrong crowd (also see “boredom” as above)

ChazsBrilliantAttitude · 06/10/2022 13:50

It depends where you live now and where you plan to move to. My teenagers like being in London because it gives them freedom. They aren't reliant on Mum and Dad to taxi them everywhere. DH is North African and from a cultural perspective London is easier than some smaller towns outside of London would be.
What is school provision like in the Grammar School areas for DC who don't pass the 11+.
What do you think you would gain and what would you lose. e.g. If a huge garden matters to you then you may need to move quite a long way out but if transport is more important, then that is the last thing you should do.

Etinoxaurus · 06/10/2022 13:47

Stay 🥰

FinanceLPlates · 06/10/2022 13:46

Will they have the best life in the countryside though? I grew up in the countryside. As a young child, I loved being able to play out and freely roam the neighbourhood with a bunch of other kids. As a teenager though I found it deadly boring and couldn’t wait to get out, eventually ending up in the biggest city I could find (London).

Swipe left for the next trending thread