Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to be wondering if we should be leaving London too?

156 replies

KarokeandGin · 06/10/2022 13:34

We currently live in east London with 3 young children in a 3 bed house. Very happy with our house and whilst the younger two share a room hopefully we will be able to afford to do a loft conversion in a few years so by 7/8 the younger two won’t have to share.

lots of our friends are leaving London and moving to Kent and Essex for the grammar system and more space. Our local secondary school is fine, nothing special but not awful.

AIBU to not really have considered if we should be leaving London too? We are happy here but I do wonder if the extra space and countryside living would benefit the DC. My main concern is moving and not being happy personally (both myself and DH grew up in London) even if it was a better life for my DC. Should I be putting their happiness and potential for a better education first?

YABU - consider going and put your children first
YANBU - continue enjoying the life you have and your children will likely do just as well

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
wemovedfromthere · 29/10/2022 20:41

I came across your thread by accident - we moved from your area last year! So I know it very well.

It’s been the right move for us but I think it’s very personal and wouldn’t be the right move for everyone. I do feel very nostalgic for Snaresbrook/Wanstead, it’s a lovely part of London.

We didn’t move to a grammar school area as we didn’t want the stress of the 11+. Instead we moved to an area which has a reputation for good comprehensives. When we lived in your area, we knew private school was out of reach financially so didn’t consider Bancrofts/Forest etc, and the grammars didn’t really appeal. It’s not a bad area for comprehensive schools though, I know people with kids at Wanstead and they are happy. Also the primaries are excellent, we had experience of two and thought they were both great.

I do miss the high street with all the shops and restaurants - we still talk about Provender and Filika! And the transport links are great (although I’m not a fan of the central line overall).

Ultimately we just aren’t really London people though so living somewhere quieter works for us. DH in particular also really wanted a bigger house and garden and is very happy to have it, although to be honest that was less of a consideration for me. Our kids are relatively young so have coped fine with the move.

I really don’t think there’s a right answer and even though we decided to move, I totally understand why you might want to stay. I think it’s a good area for families, personally.

MarshaBradyo · 07/10/2022 19:53

No don’t move if it’s not what you want

Teen years can be good in London anyway

We had similar - loads left in the early years but I’m glad we stayed

CruCru · 07/10/2022 19:51

Tiredalwaystired · 07/10/2022 12:21

Yes this for me too. Is there a mystical place which is both pretty with a nice town centre and social activities and not full of tories or brexit voters?

asking for retirement!

Brighton?

awomanofthecuntytype · 07/10/2022 13:38

London is a brilliant place to bring up children. It's big and busy and exciting and multicultural, and there is a ridiculous amount to do. Transport is fantastic (no need to use a car). I would only ever think of moving if I had children cramped into a 2-bed flat or some such.

Some PP have said you have to do what's best for the DC - but there's no way to know what's best for them without actually doing it. Plus one DC's paradise isn't necessarily so good for another DC - quite apart from the issue of whether or not they would all get into a grammar school. Even if they did get in, there's no guarantee they'd be happy there.

If I were you, I'd stay very firmly put.

refre · 07/10/2022 13:27

Mardyface · 07/10/2022 09:17

These threads airways descend into a London Vs the provinces battle but of course both have their plus and minus points and there isn't an answer. On any given day I could write easily agree with every one of these posts depending on my mood (except the one about the utopia in Surrey which I kind of don't buy).

The fact is you're happy in London, you grew up in London, and your house is big enough. I wouldn't change that for some fictional notion of what moving out might look like because everyone else is doing it.

There is no utopia in Surrey believe you me.

When the kids get to early teenage years, there are drugs galore and county lines. Teens robbing each other. Fighting, bullying, violence.

Mutilated cats recently.

Loads of sexual related attacks.

I also found it very suspect that a recent murder of a teen stabbing another teen to death was barely reported on. Why because it's Surrey and it doesn't fit the narrative that London is the only place that is to be deemed dangerous.

All you ever hear about is the demonisation of London.

chopc · 07/10/2022 13:15

@KarokeandGin I just read your OP again. I think most people move for a reason - you don't have a reason for moving. So why move?

However I do want to point out you can have a full and happy life in other areas as well if that is your concern

What ain't broke dont mend it

Obbydoo · 07/10/2022 13:03

Why do people regard Kent as countryside and this aspirational place to live? There are a few nice parts but in the main it's a bloody awful county. The UK is an amazing country with so many beautiful and vibrant places to live, there are hundreds of better options!

Pigtailsandall · 07/10/2022 12:58

Read this with interest as we too are in East London (zone 2). DH is keen to move somewhere more rural, but he grew up in London from age 12 onwards (and before that in another big city) so I think his views are a bit idealised. we have a small child who would love country rambling but I think in ten years she'd be bored to death. So we longingly look at huge 5-bed houses with enormous gardens thinking we could swap our narrow 3-bed terrace for one.. and then think, what on earth would we do with extra two bedrooms and a second living room? We'd just have more to clean and more crap!

Crikeyalmighty · 07/10/2022 12:41

@Tiredalwaystired Bath! (Lib Dem) Hebden Bridge, Lewes, Norwich , Totnes, Tunbridge Wells(more mixed than you might think, same with Winchester.

Anywhere that's relatively pretty and has a more liberal vibe is inevitably pricey-due to demand!

Tiredalwaystired · 07/10/2022 12:21

gerispringer · 07/10/2022 07:42

I wouldn’t want to live anywhere where I was surrounded by Brexit voters.

Yes this for me too. Is there a mystical place which is both pretty with a nice town centre and social activities and not full of tories or brexit voters?

asking for retirement!

Crikeyalmighty · 07/10/2022 10:27

You can have an interesting life with lots to do on your doorstep plus countryside in the southern half of the country if you can in my opinion afford to live in places like Bath, Norwich, oxford, Guildford, Canterbury winchester etc

I've lived all over including nicer bits of outer London and the Home Counties can be a shock that it really isn't 24/7 and bus services are often totally rubbish etc .

If you have a decent ish house in a leafy pleasant area but only want to go as far out as Kent or Essex I would stay put. I can't see apart from maybe a slightly bigger house you would gain anything , certainly I don't think your kids would relish it- but by all means ask them

HeavensEmbroideredCloths · 07/10/2022 09:37

I hated growing up in the countryside however it was racist AF where I grew up and I’m mixed race. I will say there were plenty of drug issues and people knew what everyone was doing. I do not miss that side at all.

GailSnail · 07/10/2022 09:36

Me & DH very glad we didn’t move. We are looking at eventually downsizing in London, and being merry middle aged/oldies who take full advantage of this wonderful city and use our Freedom passes a lot .

This really appeals to me! In my case I feel like the primary years fly by (we are part way through them already) and thereafter London comes into its own once your kids start being more independent and you get more time by yourself / with your partner. (Less taxi service more fun)!

Having said that we are lucky enough to live by one of the best parks in London with some excellent free museums and there have been a wealth of things to do on our doorstep for young DC too.

Horses for courses.

GailSnail · 07/10/2022 09:30

ChampagneCamping · 07/10/2022 07:31

Personally the pollution, violence were sticking points for me. My countryside house has a nice neighbourhood, regular city access, lots of dirt play (damning streams, scenic pub walk rambles, building shelters & fires)

This sounds more like primary aged activities though. The OP is asking regarding her teens, who I assume are past the den building stage.

lllllllllll · 07/10/2022 09:28

If you think drugs and violence don't exist in the countryside you're very naive.

Quite! County lines, anyone?

Mardyface · 07/10/2022 09:17

These threads airways descend into a London Vs the provinces battle but of course both have their plus and minus points and there isn't an answer. On any given day I could write easily agree with every one of these posts depending on my mood (except the one about the utopia in Surrey which I kind of don't buy).

The fact is you're happy in London, you grew up in London, and your house is big enough. I wouldn't change that for some fictional notion of what moving out might look like because everyone else is doing it.

eltonjohnsglasses · 07/10/2022 09:10

I just can't think of anywhere in SW that's 10-15 mins walk to two stations but a bus ride to tubes hence why I was curious.

If you're talking about meeting in St Pancras and that's where her trains get into, I can well believe that her journey is the same.

No I said because her journey to St Pancreas is so quick her journey time to meet is usually the same as mine.

But by and large if you're in zone 3, you will be able to get to a variety of different bits of London on average much faster, much cheaper and with more transport options.

I haven't disagreed that travelling from z3 wouldn't be cheaper with more options. I just made the point that some people in Kent have similar journey times to people in London. I also never said all journeys from Kent & Essex are the same as the journeys from z3. I referred to London in general because of course not everyone lives in z3, the op herself lives in z4.

gannett · 07/10/2022 09:03

Why are people so convinced that a countryside childhood is better than a city one?

I had a mixture. Loved growing up in London until I was 10. Bored to tears in the countryside as a teenager (and also experienced a lot more racism and small-minded prejudice). Got back to London as soon as humanly possible and will never live anywhere other than a big city.

If you think drugs and violence don't exist in the countryside you're very naive.

And tbh after my countryside years I felt at a significant disadvantage when it came to life experience and being streetwise when I got to university, and nearly fucked it up completely because of that. The kids who'd grown up in cities had much more of their shit together at that point.

Tomorrowisalatterday · 07/10/2022 08:57

I never said that though. I simply made the point that my journey in z3 London is very similar to my friends in Kent. I'm not sure why you having taking umbrage with that

Because it's two separate points:

If you're talking about meeting in St Pancras and that's where her trains get into, I can well believe that her journey is the same.

But by and large if you're in zone 3, you will be able to get to a variety of different bits of London on average much faster, much cheaper and with more transport options.

I don't really want to put my location on the internet but I am not SE London

Endlesssummer2022 · 07/10/2022 08:52

Stay put. Snaresbrook and places nearby like Wanstead, Walthamstow Village, Highams park, Woodford etc are lovely and have plenty of green space.

We live not too far from you, had friends move to the countryside ‘for the kids’. A few years on and they regularly ask to stay at ours in London during school holidays, weekends. Mind you, we get to stay at theirs in return which is nice for a change of scene.

eltonjohnsglasses · 07/10/2022 08:52

Zone 3 and no bus route? I would be very interested to know where that is.

I didn't say no bus route just no bus route from the station to their house. One was the back of Wimbledon & one was Streatham Common/Norbury way.

I am not saying everyone has to think the same things are important but it's disingenuous to say that there is nothing different about living in London.

I never said that though. I simply made the point that my journey in z3 London is very similar to my friends in Kent. I'm not sure why you having taking umbrage with that 🤷🏻‍♀️

I live in South London, zone 3. 10-15 mins walk from 2 train stations on different lines

Is this South East?

Hugsgalore · 07/10/2022 08:40

Not UK based… but we lived just right on the outskirts of Dublin for a very long time. Great transport system, lots of shops etc near by. We moved further out a while back for additional space, bigger garden and nicer house. We haven’t much of a life here tbh. Our dd loves it but we have no friends, there aren’t many options nearby for food/ drinks etc and when dd gets older it’ll be likely she’ll need to be ferried around. Anytime we want to go out one of us needs to drive as the public transport is terrible.

I would stay put if I were you. Nothing wrong with kids sharing a room. Sure didn’t we all when we were younger. 🤷‍♀️

LivesinLondon2000 · 07/10/2022 08:37

We stayed in London and don’t regret it. We visit the countryside lots during school holidays.
Depending on where you go, the reality of living outside London can often mean lots of time spent in the car driving places and not necessarily availing of the extra space on a day to day basis. During the week we’re all super busy with work, school and hobbies so having everything close by that the kids can get to independently is great.

And much the same way that the people who moved out travel in to avail of what London has to offer, we do the reverse and travel out when we need a countryside fix. We’re quite lucky here as there are lots of great parks close by so we don’t feel hemmed in day to day - but sometimes it is nice to get away for a few days.

Tomorrowisalatterday · 07/10/2022 08:35

eltonjohnsglasses · 07/10/2022 08:16

I see people saying this but in practice, it's not the same for a few reasons:

The people in Kent usually don't live that close to the station - sometimes a drive away

Again I think this is similar in parts of London though particularly in zones 5/6. I had two friends who lived in different parts of z3 & it was a pain to get them, a good 25 min fast walk to station & no bus route.

Frequency & cost will definitely be different but again parts of outer London are like this anyway & not everywhere even has the tube. But I was only referring to length of journey.

I've always lived in z2/3 & always allowed at least 45 mins for my journey door to door despite having train/tube/bus on my doorstep because there is generally the delays from traffic/people congestion/waiting for a tube etc. My friend in Kent takes similar time to meet (train itself is 20 mins to St Pancreas)

Where do you live @Tomorrowisalatterday?

Zone 3 and no bus route? I would be very interested to know where that is.

Yes of course if you compare zone 6 with the home counties, there won't be much difference - because they are basically right next to each other!

I know you're trying to make it all about exact journey time but my point is that's not everything - cost, frequency and number of options make a difference too. And by and large London is better for that than living outside on a train line.

I live in South London, zone 3. 10-15 mins walk from 2 train stations on different lines, can catch a bus to 3 different tube lines. I can get to most places in London in 45 mins door to door, not just one mainline rail station. I can go to a gig at the 02, the museums in Kensington, my friend's gigs in obscure Islington pubs, etc etc.

I am not saying everyone has to think the same things are important but it's disingenuous to say that there is nothing different about living in London.

eltonjohnsglasses · 07/10/2022 08:23

Plenty of Z6 stations are in Surrey anyway