Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Could it be autism? DS10 struggling and sad

39 replies

Couldtheyfly · 06/10/2022 13:02

My son is 10 years old (year 6) and has always struggled to form friendships. He is chatty and kind and sweet but broadly speaking, not as mature or sophisticated as some of his peer group. He is mildly dyslexic and has a terrible memory so he appears a little disorganised and all over the place sometimes.

But what's really holding him back is that he can't seem to adjust his behaviour socially. He does things that annoy other children, like patting them on the back or repeating an annoying phrase. Or calling out in class and making jokes that no one else seems to be amused by. He wants to get laughs from other kids as he sees that as a way of making friends. But conversely he doesn't always want to socialise or seek out the company of other kids. He is at his most content watching a favourite TV programme on the sofa or sitting on his bedroom floor with Lego. He never builds the proper Lego set - just repeatedly plays with very small rare pieces and makes his own little figures and models. He carries Lego around with him, always has to have something, like a prop or a comfort toy.

I really don't know how to help him - school have just disciplined him very severely for annoying /calling out in class and he just seems to be getting worse. He seems lost, overloaded, all over the place. Trying desperately to make friends and get the other kids to like him but the more he tries, the more they dislike him. He's so unhappy and often cries when he talks about it at home.

My older child has recently been diagnosed with high-functioning autism. They are very different children - my older son is very academic and has some good, solid friendships.

I wonder if my DS10 has autism too, but is presenting very differently. We will seek a diagnosis, but in the meantime how can I help/support him? He ultimately needs to stop with these behaviours that are not school appropriate and annoying his peers. I don't know why he continues - he does understand other people find it annoying and it's not helping him to make friends - but that doesn't seem to deter him. I don't know if he can't help himself or he genuinely cannot judge how his words/actions will be received. Probably a bit of both ... Would love to hear any advice and or similar experiences. I feel so sad that he's having such an unhappy time at school.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Phineyj · 06/10/2022 20:24

I think you're on a bit of a sticky wicket with "how annoying behaviours can be for others." My DD simply doesn't get that. Distraction and redirection work better, or some physical activity.

Phineyj · 06/10/2022 20:22

I watch TV with my daughter and talk to her a lot about the characters. Why is she sad? How do you think X felt when Y did that thing? What should she do about...etc.

The Dumping Ground is good material!

Couldtheyfly · 06/10/2022 20:10

He is receiving positive reinforcement from another teacher which is helping.

Are there any games or books that have helped with social situations - or just role play?

OP posts:
Couldtheyfly · 06/10/2022 20:07

Think we definitely need to start supporting with modelling how to start conversations with friends, how annoying behaviours can feel for others. And appropriate comebacks for when he is on the receiving end of teasing.

I haven't pushed back too much with school this time but have said I don't think the disciplinary is helpful to him while he's struggling. I am trying to maintain positive relationship with school. Feels like a balancing act and I don't want to jump in too soon before giving them a chance to support.

OP posts:
Phineyj · 06/10/2022 19:52

Music Theatre has helped my DD who is about the same age with ASD ADHD diagnoses. I think it's because it's very structured and singing, shouting and running about is positively encouraged if it's appropriate for the scene.

I think girls are sometimes better at copying social behaviour even if they don't truly get why they need to do it.

The idea of social stories is good.

yellowbananasss · 06/10/2022 19:41

maranella · 06/10/2022 19:11

Low self esteem and ADHD (not sure about autism) are unfortunately common. My DS said the first thing that he noticed when we got him on medication for his ADHD was that he felt more confident. I hadn't appreciated how low his self confidence was until then. OP it sounds like the school know that you're looking into diagnosis for him and I'm glad that they are being proactive about helping him with social issues, but it really isn't helpful to be punishing a DC who probably has SEN. All it will do is make him feel worse and not help his behaviour. Does the school have a SENCo? If so, I would arrange a meeting with them to discuss how best to deal with his more challenging behaviours in a way that doesn't cast him as naughty or badly behaved as that simply isn't helpful.

Definitely true for ASD in our case. Ds was miserable and felt like a failure getting everything wrong all the time. He called himself a weirdo etc. he is in a specialist autism secondary now and thriving because everyone is the same as him and he doesn't feel like a weirdo anymore. He walks a little bit taller and is much more confidant about himself.

Hankunamatata · 06/10/2022 19:28

We also do a family sport together that allows boys to perform individually but be part of a group

Hankunamatata · 06/10/2022 19:27

He sounds lovely not unlike my own boys who all have adhd or asd or both. We talk lots about emotions and feelings. We even role play different situations to show how behaviours can annoy people.
School need more supportive goals. Instead of punishments they could do what my sons primary do. He gets stickers every 1/4 of the day for not shouting out then certificate at the end of the day if he managed to do whole day putting up his hand. He also has timers and visual equipment list so he know what he needs to get on his desk and 3 min sand timer to start work.

Blueroses99 · 06/10/2022 19:25

My DC got support before getting a diagnosis. Perhaps speaking to the SENCO about support can be put in place to specifically help from an inclusion perspective. Good luck OP

maranella · 06/10/2022 19:11

Low self esteem and ADHD (not sure about autism) are unfortunately common. My DS said the first thing that he noticed when we got him on medication for his ADHD was that he felt more confident. I hadn't appreciated how low his self confidence was until then. OP it sounds like the school know that you're looking into diagnosis for him and I'm glad that they are being proactive about helping him with social issues, but it really isn't helpful to be punishing a DC who probably has SEN. All it will do is make him feel worse and not help his behaviour. Does the school have a SENCo? If so, I would arrange a meeting with them to discuss how best to deal with his more challenging behaviours in a way that doesn't cast him as naughty or badly behaved as that simply isn't helpful.

Couldtheyfly · 06/10/2022 16:01

Thank you, thank you. All of this is so helpful. I think rest breaks and a friendly face for a 1:1 chat would be so helpful for him. I really appreciate your responses.

OP posts:
Winter99Mermaid · 06/10/2022 14:57

Talk to SENDCO get stuff in writing to make sure there’s a paper trail as you may need that later in. Set out your concerns, if his attendance starts to drop they soon sit up and listen as that effects ofsted ratings… my DD wasn’t listened to much at primary but at secondary because they are used to seeing more of this it’s been eye opening that small things have made a huge difference to her day. She has structured breaks from learning and 1:1 chats with a well-being TA this helps emotional regulation. Encouraged to try different lunch stuff like Art, board games and music to give a break from “school”. There is things they can do but you need them to change the narrative from naughty to his needs are not being met in the current environment.

Wishiwasatsoftplay · 06/10/2022 14:56

stealthninjamum · 06/10/2022 13:32

My dd has asd and inattentive adhd. Ask school to treat him as if he has either because it might take years for a diagnosis and you do do not want his mental health to get worse.

If he is calling out in class perhaps he is self regulating and stressed underneath. Don’t stop this behaviour without finding an alternative behaviour that works for him. So perhaps doodling or playing with a toy or paper clip or blu tac under the table. If a child is self regulating or ‘masking’ ie trying to be neurotypical its harmful to stop them. Your school should know this.

In secondary this is often what ADD looks like: off task, staring into space, processing instructions behind (so getting out of seat to get book after everyone has already started reading), continuing a class joke on and not stopping until ‘told off’- so waiting for a very obvious negative reaction as a social cue to stop. Aiming social interactions with peers at a ‘whole group level’ (shouting out random stuff, for instance), or at a very tactile level personally (tapping chairs, throwing pencil cases, etc) and again, waiting for a very obvious negative reaction to stop.

the way it’s dealt with in ks3 is to- over explain (‘ie, a joke is only funny for a short time, then it stops being funny, the joke has stopped now’), clear negative and positive reactions (not punishments, but verbal statements rather than simply body language), sometimes a TA will provide a running commentary on other students reactions (x smiled the first time but now isn’t smiling, that means it’s time to stop if you still want x to feel friendly), and as a Pp - structured group activities or clubs

TangoRomeo · 06/10/2022 14:55

Get it all in writing too. Email concerns. If you have a conversation then follow it up in writing and ask for a response to confirm that your understanding is correct. Tackle dealing with school like an important project, create a paper trail and collect evidence.

mamabear715 · 06/10/2022 14:53

Oh, BLESS him.. no wonder he pushed another child if they were tormenting him.. how must it make kids feel if others are being cruel & they are the one getting punished? Obvs (before everyone gets on their high horse) 'violence' isn't good, but I'd expect school to take into account that he could be ND.
I have 2 ND kids, they do present very differently.
Mine used to appreciate just quiet comfort when they got home from school. Me being there if hugs were required, but not quizzing them.
Anyway you'll know all this already (teaches grandmother to suck eggs..) ;-)

TangoRomeo · 06/10/2022 14:53

Could be ADHD/ASD, or both.

Get the ball rolling for him to be assessed as it will take a long time (unless private)

School could support by using social stories (not calling out in class/friendships/personal space), movement breaks away from the classroom and anything else more specific to his needs. Support should be based on need, not diagnosis , so they have no excuse not to support at this stage.

Get them to put plan, do, review in place and set targets (they will then have to look at the things that will help him reach the targets)

Thurst · 06/10/2022 14:50

Social stories and comic strip conversations are my go to way of explaining recurring social issues to kids with social communication difficulties.
There definitely sounds like there is something going on. If it’s ADHD or ASC you should seek assessment.

waterrat · 06/10/2022 14:49

Huge sympathy OP my 8 year old struggles in some similar ways. Although her anxiety is so high it stops her acting out as you describe.

Would he be better out of mainstream?

cynthiasrevels · 06/10/2022 14:47

ASD and ADHD often present together. This sounds very like my son, who is also 10, and he has been diagnosed with both conditions for several years now. School is intensely stressful for him, and he also plays the clown to cope. He also needs time just watching tv at home to relax and 'shut down': don't feel bad about that, it's important for him.

I agree with the suggestion that you ask the school to treat him as if he has both conditions, and to stop treating him as if he is simply naughty. They don't sound very sympathetic to neurodiversity at all! And get an assessment if you possibly can. We did pay privately, it was really expensive but the diagnosis has helped hugely. There are various medications for ADHD that can be very effective if you want to go down that route (many do not, but it has helped our son cope at school).

HellsBellsSmellss · 06/10/2022 14:41

Join all the Facebook groups you can find to do with parenting kids with ADHD. This is my main source of information! This will give you the knowledge to find ways to help your son and more confidence to question school.

I try to keep things very undemanding after school. One of mine relaxes by going on the trampoline, another reads books, youngest plays Lego. It’s working out what will work for your child. All of my DCs diagnoses have given me confidence to go and ask for different things for my children. I think the SENCOs at their schools hate me 😂
If your son gets very distracted by using his hands to fidget, he might do better with a wobble cushion or something which moves his whole body (proprioceptive input) Would school let him go and have a movement/sensory break when he’s becoming dysregulated? There’s lots to think about and there’s no negative to getting a diagnosis.

Couldtheyfly · 06/10/2022 14:30

@stealthninjamum, he doodles when stressed. He also often carries a comfort toy like a Lego mini figure or very small soft toy.

Trouble is, he is also distracted by these things and will probably ed up having them taken away by teachers if he's playing with them in lessons.

Considering mentioning older siblings' diagnosis to ask if they will consider this but I doubt they will

OP posts:
Couldtheyfly · 06/10/2022 14:26

We have started the ball rolling with assessment but feel desperate to help him in the interim.

And even with a diagnosis - how do we help? I think he's constantly overloaded with thoughts and feelings and seems to need to 'shutdown' for an hour or two to reset.

Not sure how to handle with school - as I mentioned they have just given him a huge disciplinary which I disagreed with. DS pushed a kid (no one was in any way hurt) who was part of a group being unkind to him (and as it turns out, have been making cruel comments to him for weeks). School are not going to do a u-turn on the disciplinary but in the meantime DS feels like a failure and it's not been good for his self esteem. He really, really did not want to go to school today.

OP posts:
HellsBellsSmellss · 06/10/2022 13:47

ADHD is not just the stereotype of a hyperactive constantly on the go kid who can’t sit still. Hyperactive ADHD is the least common of the 3 types. A more inattentive ADHD is particularly difficult because they’re not seen as struggling because they’re quiet and compliant. In my experience even if a child has done well in primary with little/no support the beginning of secondary school is a massive test as pressure increases and it’s worth thinking about getting on a waiting list for assessment, either CAMHS or privately if you can.

Namechanger965 · 06/10/2022 13:46

I would pursue an assessment as he’s struggling and either way it will highlight what his difficulties are. But to help him sooner I would look into social stories, they can be really useful to clearly explain social situations to children. The social skills coaching could be really good as well.

Does he do any clubs out of school? It may be easier for him to make friends in a less formal environment.

Tigofigo · 06/10/2022 13:37

Bear in mind that there are millions of children who won't get an ADHD or autism diagnosis but that are still neurodivergent - from what you've said I wonder if your child may have processing issues, working memory issues, possibly auditory processing problems, sensory issues. Could be autistic, could not.