Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think that JK Rowling is a lioness of epic proportions?

548 replies

WandaWomblesaurus · 05/10/2022 23:52

I don't think I'm being unreasonable. She's put everything out there to safeguard children in the face of vile misogyny and cowardice from many of her fellow writers.

She also always has beautiful hair.

NYANBU

YYABUTQ+

OP posts:
Thread gallery
11
BernadetteRostankowskiWolowitz · 06/10/2022 14:28

Cw112 · 06/10/2022 14:17

What's said negatively about trans individuals affects how trans children are perceived in society. Jk rowling has also spoken about how she believes most children experiencing gender dysphoria will "grow out of it" this compromises their ability to access particular medicines and medical treatments which is important when we have a lot of children where I live who are completely unable to access medication to pause puberty until they go through gender/identity counselling work. That means they are going through puberty and then having to transition which we know makes things much harder for them. Its also led to a huge increase in children accessing those medications online and taking them in unsafe and unregulated ways which is really dangerous. So yes that is harmful.

In terms of what's happening with Mermaids that's on them 100% they should be acting (as should any charity working with vulnerable people) under robust whistleblowing and safeguarding mechanisms. They sadly haven't lived up to that but unfortunately they are not the only children's charity to fall short in this way and they need to be held fully accountable as any other provider would be and lessons need to be learnt. Those are two separate issues however...

Do you honestly think that a child who is (by law) inccapable of consenting to sex, unable to purchase alcohol, unable to vote, unable to get a drivers licence, unable to purchase a blade (including a pair of scissors), unable to choose an alternative route to education, unable to serve on a Jury, unable to be tried as an adult in a serious crime.....

Is the appropriate age to be able to decide to take chemical supplements to delay or prevent puberty, purchase and wear straps across their developing breasts, and undergo any surgery to ammend their (perfectly perfect) body?

Seriously??

We should be giving children the space and confidence to wear what they like, challenge societal stereotypes and building their confidence to be able to say "this is me and I am happy with me". Not throwing them over to groups like Mermaids and effectively telling them they are wrong and need fixing.

EdgeOfACoin · 06/10/2022 14:27

ThrowingSomeCrumbs · 06/10/2022 14:13

Say you're in hospital. The person in the bed next you has all appearance of being male. Do you ask them if they are trans? Ask the staff? Should they have a special sign at the head of their bed to make sure everyone knows?
Or would you presume you're sharing a ward with a male and feel uncomfortable about that?

ThrowingSomeCrumbs

Do you think that women have the right to feel uncomfortable sharing a ward with males?

If the person on the ward really were male, do you believe a woman in that situation has the right to ask to be moved to an all-female ward?

Or should women not have that right?

Butitsnotfunnyisititsserious · 06/10/2022 14:26

No one has any business prescribing drugs, puberty blockers, hormones to pre-pubescent children. You cannot defend that. You cannot defend that position, reasonably, morally, ethically or humanely.

This. There is absolutely no defence to that.

CatsandFish · 06/10/2022 14:24

Cw112 · 06/10/2022 14:17

What's said negatively about trans individuals affects how trans children are perceived in society. Jk rowling has also spoken about how she believes most children experiencing gender dysphoria will "grow out of it" this compromises their ability to access particular medicines and medical treatments which is important when we have a lot of children where I live who are completely unable to access medication to pause puberty until they go through gender/identity counselling work. That means they are going through puberty and then having to transition which we know makes things much harder for them. Its also led to a huge increase in children accessing those medications online and taking them in unsafe and unregulated ways which is really dangerous. So yes that is harmful.

In terms of what's happening with Mermaids that's on them 100% they should be acting (as should any charity working with vulnerable people) under robust whistleblowing and safeguarding mechanisms. They sadly haven't lived up to that but unfortunately they are not the only children's charity to fall short in this way and they need to be held fully accountable as any other provider would be and lessons need to be learnt. Those are two separate issues however...

@Cw112 Jk rowling has also spoken about how she believes most children experiencing gender dysphoria will "grow out of it"

Evidence clearly shows when children are left to grow out of it, the vast overwhelming, overwhelming majority they identify as gay. It's not just what Rowling says, departmental statistics show this.

Are you really suggesting we sterilise children, pump them full of hormones, on the off chance that 2 percent will turn out to be trans?

Please think critically about what you are saying. No one has any business prescribing drugs, puberty blockers, hormones to pre-pubescent children. You cannot defend that. You cannot defend that position, reasonably, morally, ethically or humanely.

Cw112 · 06/10/2022 14:17

TheKeatingFive · 06/10/2022 13:15

I think it's interesting you talk about her safeguarding children through these views when they are directly harmful to trans children especially

Okay two questions on this ...

What has she said that's harmful to trans children?

How do you rate the safeguarding abilities of organisations expressly catering to trans children, like Mermaids? Are they doing a better job in your eyes?

What's said negatively about trans individuals affects how trans children are perceived in society. Jk rowling has also spoken about how she believes most children experiencing gender dysphoria will "grow out of it" this compromises their ability to access particular medicines and medical treatments which is important when we have a lot of children where I live who are completely unable to access medication to pause puberty until they go through gender/identity counselling work. That means they are going through puberty and then having to transition which we know makes things much harder for them. Its also led to a huge increase in children accessing those medications online and taking them in unsafe and unregulated ways which is really dangerous. So yes that is harmful.

In terms of what's happening with Mermaids that's on them 100% they should be acting (as should any charity working with vulnerable people) under robust whistleblowing and safeguarding mechanisms. They sadly haven't lived up to that but unfortunately they are not the only children's charity to fall short in this way and they need to be held fully accountable as any other provider would be and lessons need to be learnt. Those are two separate issues however...

ThrowingSomeCrumbs · 06/10/2022 14:13

Say you're in hospital. The person in the bed next you has all appearance of being male. Do you ask them if they are trans? Ask the staff? Should they have a special sign at the head of their bed to make sure everyone knows?
Or would you presume you're sharing a ward with a male and feel uncomfortable about that?

EdgeOfACoin · 06/10/2022 13:46

Beowulfa · 06/10/2022 13:25

Look, if you'd just stop weaponising your middle aged ignorance and watched a YouTube video of Barry who's now Bonita explaining how wearing lipstick and dresses gives him special woman feelings you'd have your stupid answers.

No, that can't be it, Beowulfa because clothing and make-up are to do with stereotypes and I have been told repeatedly that being trans is nothing to do with stereotypes.

Perhaps figtrees or another poster could recommend a particularly helpful video?

I've watched quite a few of Jammiedodger's videos over the years, but my questions are still very much unanswered.

WandaWomblesaurus · 06/10/2022 13:46

Back to JKR, I cannot imagine Pullman or Gaiman or King being as brave, but then they wouldn't get the rape threats would they.
Can't think why that is?

OP posts:
WandaWomblesaurus · 06/10/2022 13:44

"Look you old saggy TERF old granny women, get over your ignorance and watch a YouTube video of Alok saying "I believe in the radical notion that little girls are complicated people. There are no fairy tales and no princess here. Little girls are trans, queer, kinky, devious, kind, mean, beautiful, ugly, tremendous and peculiar.”
Then you would understand how PROGRESSIVE THE NEW RELIGION IS.

OP posts:
TheKeatingFive · 06/10/2022 13:35

What happens is some big name reads it, declares it transphobic, makes up some shit about it and then says no one else should read it.

Interestingly, this is the approach the catholic clergy historically took to the bible. They controlled the narrative and limited the plebs ability to analyse for themselves. The religious parallels here just pile up and pile up.

ginslinger · 06/10/2022 13:34

Ican't find any direct quotes to show JKR is bigotted either because - spoiler alert - there are NONE

I love her

maranella · 06/10/2022 13:32

Agreed - she's just so fucking fearless and outspoken (or at least, she gives the impression of being fearless - I don't know if she really is!).

I didn't love the HP books and couldn't get into the Cormoron Strike ones either, but god I love her as a woman!

SantaCarlaCalifornia · 06/10/2022 13:32

TheKeatingFive · 06/10/2022 13:26

Have you even read what she said about trans people?

Another thing I often wonder.

What proportion of those criticising Rowling's views have read the essay? I'm guessing this is under 10% and even that seems optimistic sometimes. Because none of them seem to have a frigging clue what's in it.

Very few do, it's obvious when they can't answer any questions about it. What happens is some big name reads it, declares it transphobic, makes up some shit about it and then says no one else should read it.

You no longer have to seek things out, someone has already done it and then made a youtube video about their opinion, so you watch that instead and now their opinion is yours without having ever set eyes on the original. It's pretty scary when people are being spoonfed lies about so many things and never think to question them.

Butitsnotfunnyisititsserious · 06/10/2022 13:27

Look, if you'd just stop weaponising your middle aged ignorance and watched a YouTube video of Barry who's now Bonita explaining how wearing lipstick and dresses gives him special woman feelings you'd have your stupid answers.

😂😂😂

TheKeatingFive · 06/10/2022 13:27

Nobody can provide direct quotes from JKR to show how bigoted she is?

Nobody at all?

Ive seen this played out many times of Twitter. The barrel scraping is quite something to watch.

Hoppinggreen · 06/10/2022 13:27

I really loathe the HP books (there, I said it) but I do appreciate they helped a lot of children to love reading.
I do think she’s awesome though, finally someone using their privileged position for good

TheKeatingFive · 06/10/2022 13:26

Have you even read what she said about trans people?

Another thing I often wonder.

What proportion of those criticising Rowling's views have read the essay? I'm guessing this is under 10% and even that seems optimistic sometimes. Because none of them seem to have a frigging clue what's in it.

Caroffee · 06/10/2022 13:26

EdgeOfACoin · 06/10/2022 13:21

So... nobody reading this thread can explain how mtf transitioners are women?

Nobody can explain which rights trans people need that they don't already have?

Nobody can provide direct quotes from JKR to show how bigoted she is?

Nobody at all?

Their opinions lack the basic point-evidence-explain needed to justify them.

Beowulfa · 06/10/2022 13:25

EdgeOfACoin · 06/10/2022 13:21

So... nobody reading this thread can explain how mtf transitioners are women?

Nobody can explain which rights trans people need that they don't already have?

Nobody can provide direct quotes from JKR to show how bigoted she is?

Nobody at all?

Look, if you'd just stop weaponising your middle aged ignorance and watched a YouTube video of Barry who's now Bonita explaining how wearing lipstick and dresses gives him special woman feelings you'd have your stupid answers.

MarieIVanArkleStinks · 06/10/2022 13:25

Any fringe movement or rights lobby which flags the word 'safeguarding' as a dog whistle is jumping up and down in plain sight showing the whole world exactly what they are, what they do, and what their goals and intentions are.

When someone shows who they are, believe them the first time. This is children's entire futures being sacrificed on the altar of ideology. And the back-tweets of many Mermaids supporters are mysteriously disappearing into the memory hole.

The feminists are the ones who told you so.

Butitsnotfunnyisititsserious · 06/10/2022 13:24

EdgeOfACoin · 06/10/2022 13:21

So... nobody reading this thread can explain how mtf transitioners are women?

Nobody can explain which rights trans people need that they don't already have?

Nobody can provide direct quotes from JKR to show how bigoted she is?

Nobody at all?

Apparently not. It's a shame no one can actually defend their views.

Caroffee · 06/10/2022 13:24

FortunesFavour · 06/10/2022 13:03

Sadly for you @figtrees, the whole UK population has indeed been “educating itself” so now everybody can see what a steaming pile of woman hating bullshit gender ideology truly is.

Although do crack on, your angry little outbursts on this thread only show up the grubby misogyny you espouse.

Yes, yes, yes!!

EdgeOfACoin · 06/10/2022 13:21

So... nobody reading this thread can explain how mtf transitioners are women?

Nobody can explain which rights trans people need that they don't already have?

Nobody can provide direct quotes from JKR to show how bigoted she is?

Nobody at all?

MarieIVanArkleStinks · 06/10/2022 13:21

figtrees · 06/10/2022 12:48

Oh please it's just more laziness. If you actually wanted to educate yourselves you would.

Instead you want to use weaponised ignorance to try and make me explain myself. The arguments already exist and I do not owe you an explanation. Nobody owns you anything....

But you can find out if you bothered to look. You're just either too stupid, too lazy, or actually don't really want to hear it you just want to defend your ideologies with a wall of ignorance.

Meaning you've witnessed the vociferous chanting of 'burn the witch!' on SM but haven't actually read a word of Rowling's essay.

Righty ho.

Interesting the way people double down when asked exactly what it is JKR has said that is evil, or whether the hatred spews at her is in any way justified by what she said in the first place (but what is that? Her detractors rarely seem to know).

Unsurprising. 280 characters per tweet isn't conducive to a nuanced argument.

Igmum · 06/10/2022 13:20

Can't vote because I'm on the app but ❤️❤️❤️JKR

Swipe left for the next trending thread