Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think that JK Rowling is a lioness of epic proportions?

548 replies

WandaWomblesaurus · 05/10/2022 23:52

I don't think I'm being unreasonable. She's put everything out there to safeguard children in the face of vile misogyny and cowardice from many of her fellow writers.

She also always has beautiful hair.

NYANBU

YYABUTQ+

OP posts:
Thread gallery
11
Knittingmonster · 06/10/2022 14:56

lupron even. Lipton is innocent

Hoppinggreen · 06/10/2022 14:56

CatsandFish · 06/10/2022 14:53

@Hoppinggreen No, that is the argument I was making. We should not make it legal.

I know @CatsandFish , I was agreeing with your argument with another poster
Its the way the new quote system works now, it’s not always clear

Knittingmonster · 06/10/2022 14:56

CatsandFish · 06/10/2022 14:53

@Hoppinggreen No, that is the argument I was making. We should not make it legal.

But puberty blockers such as Lipton have been shown to be highly dangerous have they not? Wasn’t Lupron considered to dangerous to give to pedophiles to chemically castrate them? Didn’t it cause horrendous problems when it was given to women with cancers? So why would anyone give it to children?

TheKeatingFive · 06/10/2022 14:55

I'd still like clarification on exactly what comments JKR has made on the treatment of TG kids.

CatsandFish · 06/10/2022 14:53

Hoppinggreen · 06/10/2022 14:36

So we should make something dangerous legal in case children do it illegally?

@Hoppinggreen No, that is the argument I was making. We should not make it legal.

CrossStichQueen · 06/10/2022 14:53

But by taking away options,

But nobody is taking away options.
What is now starting to happen is that children and young people are not being put on a medical pathway after only 2 short appointments.
They are not being encouraged to see surgery as the only option.

If someone is suicidal then that is a mental health problem and they need proper mental health support by professionals. What they don't need it to be prescribed drugs to halt their natural development or to be offered free breadt ironing wear without parental consent.

CatsandFish · 06/10/2022 14:53

dianthus101 · 06/10/2022 14:35

I thought that this would be a thread about JK Rowling books but it is just the usual attempt by the same old posters to have an argument with anyone who isn't transphobic.

@dianthus101 You mean a usual attempt by people who want to accuse vulnerable women who want to keep our human rights that our foresister feminists fought for as 'transphobic'. Have you even read this thread?

Ramblingnamechanger · 06/10/2022 14:52

both may be a big flag for mental health issues arising from various problems.

TheKeatingFive · 06/10/2022 14:52

We know eating disorders are very different than identifying as transgender so let's not try to compare the two shall we?

In that we apply basic safeguarding principles to the management of eating disorders, but not transgender?

How are you not appalled by this?

Knittingmonster · 06/10/2022 14:52

Cw112 · 06/10/2022 14:49

We know eating disorders are very different than identifying as transgender so let's not try to compare the two shall we?

How so? How is one dysphoria treatable by affirmation and the Other not?

Cw112 · 06/10/2022 14:49

Knittingmonster · 06/10/2022 14:47

So If a teenage girl came to you and said she identified as fat but her parents didn’t believe her, and they kept making her eat, and this made her want to kill herself, would you refer her to weightwatchers behind her parents backs and give her weight loss tips?

We know eating disorders are very different than identifying as transgender so let's not try to compare the two shall we?

FlirtsWithRhinos · 06/10/2022 14:49

It's clearly upsetting you way more than it upsets me. I don't care about same sex toilets. I don't care who identifies as what gender. I don't care what somebody else's genitals look like.

I am very happy that this poster has the privilege not to care about anyone's sex.

I don't think this poster's good fortune to have avoided the many ways male people impose themselves on female, from the worst of physical attacks (rape, femicide), through belittlement and coercive control, to the daily grind of male people talking over us, or monopolising our time, or underestimating our abilities and generally making our lives a little bit harder to make their own a little bit easier...

I don't think this poster's good fortune to have avoided all the above gives them any right to deny single sex support to the many many female people who have experienced this, who are upset when male privilege encroaches on them, who do care about same sex toilets, who do care who identifies as what gender if this allows them to override protections and rights based on sex, and who do care what somebody else's genitals look like if they are likely to be alone and vulnerable with that person, or share an intimate space with them.

Knittingmonster · 06/10/2022 14:47

Cw112 · 06/10/2022 14:37

Have you read the stats on suicide and attempted suicide rates among trans individuals, they are exceptionally high and most cite lack of support, understanding and access to medical provision as a large reason for that. For me, that's a decision that needs to be made between medical providers, parents and absolutely I do think young people need and deserve to be consulted and their views taken into consideration. I've worked with a large number of actively suicidal young people who when they opened up about being trans and accessing supports like binders etc their suicide attempts stop. For me if it's deemed safe and appropriate for them to access puberty blockers by medical professionals until they are able to access the relevant counselling then yes I'd rather they stayed alive in the first instance to then get the option of deciding whether or not to proceed. But by taking away options, we are increasing suicidal ideation and driving young people to unregulated meds which does god knows how much damage. I'm not saying the system is prefect- it needs massively overhauled in terms of how gender identity is addressed and better support available but working within what's currently on the table I think we're between a rock and a hard place. I don't think anyone is telling kids they are wrong or needing fixing... but when a young person is in so much distress that they'd rather die than continue as they are that needs to be addressed seriously.

So If a teenage girl came to you and said she identified as fat but her parents didn’t believe her, and they kept making her eat, and this made her want to kill herself, would you refer her to weightwatchers behind her parents backs and give her weight loss tips?

RufusthefIoraImissingreindeer · 06/10/2022 14:41

dianthus101 · 06/10/2022 14:35

I thought that this would be a thread about JK Rowling books but it is just the usual attempt by the same old posters to have an argument with anyone who isn't transphobic.

I thought it would be an appreciation thread

But then some posters arrived and said JKR was transphobic and then refused to clarify what they meant by it

Guess we are both disappointed in how it turned out...disappointed but not surprised as it always happens

TheKeatingFive · 06/10/2022 14:39

Have you read the stats on suicide and attempted suicide rates among trans individuals

Isn't that data all highly disputed / debunked? And what about suicide rates among regretful transitioned?

Cw112 · 06/10/2022 14:37

BernadetteRostankowskiWolowitz · 06/10/2022 14:28

Do you honestly think that a child who is (by law) inccapable of consenting to sex, unable to purchase alcohol, unable to vote, unable to get a drivers licence, unable to purchase a blade (including a pair of scissors), unable to choose an alternative route to education, unable to serve on a Jury, unable to be tried as an adult in a serious crime.....

Is the appropriate age to be able to decide to take chemical supplements to delay or prevent puberty, purchase and wear straps across their developing breasts, and undergo any surgery to ammend their (perfectly perfect) body?

Seriously??

We should be giving children the space and confidence to wear what they like, challenge societal stereotypes and building their confidence to be able to say "this is me and I am happy with me". Not throwing them over to groups like Mermaids and effectively telling them they are wrong and need fixing.

Have you read the stats on suicide and attempted suicide rates among trans individuals, they are exceptionally high and most cite lack of support, understanding and access to medical provision as a large reason for that. For me, that's a decision that needs to be made between medical providers, parents and absolutely I do think young people need and deserve to be consulted and their views taken into consideration. I've worked with a large number of actively suicidal young people who when they opened up about being trans and accessing supports like binders etc their suicide attempts stop. For me if it's deemed safe and appropriate for them to access puberty blockers by medical professionals until they are able to access the relevant counselling then yes I'd rather they stayed alive in the first instance to then get the option of deciding whether or not to proceed. But by taking away options, we are increasing suicidal ideation and driving young people to unregulated meds which does god knows how much damage. I'm not saying the system is prefect- it needs massively overhauled in terms of how gender identity is addressed and better support available but working within what's currently on the table I think we're between a rock and a hard place. I don't think anyone is telling kids they are wrong or needing fixing... but when a young person is in so much distress that they'd rather die than continue as they are that needs to be addressed seriously.

Butitsnotfunnyisititsserious · 06/10/2022 14:37

dianthus101 · 06/10/2022 14:35

I thought that this would be a thread about JK Rowling books but it is just the usual attempt by the same old posters to have an argument with anyone who isn't transphobic.

Where's the transphobia please?

TheKeatingFive · 06/10/2022 14:37

I thought that this would be a thread about JK Rowling books but it is just the usual attempt by the same old posters to have an argument with anyone who isn't transphobic.

Are you going to help us all out by pointing out anything JKR has said that is transphobic? C'mon, I dare you.

Hoppinggreen · 06/10/2022 14:36

CatsandFish · 06/10/2022 14:33

Its also led to a huge increase in children accessing those medications online and taking them in unsafe and unregulated ways which is really dangerous. So yes that is harmful.

I forgot this. This pitiful argument can be used for crystal meth or heroin. It leads to an increase in people networking on the internet to gain access to dangerous illicit drugs.

It does not make it right.

So we should make something dangerous legal in case children do it illegally?

dianthus101 · 06/10/2022 14:35

I thought that this would be a thread about JK Rowling books but it is just the usual attempt by the same old posters to have an argument with anyone who isn't transphobic.

CatsandFish · 06/10/2022 14:33

Its also led to a huge increase in children accessing those medications online and taking them in unsafe and unregulated ways which is really dangerous. So yes that is harmful.

I forgot this. This pitiful argument can be used for crystal meth or heroin. It leads to an increase in people networking on the internet to gain access to dangerous illicit drugs.

It does not make it right.

TrashyPanda · 06/10/2022 14:33

JKR is an amazing woman: intelligent, inspiring, and brave.

she stands up to bullies
she donates millions to charity
She is a self-made woman, who survived grinding poverty and has never forgotten how grim life can be for so many people
she will not be silenced by those seeking to deny the bleeding obvious.

we need more people like her.

tellmewhentheLangshiplandscoz · 06/10/2022 14:31

Cw112 · 06/10/2022 13:12

There are certain things I really admire about her- I think she's a complete badass for overcoming all the hardships she's been through with a small child as a single mum to get to where she's at now and I love HP, it's a brilliant series and a huge accomplishment for any writer and I love how much she's done for charity so you're not bu to think she's awesome for that but I was disappointed in her comments regarding trans people. I think it's interesting you talk about her safeguarding children through these views when they are directly harmful to trans children especially and to the children of trans parents and their needs should be considered equally to any other child. But as I say you can admire certain things about people without having to think they're a complete Saint and there are certain things about her that are certainly very inspiring.

Hey CW112 👋
Could you expand on how you think she's harmful to trans kids and their families?

TheKeatingFive · 06/10/2022 14:30

What's said negatively about trans individuals affects how trans children are perceived in society.

And what has she said about trans individuals?

Jk rowling has also spoken about how she believes most children experiencing gender dysphoria will "grow out of it"

Quote please? What did she say exactly?

And regardless, isn't that position well evidenced? That the process of going through puberty can alleviate GD feelings? Are you really suggesting that every child who expresses discomfort with their changing body needs medicalising?

when we have a lot of children where I live who are completely unable to access medication to pause puberty

Have you actually read the CASS report and the conclusions from Sweden and Finland about the huge concerns of the long term effects of puberty blockers? We can't just 'pause' puberty with no consequences. We aren't gods.

I am constantly gobsmacked at how little those who claim to speak for Trans children seem to care about the long term impact of these medical interventions on them?

Its also led to a huge increase in children accessing those medications online and taking them in unsafe and unregulated ways which is really dangerous. So yes that is harmful.

So crack down on that then, that's hardly JKR's fault. C'mon. Some common sense here.

CatsandFish · 06/10/2022 14:29

What's said negatively about trans individuals affects how trans children are perceived in society.

What's said negatively about women affects how women (51% vs less than 2%) are perceived in society.

When you say women don't deserve human rights, you are saying women have no place in society. Already there are women at work saying they hold on to their urine until they get home, risking a Urinary Tract Infection. My father died in 2016 from Sepsis due to a UTI. I know how serious it is. There are also reports of where I live of Muslim women no longer going swimming because those areas cannot be guaranteed to be free of males. Some Muslim women and other women change their babies on the side of the road, in a gutter. Rather than go to a woman's space.

What you are doing, is advocating for the eradication of female participation in society. Try some critical thinking and truly, deeply have a long hard think about what you are advocating, to appease privileged males.