Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To wonder why benefits should rise in line with inflation when no job is?

409 replies

Bananil · 05/10/2022 22:22

Massively struggling with food prices and absolutely no chance the heating is going on for a long time yet. DH and I work full time but have not had a pay rise since before the pandemic and wouldn’t ask for one as our industry has taken a real hit. I can’t think of any jobs that are expecting a pay rise in line with inflation so why do much fuss about making sure benefits do?

OP posts:
Museya15 · 06/10/2022 05:26

Go try and live on universal credit OP, then get back to me. I was a single mum on universal credit renting privately,there wasn't enough coming in to pay what was going out. We ended up homeless, it was horrific. Universal credit works for some but majority of the time it's dire.

Nat6999 · 06/10/2022 05:19

I didn't choose to be disabled & housebound, I worked for 27 years before I had to give up work due to ill health.

Rinatinabina · 06/10/2022 05:17

I think you have to admit that every population genuinely has its share of feckless wasters who can’t be arsed. But benefits are a blunt tool and there will always be people who are genuinely in need or doing their best under not ideal circumstances. I’m not sure what I think of an inflationary rise tbh, I’m inclined to say no on the basis of current government support packages.

The lady talking about 39k said she was topped up to equivalent of 39k not that she was making 39k net. So 1200 uc a month which is believable. Tbh if you are a single parent working and with kids I wouldn’t begrudge that.

www.mumsnet.com/talk/am_i_being_unreasonable/3919414-People-on-universal-credit-how-much-do-you-get-a-month

thats an interesting thread, some people will be doing ok, some people struggling depending on their circumstances.

RoachTheHorse · 06/10/2022 05:16

Because it reflects on society most how we treat those who are lost at risk and most vulnerable.

If you are working you are already. I'm a better financial position than someone solely reliant on benefits.

In theory to be eligible to claim benefits you should be unable to work or out of work but trying to get back to work. Comparatively, there are very few people solely relying on benefit claims to survive (most of the "pot" for the benefit costs are actually pensions). I assume these are the people we are talking about.

So you have a small number, compared to whole population, who already get a paltry sum to live on, who are facing increases in cost across the board. These are some of the most vulnerable people in our society.

They should absolutely get an increase in line with inflation because without it these people simply won't be able to live. If someone is living with severe disability do you think, as a society, they should also have the worry of whether to heat or eat?

If we make decisions that impact the most vulnerable positively, that becomes the culture more widely and businesses, and other areas of life will see treating people better as something we just do. It's part of the fabric of what we are as a country. Ultimately, we all benefit from a bit of compassion and moral fortitude.

AndTwoFilmsByFrancoisTruffaut · 06/10/2022 05:02

PupInAPram · 06/10/2022 04:40

I agree with the rationale of your argument but not the patronising, dismissive tone. People who talked down to folk like the OP instead of trying to make address the concerns of others as a discussion between equals, contributed greatly to the feelings of resentment coming from red-wall, first time Conservative voters.

I agree. The tone in some of the responses in this thread is so condescending, it’s just not the way to go about educating others. That’s MN for you though, so often posters use aggression and sarcasm to get their point across. Such a ineffective approach. You catch more flies with honey than vinegar, and another opportunity to enlighten and educate has gone to waste because some folk cannot control their tempers 🤷🏻‍♀️

containsnuts · 06/10/2022 04:53

"But £1400 per month is more than a lot of people bring home from work and have to pay a lot of money for the privilege of going to work - transport costs, smarter clothes, contributions at work.

Going to work is stressful, and those at the lower pay scales are not being listened to"

But for people on benefits there's likely no other means of topping-up in an emergency. No credit, no overdraft, no loans etc so it doesn’t take much to push people over the edge. Poor housing with inefficient heating systems, expensive top-up meters, phone & internet on pay-as you-go can cost more in the long run. Being poor is expensive.

Chilesstanton · 06/10/2022 04:43

Just because you can form a question doesn’t mean you should post it here.

PupInAPram · 06/10/2022 04:41

*sorry 'trying to address or make their point'.

onanotherday · 06/10/2022 04:40

happyinherts · 05/10/2022 22:56

1 single parent adult not working, 2 children, £1400 UC per month, £800 to rent leaves £600. £600 for gas, electric, mobile phone, food and clothing. Electric & gas is £300pm on its own. It’s no life. No life at all, and it makes me so sad when people say things like “I’m sick of paying for others to live” most aren't living, they’re barely surviving.

But £1400 per month is more than a lot of people bring home from work and have to pay a lot of money for the privilege of going to work - transport costs, smarter clothes, contributions at work.

Going to work is stressful, and those at the lower pay scales are not being listened to.

I agree it's not enough for those working either.But it isn't the fault of people on UC, we have a government who have kept wages low for 12 years. They delight in the poor attacking each other. Look at the culprits not the less fortunate.

PupInAPram · 06/10/2022 04:40

yogalu · 06/10/2022 01:53

I can't tell many of you apart from the Daily Mail comments section.
We love a good scapegoat for the cost of living, no better than to poke the poor with a stick. It just isn't as fashionable in the current climate to poke the other one - immigrants.
I always presume that those who begrudge others a dignified living are generally bitter, trapped in a job they loathe and have many unfulfilled dreams sliding down the gutter.

The hard up working classes are obsessed with oneupmanship.
You define work as drudgery because it is all you know. And instead apportioning the blame to those who create the policies and rules, you prefer to stick the boot into those who appear weaker than you. I imagine this is the same contingent who think education is for time wasting sissy's.

I agree with the rationale of your argument but not the patronising, dismissive tone. People who talked down to folk like the OP instead of trying to make address the concerns of others as a discussion between equals, contributed greatly to the feelings of resentment coming from red-wall, first time Conservative voters.

ClaudineClare · 06/10/2022 04:29

Interesting first thread btw OP. Trip trap along now and mind you don't get your hairy hands caught in the door on your way out.

ClaudineClare · 06/10/2022 04:24

Any rise in benefits mostly goes straight back into the economy and the tax system ( via VAT). So all round win-we don't have people going cold and hungry(which will make them ill and put further strain on the NHS) and the economy grows.

FindingMeno · 06/10/2022 04:10

If you're worried about who is screwing us, you need to look up, not down.

Kentgirl2525 · 06/10/2022 04:00

Swizandswap · 05/10/2022 22:34

Quite simply Op those of us who are working class are expected to fund every one, the titch dodge it and the poor expect it. God forbid we are not happy being cash cows working out fingers to the bone. To be honest I'm sick of being in n the group of people who work dam hard and expected to pay for others lives and alit of the time chosen life styles.

Also before others start quoting me, first of all me and my dh have not had children because we have decided we want to be financially viable first and second we don't drink, don't smoke and have not had a holiday in years and years. We work dam hard to save up for a mortgage and sick of being cash cows buy every government.

I agree with you. In another thread I tried to explain exactly this but was shot down!
I decided I wouldn’t have a child until I owned my own property and if not then I wouldn’t have one. After years of saving I managed to buy a property and then got pregnant just before 40. I watched everyone else have kids thinking I’d never be able to. My decision was based on my own upbringing and watching my mum have kids young and this not be able to afford to buy a home and stuck in renting. That was her choice but wasn’t mine.
I think forgoing kids is a pretty big sacrifice. In my experience people who have kids young are less likely to be able to afford to buy because of this choice. It is a choice though. Is it fair? No but it’s life. I think I made good choices in difficult situations and don’t think I should have to pick up the slack for others who haven’t made the same. I know people will don’t down my throat saying I’ve said no1 should have kids who can’t afford them/a house but yes in my opinion that’s what it takes in life sometimes. Harsh but reality.

kateandme · 06/10/2022 03:54

Plus in the papers today it won’t be that they haven’t risen.in real money due to how little it is and the rise in inflation they will actually be at a loss.
move really appreciated seeing this tonight.I darent click on the title at first.I thought it would be the usual bullies and bashing and lies. But there has actually been empathy,There has been the truth of what it’s actually like to be on benefits not what the daily mail spread.
it’s shit op.it’s really f shit to be on benefit’s.
and with no wiggle room,they will literally be struggling to stay alive.

VoiceOfCommonSense · 06/10/2022 03:47

Cloverforever · 05/10/2022 22:28

Maybe time to change industry then? I've had a pay-rise every year as has my boyfriend. Not to match inflation but not bad.

Yep, it’s built in to our contracts we have a yearly remuneration review on a certain date. Always got at least 2% and when taking on more responsibilities I would push for more.

Tyrozet · 06/10/2022 03:42

As a single parent on a low income with benefits to top it up, I really can't get myself worked up about other people potentially getting more help than I do.

I'm privileged to be able to work full time job with scope to improve my income over time - that's not a possibility for many.

There needs to be change accross the board, but I think starting with those who have next to nothing and will really struggle makes sense. Sometimes I stick a blanket on or use a hot water bottle instead of turning the heating on but I'm able to cover the bill, we are not hungry, we are by no means hard done by - that wont change because other people are getting a hand up which will likely still be far, far less than what would fund a family to actually be comfortable.

As PP have said - it's not a race to the bottom.

Trez1510 · 06/10/2022 03:08

Discovereads · 06/10/2022 02:31

@Trez1510
Great post. I think that certain people are a bit gullible and the ones that believe the poor bashing propaganda are probably the same ones that believe Putin is actually paying families with fish to recruit soldiers (if a supposed trained journalist cannot discern a deliberate misinformation campaign from genuine news, not sure the average reader can either).

Thanks, I can turn a thought into a rant in a nanosecond ... it's my superpower! 😬

I agree that the standard of 'journalism' these days is pretty much a joke, and investigative journalism doesn't even strike me as 'investigative' these days.

Bring back Snow and PIlger, and let's waken people up again!!

BrightOrangeRectangles · 06/10/2022 03:03

Yes OP. The poor are to blame for the cost of living crisis, so should be made to bear the brunt. 🙄

What wonderful words of wisdom that I'm sure Liz would wholeheartedly agree with.

BeserkGiraffe · 06/10/2022 02:59

£265 on energy bills ? Pull the other one

That's not far off the "average" per the new price cap. Why do you find this difficult to believe when regulators etc have determined it as the "normal" kind of level to spend?

Riddlemethisplz · 06/10/2022 02:57

Probably because poor people deserve to eat too maybe?

god this, stamp my feet, if I can’t have it they can’t have it mentality is childish.

companies should give pay rises, i agree but if they haven’t then you start to look elsewhere at a place that values you more, not dump on the most vulnerable in society

Anon778833 · 06/10/2022 02:57

Dalaidramailama · 05/10/2022 22:25

Oh my can’t you expand your brain a little? It’s quite obvious benefits are a lot less than yours and your husbands job. Stop being so ridiculous it’s not a race to the bottom.

This ^^

BeserkGiraffe · 06/10/2022 02:55

Blowing out someone else's candles (or the flame on their boiler for that matter) won't make yours shine any brighter.

DaughterofDawn · 06/10/2022 02:54

IncessantNameChanger · 05/10/2022 22:28

Because benefits are close to the bone with little wiggle room. My mate, on uc, disabled with two SEN kids has £65 a week left bills to eat. I find it really very very hard to envy her life. £65 to feed and clothe 3 is pretty grim. I can't see thise kids having life transforming outcomes tbh. Yes you always work more hours, get promotions but you'd find that slightly tricky if you couldn't get out of bed due to pain and exhaustion from fibromyalgia while your 14 year old with asd has a mental breakdown

I'm from the United states and when folks are struggling financially and asking for help the answer is always just "work a little more"and you're called lazy and a societal parasite for even asking. So you little and "work a little more" every day until you've realized you woke up and you worked your life away and you hardly spent time with your kids, spouse, friends or even just doing the little things that you love. It's slippery slope.

Folks need help. Covid f**ked everything and everyone. Communities got to pitch in and help each other and try to be understanding.

Discovereads · 06/10/2022 02:31

@Trez1510
Great post. I think that certain people are a bit gullible and the ones that believe the poor bashing propaganda are probably the same ones that believe Putin is actually paying families with fish to recruit soldiers (if a supposed trained journalist cannot discern a deliberate misinformation campaign from genuine news, not sure the average reader can either).

Swipe left for the next trending thread