Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To wonder why benefits should rise in line with inflation when no job is?

409 replies

Bananil · 05/10/2022 22:22

Massively struggling with food prices and absolutely no chance the heating is going on for a long time yet. DH and I work full time but have not had a pay rise since before the pandemic and wouldn’t ask for one as our industry has taken a real hit. I can’t think of any jobs that are expecting a pay rise in line with inflation so why do much fuss about making sure benefits do?

OP posts:
lannistunut · 06/10/2022 08:20

I think in these awful times, when people quite a long way up the income scale are starting to worry about their bills and their futures, if you are the sort of person who looks at someone worse off than you financially and says I want them to struggle even more then you are a total cock. Therapy might help, but you are probably too far gone into the land of bitter bastards.

I'm really worried about my own finances, but I can see those with less than me are going to struggle more and my natural human instinct is to want people to be OK.

Miajk · 06/10/2022 08:16

Oldsu · 05/10/2022 23:23

@SarasandmanYes you are correct most CONTRIBUTION based benefits go to pensioners and you do realise that pensioners also pay tax, I am a working pensioner the extra tax I pay (over and above the tax and NI combined I paid when I was working age) equates to a weeks pension every 4 weeks, a pension that I paid NI for the best part of 51 years before I qualified for it, even when I stop work I will still be paying tax.

This is a genuine question, but isn't it weird that the current generations are paying for pensioners (state pension)?

Cost of living and everything has been going up steadily while wages have been stagnant. Especially things like housing.

Older generations were able to save, buy a home at a reasonable proportion to their salary, etc. so why have so many of them not saved for retirement? I'm not from the UK so beyond interest rates in the 70s and recessions I'm not familiar with how different generations were off financially, and I genuinely don't mean offense. Did people get screwed over with their pensions back then? As I also thought many In that generation would be on a final salary pension, which younger people have missed out on.

YomAsalYomBasal · 06/10/2022 08:14

As above, you can have my £70 a week carers allowance if you'll do the 24/7 care my child needs. And it really is 24/7, I don't sleep for more than 2 hours at a time. If I stop caring for her she needs a specialist nursing placement that would cost the state over £100k a year. Carers save the public purse so much money, that's why we should make sure they can at least eat.

ZaZathecat · 06/10/2022 08:14

Many people in work rely on benefits to top them up in order to live. Yes, wages should go up to stop this being the case, as well as benefits needing to increase.

lannistunut · 06/10/2022 08:13

RamsayEaster · 06/10/2022 08:03

I generally don’t think OP was meaning benefits should not increase for those who can’t work due to medical reasons / carer / single parent etc they shouldn’t increase for people who chose not to work even though they can

People who choose not to work even though they can are already sanctioned.

Do you know what someone on 'the dole' is required to do in 2022? No, thought not. Just spouting bollocks.

ClaudineClare · 06/10/2022 08:13

If your not getting a fair pay deal then fight against it

Yes, exactly. But no, people will prefer the poor and vulnerable are mistreated and blamed. Which is exactly how the government likes it.

TheFairyCaravan · 06/10/2022 08:13

I see someone has left the gate open at the cunt farm again...

There's so much bullshit on this thread it's unbelievable/. People who are on benefits don't have a better life than those who are in work. The vast majority of people claiming UC are in work. Pensioners receive the most in benefits.

I get PIP. I can't work because of my disabilities. I'd love to be able to, but I can't. I live a very lonely life in a lot of pain, unable to do the simplest of tasks. I have an adapted cat so in theory I can go out, but that rarely happens. My husband works, he's always worked. There's times when I've been left in very dangerous situations so he could continue working. He's had a substantial pay rise this year and will be getting a bonus at Christmas.

If life on benefits is so great then maybe people would like to swap with some of us disabled people, or some carers who get less than £70 a week, or some families who have bills larger than what they receive on UC?

The problem in this country isn't the people on benefits, it's the people at the top, hence why everything when tits up when the Govt announced the 45% tax cut. Look up, instead of down, because that's where the real problems are.

lannistunut · 06/10/2022 08:11

ClocksGoingBackwards · 06/10/2022 08:04

I agree with the OP that it seems wrong to raise benefits in line with inflation when wages don’t do the same.

Disability benefits should be higher to start with and should rise in line with inflation, but other working age benefits need to be difficult to live on to provide an incentive to work.

We should be able to expect more out of a life of full time work than we should out of a life on benefits, but that’s not how it works right now. People feel entitled to the same standard of living as working people no matter how little they do to provide for themselves and that needs to change, especially at a time when the country has more employment opportunities than it has healthy unemployed people.

There is so much wrong with this, it is hard to know where to start. Misinformation about benefits has been fed to people for years.

Are you happy for people on benefits to die in greater numbers than they would if their benefits were uprated in line with inflation? Because that is what is expected to happen this year - that is why many Tories are in favour of uprating in line with inflation.

Your views are at the extreme right-wing on this issue and you are entitled to that but when Tory Ministers are to the left of you, you have to own your politics - your views are genuinely disgusting to me as they are based on things made up to turn the working poor against those on benefits.

I would urge everyone to read sources like the Resolution Foundation and the Joseph Rowntree Foundation to hear the other side of the issue.

ClaudineClare · 06/10/2022 08:09

If they changed benefits system, allowed a set amount of time to find work (for those able) before stopping it, do you think it would work?

And then what? Do we leave people to starve? That will up the crime figures nicely as desperate people turn to burglary and mugging. Or maybe we could have workhouses. Or euthanasia for the long term unemployed.

Sirzy · 06/10/2022 08:08

If your not getting a fair pay deal then fight against it.

its not a race to the bottom. Nobody should be left worrying about paying the bills.

the vast majority of people are benefits work but in such badly paid jobs they need their pay topping up. Many others are relisant on benefits because their disabilities and/or caring needs mean they have no choice. But some on here would happily leave them to rot while the rich get richer

TangoRomeo · 06/10/2022 08:08

@ClaudiasWinkleMan - in the situation that you describe, you should be entitled to DLA. If you have been turned down then apply again - I can send you a link to a really helpful guide - and get someone to check it with you afterwards. You providing much more care than you would be to teens without disabilities and some of that is help with daily hygiene tasks, as well as a mobility element if they can’t go out and walk to school alone in the way a neurotypical DC of the same age would.

dworky · 06/10/2022 08:07

Because people on them will starve, die of hypothermia or both.
Is that clear enough?

MeowMeowPowerRangers · 06/10/2022 08:05

Imagine caring for a loved one, saving the government thousands every single year for the pittance of £69.70, that's not even £2 a hour.....

That's why.

ClocksGoingBackwards · 06/10/2022 08:04

I agree with the OP that it seems wrong to raise benefits in line with inflation when wages don’t do the same.

Disability benefits should be higher to start with and should rise in line with inflation, but other working age benefits need to be difficult to live on to provide an incentive to work.

We should be able to expect more out of a life of full time work than we should out of a life on benefits, but that’s not how it works right now. People feel entitled to the same standard of living as working people no matter how little they do to provide for themselves and that needs to change, especially at a time when the country has more employment opportunities than it has healthy unemployed people.

dottiedodah · 06/10/2022 08:04

Gosh this is an eye opener! Liz truss wants to cut benefits. Of already vulnerable people 🙄 wtf ! A mark of a society is that we look after the poor and needy.was it thatcher who famously said there is no such thing as society?anyway truss seems to have taken this to heart.one thing why if Benefits are so generous are so many at a food bank.why on the south coast in a prosperous town with expensive housing are they opening a warm Bank I wonder

RamsayEaster · 06/10/2022 08:03

I generally don’t think OP was meaning benefits should not increase for those who can’t work due to medical reasons / carer / single parent etc they shouldn’t increase for people who chose not to work even though they can

Sub1required · 06/10/2022 08:03

Forfrigz · 06/10/2022 07:34

But surely the problem is that the employers aren't paying enough for people to live on? Benefits are an absolute minimum to stay alive, they are not generous. Make businesses pay people enough to live on and watch how it changes things.

But then half the people on this thread are saying benefits isn't enough to live on yet I see it happening all around me. Plenty of people playing the system too, it's easier than you think.

The people near me don't want to go to work, gain experience and progress to a higher rate of pay because they don't have to, they can sign on.

If they changed benefits system, allowed a set amount of time to find work (for those able) before stopping it, do you think it would work?
Surely this would allow an increase to the amount for those who can't work or need a top up.

ClaudineClare · 06/10/2022 08:02

lannistunut · 06/10/2022 07:58

Funnily enough the OP hasn't been back, just another goady benefits-bashing thread to start an argument?

Yep and people are happy to pile on. The same people probably cheered when Braverman made disgusting "my dream" comment. The UK is full of odious little shits, it seems.

ClaudineClare · 06/10/2022 08:00

Threads like this where the OP never returns should just be deleted. Why does MNHQ not get better at zapping hate threads?

lannistunut · 06/10/2022 07:58

Funnily enough the OP hasn't been back, just another goady benefits-bashing thread to start an argument?

YoSofi · 06/10/2022 07:57

UnderCoverFieldAgent · 06/10/2022 07:41

Most people on benefits can get a job (excusing some severely disabled and those of pension age). If they choose not to work then why should working people support that lifestyle choice? It’s sickening to see people able to go out during the week (admittedly with not a lot of money) when I’m stuck in front of my computer 40 hours a week.

Most people on benefits have got a job.

Fml1980 · 06/10/2022 07:55

Can we get this straight, YOU CAN ONLY CLAIM FOR 2 CHILDREN AND HAS BEEN THE CASE FOR A FEW YEARS NOW!
So no woman can't pop out baby after baby to get money!

If you are not working and don't have any caring responsibilities(children under a certain age I think from 3/4) not disabled (you have to be on certain disability benefits and prove to UC you are not fit for work, or a Carer which you have to claim carers allowance (and they take it pretty much back of you if you get UC) then you have to look for work for what is around 30 hours a week!

And prove it, and go and have interviews at the job centre so I really can't see how all these people are just so bloody happy to be on benefits!

And yes I do agree that ALL workers should get a proper living wage.
My husband is one of them.
But it's not helping pitting against people on benefits it's not their fault that employers are allowed to pay such shit wages and get away with it, let's make it better for everyone.

AllyCatTown · 06/10/2022 07:55

I hate in these discussions people always target the individuals claiming benefits. What about the companies who make billions but pay their workers so little they have to claim benefits. The government is essentially subsidising these companies. Be angry at that.

KatnissNeverdone · 06/10/2022 07:54

UnderCoverFieldAgent · 06/10/2022 07:41

Most people on benefits can get a job (excusing some severely disabled and those of pension age). If they choose not to work then why should working people support that lifestyle choice? It’s sickening to see people able to go out during the week (admittedly with not a lot of money) when I’m stuck in front of my computer 40 hours a week.

I'll tell you what, we can swap. You can have my lovely benefits and I'll have your 40 hour working week. Only thing is you now have to care for my disabled son 24 hours a day, 7 days a week for just under £68 a week. Don't worry I'll show you how to use all his medical equipment that puts our fuel bills up to £280.

MagpieSong · 06/10/2022 07:53

As many others have said, benefits do not have wriggle room for most. Equally most people on benefits are in a very tough position. They aren’t lucky enough to be able to work currently, but they are described as lazy and constantly made to feel guilty by the media. Carer’s allowance is one of the biggest mickey takes there is and carer’s cannot work to top up or they lose the benefit. It’s a very tough existence.

Swipe left for the next trending thread