Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To wonder why benefits should rise in line with inflation when no job is?

409 replies

Bananil · 05/10/2022 22:22

Massively struggling with food prices and absolutely no chance the heating is going on for a long time yet. DH and I work full time but have not had a pay rise since before the pandemic and wouldn’t ask for one as our industry has taken a real hit. I can’t think of any jobs that are expecting a pay rise in line with inflation so why do much fuss about making sure benefits do?

OP posts:
Hollyhead · 06/10/2022 08:52

The lowest paid at my work are getting a 10% increase, so some people are getting a significant pay rise.

Lovemusic33 · 06/10/2022 08:51

IncessantNameChanger · 05/10/2022 22:28

Because benefits are close to the bone with little wiggle room. My mate, on uc, disabled with two SEN kids has £65 a week left bills to eat. I find it really very very hard to envy her life. £65 to feed and clothe 3 is pretty grim. I can't see thise kids having life transforming outcomes tbh. Yes you always work more hours, get promotions but you'd find that slightly tricky if you couldn't get out of bed due to pain and exhaustion from fibromyalgia while your 14 year old with asd has a mental breakdown

That’s very unlikely. I am a parent of 2 SEN kids, I get carers allowance, tax credits and both my dc get DLA, I have a lot more than £65 a week to live off.
one of my DC’s have just left home so my money has reduced some what but I still have around £122 a week to cover food, clothes. My biggest cost at the moment is fuel for my car which costs me £60pw (my carers allowance goes straight on fuel). Money is tight but we do have more than £65 a week. I do agree that benefits need to increase but wages also need to too. A lot of people are struggling, especially people on low incomes.

newnamethanks · 06/10/2022 08:51

What a sad and miserable life one must have to be jealous of someone on benefits. What a country we've become, people happy to take the bread out of the mouths of children. Squander some of your hard earned cash on a mirror OP and look yourself in the eye.

Sirzy · 06/10/2022 08:51

When we have a goverment who believe that people make the choice to become full time unpaid carers so should he just accept the insulting allowance with no complaints (see their response to the petition with regards paying carers a halfway decent wage) then it’s no surprise that their attitudes rub off on the people who vote for them.

TirisfalPumpkin · 06/10/2022 08:49

YANBU.

Taking into account housing and child element, a benefit income can be very comparable to a fulltime wage.

Both benefits and wages should rise in line with inflation. Taxing wages to pay for a benefit increase is going to stir up anti-claimant sentiment and pit people against each other, because it's genuinely unfair. We already have an issue with perceived injustice and people assuming those claiming are work-shy, spongers or [insert negative stereotype] - if we make it an actual injustice this will only compound the issue.

slowquickstep · 06/10/2022 08:48

Bananil Do you understand how hellish it is to not even afford to walk into a supermarket and know you can't afford 99% of the food in there, or to not be able to buy a stamp to send a birthday card ? Have you ever had to save up to buy Sanitary towels ? If not you are not "massively struggling" Have a bit of compassion.

lannistunut · 06/10/2022 08:45

FridayTheThirteeth · 06/10/2022 08:41

Many on benefits struggle but some don't and do get all the various extra add ons. If you are on tax credits with a child with ADHD and get DLA for child, then carers allowance, then disability extra on Tax credit and working tax credit if one works over 16 hours you would be surprised how much you get - friend shared with me.

However, many do not get those add ons.

Oh my god, I can't belive you referred to disability benefits as 'add-ons'.

ChampagneLassie · 06/10/2022 08:44

My impression is quite the opposite, my BF had 2 at rises this year and a wacking great bonus as his employers finding it so hard to recruit skilled people. His salary has almost doubled since 2019

Simmilary friends across professional services have seen nice rises, that is part of inflation.

lannistunut · 06/10/2022 08:43

happyinherts · 06/10/2022 08:40

@YoSofi and Sirzy

You're both missing my point

Sirzy - I have never 'benefit bashed.' I've NEVER said it's okay to leave people struggling. Please point out where I have.

YoSoFI - My daughter's employer doesn't pay a bad wage. He has to raise a certain amount of turnover to be able to pay staff, and of course that's never guaranteed. Plus, he doesn't care - and why should he - that staff pay £90 a week to get there. My point is that the government take, take, take off this section of the community until there's nothing left. They're left below UC levels and cannot claim.

Nowhere have I begrudged benefit claimants their money.

The government takes from most of us. That is what is happening now - there is a huge group, probably the bottom three-quarters - who are losing out now seriously from the last 12 years of Tory choices.

Look at what is happening with GP appointments. Labour's target was 48 hours for a GP appointment - and they met it. Tories now saying we can all have an appointment in TWO WEEKS - that is a) shit and b) not likely to be met anyway.

They take in cash from those who use public transport and pay student loans. But they take from most of us in all sorts of ways.

FridayTheThirteeth · 06/10/2022 08:41

Many on benefits struggle but some don't and do get all the various extra add ons. If you are on tax credits with a child with ADHD and get DLA for child, then carers allowance, then disability extra on Tax credit and working tax credit if one works over 16 hours you would be surprised how much you get - friend shared with me.

However, many do not get those add ons.

happyinherts · 06/10/2022 08:40

@YoSofi and Sirzy

You're both missing my point

Sirzy - I have never 'benefit bashed.' I've NEVER said it's okay to leave people struggling. Please point out where I have.

YoSoFI - My daughter's employer doesn't pay a bad wage. He has to raise a certain amount of turnover to be able to pay staff, and of course that's never guaranteed. Plus, he doesn't care - and why should he - that staff pay £90 a week to get there. My point is that the government take, take, take off this section of the community until there's nothing left. They're left below UC levels and cannot claim.

Nowhere have I begrudged benefit claimants their money.

lannistunut · 06/10/2022 08:40

whowhatwerewhy · 06/10/2022 08:36

@happyinherts
I have to agree, I think there is a section of society who are being overlooked.

Under this government, a whole host of groups are being overlooked! Don't fall into to the trap of looking at someone else with fuck all and squabbling with them.

If you are a Tory, be proud of it. But if you are not a Tory don't fall for this again.

We are ALMOST ALL being overlooked, except for home-owning pensioners and the rich i.e. core Tory voters.

womaninatightspot · 06/10/2022 08:39

Labraradabrador · 05/10/2022 23:00

If you earn enough to be a net contributor, then you can afford to help those who are vulnerable
^^
Happy to help those that are truly vulnerable, but far too many receive state support. HALF of UK households receive benefits? The sense of entitlement is baffling. In order for the economy to thrive, surely we need more people contributing?

A lot of people receive benefits simply due to the high cost of childcare and/or rent. They pay tax/ni.

I think what we’ve needed as a country for a long time is an increase in social housing and subsidised childcare. Many European countries provide subsidised childcare enabling both parents to work. Expensive in the short term worthwhile in the long term

W00p · 06/10/2022 08:37

Why wouldn't you ask for a pay rise? You sell your labour for money right? Or do you go to work to keep yourself occupied despite being a multi millionaire? You're worth a lot more than you think you are.

whowhatwerewhy · 06/10/2022 08:36

@happyinherts
I have to agree, I think there is a section of society who are being overlooked.

lannistunut · 06/10/2022 08:35

happyinherts · 06/10/2022 08:28

I think people are twisting the point of the OP's original statement.

I don't think she is criticising benefit rises or begrugding anyone anything. Her point is that the working poor are never listened to.

To those who say the working poor can claim UC, they're poor after their deductions which are not taken into account. My daughter's travel to work (£90), tax, NI, pension and student loan amount to £200 per week. That's £10K per year she doesn't see. Fair enough - but it brings her to a take home level which is less than I've seen quoted for UC.

No, I don't think so. The OP started a goady thread and fucked off. It is yet another benefits attack IMO.

We can all find people in any category who are having a hard time. It is a universal cost of living crisis and the government is doing too little - and has done too little for the last 12 years since they decided to cut all the support that used to be there, both for individuals and for services.

Your daughter's issues are worsened by the high costs of student loans and the high cost of transport in this country - both political choices made by the Tories.

But your DD's issues do not change the fact that benefits should rise in line with inflation.

waffless · 06/10/2022 08:34

Do not even go that route OP. In this country whoever questions anything about the benefits system better move away. I personally thing the system needs a proper shake up. With only disabled, carers and people who loose their jobs for a certain period receiving it. People should be paid enough to live without tax credits. However, this unsustainable situation can only get worse as nobody in government would dare to have a honest conversation. The people once in benefits need to have them raise with the inflation. Otherwise, they would be extremely poor which is pointless. Less people on benefits and raise the amount for those in the system to have a good standard of life. Pensioners are receiving back what they put in so they should still get protection.

Sirzy · 06/10/2022 08:34

lannistunut · 06/10/2022 08:20

I think in these awful times, when people quite a long way up the income scale are starting to worry about their bills and their futures, if you are the sort of person who looks at someone worse off than you financially and says I want them to struggle even more then you are a total cock. Therapy might help, but you are probably too far gone into the land of bitter bastards.

I'm really worried about my own finances, but I can see those with less than me are going to struggle more and my natural human instinct is to want people to be OK.

Perfectly put

Sirzy · 06/10/2022 08:33

happyinherts · 06/10/2022 08:28

I think people are twisting the point of the OP's original statement.

I don't think she is criticising benefit rises or begrugding anyone anything. Her point is that the working poor are never listened to.

To those who say the working poor can claim UC, they're poor after their deductions which are not taken into account. My daughter's travel to work (£90), tax, NI, pension and student loan amount to £200 per week. That's £10K per year she doesn't see. Fair enough - but it brings her to a take home level which is less than I've seen quoted for UC.

And what in there means it’s ok to leave people on much less struggling then?

Twiglets1 · 06/10/2022 08:33

happyinherts · 06/10/2022 08:28

I think people are twisting the point of the OP's original statement.

I don't think she is criticising benefit rises or begrugding anyone anything. Her point is that the working poor are never listened to.

To those who say the working poor can claim UC, they're poor after their deductions which are not taken into account. My daughter's travel to work (£90), tax, NI, pension and student loan amount to £200 per week. That's £10K per year she doesn't see. Fair enough - but it brings her to a take home level which is less than I've seen quoted for UC.

I agree with this and think people are piling in on the OP a bit too much. If you look at her poll results on page 1 it is clear that over 40% of people reading her statement agree with her so the issue of whether she raises a valid point is not as clear cut as some people seem to think.

YoSofi · 06/10/2022 08:32

happyinherts · 06/10/2022 08:28

I think people are twisting the point of the OP's original statement.

I don't think she is criticising benefit rises or begrugding anyone anything. Her point is that the working poor are never listened to.

To those who say the working poor can claim UC, they're poor after their deductions which are not taken into account. My daughter's travel to work (£90), tax, NI, pension and student loan amount to £200 per week. That's £10K per year she doesn't see. Fair enough - but it brings her to a take home level which is less than I've seen quoted for UC.

And so the answer is to not increase benefits in line with inflation?

Or is it that your daughter should look at her employer and start asking questions?

FOTTFSOFTFOASM · 06/10/2022 08:32

@Bananil I agree with you. However, you will never, ever get away with saying anything like this on MN because, like the NHS, 'defending people on benefits' is a quasi religion here.

happyinherts · 06/10/2022 08:28

I think people are twisting the point of the OP's original statement.

I don't think she is criticising benefit rises or begrugding anyone anything. Her point is that the working poor are never listened to.

To those who say the working poor can claim UC, they're poor after their deductions which are not taken into account. My daughter's travel to work (£90), tax, NI, pension and student loan amount to £200 per week. That's £10K per year she doesn't see. Fair enough - but it brings her to a take home level which is less than I've seen quoted for UC.

JocelynBurnell · 06/10/2022 08:26

I can’t think of any jobs that are expecting a pay rise in line with inflation so why do much fuss about making sure benefits do?

So lets all accept a lower standard of living but we will only happily do so if the very poorest in society freeze and starve first?

Quveas · 06/10/2022 08:20

I suspect this is just a goady post, but if the OP really thinks that they can live on benefits, they should perhaps try it.