Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To wonder why benefits should rise in line with inflation when no job is?

409 replies

Bananil · 05/10/2022 22:22

Massively struggling with food prices and absolutely no chance the heating is going on for a long time yet. DH and I work full time but have not had a pay rise since before the pandemic and wouldn’t ask for one as our industry has taken a real hit. I can’t think of any jobs that are expecting a pay rise in line with inflation so why do much fuss about making sure benefits do?

OP posts:
mam0918 · 06/10/2022 09:26

I have been a carer almost all my life, I was a child carer that go no help and still am a carer. I haven't held an employed job since 16 because its impossible but I attempt self employment alongside my care responsabilities but make only a couple of thousand a year if lucky depending on the market at the time which is then topped up buy a few benefits (carers allowence and child benefit).

My current over all income per year is £6k (thats with benefits).

Lets view carers allowence, it requires FULL TIME hours of 37 hours of care a week (when really its 24/7 but lets just take their number) for this we are paid £69.70 = £1.88 per hour.

The biggest drain cost on the NHS and emergancy services is people abandoning disabled and mentally ill family member. Us carers litrally save the country MILLIONS and they can't even be bothered to even attempt to pay us anywhere close to minimum wage.

Do you REALLY think a 9% increase instead of 4% would put us in a position of being 'better off' than those getting minimum wage?

Rabbitbabbit · 06/10/2022 09:24

newnamethanks · 06/10/2022 09:14

Well said CH8. When will we see headlines excoriating employers happy to keep their business running due to government subsidy in the form of UC to their low paid employees? How are those viable businesses? Those employers are exploiting the benefits system at vast expense yet I never see the whingers mention it.

It would be interesting to know what businesses this mainly effects (taking into account the hours typically offered as well to each member of staff). I suspect its those on zero hours/very part time contracts as big retailers now favour, small businesses or underfunded sectors such as social care and childcare? Most of which lead back to corporate greed or government dismantling of essential services.

GreenFingersWouldBeHandy · 06/10/2022 09:21

Because my benefits don't even cover my current bills! I'm scared shitless of this winter. I'm self employed but my clients are cutting costs left right and centre so I'm getting less work. I also have been advised not to work full time due to a medical condition but I will if it's offered.

So should I be cold and hungry as well?

LaPerduta · 06/10/2022 09:19

Well equally I could wonder why a couple both working full time are "massively struggling" to afford food and heating. But as you haven't said what work you do, where you live or whether you have children to feed, there's no way of knowing whether any of that is down to poor money management or circumstances beyond your control.

All I'm saying is that you're unlikely to know other people's full circumstances, but one thing we do know is that those on benefits will be hit the hardest by rising prices.

newnamethanks · 06/10/2022 09:14

Well said CH8. When will we see headlines excoriating employers happy to keep their business running due to government subsidy in the form of UC to their low paid employees? How are those viable businesses? Those employers are exploiting the benefits system at vast expense yet I never see the whingers mention it.

Mombie2016 · 06/10/2022 09:13

lannistunut · 06/10/2022 08:45

Oh my god, I can't belive you referred to disability benefits as 'add-ons'.

“With ADHD” as if it’s some made up disability. PP needs to pop over to the ND board and see just what life as an adult with ADHD is like and just maybe she would realise how hard it is.

Ponoka7 · 06/10/2022 09:13

@Hillary17 , how do you magic up these extra hours when it's difficult to find jobs over 27 hours as it is? A lot of employers offer 16 hours and no more. Those employers want flexibility, so the old 'work two jobs' can't be done anymore. I wasn't a fan of Corbyn but he wanted to tackle large employers and put pressure on to create proper full time jobs. As for night work, it only works if it is local and there are bus routes so hand-over of children can be done. You aren't in the middle if you are having the same lifestyle as benefit claimants, you are the working poor.

The reason so many are topped up by benefits and/or are living in poverty is the lack of full time jobs. Our local hospital is always looking for staff, because most jobs are twenty hours. As for those who want benefits to stop after a certain time, how does that work in areas that have a lack of jobs?

C8H10N4O2 · 06/10/2022 09:12

happyinherts · 06/10/2022 09:07

@ C8H10N4O2

Can we forget this idea that the low paid are all entitled to UC. It's misleading....

They aren't exactly low paid, BUT they can be spending up to £200 per week on work related expenses which are obviously not taken into account for UC purposes - think travel, tax, NI, pensions, student loans - then there are contributions needed for colleague's babies, retirements, etc, smart clothes for work, etc. These all bring take home pay down.

NOTE - I am in no way benefit bashing. I am trying to inform that too much is taken from workers and they are not all entitled to UC. It's like Chinese whispers handed down - not factual and quite misleading.

My point was that if someone is earning less that the level of standard benefits they likely are eligible for something - most likely tax credits. Probably not well phrased tbh.

My bigger point is that people (especially new names it seems) regularly start threads here complaining about people on benefits, completely ignoring that most recipients are actually in work or working families. Therefore the true benefit is to the employer getting subsidised labour.

Where are all the threads saying "why am I paying so much tax to subsidies business owners?"

Mombie2016 · 06/10/2022 09:10

@bloodyplanes do you seriously resent disabled people being exempt from the benefit cap?

Anyone on here who works with vulnerable people - most of which will be on benefits - whilst clearly carrying so much contempt for them should fucking quit their jobs today.

C8H10N4O2 · 06/10/2022 09:09

I wonder if the OP will be back, having lit the touch paper?

happyinherts · 06/10/2022 09:07

@ C8H10N4O2

Can we forget this idea that the low paid are all entitled to UC. It's misleading....

They aren't exactly low paid, BUT they can be spending up to £200 per week on work related expenses which are obviously not taken into account for UC purposes - think travel, tax, NI, pensions, student loans - then there are contributions needed for colleague's babies, retirements, etc, smart clothes for work, etc. These all bring take home pay down.

NOTE - I am in no way benefit bashing. I am trying to inform that too much is taken from workers and they are not all entitled to UC. It's like Chinese whispers handed down - not factual and quite misleading.

Sirzy · 06/10/2022 09:04

Hillary17 · 06/10/2022 08:57

I absolutely agree. There’s plenty of people not getting an inflation pay-rise at the moment; for several people I know if benefits increased they would be better off not going to work. Everyone is struggling but most of us go to work for our money. Controversial maybe, but if you’re struggling then get a job. Work more hours, find childcare, work nights etc. It is getting very tiresome being in the middle and knowing there’s people out there not working, sitting at home all day but still having the same standard as living as us.

Brilliant I look forward to you finding me a job which allows

  • the ability to drop everything when a child is ill.
  • the ability to be able to attend on average 2 appointments plus different therapy sessions a week.
  • abiluty to drop everything when their is an issue at school.
  • doesn’t mind people who are sleep deprived because their child doesn’t sleep.
  • allows time for the admin needed to keep said child alive.
  • doesn’t require anything out of school hours because at 13 he needs full 1-1.

i could carry the list on but I think that’s enough for you to go on.

Brefugee · 06/10/2022 09:03

ave not had a pay rise since before the pandemic and wouldn’t ask for one as our industry has taken a real hit

that's on you. Either your company can afford to pay you or it can't. If you want to get dragged down into supporting a company (who will fire you without a backward glance if it profits them to do so) that's your look-out. Everyone else doesn't have to get dragged down with you.

bloodyplanes · 06/10/2022 09:02

@The4teddybears you are wasting your breath on here trying to explain that benefits are a lifestyle choice for many! I to work in a job in which i come into contact with many many people like this! They know exactly what they are doing what they are entitled to and its the hard working that pay for their lifestyle! Yes there are many vulnerable people on benefits but there are equally as many who have no intention of ever providing for themselves or their families! Also people with disabilities are exempt from the benefits cap!

LunchBoxPolice · 06/10/2022 09:02

Oh fucking lovely, another benefits bashing post.

Mombie2016 · 06/10/2022 09:01

My wealthy(ish - hasn’t had a mortgage since her mid 30s, retired at 65, various savings/investments, zero money worries) Boomer Grandmother was crying this weekend at the state of the UK.

She is 80 and grew up poor with a mother who worked 3 jobs (school cook 6am-2pm, seamstress, from home until around 7pm, waitress at weekends - 7 days a week for decades) and a father who couldn’t work due to the injuries he got when his parents died and he was shoved in a workhouse at four years old.

She is devastated that people are now living in the same, if not worse conditions than she did in her early life.

“What happened to progress? What happened to leaving this world better for the next generation? My children* certainly benefited from that, but my Grandchildren haven’t and I can’t let myself think what life will be like my Great Grandchildren if this continues.”

*My Dad is thrice divorced and an absolute fuck knuckle with money.

I’m a disabled single parent to 3, one of whom is disabled, I work full time in STEM, I rent, I get UC due to the disabilities in my household.

Even if I had extra money to save for a deposit, I wouldn’t be able to save fast enough unless it was around 2K a month for 24 months (based on today’s prices…) because as a single adult, despite my qualifications, I do not earn enough to get a mortgage for even a 3 bed, run down terrace in the worst areas in my county.

I had to take a different, less well paid job that has much higher flexibility and WFH options due to the needs of my child, and, for a while, my own medical needs. I was off sick for a year, at crisis point with both mental health and physical health. I sure as shit didn’t expect, as a healthy 30 something to get smacked down by Covid/long Covid, to be unable to do even the most basic tasks.

And yet during the last 3 years, I haven’t once cried about my finances. I’ve laid awake many a night worrying, spent countless hours pouring over spreadsheets, trying to squeeze out money that just isn’t fucking there.

But watching my Grandmother cry this weekend has done something to me.

I was so close close to my Great Grandmother, who died at 98 (compared to her husbands 51…) when I was 20, I could easily write a book about her life from memory.

I also don’t think most people realise how much certain aspects of Public Health, such as infant mortality, have dropped due to things like properly heated homes, access to decent food and the time to prepare proper meals. This concerns me the most.

C8H10N4O2 · 06/10/2022 09:00

Swizandswap · 05/10/2022 22:59

Exactly I know plenty of single people who work dam hard and travel miles every day of the week and earn less than this. There seems to be some sad opinion that those of us who work should shut up and not complain.

In which case they would be eligible for tax credits and other benefits...

Benefits by design are low, on the assumption that they are temporary and only provide for the bare minimum.

The problem is not benefits - its employers who pay below a liveable wage for a full week's wages and use the benefits system (via tax credits) to subsidise their businesses. You do know that most benefits recipients are actually working in these jobs?

ivykaty44 · 06/10/2022 08:59

The lowest paid at my work are getting a 10% increase, so some people are getting a significant pay rise.

that ^ is not a payrise, however you look at it its not even keeping up with inflation - therefore its not a rise.

Rabbitbabbit · 06/10/2022 08:58

Older generations were able to save, buy a home at a reasonable proportion to their salary, etc. so why have so many of them not saved for retirement?

Because not everyone was able to hop onto the property ladder or to save, the premise was pretty much pay enough of your stamps and you will receive a State pension when you retire. Of course now employers have to contribute I think it'll look different in the coming decades; but the notion that every elderly person is sitting on a nice nest egg yet demanding more money is just not true.

ivykaty44 · 06/10/2022 08:57

@IhateJan22 a care leave will be allocated approximately £70 per week towards housing themselves - they are only allowed this amount as they are expected to get board and lodging a room in a house share and that will be the case until they are 25 year old.

42% of claiments of UC are working, they are not unemployed, the are in general low paid and indeed there wages are not rising with inflation - something has got to give for them to make ends meet

ClaudineClare · 06/10/2022 08:57

friend shared with me

I am sure your friend would be delighted to know how you are using her private information.

Hillary17 · 06/10/2022 08:57

I absolutely agree. There’s plenty of people not getting an inflation pay-rise at the moment; for several people I know if benefits increased they would be better off not going to work. Everyone is struggling but most of us go to work for our money. Controversial maybe, but if you’re struggling then get a job. Work more hours, find childcare, work nights etc. It is getting very tiresome being in the middle and knowing there’s people out there not working, sitting at home all day but still having the same standard as living as us.

YoSofi · 06/10/2022 08:55

newnamethanks · 06/10/2022 08:51

What a sad and miserable life one must have to be jealous of someone on benefits. What a country we've become, people happy to take the bread out of the mouths of children. Squander some of your hard earned cash on a mirror OP and look yourself in the eye.

👏 👏 👏

bloodyplanes · 06/10/2022 08:55

Swizandswap · 05/10/2022 22:34

Quite simply Op those of us who are working class are expected to fund every one, the titch dodge it and the poor expect it. God forbid we are not happy being cash cows working out fingers to the bone. To be honest I'm sick of being in n the group of people who work dam hard and expected to pay for others lives and alit of the time chosen life styles.

Also before others start quoting me, first of all me and my dh have not had children because we have decided we want to be financially viable first and second we don't drink, don't smoke and have not had a holiday in years and years. We work dam hard to save up for a mortgage and sick of being cash cows buy every government.

👏👏👏👏

High5InALowRide · 06/10/2022 08:52

Cloverforever · 05/10/2022 22:28

Maybe time to change industry then? I've had a pay-rise every year as has my boyfriend. Not to match inflation but not bad.

Can I ask what industry? I'm civil service so no increase for 10 years save for promotion and that's no longer a possibility so considering getting out.

Swipe left for the next trending thread