Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To wonder why benefits should rise in line with inflation when no job is?

409 replies

Bananil · 05/10/2022 22:22

Massively struggling with food prices and absolutely no chance the heating is going on for a long time yet. DH and I work full time but have not had a pay rise since before the pandemic and wouldn’t ask for one as our industry has taken a real hit. I can’t think of any jobs that are expecting a pay rise in line with inflation so why do much fuss about making sure benefits do?

OP posts:
Rabbitbabbit · 06/10/2022 10:18

However, it could be tricky explaining why there should be a cut for low-income working-age people but not pensioners.

Would it be tricky?

AuntSalli · 06/10/2022 10:15

BoxcarMilly · 06/10/2022 09:59

@AuntSalli Well precisely that is the first thing that needs fixing if we want to fix our benefit bill is to nail these bastards

I couldn't agree more.

However, there needs to be better education to stop some girls getting themselves pregnant with these wasters.

Again you won’t get any argument there from me however, they moan on and on and on about how much it would cost to implement a proper robust child-support system like they have in Australia. They would not dare try and get out of child-support over there. We split on the Thursday and the first payment was in my account the following Tuesday.

but some of the women are wasters as well and it’s better that they don’t affect to families by breeding together I guess

AndSoFinally · 06/10/2022 10:14

People need to stop thinking of benefits as one homogenous pile. I can't see why anyone would have an issue with disabled people/people who care for someone full time/pensioners/people who work 40 hours a week but still don't have enough to support their family, etc having benefits that keep up with the cost of living.

I think people conflate the above "deserving poor" with those people who decide that for whatever reason, working isn't worth their while.

There are often threads on here along the lines of "after I've paid for childcare and all my bills, I've only got £20 a week left so would I be unreasonable to quit and claim benefits instead?" These are the ones people have most issue with. Because that's a lifestyle choice. If you can afford to pay all your bills and your childcare on your wage, then that is what you should do, even if it doesn't leave you with much leftover. Deciding you'd rather someone else paid for it shouldn't really be an option

Alltheseasonsaregood · 06/10/2022 10:14

Mombie2016 i have ahdh. I do not consider it a disability or to get benefits due to this?
Yes , life is harder with adhd as we are not neuro typical. But i celebrate my differences , work with the good and the bad. I do not consider it a reason to claim benfits,/ not work?
I would make an absolute mess of some jobs .like an office job, but with my hyperfocus abities , i had a very good specialist career. This in spite of ahd , working to my stregths , despite being laughes at all my life and being seen as odd, flighty , funny.
I think we have to be careful not to label ourswlves , but to celebrate neuro diversity. I also think it comes down to acknowleding and taking responsibility for it.i wd not dream of claiming benefits due to adhd. Its the card ive been given , ive been given , its my job to work with it .

KermitlovesKeyLimePie · 06/10/2022 10:11

Meanwhile how much did the back tracking on the top rate tax cuts cost us?

Fucking sickening.

WakeUpAndBe · 06/10/2022 10:06

@Bananil I just read a very informed article that breaks it all down. It has helped me understand why Truss’ refusal to commit to a rise in line with inflation this has caused unrest among Tories

What would a real-terms benefits cut mean for UK claimants?

These two sections stand out:

So benefit claimants are already enduring a real-terms cut?
Yes. The April 2022 uprating was the biggest fall in the real value of the basic rate of unemployment benefits in 50 years, according to the Joseph Rowntree Foundation (JRF). The government deflected criticism by arguing claimants would “catch up” next year, when the September 2022 rate of CPI inflation (about 10%) would be reflected in April 2023 benefit rises. The former chancellor Rishi Sunak promised in May that this would indeed be the case.

Will Great Britain’s 12.5 million pensioners be affected by a real-terms cut in the value of benefits? So far the prime minister, Liz Truss, has indicated there will be no real-terms cut in the level of the state pension next April. However, it could be tricky explaining why there should be a cut for low-income working-age people but not pensioners.

Twillow · 06/10/2022 10:03

So many myths about benefits being the source of the money drain that I don't know where to start - for example:
In 2011-12 just 0.7 per cent of the benefits bill was overpaid due to fraud – £1 billion compared with £70 billion lost through illegal tax evasion.

TheReallyUsefulCrew · 06/10/2022 10:03

Blossomtoes · 05/10/2022 23:28

There was an op on another post two nights ago who stated that she earned £18k and with benefit top up earned close to £39k a year! She's certainly not doing bad

No, she not doing bad, she’s lying.

Not necessarily. Depending on what elements one has on the claim it is possible to be topped up that amount.

BoxcarMilly · 06/10/2022 09:59

@AuntSalli Well precisely that is the first thing that needs fixing if we want to fix our benefit bill is to nail these bastards

I couldn't agree more.

However, there needs to be better education to stop some girls getting themselves pregnant with these wasters.

AuntSalli · 06/10/2022 09:56

BoxcarMilly · 06/10/2022 09:53

1 single parent adult not working, 2 children, £1400 UC per month, £800 to rent leaves £600. £600 for gas, electric, mobile phone, food and clothing. Electric & gas is £300pm on its own.

Where are the father's payments for his children in all this?

Well precisely that is the first thing that needs fixing if we want to fix our benefit bill is to nail these bastards

firef1y · 06/10/2022 09:55

UnderCoverFieldAgent · 06/10/2022 07:41

Most people on benefits can get a job (excusing some severely disabled and those of pension age). If they choose not to work then why should working people support that lifestyle choice? It’s sickening to see people able to go out during the week (admittedly with not a lot of money) when I’m stuck in front of my computer 40 hours a week.

How about parents of disabled children who are also disabled themselves??

I'd love to work, first hurdle would be the stupid questionnaire things, that really aren't suitable for someone who has autism. I have no idea what sort of answers they want, my brain just doesn't work that way. Then I can't do anything that involves talking on a phone, or face to face or in noisy environments etc etc.

Then I have a disabled child with all the appointments that involves and occasional hospital stays without notice.

Now find me a job that I can work round that with.

BoxcarMilly · 06/10/2022 09:53

1 single parent adult not working, 2 children, £1400 UC per month, £800 to rent leaves £600. £600 for gas, electric, mobile phone, food and clothing. Electric & gas is £300pm on its own.

Where are the father's payments for his children in all this?

bloodyplanes · 06/10/2022 09:49

Mombie2016 · 06/10/2022 09:10

@bloodyplanes do you seriously resent disabled people being exempt from the benefit cap?

Anyone on here who works with vulnerable people - most of which will be on benefits - whilst clearly carrying so much contempt for them should fucking quit their jobs today.

Please explain where i said i resent people with disabilities being exempt from the benefits cap......i will wait! I was merely stating a fact!

54isanopendoor · 06/10/2022 09:49

I am a full time Carer to a disabled person.
Therefore, I cannot work (they have High level Care needs according to PIP)
I receive £69.70 per week Carers allowance.

Food costs more than last year. Petrol costs more. Electricity costs more.
For ALL of us. Some of us have the opportunity to increase hours / change job.
For many this is hard / borderline impossible due to family circs etc.

But I CANNOT as my 'job' is already full time (& saves the Govt a fortune in fees)
Now, it's not the Govt's 'fault' I had a disabled child. Nor was it forseeable.
I can't live on £10 a day to cover my costs (yet alone a lack of pension etc)
So, I would like our Govt to increase my Carers allowance in line with inflation.
It's really a case of whether we choose to look after our most vulnerable. Or not.

(& incidentally this is a Govt that spaffed £xM on unusable PPE & has just wasted £65BN on unworkable budget proposals)

Manekinek0 · 06/10/2022 09:47

Wages and benefits are two separate issues. Benefits should provide the minimum someone needs to survive and at the moment they don't. Wages should pay enough that someone working full-time should be able to afford to live comfortably but again at the moment they don't.

Benefits should track inflation, this would give some stability to those who are the most financially vunerable. But this won't happen because in part some people have convinced themselves that benefit claimants not facing a real term reduction in income will have some sort of impact on their wages. It won't.

GertrudePerkinsPaperyThing · 06/10/2022 09:46

Benefits, the minimum / living wage and public sector jobs salaries should all rise in line with inflation.

Private employers can make their own choices (obviously not below minimum wage) to ensure job retention - of the above all rise with inflation employers will need to say competitive, so would never be unfair to private sector employers. Would just make public sector more attractive than currently.

Firkinhavinalaugh · 06/10/2022 09:43

Each benefit should be raised depending in its function.

  • carers and those who look after others should have a huge raise - as said before they save the country millions.
  • job seekers - so many jobs around so nope
  • childcare should be boosted to allow those who can work to work

not all benefit recipients are scroungers, realistically we shouldn’t need UC - living wage should be standard, with childcare (see above)it shouldn’t be needed.

it’s so depressing that benefits are needed at all for those who work or can work.

I’m disgusted by Liz, at least Boris was going to “look” at it 😡

AnonWeeMouse · 06/10/2022 09:43

I'd just like to point out a little couple details, well one mainly.

People clapped every week for the millions of workers stacking shelves so you could buy food, clapped for the people caring for your relatives,
Clapped for the nurses and porters and hospital staff that cared for your sick and dying relatives...

Now, those begrudging those same people a few extra quid a month, you should hang your heads in absolute shame.

If life on benefits is so awesome, shut up and do it. You won't though, because deep down you know it's all nonsense. The friend of a friend of a person you know is getting £££ on benefits.. find them, find out how, copy them, what's stopping you?

You all need to realise that taking food off the poorest in society won't put more food on your table, all it will do is force the poorest into desperation. If those people get desperate enough, crime, violence, burglaries, theft it'll all go up. Who will that affect? Those at the top behind guilded gates and security? Doubtful.. it'll be the very people on this thread complaining the poor have too much.

Ginandthings · 06/10/2022 09:42

Does no one else think that rather than all turning on each other over who pays what, who claims what etc. that maybe we should start looking at mp’s and what they cost? Why do they need second homes that they then claim expenses for? Why do they get large pay rises whilst teachers etc. get none? If we are all in this together as they claim then surely they should lead by example?
And before anyone says about who you voted for, I’m not talking about individual parties, I’m talking about the system as a whole not being suitable.

WrongWayApricot · 06/10/2022 09:39

So that more division can be sown between voters. You're doing their job for them 👍

lannistunut · 06/10/2022 09:37

happyinherts · 06/10/2022 09:07

@ C8H10N4O2

Can we forget this idea that the low paid are all entitled to UC. It's misleading....

They aren't exactly low paid, BUT they can be spending up to £200 per week on work related expenses which are obviously not taken into account for UC purposes - think travel, tax, NI, pensions, student loans - then there are contributions needed for colleague's babies, retirements, etc, smart clothes for work, etc. These all bring take home pay down.

NOTE - I am in no way benefit bashing. I am trying to inform that too much is taken from workers and they are not all entitled to UC. It's like Chinese whispers handed down - not factual and quite misleading.

You are benefits bashing by constantly drawing comparisons. Do you think benefits should keep pace with inflation or be subject to a real-terms cut this year, given the rising costs eveyone is dealing with?

No one has to contribute to colleagues' collectons and I get my work clothes in the charity shop. Everyone can criticise the spending of other people.

Pensions are not 'taken' from anyone - they are a voluntary contribution to ones own future wealth. Tax and NI are not 'taken' - they are democratically-mandated deductions that benefit the payee by providing current services AND future pensions. Vote for the Tories if you think your DD would be benefitted by the low-tax, low-service, low-regulation madness Truss is in favour of (she won't benefit from it, obviously).

TheReallyUsefulCrew · 06/10/2022 09:33

mam0918 · 06/10/2022 09:26

I have been a carer almost all my life, I was a child carer that go no help and still am a carer. I haven't held an employed job since 16 because its impossible but I attempt self employment alongside my care responsabilities but make only a couple of thousand a year if lucky depending on the market at the time which is then topped up buy a few benefits (carers allowence and child benefit).

My current over all income per year is £6k (thats with benefits).

Lets view carers allowence, it requires FULL TIME hours of 37 hours of care a week (when really its 24/7 but lets just take their number) for this we are paid £69.70 = £1.88 per hour.

The biggest drain cost on the NHS and emergancy services is people abandoning disabled and mentally ill family member. Us carers litrally save the country MILLIONS and they can't even be bothered to even attempt to pay us anywhere close to minimum wage.

Do you REALLY think a 9% increase instead of 4% would put us in a position of being 'better off' than those getting minimum wage?

Unless you have savings/capital etc. you would be eligible for UC which would give you a few hundred more each month. Unless you have a working DP whose warning would wipe out an award.

lannistunut · 06/10/2022 09:30

C8H10N4O2 · 06/10/2022 09:09

I wonder if the OP will be back, having lit the touch paper?

Nope! Wish @mumsnet would deal with these repeated goady threads, they are just a wind up exercise.

KermitlovesKeyLimePie · 06/10/2022 09:30

@The4teddybears A fucking "lifestyle choice"?

I had to give up a 20 year career to become the fulltime carer for my DC17.

I must have missed where I "chose" for him to have SLD, unable to feed himself, dress himself, bathe, be totally non verbal and require lifetime 1:1 care.

TheReallyUsefulCrew · 06/10/2022 09:26

happyinherts · 06/10/2022 09:07

@ C8H10N4O2

Can we forget this idea that the low paid are all entitled to UC. It's misleading....

They aren't exactly low paid, BUT they can be spending up to £200 per week on work related expenses which are obviously not taken into account for UC purposes - think travel, tax, NI, pensions, student loans - then there are contributions needed for colleague's babies, retirements, etc, smart clothes for work, etc. These all bring take home pay down.

NOTE - I am in no way benefit bashing. I am trying to inform that too much is taken from workers and they are not all entitled to UC. It's like Chinese whispers handed down - not factual and quite misleading.

Before trying to inform others you should ensure you are informed with the correct information yourself so your post isn’t misleading. The earnings used by UC to calculate deductions do take into account tax, NI and pension.

You can’t seriously be suggesting contributions to voluntary things such as someone’s retirement or birth should be taken into account?