Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To wonder why benefits should rise in line with inflation when no job is?

409 replies

Bananil · 05/10/2022 22:22

Massively struggling with food prices and absolutely no chance the heating is going on for a long time yet. DH and I work full time but have not had a pay rise since before the pandemic and wouldn’t ask for one as our industry has taken a real hit. I can’t think of any jobs that are expecting a pay rise in line with inflation so why do much fuss about making sure benefits do?

OP posts:
WakeUpAndBe · 06/10/2022 12:09

Rabbitbabbit · 06/10/2022 11:20

People wouldn't be arsed if it was the other way round would they- the point is that we should be pushing for everyone to get one rather than saying a certain group essentially shouldn't. Ew.

They would care if it was the other way round.

Pensioners are peoples’ parents and grandparents.

The begrudging at the inequality comes from knowing that pensioners are protected because they are statistically likely to vote Tory. Liz Truss is protecting her voter base.

The decision to give pensions a rise in line with inflation has more to do with the politics of staying in power than doing what is right and fair in civilised society.

TheReallyUsefulCrew · 06/10/2022 12:05

ChelseaRobertsofMalibu · 06/10/2022 11:28

I'm sorry but this is false. Unless you get the LCWRA component for disability then you do not get £1400! That's just given a load on mumsnetters the total wrong impression of what people on UC receive!

If you're not disabled and don't have a disabled child then the rate of UC inc the rent payment is less than £1000

A single parent with 2 DC with the housing element will always get more than £1000 per month, even using the lowest figures.

Standard element for under 25 £265.31
2 children born after 6th April 2017 £244.50 x2
The lowest housing element for a 2 bed is £87.45 per week so £378.95 per month.
= £1133.26.

So if they are over 25, have an older DC, live somewhere with a higher rate/eligible for 3 bed rate it is perfectly possible to receive £1400 per month.

anyoneanyoneanyone · 06/10/2022 11:59
  • Quite simply Op those of us who are working class are expected to fund every one, the titch dodge it and the poor expect it. God forbid we are not happy being cash cows working out fingers to the bone. To be honest I'm sick of being in n the group of people who work dam hard and expected to pay for others lives and alit of the time chosen life styles.

Also before others start quoting me, first of all me and my dh have not had children because we have decided we want to be financially viable first and second we don't drink, don't smoke and have not had a holiday in years and years. We work dam hard to save up for a mortgage and sick of being cash cows buy every government.*

I HOPE TO GOD that if you ever fell on hard times, become physically or mentally unwell that there are fewer people with your stinking attitude around to beat you further down. In fact I'm sure you will change your mind pretty sharpish.

Thebestwaytoscareatory · 06/10/2022 11:56

Will Great Britain’s 12.5 million pensioners be affected by a real-terms cut in the value of benefits? So far the prime minister, Liz Truss, has indicated there will be no real-terms cut in the level of the state pension next April. However, it could be tricky explaining why there should be a cut for low-income working-age people but not pensioners.

Oh that one’s easy, it’s because they’re more likely to be Tory voters and they can’t risk upsetting them by forcing the most entitled generation in history to suffer any decline in living standards. No, much better to pay for the mistakes of the old with the blood and sweat of the young.

WatchoRulo · 06/10/2022 11:49

I can’t think of any jobs that are expecting a pay rise in line with inflation
CEOs got 39% in 2021 - way ahead of inflation.
highpaycentre.org/ceo-pay-increased-by-39-in-2021-the-reaction/

ChelseaRobertsofMalibu · 06/10/2022 11:48

Trez1510 · 06/10/2022 02:18

Playing Daily Mail Bingo here, and I have a full house!! Go, me!!

Lazy/feckless? Dab!
Entitled? Dab!
Cheats? Dab!
Tales of ridiculous amounts (£2.6k pm for one person) Dab!
Work Will Set You Free. Dab!

Patronising of disabled people, but only the 'right sort' of disabled people? Dab!
Drain on resources? Dab!
Freebies? Dab!
Production of 'crotch goblins' to maximise benefits? Dab!

On the other hand, there are genuine, empathetic, realistic people who realise their own good fortune in life and also that events happen in life that turn it upside down well-beyond financial.

In what should be the wider picture of the Daily Mail reader, there are factors that really should concern them, but don't.

High rents? Look to your own parents who bought up the social housing stock, and who now rent them out at 3 or 4 times the equivalent social housing rent. Perhaps you even do this yourself with your 'inheritance'? Anyway most private landlords are, imo, benefits parasites on a far greater scale than someone out of work. They are leeching from the taxpayer to pay their fucking mortgages via housing benefits!!

Low pay? Look to your employer who is permitted to underpay you due to the benefits safety-net which creates the people upon whom you feel entitled to spit. These are leeching from the taxpayer via in-work benefits to pay their shareholders dividends.

Unions? The organisations designed to represent workers to obtain a fair day's pay for a fair day's work. Either you choose not to join them (yet gladly - and despicably - accept any benefits won by them) or you're delighted to see them being bashed by whatever Tory government for which you voted.

Can you not see? The Tories are lining the pockets of their buddies (businesses and landlords) from your taxes and their compliant media is telling you it's all the fault of individual benefit claimants.

That's off the top of my head at 2:00am.

This really made me giggle! Grin

Dab! 👏🏻

WatchoRulo · 06/10/2022 11:46

There seems to be some sad opinion that those of us who work should shut up and not complain.
Complain about shit wages, don't complain about people who get very minimal benefits.

ChelseaRobertsofMalibu · 06/10/2022 11:40

Foxsache · 06/10/2022 00:31

Hi op.

I have a degree from Oxford University, I was fortunate by accident of birth to have had parents with professional careers that afforded us a relatively comfortable upbringing. this meant I could gone to a good school and when I struggled with maths gcse, my parents paid for a tutor. My parents paid for music lessons, and I was able to achieve top grades and get into university which is recognised enough that meant I walked into a good job on graduating.

i had a great career until I had children. One of them has a severe disability. I am unable to work due to having to meet my child’s needs.

I have gone from earning a great salary for a 40 hour week to being given a benefit of just £69.70 a week carer’s allowance. Gone was my chance to pay into a private pension, or anything else that comes from being able to work.

At one point, I would’ve agreed with you, until benefits became my life. I have my hair cut twice a year because I cannot afford to have it cut more often than that. In between times my friend cuts a straight line for me. I haven’t had new clothes since before covid. My shoes are all worn. There is no one else who could care for my child as my parents are now elderly pensioners, I’m exhausted from regular night waking and all the washing and hospital visits etc that I have to do. I can barely
afford fuel for my car.

I have met lots of people in the same boat as me. Every single penny literally counts, every price rise in the shops is a worry. I am not sure how we will cope this winter.

Back in my corporate world years, I know how much money is being made at the top. Wages are kept low. I’m sorry if you fail to see why the money I need to keep myself and my children from starving and dying isn’t fair when your wages don’t rise, but believe me it is a pretty shitty existence at the bottom when people are blaming me and others in similar circumstances.

Every one of us is only one or two life events from falling to the bottom of society. I sincerely hope that you never have to experience it too.

From what you describe, you're not getting everything you're entitled to. If you pm me, I can help Flowers If you'd rather not, I understand but please look into DLA for your child. Not only will you receive that but you also then receive added UC for having a disabled child and caring for them 30+ hours per week. This is in addition to Carer's allowance

ChelseaRobertsofMalibu · 06/10/2022 11:38

@Devon01 As I said above, disabled people are exempt from the benefit cap. However without kids she cannot get £2600pm even if 50% was wages. Those payments don't exist.

I however am disabled and a widowed parent to a child with special needs. Therefore my total amount is just under £30k. However I'd give up half of it to be able to go back to the career I adored before the accident which killed my husband and made me disabled for life

ChelseaRobertsofMalibu · 06/10/2022 11:34

StarbucksSmarterSister · 06/10/2022 00:26

someone I know disclosed how much they get to me the other day and this is after their rent has been paid for them through another scheme. No dependents. No car to run. No travel costs to get to work due to being on benefits. £2600 per month. I was astounded!

Me too since that works out at more than 30K and the benefits cap is 23K.

Disabled people are exempt from the benefits cap. However if she has no kids then it's not physically possible for her to be getting £2600pm. Even if 50% was earnings. Those payments don't exist and I know the DWP inside & out

ChelseaRobertsofMalibu · 06/10/2022 11:28

RequiemForAcat · 05/10/2022 22:47

1 single parent adult not working, 2 children, £1400 UC per month, £800 to rent leaves £600. £600 for gas, electric, mobile phone, food and clothing. Electric & gas is £300pm on its own. It’s no life. No life at all, and it makes me so sad when people say things like “I’m sick of paying for others to live” most aren't living, they’re barely surviving.

I'm sorry but this is false. Unless you get the LCWRA component for disability then you do not get £1400! That's just given a load on mumsnetters the total wrong impression of what people on UC receive!

If you're not disabled and don't have a disabled child then the rate of UC inc the rent payment is less than £1000

Rabbitbabbit · 06/10/2022 11:20

WakeUpAndBe · 06/10/2022 10:51

I don’t think it’s about begrudging. It’s about not creating an inequality that leads to begrudging.

Both pensioners and the disabled struggle to improve their income, which explains why inflation rises make sense for both groups. Why should they both not be treated the same when it comes to state welfare?

People wouldn't be arsed if it was the other way round would they- the point is that we should be pushing for everyone to get one rather than saying a certain group essentially shouldn't. Ew.

ShepherdMoons · 06/10/2022 11:06

It's worrying that OP is even asking this!! The vulnerable really are struggling at the moment.

kikisparks · 06/10/2022 11:04

KermitlovesKeyLimePie · 06/10/2022 10:11

Meanwhile how much did the back tracking on the top rate tax cuts cost us?

Fucking sickening.

Exactly, far more than the cost of keeping benefits in line with inflation. But, predictably, this government will try to sail through its many costly blunders or deliberate mis-spending of public money by getting the poorest to point the finger at each other- scapegoating benefits claimants and migrants has long been a Tory strategy and sadly it works all too well.

ClaudineClare · 06/10/2022 11:00

OP hasn't come back. Probably sitting under their bridge chortling at the hate they have unleashed.

kikisparks · 06/10/2022 11:00

Rosehugger · 06/10/2022 10:47

Perhaps you should follow the advice of the Tory scions and Get A Better Job.

I know, all the country needs is for all the cleaners, nurses, refuse collectors, shop assistants, carers, factory workers, hospitality workers, delivery drivers, admin staff, teaching assistants, nursery workers etc etc to become bankers or hedge fund managers! It’s so simple, I don’t know why nobody thought of it before.

kikisparks · 06/10/2022 10:54

Swizandswap · 05/10/2022 22:59

Exactly I know plenty of single people who work dam hard and travel miles every day of the week and earn less than this. There seems to be some sad opinion that those of us who work should shut up and not complain.

Why shut up and not complain? Why not complain- by striking, writing to your MP, protesting etc the low wages and high transport costs, I.e. the things that will actually make a difference? Instead of just bashing those also in an awful situation.

Also you can’t really compare a single person to a single parent with 2 children. If a single parent of 2 only earned £1400 they’d be entitled to Universal Credit. Many of those receiving benefits are in work.

WakeUpAndBe · 06/10/2022 10:51

Rabbitbabbit · 06/10/2022 10:33

Not really no. I agree benefits should rise, but I don't get the we shouldn't begrudge people on benefits getting more (even though wages have stagnated) but fuck pensioners they should suffer too. I'd suggest the justification is that people have pair their stamps for the qualifying amount of years, the triple lock has long been promised and most aren't able to supplement their pension with work. For every pensioner sitting on a throne of their riches they accumulated when times were good in their huge homes there are plenty struggling. A state pension (bearing in mind most jobs didn't have employment pensions as they do now so didn't have the chance to put towards one of those) isn't much at all, and many still have to pay for their social housing or whatever.

I don’t think it’s about begrudging. It’s about not creating an inequality that leads to begrudging.

Both pensioners and the disabled struggle to improve their income, which explains why inflation rises make sense for both groups. Why should they both not be treated the same when it comes to state welfare?

Junipercrumble · 06/10/2022 10:50

IncessantNameChanger · 05/10/2022 22:28

Because benefits are close to the bone with little wiggle room. My mate, on uc, disabled with two SEN kids has £65 a week left bills to eat. I find it really very very hard to envy her life. £65 to feed and clothe 3 is pretty grim. I can't see thise kids having life transforming outcomes tbh. Yes you always work more hours, get promotions but you'd find that slightly tricky if you couldn't get out of bed due to pain and exhaustion from fibromyalgia while your 14 year old with asd has a mental breakdown

I hope your friend is receiving all of the benefits she is entitled to.
If they are all severely disabled, she could claim up to £1842.01 per month UC PLUS housing allowance (dependant on her LHA rates and size of property) PLUS up to £470.70 per week in disability benefits.

That's the equivalent of UP TO £3881.71 per month (or £895.78 per week) plus extra for housing element.

If she is claiming all she is entitled to, apologies, i cant imagine how difficult it must be to try to survive on £65 per week to feed and clothe herself and her children. 💐

Rosehugger · 06/10/2022 10:47

Perhaps you should follow the advice of the Tory scions and Get A Better Job.

Rabbitbabbit · 06/10/2022 10:36

Surely we should all be pushing for benefits to rise but not complaining about a group who will have theirs do so. Lots of people hate the elderly mind and either have wild ideas about their wealth or begrudge them for some reason.

Rabbitbabbit · 06/10/2022 10:33

WakeUpAndBe · 06/10/2022 10:23

Read it in the context of the article. There is a section on: How working age benefits and pension age benefits compare

amp.theguardian.com/society/2022/oct/04/what-would-real-terms-benefits-cut-mean-uk-claimants-inflation-liz-truss

Once you’ve read the article the question should answer itself.

Not really no. I agree benefits should rise, but I don't get the we shouldn't begrudge people on benefits getting more (even though wages have stagnated) but fuck pensioners they should suffer too. I'd suggest the justification is that people have pair their stamps for the qualifying amount of years, the triple lock has long been promised and most aren't able to supplement their pension with work. For every pensioner sitting on a throne of their riches they accumulated when times were good in their huge homes there are plenty struggling. A state pension (bearing in mind most jobs didn't have employment pensions as they do now so didn't have the chance to put towards one of those) isn't much at all, and many still have to pay for their social housing or whatever.

Meklk · 06/10/2022 10:27

My advice from personal experience - NEVER EVER moan about benefits or downgrade people who receive them. Life can be unpredictable.
You'll be very surprised how low they are when the day you need them will come.

bingbummy · 06/10/2022 10:27

So if your job went up would you then want benefits to go up?

WakeUpAndBe · 06/10/2022 10:23

Rabbitbabbit · 06/10/2022 10:18

However, it could be tricky explaining why there should be a cut for low-income working-age people but not pensioners.

Would it be tricky?

Read it in the context of the article. There is a section on: How working age benefits and pension age benefits compare

amp.theguardian.com/society/2022/oct/04/what-would-real-terms-benefits-cut-mean-uk-claimants-inflation-liz-truss

Once you’ve read the article the question should answer itself.