Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To wonder why benefits should rise in line with inflation when no job is?

409 replies

Bananil · 05/10/2022 22:22

Massively struggling with food prices and absolutely no chance the heating is going on for a long time yet. DH and I work full time but have not had a pay rise since before the pandemic and wouldn’t ask for one as our industry has taken a real hit. I can’t think of any jobs that are expecting a pay rise in line with inflation so why do much fuss about making sure benefits do?

OP posts:
PinkFrogss · 05/10/2022 23:44

How long before someone suggests the reintroduction of workhouses, that usually pops up on these threads eventually

Feelingconfused2020 · 05/10/2022 23:44

She is referring to people that can’t be arsed to work/work very little and pop out crotch goblin after crotch goblin to get free dosh

So judgmental. How many people do you/she actually think are doing this? There are systems (quite Draconian) in place to prevent this and the number who do this is proportionally small. These people will not make a huge difference to the benefit bill for the whole country. Legislating with these people in mind instead of those who are really struggling will bring the whole country down and make no significant difference to the few who commit benefit fraud.

Stop reading the daily mail and start using some critical thinking.

Babyroobs · 05/10/2022 23:42

RequiemForAcat · 05/10/2022 22:47

1 single parent adult not working, 2 children, £1400 UC per month, £800 to rent leaves £600. £600 for gas, electric, mobile phone, food and clothing. Electric & gas is £300pm on its own. It’s no life. No life at all, and it makes me so sad when people say things like “I’m sick of paying for others to live” most aren't living, they’re barely surviving.

Could you work even a few hours a week ? You could earn up to £344 a month and keep all your UC and up to 85% of childcare costs. UC is rubbish for people in your situation but even working a few hours really boost your overall income.

Labraradabrador · 05/10/2022 23:42

@Sarasandman of my life is lovely, thanks! I worked really hard for it, and enjoy every bit of it guilt free. I think it is sad that you find work ‘miserable’, and might explain why you feel so reliant on state support.

MotherOfPuffling · 05/10/2022 23:42

Labraradabrador · 05/10/2022 23:35

@Devon01 but all of those things exist in other countries where benefits are less freely available? Truly you have no idea how good you have it.

I think part of the problem is the unequal division of resources in the UK. Money and resources like housing are being increasingly hoarded by the wealthy, meaning there is less for everyone else. Resentment breeds because people know a lot of their value as a worker is not paid to them, but goes into the pockets of the already wealthy. It seems a lot of that money is then kept offshore in tax havens, where it doesn’t benefit the UK, whereas if the rich hadn’t been allowed to hoard it, and it had instead instead been paid as tax or higher wages to those lower down the chain, it would have mostly been spent in the UK, benefiting the economy more. Velocity of money and all that.

PinkFrogss · 05/10/2022 23:41

Badgirlriri · 05/10/2022 23:33

But that’s what other people get paid working full time!

If a single adult works full time on minimum wage, rents, and has two children they would be entitled to UC as well.

Sarasandman · 05/10/2022 23:40

Badgirlriri · 05/10/2022 23:33

But that’s what other people get paid working full time!

Someone earning that working full time would receive universal credit on top, as well as help with childcare costs.

Babyroobs · 05/10/2022 23:39

Mrsjayy · 05/10/2022 22:30

I mean if you are "massively " struggling maybe you are entitled to universal credit.

This. I think a lot of working people just think they won't be entitled to UC but the work allowances and taper rates may mean you are especially if you have kids and rent to pay or childcare. I am really surprised by some of the earnings that some couples can have and still claim UC where one is too ill to work and has the LCWRA element on the claim meaning they get a generous work allowance on the claim.

Feelingconfused2020 · 05/10/2022 23:38

Firstly because it's not a race to the bottom and secondly because benefits recipients are the poorest in our society but their energy bills and food bills are also rising astronomically so proportionally they will be worse hit even than you. You say you and your DH are both working and presumably you are not benefits claimants so you must be earning more than the threshold for benefits. They are poorer than you.

Maybe join a union and fight for better pay. It's not your responsibility to suffer your industry and take the hit because they are struggling.

Sarasandman · 05/10/2022 23:37

Labraradabrador · 05/10/2022 23:32

@Sarasandman the system only works if the majority contributes.

It would be easy and enjoyable to spend my day in leisure rather than work, or spend more time at leisure than work, but that doesn’t put food on the table does it? for all the grasshoppers having an easy and enjoyable life, you need twice as many worker ants

Perhaps find work you find easier and more enjoyable? What a miserable take on life you have. Or change the system, if it depends on the majority being miserable and having difficult lives? Make some positive change? Perhaps taking a break would help you change your perspective, lessen your negativity.

Labraradabrador · 05/10/2022 23:35

@Devon01 but all of those things exist in other countries where benefits are less freely available? Truly you have no idea how good you have it.

NewBootsAndRanty · 05/10/2022 23:35

Sarah13xx · 05/10/2022 23:30

I have worked full time for the last 10 years, gone to uni etc and make £2100 per month. I have even opted out of the pension scheme (which is stupid, I know) just to be able to have some more money to live off of now as I am in my overdraft every month just trying to cover the essentials. We have a young child to feed, house to heat, car to run etc etc.

Im sure most people on benefits don’t get this amount and many do genuinely need it but someone I know disclosed how much they get to me the other day and this is after their rent has been paid for them through another scheme. No dependents. No car to run. No travel costs to get to work due to being on benefits. £2600 per month. I was astounded!

Hmm
Badgirlriri · 05/10/2022 23:33

RequiemForAcat · 05/10/2022 22:47

1 single parent adult not working, 2 children, £1400 UC per month, £800 to rent leaves £600. £600 for gas, electric, mobile phone, food and clothing. Electric & gas is £300pm on its own. It’s no life. No life at all, and it makes me so sad when people say things like “I’m sick of paying for others to live” most aren't living, they’re barely surviving.

But that’s what other people get paid working full time!

Devon01 · 05/10/2022 23:33

@NellesVilla It’s pretty obvious OP is NOT referring to people who are truly deserving of benefits such as carers and the disabled and single mums etc. She is referring to people that can’t be arsed to

Sorry, I must have misread it OP's original post. Can you direct me to the bit where they make this obvious?

Krabapple · 05/10/2022 23:32

Because that’s the rest the rise is calculated - based on inflation. You can’t expect it to be changed now as inflation is high! It’s not a trace to the bottom ffs! Perhaps the government should do set with benefits altogether and bring back workhouses. Would that make you happy?

Labraradabrador · 05/10/2022 23:32

@Sarasandman the system only works if the majority contributes.

It would be easy and enjoyable to spend my day in leisure rather than work, or spend more time at leisure than work, but that doesn’t put food on the table does it? for all the grasshoppers having an easy and enjoyable life, you need twice as many worker ants

IndianSummer78 · 05/10/2022 23:31

"wonder why benefits should rise in line with inflation when no job is?"

Because employees have the option of upskilling and going for promotion, looking for another job or changing careers, or working more hours, if they need more money. People living solely on benefits due to illness or disability or caring responsibilities meaning they can't work have zero options to do anything to increase their income.

Don't look to improve your quality of life by stamping others down so yours looks better by comparison. Stop thinking others, whose situations are worse than yours anyway, should be equally as badly treated as you are and start hoping/campaigning/whatever for everyone to be better treated. If one sector of society achieves it faster than you do, be happy for them instead of bitter for yourself. A positive mindset makes for a more enjoyable life. Looking at the negatives and holding petty jealousies only makes you miserable and eventually quite toxic.

StinkyWizzleteets · 05/10/2022 23:31

Ah the good old race to the bottom.
We can’t possibly be helping those worse off than you up, eh? Can’t be fighting to improve your own lot in life so let’s publicly shit on those who are already worse off and make them feel worse than they already do about the poverty trap they find themselves unable to get out of.

lovely human being. So caring and supportive. Let’s hope you never need to rely on the IC pittance. I’ve no idea how they manage and I’m ashamed I live in a country where that is deemed an appropriate and acceptable income to survive on.

Devon01 · 05/10/2022 23:31

@Labraradabrador If you are able to work, you should not receive benefits. I expect there are lots of excuses for why this isn’t possible, but in countries with less extensive benefits systems people find a way. As someone raised by a single mother in one of those other countries I know exactly how challenging it can be, but far too many in this country feel entitled to an easy life.

Were not talking about other countries, we're talking about UK, where our government allow zero hour contracts, terrible minimum wage, which leads to debt and poverty, they allow 'pay day loans' which leads to homelessness and suicide, will soon abandon all EU directives that protect worker's rights, where the ill and disabled are forced to find work, which leads to perpetual cycle of physical and mental health issues, which leads to poverty, debt and suicide. The same government who don't help ex-forces to find jobs, housing or emotional support after serving our country, which leads to homelessness, poverty, health issues and suicide. The same government who ignores the fact that people have to rely on charities, food banks etc, can turn a blind eye to all this, refuse to give these vulnerable people true cost of living but can give the wealthy tax cuts as this will give them more money to spend and this will 'trickle down' to benefits the rest of us.

Sarasandman · 05/10/2022 23:30

NellesVilla · 05/10/2022 23:28

Haven’t read entire thread but YANBU OP.

It’s pretty obvious OP is NOT referring to people who are truly deserving of benefits such as carers and the disabled and single mums etc. She is referring to people that can’t be arsed to work/work very little and pop out crotch goblin after crotch goblin to get free dosh.

The amount of people I’ve heard on buses etc saying it’s not worth their while to work and it’s easier to be on benefits. Why would we do if everyone felt like that?!

And if anyone has a go at me, I do not claim benefits and work bloody hard. I’m fed up of paying for prescriptions when benefit claimants get it all for free (again, I’d never begrudge those truly in need).

If we all did it, it would be a general strike and might force a change of system to something beautiful and beneficial.

Blossomtoes · 05/10/2022 23:30

I don’t take money deducted from your pay @Swizandswap. I’m also a taxpayer, difference is I recognise that having an income that attracts the tax I pay makes me privileged.

Sarah13xx · 05/10/2022 23:30

I have worked full time for the last 10 years, gone to uni etc and make £2100 per month. I have even opted out of the pension scheme (which is stupid, I know) just to be able to have some more money to live off of now as I am in my overdraft every month just trying to cover the essentials. We have a young child to feed, house to heat, car to run etc etc.

Im sure most people on benefits don’t get this amount and many do genuinely need it but someone I know disclosed how much they get to me the other day and this is after their rent has been paid for them through another scheme. No dependents. No car to run. No travel costs to get to work due to being on benefits. £2600 per month. I was astounded!

echt · 05/10/2022 23:30

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

Jknow · 05/10/2022 23:29

MotherOfPuffling · 05/10/2022 23:25

Thank you for sharing this! I really don’t understand why people don’t understand that social inequality is bad for everyone. Sigh!

You’re welcome, although I can’t imagine anyone who truly thinks that way will read it, they’ll just carry on repeating their Daily Mail headline sound bites whilst fiercely believing they’re right. Shame though as it’s an eye opener.

Sarasandman · 05/10/2022 23:29

Oldsu · 05/10/2022 23:23

@SarasandmanYes you are correct most CONTRIBUTION based benefits go to pensioners and you do realise that pensioners also pay tax, I am a working pensioner the extra tax I pay (over and above the tax and NI combined I paid when I was working age) equates to a weeks pension every 4 weeks, a pension that I paid NI for the best part of 51 years before I qualified for it, even when I stop work I will still be paying tax.

All benefits recipients pay tax, yes, including pensioners. More than half of all benefits recipients are pensioners, not of just contribution-based benefits.