Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To wonder why benefits should rise in line with inflation when no job is?

409 replies

Bananil · 05/10/2022 22:22

Massively struggling with food prices and absolutely no chance the heating is going on for a long time yet. DH and I work full time but have not had a pay rise since before the pandemic and wouldn’t ask for one as our industry has taken a real hit. I can’t think of any jobs that are expecting a pay rise in line with inflation so why do much fuss about making sure benefits do?

OP posts:
PrincessFiorimonde · 06/10/2022 00:55

NellesVilla · 05/10/2022 23:28

Haven’t read entire thread but YANBU OP.

It’s pretty obvious OP is NOT referring to people who are truly deserving of benefits such as carers and the disabled and single mums etc. She is referring to people that can’t be arsed to work/work very little and pop out crotch goblin after crotch goblin to get free dosh.

The amount of people I’ve heard on buses etc saying it’s not worth their while to work and it’s easier to be on benefits. Why would we do if everyone felt like that?!

And if anyone has a go at me, I do not claim benefits and work bloody hard. I’m fed up of paying for prescriptions when benefit claimants get it all for free (again, I’d never begrudge those truly in need).

Crotch goblins? If you - or your friends or family members - have children, is that how you refer to them?

Do you really think that the 'free dosh' received for each extra child claimed for (£14.45 a week in Child Benefit, I believe) makes for a life of luxury?

Like you, I work and don't claim any benefits. But because I'm over 60, I am eligible for free prescriptions. You'll find there are quite a few of us in this category.

Lalliella · 06/10/2022 00:55

Wow aren’t you the milk of human kindness? People on benefits get the minimum required to live. If that reduces in real terms they don’t live. Is that what you want OP? Try having some fucking empathy. What the hell is this country becoming? Wanting to stamp on people when they’re down? Shame on you OP.

Livelovebehappy · 06/10/2022 00:54

Benefits for the disabled, and everyone else currently unemployed should get one of the thousands of jobs out there.

StarbucksSmarterSister · 06/10/2022 00:53

Devon01.

Read again. I didn't say that. I was replying to that post, pointing out it was way above the cap!

BertaHoon · 06/10/2022 00:51

The4teddybears · 05/10/2022 22:40

Wouldn’t their rent be paid by benefits too , and I’m sure that with most councils the council tax is waived until the care leaver is 25.
So it is more than £265 pm to live on isn’t it .

Nope, you still have to pay a percentage of council tax.

So imagine that comes out of you £77 a week.

Then you need a phone (job centres say this is must for interviews), they like you to have an internet connection as all job searching is web based. You still have to pay bills and feed yourself.

Good luck to anyone that can do that on 77 a week.

Whammyyammy · 06/10/2022 00:51

I think benefits should increase with inflation, its not a race to the bottom.
But I see what youre saying, benefits and wages should be increased with inflation.

Devon01 · 06/10/2022 00:51

@StarbucksSmarterSister yes, you were included in that comment. You were telling us that someone you knew was getting £30k in benefits so I was asking, as you seem to know, exactly what benefits this person was claiming. Although, in your first post you were quite confident of this fact, but now it's only 'apparently' this amount. Either way, I'd sincerely be interested to know this person's circumstances, what kind of benefits they're claiming etc. I mean, no point in being discreet now seen as you've already shared their personal details/income anyway

happyfishcoco · 06/10/2022 00:48

Don't look to improve your quality of life by stamping others down so yours looks better by comparison. Stop thinking others, whose situations are worse than yours anyway, should be equally as badly treated as you are and start hoping/campaigning/whatever for everyone to be better treated. If one sector of society achieves it faster than you do, be happy for them instead of bitter for yourself. A positive mindset makes for a more enjoyable life. Looking at the negatives and holding petty jealousies only makes you miserable and eventually quite toxic.

@IndianSummer78

well said!

StarbucksSmarterSister · 06/10/2022 00:44

A breakdown please - I mean, you must know, you're both so knowledgeable and precise about the subject of these people's claims

I'm not sure if the "both" includes me since all I did was point out how much over the cap the person's apparent income is, but I'd also be interested to know how someone gets so much, plus rent paid.

Or perhaps I've misunderstood your use of"both" .

Devon01 · 06/10/2022 00:43

It's so sad and makes me angry that people feel they have to justify the reasons why they are in a position to have to (not want or choose to) claim benefits to the ignorant few on here. (Thankfully they are in the minority). There are some heartbreaking stories on this thread and for those of you who still feel they should be 'working harder', shame on you. If you're so angry and bitter about the situation, go join the tory party and campaign to get all benefits claimers put in a poor house or whatever you think is a suitable 'punishment', whilst giving all the millionaire bankers and business owners the right to give themselves ridiculous salaries and bonuses, the right to pay atrocious wages and offer zero hour contracts. Hope you never fall off your high horses

Willyoujustbequiet · 06/10/2022 00:38

Foxsache · 06/10/2022 00:31

Hi op.

I have a degree from Oxford University, I was fortunate by accident of birth to have had parents with professional careers that afforded us a relatively comfortable upbringing. this meant I could gone to a good school and when I struggled with maths gcse, my parents paid for a tutor. My parents paid for music lessons, and I was able to achieve top grades and get into university which is recognised enough that meant I walked into a good job on graduating.

i had a great career until I had children. One of them has a severe disability. I am unable to work due to having to meet my child’s needs.

I have gone from earning a great salary for a 40 hour week to being given a benefit of just £69.70 a week carer’s allowance. Gone was my chance to pay into a private pension, or anything else that comes from being able to work.

At one point, I would’ve agreed with you, until benefits became my life. I have my hair cut twice a year because I cannot afford to have it cut more often than that. In between times my friend cuts a straight line for me. I haven’t had new clothes since before covid. My shoes are all worn. There is no one else who could care for my child as my parents are now elderly pensioners, I’m exhausted from regular night waking and all the washing and hospital visits etc that I have to do. I can barely
afford fuel for my car.

I have met lots of people in the same boat as me. Every single penny literally counts, every price rise in the shops is a worry. I am not sure how we will cope this winter.

Back in my corporate world years, I know how much money is being made at the top. Wages are kept low. I’m sorry if you fail to see why the money I need to keep myself and my children from starving and dying isn’t fair when your wages don’t rise, but believe me it is a pretty shitty existence at the bottom when people are blaming me and others in similar circumstances.

Every one of us is only one or two life events from falling to the bottom of society. I sincerely hope that you never have to experience it too.

Well said.

I have a similar story and had to give up a career in law to become a carer for for dc with complex needs. People are utterly clueless until it happens to them.

Willyoujustbequiet · 06/10/2022 00:34

OP yabvu and so naive

Benefits are a pittance. My friend ( single and childless with a mortgage) became disabled suddenly. She waited over 18 months for an assessment and in that time received less than £400 per month whilst being liable for a £800 mortgage nevermind actual living costs.

There was no help whatsoever and along with having to adjust to her disability she consequently lost her home after using up all her savings. She paid into the system for years . There is no safety net.

Benefit amounts are a disgrace and should absolutely increase with inflation....and then some!

BitterAndTwistedChoreDodger · 06/10/2022 00:34

This is why we should be furious at a government that lets tax payers prop up large companies so that they can legally be allowed to pay their employees a pittance.

Don't waste your anger on those getting benefits, it should be employers taking the hit to pay better wages, not the tax payer.

Devon01 · 06/10/2022 00:33

@StarbucksSmarterSister

@Sarah13xx

someone I know disclosed how much they get to me the other day and this is after their rent has been paid for them through another scheme. No dependents. No car to run. No travel costs to get to work due to being on benefits. £2600 per month. I was astounded!

Me too since that works out at more than 30K and the benefits cap is 23K

Pray tell, what exactly are these benefits are that takes then over the benefit cap? A breakdown please - I mean, you must know, you're both so knowledgeable and precise about the subject of these people's claims. What exactly does the £2600 per month or £30k pa consist of? I'm sure all the lazy out there will be dying to know how much more they can claim if £30k is being offered to the select (imaginary) few - might help them be confident enough to turn their heating on this winter

Foxsache · 06/10/2022 00:31

Hi op.

I have a degree from Oxford University, I was fortunate by accident of birth to have had parents with professional careers that afforded us a relatively comfortable upbringing. this meant I could gone to a good school and when I struggled with maths gcse, my parents paid for a tutor. My parents paid for music lessons, and I was able to achieve top grades and get into university which is recognised enough that meant I walked into a good job on graduating.

i had a great career until I had children. One of them has a severe disability. I am unable to work due to having to meet my child’s needs.

I have gone from earning a great salary for a 40 hour week to being given a benefit of just £69.70 a week carer’s allowance. Gone was my chance to pay into a private pension, or anything else that comes from being able to work.

At one point, I would’ve agreed with you, until benefits became my life. I have my hair cut twice a year because I cannot afford to have it cut more often than that. In between times my friend cuts a straight line for me. I haven’t had new clothes since before covid. My shoes are all worn. There is no one else who could care for my child as my parents are now elderly pensioners, I’m exhausted from regular night waking and all the washing and hospital visits etc that I have to do. I can barely
afford fuel for my car.

I have met lots of people in the same boat as me. Every single penny literally counts, every price rise in the shops is a worry. I am not sure how we will cope this winter.

Back in my corporate world years, I know how much money is being made at the top. Wages are kept low. I’m sorry if you fail to see why the money I need to keep myself and my children from starving and dying isn’t fair when your wages don’t rise, but believe me it is a pretty shitty existence at the bottom when people are blaming me and others in similar circumstances.

Every one of us is only one or two life events from falling to the bottom of society. I sincerely hope that you never have to experience it too.

happyfishcoco · 06/10/2022 00:28

@Sarasandman That's why we go on strike. We have unions and we support one another. Benefits claimants don't have the option of striking, so need our support.

not many people can go on strike.
that's why op is saying they don't / won't get raise.
I know some people only get 1% raise last and this year. and some people even don't get raises.
who supports them?

StarbucksSmarterSister · 06/10/2022 00:26

someone I know disclosed how much they get to me the other day and this is after their rent has been paid for them through another scheme. No dependents. No car to run. No travel costs to get to work due to being on benefits. £2600 per month. I was astounded!

Me too since that works out at more than 30K and the benefits cap is 23K.

Willyoujustbequiet · 06/10/2022 00:25

The4teddybears · 05/10/2022 22:40

Wouldn’t their rent be paid by benefits too , and I’m sure that with most councils the council tax is waived until the care leaver is 25.
So it is more than £265 pm to live on isn’t it .

There is no help towards a mortgage ( save for a loan that pays interest only). What are people meant to do who get less than £400 but have a mortgage double that?

So no, its nowhere near enough to live on.

Devon01 · 06/10/2022 00:25

@Labraradabrador exactly the kind of defeatist mentality I was referring to!

Please be kind enough to point out the bits of any of my posts on this thread that shows a defeatist mentality (a little copy and paste would be most helpful). I'm truly interested in how your mind is interpreting anything I've said in such a way, rather than just trying to speak out to say that the majority haven't been and aren't in such a position to fight their way out of homelessness and poverty. And if it can be classed as a defeatist mentality, then feel free to educate all these grasshoppers on how to fight their way out of the circumstances they've so selfishly and needlessly put themselves in.

Chaotica · 06/10/2022 00:20

SillySausage81 · 06/10/2022 00:08

What you SHOULD be asking, OP, is why so many jobs aren't getting pay rises when the bosses and shareholders of those very same organisations are raking in millions if not billions in profits, dividends and bonuses. Many companies can clearly afford to pay their employees more but are CHOOSING not to. Get angry about that, rather than getting angry that some people on the breadline might get enough so they don't starve to death.

Exactly this.

Most people on benefits of working age are working. Many of the rest are disabled. Benefits are worth fuck all. Please take your anger at benefit claimants and redirect it at the system which leaves many of the working people poor and lets the government waste billions through their own stupidity and greed.

OldFan · 06/10/2022 00:18

As a PP said- if you really can't put your heating on at all yet @Bananil due to poverty, you will be entitled to universal credit. Smile

Devon01 · 06/10/2022 00:17

@Queuesarasarah This is a classic case of
a) you thinking that you not needing to be on benefits is due to your own merit and hard work as opposed to at least one of wealth, reasonable health, luck of family upbringing and reasonable health of dependents.
b) what’s fair isn’t the same as what is right. If in order to avoid children starving we have to be unfair I think that’s a price worth paying
c) finally and most importantly - looking to the bottom of society rather than the top to see who is to blame for the fact you have had a real terms pay cut.

Exactly this

Merlott · 06/10/2022 00:16

SillySausage81 · 06/10/2022 00:08

What you SHOULD be asking, OP, is why so many jobs aren't getting pay rises when the bosses and shareholders of those very same organisations are raking in millions if not billions in profits, dividends and bonuses. Many companies can clearly afford to pay their employees more but are CHOOSING not to. Get angry about that, rather than getting angry that some people on the breadline might get enough so they don't starve to death.

This is the answer.

OP move jobs and get a pay rise.

You are angry at the wrong people

AsAnyFuleKno · 06/10/2022 00:14

SillySausage81 · 06/10/2022 00:08

What you SHOULD be asking, OP, is why so many jobs aren't getting pay rises when the bosses and shareholders of those very same organisations are raking in millions if not billions in profits, dividends and bonuses. Many companies can clearly afford to pay their employees more but are CHOOSING not to. Get angry about that, rather than getting angry that some people on the breadline might get enough so they don't starve to death.

💯

Devon01 · 06/10/2022 00:14

@Sarah13xx someone I know disclosed how much they get to me the other day and this is after their rent has been paid for them through another scheme. No dependents. No car to run

And I'm sure this person who trusted you enough to share such information with no idea you'd be sharing it and slagging her off on MN really appreciates you as a good and loyal friend.

I bet if she did have dependants you'd be outraged that she dared to have kids and claim benefits, just as if she did have a car to run you'd be equally scandalised that such a benefit claimant was actually allowed to own/rent/hire a car.

Swipe left for the next trending thread