Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To wonder why benefits should rise in line with inflation when no job is?

409 replies

Bananil · 05/10/2022 22:22

Massively struggling with food prices and absolutely no chance the heating is going on for a long time yet. DH and I work full time but have not had a pay rise since before the pandemic and wouldn’t ask for one as our industry has taken a real hit. I can’t think of any jobs that are expecting a pay rise in line with inflation so why do much fuss about making sure benefits do?

OP posts:
Discovereads · 06/10/2022 02:19

@Hoppymclimpy
I hope you can find a food bank? Gosh, I’m lucky compared to you as my DH stuck by us and he’s working PT so he can care for me, but I can’t imagine surviving as you are with a single disability income and DC. What kind of bastard thinks his child can eat on £0?! 💐

Trez1510 · 06/10/2022 02:18

Playing Daily Mail Bingo here, and I have a full house!! Go, me!!

Lazy/feckless? Dab!
Entitled? Dab!
Cheats? Dab!
Tales of ridiculous amounts (£2.6k pm for one person) Dab!
Work Will Set You Free. Dab!

Patronising of disabled people, but only the 'right sort' of disabled people? Dab!
Drain on resources? Dab!
Freebies? Dab!
Production of 'crotch goblins' to maximise benefits? Dab!

On the other hand, there are genuine, empathetic, realistic people who realise their own good fortune in life and also that events happen in life that turn it upside down well-beyond financial.

In what should be the wider picture of the Daily Mail reader, there are factors that really should concern them, but don't.

High rents? Look to your own parents who bought up the social housing stock, and who now rent them out at 3 or 4 times the equivalent social housing rent. Perhaps you even do this yourself with your 'inheritance'? Anyway most private landlords are, imo, benefits parasites on a far greater scale than someone out of work. They are leeching from the taxpayer to pay their fucking mortgages via housing benefits!!

Low pay? Look to your employer who is permitted to underpay you due to the benefits safety-net which creates the people upon whom you feel entitled to spit. These are leeching from the taxpayer via in-work benefits to pay their shareholders dividends.

Unions? The organisations designed to represent workers to obtain a fair day's pay for a fair day's work. Either you choose not to join them (yet gladly - and despicably - accept any benefits won by them) or you're delighted to see them being bashed by whatever Tory government for which you voted.

Can you not see? The Tories are lining the pockets of their buddies (businesses and landlords) from your taxes and their compliant media is telling you it's all the fault of individual benefit claimants.

That's off the top of my head at 2:00am.

Katypyee · 06/10/2022 02:11

So just because you and your husband have not had a raise, you are saying nobody should? That is not equitable.

Have you ever tried to live off benefits? I am guessing not.

You don't vote Conservative do you?

sashh · 06/10/2022 02:10

You have no idea what kind of citizen I am. I do a lot of work with the most vulnerable in society . But i have also seen how much some people do get in benefits. Not all. But some. And when those few are getting more in total than someone working full time then something is wrong. For millions of people benefits is a life style choice .

I have 20+ years of NI contributions, I also get a private pension, as someone mentioned above because of the pension my contribution based ESA is cut in half.

Now that's unfair. I paid into a pension which I was only able to claim because of disability and I lose half the money I have paid NI contributions for because of it.

I didn't choose to become disabled. I don't think many people do. It's shit and I'd much rather be working and earning.

In some other European countries your benefit amount is worked out depending on what you were earning before you needed to claim benefits.

Discovereads · 06/10/2022 02:05

@Foxsache
Every one of us is only one or two life events from falling to the bottom of society.

Yep. Had a life event too. Now I’m permanently disabled and cannot work. Thank you for sharing your story so eloquently. I hope the OP takes notice. Too many people think it can’t happen to them.

echt · 06/10/2022 02:05

Funny how the OP hasn't been back to their shit-stirring goady thread.

alwayscrashinginthesamecar1 · 06/10/2022 01:58

Anybody looking at benefits claimants and thinking they are getting too much money is looking in the wrong direction. Divide and rule really works, doesn't it? The working classes should be looking at the rich, not the poor if they are looking for inequality and unfairness. This is why the bloody Tories win, time and time again!

yogalu · 06/10/2022 01:53

I can't tell many of you apart from the Daily Mail comments section.
We love a good scapegoat for the cost of living, no better than to poke the poor with a stick. It just isn't as fashionable in the current climate to poke the other one - immigrants.
I always presume that those who begrudge others a dignified living are generally bitter, trapped in a job they loathe and have many unfulfilled dreams sliding down the gutter.

The hard up working classes are obsessed with oneupmanship.
You define work as drudgery because it is all you know. And instead apportioning the blame to those who create the policies and rules, you prefer to stick the boot into those who appear weaker than you. I imagine this is the same contingent who think education is for time wasting sissy's.

Discovereads · 06/10/2022 01:53

nightbulb · 05/10/2022 23:48

This just isn’t how pay works in FS.

This was last years bonuses with the cap…..
”As most Britons face the biggest squeeze on their incomes since at least 1990, already very highly paid bankers are celebrating “particularly obscene” bonuses in the City’s pubs and wine bars.…London’s mergers and acquisitions (M&A) bankers earned total fees of $3.5bn (£2.6bn) in 2021, according to research by financial data provider Refinitiv for the Guardian. It is the highest annual total for M&A banker fees paid since Refinitiv’s records began in 2000, fuelled by a frenzy of corporate takeovers sparked by a flood of private equity cash and acquisitive American buyers preying on undervalued British targets.

That money is now set to be returned to bankers in their bonuses. London’s big four banks – HSBC, Barclays, Lloyds Banking Group and NatWest – are expected to pay out bonuses totalling more than £4bn when they report their annual results in the next fortnight….

The bumper bonuses will tip several hundred more UK bankers into the EU’s “high earners” warning report which details every banker earning more than €1m (£835,000) a year. The European Banking Authority (EBA) found that 3,519 bankers working in the UK earned more than €1m-a-year last year – more than seven times as many as those working in Germany which has the second highest number of €1m-a-year bankers.
www.theguardian.com/business/2022/feb/16/weve-had-a-run-on-champagne-biggest-uk-banker-bonuses-since-financial-crash

The cap.
“At the moment, that limit stands at 100% of a banker’s salary, but can be doubled to 200%, subject to shareholder approval. So a banker earning, say, £100,000 a year can only receive an annual bonus of £100,000, or £200,000 in special circumstances….Liz Truss and her chancellor Kwasi Kwarteng, appear to see scrapping the cap as a key part of their “pro-growth” post-Brexit agenda.”

This years bonuses with no cap? Can’t really argue the cap hindered bankers pay when last year with the cap they had the highest bonuses since records began…

myteethwerefine · 06/10/2022 01:46

I can confirm that housing benefit doesn't cover rent. I have to use nearly all of my esa to cover the shortfall and then use my dla for all other costs (food, utilities etc).

Also I would like to thank all those who have passionately yet articulately described the harsh realities of life on benefits. I used to have more fight in me to do so myself but I feel ground down by the apparent hatred and resentment by a certain section of society over the past 12 years. I cannot describe the psychological effect of watching a sizeable proportion of your fellow humans vote in a party again and again which doesn't even hide its contempt for the disabled and vulnerable. It's hard enough being too sick to have any agency over your life; to be hated for that fact in addition is unbearable.

Discovereads · 06/10/2022 01:41

Labraradabrador · 05/10/2022 23:32

@Sarasandman the system only works if the majority contributes.

It would be easy and enjoyable to spend my day in leisure rather than work, or spend more time at leisure than work, but that doesn’t put food on the table does it? for all the grasshoppers having an easy and enjoyable life, you need twice as many worker ants

The grasshoppers are not benefits claimants, they are the ultra-rich who pay less tax through bought and paid for MPs & PMs writing tax loopholes passing laws to benefit them. Truss’ mini reverse Robin Hood budget is a good example remarkable only for its blatant out there we are cutting taxes on the rich and cutting benefits for the poor. But it’s not different from what past 12yrs has been, they’re just not pretending to care anymore.

Floating around on a super yacht surrounded by super models being fed by a your own Michelin starred chef and having one nanny per child….that’s life of luxury.

Jumping through hoops to keep your pittance so you don’t starve to death, not a grasshopper life. It’s a squashed ant life.

Mfsf · 06/10/2022 01:40

It’s people like you that create this culture of “ people on benefits are lazy or sponge of the state “ . If you are worried about your own circumstances then blame the appropriate people , your employer, the government, not those just above the bread line . You are doing exactly what this government is going for making everyone blame those on benefits, it’s their way to divide , it’s either the poor or the immigrants or the refugees or the disabled , then your focus is not on the government .

This comes to mind :
“A billionaire, a working man, and an immigrant are all in a room with 100 cookies on the table. The billionaire takes 99 of them and then whispers to the working man, “That guy’s gonna steal your cookie.””

altmember · 06/10/2022 01:37

I'm a single parent of 3, and we're still receiving tax credits (haven't been migrated over to UC yet). I don't know exactly what they've done with increases/thresholds but the actual amount I receive hasn't increased in line with inflation for years. Some years its gone down, despite my circumstances (earnings) barely changing. I'm convinced most benefits haven't genuinely tracked the rate of inflation in real terms for ages.

And according to online benefits calculators, UC in my circumstances is actually less than the current child tax credits calculation (I appreciate transitional protection should cover the difference, but as I'm self employed I'm not sure that'll actually last long).

I don't qualify for or receive housing benefit, but I know people who do. And there is no way that has increased with the real rate of rents for years either. Currently there is no way that it will cover actual private rent charges. Someone entitled to single bedroom housing benefit gets £440 a month. That's supposed to be the rate for self contained living accommodation, not a room in shared accommodation. There is nothing self contained available to rent for less than £600, typically it's more like 700+ (and that's if you can actually find somewhere).

The national min wage has gone up significantly over the last few years, but benefits amounts and thresholds haven't been adjusted in line with that.

Yes there is a problem with the social economy in this country - it shouldn't be necessary to prop up by household incomes with government handouts yet still leave people below the poverty line. I don't know what the answer is, but things are badly broken in this country.

Hoppymclimpy · 06/10/2022 01:26

I've just sat here reading some of these comments. Bloody hell it's depressing to realise that if these comments are to go by then there's a large minority of society looking down on me because of my situation.
Life is a funny old thing, you never know what's around the corner.
5 years ago I had a well paying career, infact paid 40% tax on some earnings, was married and living a comfortable life with my child as a double income family.
Fast forward to now. Disability took my career, husband decided he wanted a 'normal' wife (his delightful words) and overnight I became one of the people some of you seemingly despise.
I now survive on my medical retirement pension, ESA and PIP. The ex has decided he can't afford CM this month so I'm currently trying to figure out how I'm going to feed my 11 year old and I.
I'd not wish disability or misfortune on anyone but believe me when I say life can take an unexpected turn at any point.
For those thinking 'but you're one of the okay ones, cos you're disabled', we don't wear bloody labels so we can be judged as to how deserving we are for the handouts that are just about keeping my head above water.
I'm scared. I'm tearful most of the time. I'm not being the best Mum I should be because my mind is thinking of what else I can flog for a bit of cash or how I'm going to get petrol this week. Then I read some of the comments on here and think 'you haven't got a clue' because honestly, for some of you, you've got no bloody idea what you're talking about.
Rant over, I'm going back under the pile of blankets x

Discovereads · 06/10/2022 01:25

I’m fed up of paying for prescriptions when benefit claimants get it all for free (again, I’d never begrudge those truly in need).

@NellesVilla I claim PIP benefit and pay for my 7 prescriptions I need every month…..if you’re struggling, may I suggest you look into a prepayment certificate? It’s only £108/yr for unlimited prescriptions and the NHS can do a monthly DD for £10.80 for ten months and then auto-renew. Anyone can get one.

beachcitygirl · 06/10/2022 01:22

Secondly, what has become of
This country when people like you feel
Empowered to say something so truly selfish & vile.

beachcitygirl · 06/10/2022 01:20

Because it is very very very expensive to be poor.
Much more so than to be an average or high earner.

Discovereads · 06/10/2022 01:19

StressedToTheMaxxx · 05/10/2022 23:16

Yes, some benefits are less than a wage, some really are pitiful. However some are more than a minimum wage, full time worker would bring in.

But all those workers get top up benefits to the same level so they are actually no worse off. Then they often get tax credits on top of that, so still end up ahead.

JockTamsonsBairns · 06/10/2022 01:17

PickAChew · 06/10/2022 00:00

What benefits were they, then?

They weren't any, because that never happened.

Discovereads · 06/10/2022 01:16

The4teddybears · 05/10/2022 23:09

Say it as slow as you like. You’re wrong

“In 2018, EPC requirements
changed for landlords through
the introduction of a minimum
energy rating of 'E' or above for
new tenancies. Now, this rule
applies to all tenancies, not just
new ones.”

My old home was EPC E. It was grade II listed with 200yr old single glazed rotting out of their wood frames windows….no foundation 5mm gaps between floor boards and “dirt” under floor, loft insulation last chucked up there circa 1970, solid brick walls so no cavity insulation….

EPC E is a very bad rating.

Discovereads · 06/10/2022 01:11

Sarasandman · 05/10/2022 23:05

Most benefits go to pensioners. The rest are mostly working and paying taxes, unless they have very severe disabilities.

Don’t forget the benefits that are not means tested…PM Cameron was claiming DLA for his disabled son while earning what a quarter million quid a year? Which is fine, but these sort of top line stats don’t mean what you, labrador, think they do.

happyfishcoco · 06/10/2022 01:04

@PickAChew this winter? I think I will only pay £30-40 per month.
with a family of 4.

StarbucksSmarterSister · 06/10/2022 01:03

My father became disabled and my mother had to be his full time carer. My sibling and I were kids. We lived hand to mouth, God knows how we'd have coped without family helping out. That was decades ago and we had a Labour government.

I can't imagine how horrific it must be now to have to rely solely on benefits.

blameless · 06/10/2022 01:03

Lots of posts about the benefits cap, but no mention of when it doesn't apply:

www.gov.uk/benefit-cap/when-youre-not-affected.

There are ways to enjoy a well-funded lifestyle on benefits, but to do so requires you to carefully structure your life - often before you need to claim - and to have an encyclopedic knowledge of the benefit rules and regulations. These are things that those unexpectedly finding themselves vulnerable due to trauma or illness (the kind of things that benefits were designed for) are least able to do.

This is why while many 'deserving' people find themselves ineligible for benefits, the likes of Errol Graham starve in our midst, out of sight while those who navigate the system well are more conspicuous.

Whammyyammy · 06/10/2022 00:59

My next door neighbour rents and solely relies on benefits aa disabled. She doesn't smoke, doesn't have a huge TV, doesn't drive a flashy car (2004 ford), doesn't go out or on holiday, lives quite a dull boring life and she is absolutely dreading this winter due to increasing bills.

My husband and I pay circa £2000 ,per month in tax, do I begrudge a portion of it helping those genuine claimants like my neighbour, and an increase in her help, not at all.
My mortgage is going to increase, same as my bills, but I'm glad we both work and are able to afford to live comfortably.

I don't see degrading her life aa a way of improving my own.

Swipe left for the next trending thread