Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Why do you think the highest suicide rate of all is of men approaching 50?

169 replies

RR64 · 05/10/2022 21:47

Why do you think the highest suicide rate of all is of nen approaching 50?

Surely this needs to be addressed?

OP posts:
DogInATent · 06/10/2022 09:17
  • Loneliness.
  • Financial pressures.
  • The societal pressure of male stereotype to be the breadwinner/rock.
  • Poor emotional education.
  • Undiagnosed health issues.
  • Work:life balance.
  • The "Is this it?" of late middle-life when you realise that most of your managers are younger than you, and you're not going to progress much further in your career if you stay where you are and doing what you do - but see Pressure of Being the Breadwinner that stops you doing something different.

And some of these combine in ways that are greater than the sum of the parts. If you identify primarily as all the stereotypes of maleness, you can end up with your emotional foundations resting entirely on your relationship. Anything that threatens that threatens to kicks the blocks from the bottom of an emotional Jenga pile.

A neighbour took his life two years ago. I didn't know him, they'd only moved in a couple of months earlier just as we all went into lockdown. I heard his wife's scream when they found him. He had a lot of friends, but apparently no one to talk to on difficult matters other than his wife. And it's thought he believed he was letting her and the family down when the business dropped off due to lockdown.

The balance to these negative stereotypes can be seen in typical "male" activities. It's been said by the founder of the Men's Shed movement that women talk face-to-face and men talk shoulder-to-shoulder. And I think you can see this in activities such as fishing, golf, or going to the football match. Whenever a thread comes up where there's a complaint that DH works 8-6 Mon-Fri and then clears off every Saturday afternoon for "his hobby", I wonder to what extent it's being underestimated how important that hobby might be for DH's emotional wellbeing.

GreyBlossom · 06/10/2022 09:11

Maybe the read all the hatred for middle aged men on MN?

It's a key transition for them as it is for women, career opportunities reduce, children gone/going, long relationships drifting/ending, parents ill or dying, but men aren't allowed to feel these things the way women do.

MelonMojito · 06/10/2022 09:07

Wow. More men die by suicide in this age group but more women ATTEMPT it so that’s the real tragedy?! People actually dying is less to people trying… riiiiight.

FridayTheThirteeth · 06/10/2022 08:49

They tend to have a really tough time. Divorce often means they lose everything and in most cases the woman keeps home, furnishings and they have to start again from scratch (not always obviously). They have often worked full time since leaving education and not taken any breaks and then poof off it walks.

InCheesusWeTrust · 06/10/2022 08:47

I take that points.

Lopilo · 06/10/2022 08:44

This age coincides with when they have hormonal changes that can lead to depression.

FayeGovan · 06/10/2022 08:43

TheMoonLight · 05/10/2022 22:14

It's a very difficult age for men and women. You realise that you have probably lived more than half of your life. By this age you have collected a lot of experiences and can be carrying them all in a very heavy sack on your back. Some of your family and friends are dead, dying or facing terminal and very serious illnesses. This makes you scared about getting older. You worry that you are about to be thrown on to the scrap heap at work due to your age. You feel depleted and tired. You feel that time is running out to try new careers. Unless you are financially very secure you feel trapped by your circumstances.

I appreciate that each age group has its challenges but there is definitely a truth to the 'crisis' of middle age.

Very good post and exactly how i feel actually.

KILM · 06/10/2022 08:27

InCheesusWeTrust · 06/10/2022 08:06

I am surprised how many people do "but women" here. We all know what happens when post is about women and someone says "but men"...
Media can talk about suicide rates in men without doing "but women". Actually they should..same way like they should talk about women's issues without "but men"

I completely take your point here, after being irritated time and time again by seeing domestic violence against women discussions getting derailed by 'but men get hit too'
However, it is relevant - we are asking why men succeed more - the answer is patriarchal conditioning, and it becomes necessary to mention women in that.

Ponoka7 · 06/10/2022 08:14

@InCheesusWeTrust , you can't really ask why the rate of male suicide is so high, without discussing women. Likewise more boys manage to kill themselves than girls. There's a sex bias, so both sexes have to be compared. Lack of involvement in family life/feeling isolated is a recurring factor. That's quite easy to fix.

InCheesusWeTrust · 06/10/2022 08:06

I am surprised how many people do "but women" here. We all know what happens when post is about women and someone says "but men"...
Media can talk about suicide rates in men without doing "but women". Actually they should..same way like they should talk about women's issues without "but men"

KILM · 06/10/2022 08:01

If you google it, a really well put together briefing from the samaritans comes up 'samaritans suicide research briefing'
Where it states that women attempt suicide more, men just choose more lethal methods.
There is of course suspicion that men are less likely to report an attempt, women's attempts are seen more as attention seeking so wont be categorised as a 'serious' attempt, but i find it really interesting that the prevailing narrative in this country is that male suicide is a crisis.
Personally i think this 'more lethal methods' is the key - as noted by a PP, women are more likely to have caring responsibilities - be a single parent, be caring for elderly relatives etc - 'more lethal methods' for the most part equal = messy and horrible for someone to find. And its not a stretch to imagine that women would shy away from these methods even at rock bottom due to societal conditioning, being concerned about who would find then as they are likely to be missed quicker.
The other really interesting thing in that was that biggest correlating factors - bereavement and divorce were highest in men, whereas self harm, mood disorders and domestic violence were for womem, despite women also suffering bereavement and divorce.
Again, the lack of self reporting will factor in, Another way we let down men and boys by not encouraging them to be able to talk about their emotions. I find it interesting that the media try and create this 'there's a war on men causing a suicide crisis' but dont report that women attempt more, and that domestic violence is a factor?

Babyroobs · 05/10/2022 23:52

I think as others have said, there is often seperation and divorce, not being able to afford to take on another mortgage after divorce, maybe having to move back with ageing parents, not being able to have their kids to stay, financial problems, mid life crisis. All kinds of reasons I guess. And as other have highlighted men often don't have the same close support networks.

InCheesusWeTrust · 05/10/2022 23:52

I wonder how much it corellates with things like unrmployment.
I remember a programme years ago from deprived communities and the men were mentioning things like feeling absolutely useless and at some points suicidal because they couldn't take care of their families like they were supposed to etc.

Everyone has some societal pressures which they battle.

Lochjeda · 05/10/2022 23:46

Testosterone dropping and creating an imbalance.

tolerable · 05/10/2022 23:45

@RR64 really?if you can find the statistic did you not google the rationale/thats prob not what the word id in this sense
why do you think?

Dalaidramailama · 05/10/2022 23:35

Financial woes, lack of support/friends, an unwillingness to seek help which escalated into poorer MH. Women struggle with menopause but in general they do talk to each other and there’s more information in general etc.

justasking111 · 05/10/2022 23:24

Wanttobeanastronaut · 05/10/2022 23:20

I agree with @NOTANUM . In my experience of observing the men around me of that age bracket, one thing they all seem to have in common is that they realise they are no longer young, virile and 'top of the social pecking order' as it were, and struggle to adjust. Several of the ones I know are very angry and feel threatened by men 20 or so years younger than them and struggle to understand or elaborate on why that is.

Such good points. If only men would confide in each other they'd realise it's a normal progression

justasking111 · 05/10/2022 23:22

RandomMess · 05/10/2022 22:00

Looks go
Sexual performance goes/changes
DC flying the nest
Career plateaus
Old age fast approaching
Losing parents/siblings

Those are more particular to that age group

I agree with this.

Wanttobeanastronaut · 05/10/2022 23:20

NOTANUM · 05/10/2022 22:07

It’s a worthwhile question.

Now that I’m a bit older, I can see that men leaving wives in their 40s - often for a new younger version - is largely a backlash against being middle aged. It doesn’t always work out so well personally. Professionally they can feel usurped as the younger generation pass them by.

In contrast I think women come into their own after 45/50 when the intense child rearing days are done. They often pick up their careers or interests again, seem full of life, and are much less bothered by career politics.

I agree with @NOTANUM . In my experience of observing the men around me of that age bracket, one thing they all seem to have in common is that they realise they are no longer young, virile and 'top of the social pecking order' as it were, and struggle to adjust. Several of the ones I know are very angry and feel threatened by men 20 or so years younger than them and struggle to understand or elaborate on why that is.

MoneytoaBee · 05/10/2022 23:20

I read a study years ago that looked at the suicide notes and lifestyle of people who had survived a suicide attempt and compared this to people who sadly had not. Looking to identify what, if any, differences were happening between these two groups. (I can't find the study though). It said that people who had died through suicide were more likely to feel burdensome on close family/friends and they were also more likely to have a high tolerance for pain (through self-harm, injury or maybe they were into sports like boxing). I've always thought about this and maybe men are more likely to feel burdensome than women during middle age. Women are more likely to be in a caring role, either their own children, or their parents or even their job and this could act as a buffer against suicide?

It is very sad, and suicide is something that society has to look at more closely, it really is an indication of a very sick society that dying is more tolerable than the pain of living.

Chonfox · 05/10/2022 23:17

I know quite a lot of men in this age bracket - I have come to realise that the male mid life crisis is definitely a thing.

Ditto. I've come to realise it's one of those stereotypes that definitely exists for a reason.

There will be multiple reasons but overall it's an issue for men to fix. Most of them are emotionally stunted in many ways. Until they address that and learn better coping mechanisms for stress and worry then this statistic is just going to be one of those things that happens in a highly competitive, superficial, consumerist society.

Bookerly · 05/10/2022 23:17

Women have more varied lives on average and don't get judged so much on their "success".

Men feel like a failure if they've got job, financial, relationship problems. And they often don't know how to deal with their feelings. They are also naturally more aggressive which means they are more likely to actually go through with it.

verytired42 · 05/10/2022 23:09

It’s very sad indeed. I think middle aged women are a bit better at accepting help and making supportive networks. For some men it can be very difficult to reach out and voice sadness and despair. Especially if there’s a history of trauma. Especially if they cope by being busy at work or using substances.

MrsTerryPratchett · 05/10/2022 23:08

RR64 · 05/10/2022 22:45

Let's all talk about dentists then, rather than boring middle aged men.

Maybe that's part of the problem?

Huh?

I think it's worth saying that just because men are dying, doesn't mean women are at fault. Posting on MN is ignoring the fact that support services, by and large, are staffed by underpaid women. Crisis lines, homeless services, even counselling, mostly women.

It's men not supporting services with money and time that's missing. Maybe ask on Reddit or Twitter and get men to tell you why they aren't acting.

As a woman whose spent 30 years supporting people, more than half of whom were male (often 100% were male), I don't think women are the issue.

verytired42 · 05/10/2022 23:07

More broadly: the Manchester group looked at this demographic group using the national confidential enquiry into suicide dataset. They found common factors: unemployment, deprivation, social isolation, bereavement, physical health problems, alcohol and/or other drug use, and mental health problems, mainly depression.