Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to be shocked the BBC asked a searching question re benefits?

36 replies

inheritanceshiteagain · 05/10/2022 19:26

This morning I think it was Gordon Brown saying people on benefits should get a rise in line with cost of living increase (9%ish), rather than in line with wage rises (5%ish).
The BBC presenter asked him if it was fair to people getting up at 6am to go to work to support their families, who would not get this higher amount?
GB pointed out that 40% of people on tax credits are working... but that leaves 60% of people fit to work who don't work?

Of course there are multiple factors, childcare, single parenthood, no jobs available in the area where they are needed and so on, but why is there such a crazy system that makes it financially better to work 16 hours a week? Why isn't there more affordable childcare available? If this fixable?

OP posts:
ComebackQueen · 05/10/2022 19:38

DashboardConfessional · 05/10/2022 19:32

Why isn't there more affordable childcare available?

Why indeed. And they wonder why so many households of 2 adults are "replacing" themselves in the economy with one child.

Childcare, full time in Hendon which is North West London is c£1400 and that’s at a place I am expected to provide nappies, wet wipes and his milk. At a nursery where all this was included it was more.

For those on average income, this is most likely most of their net pay.

One partner is then, inevitably going to give up work to look after the child, without benefits due to the spouse or partner still working.

I can see then, why they may be resentful at Gordon Brown asking for them to get a higher percentage increase.

On the other side, people with disabilities, on a small pension credit etc are choosing to heat or eat, that’s completely unacceptable and should be deserving of being provided benefits to make essential household bills and shopping possible out of their benefit payments.

Givenuptotally · 05/10/2022 19:34

but that leaves 60% of people fit to work who don't work?

Does it? You sure of that? Maybe have a think.

And I think you'll find statistically, the majority of people claiming tax credits are in work.

DashboardConfessional · 05/10/2022 19:32

Why isn't there more affordable childcare available?

Why indeed. And they wonder why so many households of 2 adults are "replacing" themselves in the economy with one child.

PeekAtYou · 05/10/2022 19:31

Considering the lack of investment in schools, investing in Early Years is an even bigger pipe dream.
Employers in industries with vacancies seem to require extraordinary flexibility. I saw an ad of the door on B&M which was for 12 hour a week job and you had to be available nights and weekends which are times you can't get childcare. Loads of zero hour jobs seem to require full flexibility when you're not even guaranteed hours. How can you survive on that ?

Rayn22 · 05/10/2022 19:30

60% won't be carers or on disability!

ErmNoThankYou · 05/10/2022 19:30

Not a lot of people get tax credits so your 40% and 60% don't mean a lot.
There are other reasons that people dont/ aren't expected to work other than childcare.

OnanotherPier · 05/10/2022 19:29

And yes you are being unreasonable to think journalists wouldn't ask leading questions.

properdoughnut · 05/10/2022 19:29

Problem is if they don't do this it will just mean people on benefits going hungry and maybe dying of cold. You aren't going to get that 60% into work magically. They might have been out of work ages or have other stuff going on or live in areas where there just aren't any jobs.

RogueRebel · 05/10/2022 19:28

If 40% are working how does that make 60% of people fit to work?

What about people who are disabled? People who have cancers/ illnesses that mean they cannot work?

I think you need to look at your statistics again

OnanotherPier · 05/10/2022 19:28

but why is there such a crazy system that makes it financially better to work 16 hours a week

There isn't in reality for the vast majority of people and it's no different to some people being paid more for the same role than others.

Threadkillacilla · 05/10/2022 19:28

How many of the 60% are carers or have limited capability due to illness?