Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To tell my DD's school she isn't doing a detention for this?

89 replies

Krank · 05/10/2022 16:56

My daughter leaves for school every day at 7.30am to get the bus to school. Today unfortunetly the bus was late, and she ended up being 10 minutes late. They've given her a 30 minute detention for tommorow. I am going to phone her school tommorow, and have a calm word, apparently even her tutor thinks its stupid!

AIBU?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Willyoujustbequiet · 06/10/2022 00:21

andrew16 · 06/10/2022 00:03

All I am doing here is stating the facts, I am not providing an opinion either way.

Schools have a legal right to keep a child for an after school detention; are not legally required to inform parents beforehand; and are also not legally required to give a reason for the detention.

Parents do not have a legal right to refuse a detention, meaning that a school is well within its rights to escalate the sanction according to their behaviour policy if a child does not attend.

If parents feel a detention is unjust, they can file a complaint with the headteacher, or governors.

www.gov.uk/school-discipline-exclusions

Now, that being said, I imagine most schools will both inform parents and give a reason for any after school detentions that have been set as that is in the best interests of both parental engagement and support.

In OP’s case, I imagine what will have happened is that the student was marked late on the register (which is totally understandable and necessary as the attendance register needs to be accurate to comply with safeguarding requirements), and an automated detention set without anybody knowing the reason for the lateness. I am sure that once the school are made aware of the reason after a conversation with parents, the detention will be cancelled.

That is rather confusing as given that legally children do not have to attend school at all, I can't see how it could possibly withstand a court challenge.

andrew16 · 06/10/2022 00:07

This was meant to be in reply to @AMindNeedsBooks but I must have forgotten to reply to their post!

andrew16 · 06/10/2022 00:03

All I am doing here is stating the facts, I am not providing an opinion either way.

Schools have a legal right to keep a child for an after school detention; are not legally required to inform parents beforehand; and are also not legally required to give a reason for the detention.

Parents do not have a legal right to refuse a detention, meaning that a school is well within its rights to escalate the sanction according to their behaviour policy if a child does not attend.

If parents feel a detention is unjust, they can file a complaint with the headteacher, or governors.

www.gov.uk/school-discipline-exclusions

Now, that being said, I imagine most schools will both inform parents and give a reason for any after school detentions that have been set as that is in the best interests of both parental engagement and support.

In OP’s case, I imagine what will have happened is that the student was marked late on the register (which is totally understandable and necessary as the attendance register needs to be accurate to comply with safeguarding requirements), and an automated detention set without anybody knowing the reason for the lateness. I am sure that once the school are made aware of the reason after a conversation with parents, the detention will be cancelled.

Handsoffmyrights · 05/10/2022 23:17

My child catches 2 buses to/from school.
We have major issues here with half the services not running, late buses, buses not turning up, buses not stopping etc.
The bus garage is understaffed and drivers are struggling.
As such, buses are all over the shop. It's been this way since the pandemic. Not sure some posters understand these realities.

LivingMyBestLie · 05/10/2022 22:53

RusticChips · 05/10/2022 18:14

The same happened to my daughter, I sent in an email and they still gave her a detention 🙄

Did you take it further? That seems really unfair of them (and beyond their power?)

HollyJollyXmas57 · 05/10/2022 22:48

Ridiculous.

Id be telling my DD to do the same and just leave at the end of the day.

Some teachers are not fit to be teachers. A girl in my daughters class got told off for scratching her face the other day. I know who the child is and she really is a goodie goodie. Everything my daughter has told me about him indicates he’s a horrible teacher that has little patience and wants to rule with a iron fist. So he’s now called Mr Asshole because he is one.

Magnanimouse · 05/10/2022 21:31

Firstly, I agree, school are wrong. Treating kids like this has no benefits at all, and I'm a headteacher (albeit primary!).

They'll justify it by pointing out that they're preparing kids for the workplace (all the shops/factories I worked in as a student had a policy that if you were not clocked in on time, to the minute, you lost half an hour's pay; in one supermarket, you were expected to have clocked in 5 mins before your pay started because you were expected to be on the shop floor when your shift started). Excuses about buses made no difference.

They're also reasonable in that once they've let it go once, every kid will use the "late bus" excuse and they can't spend all day phoning the bus company to find out who is telling the truth.

Personally, I'd pick your battles. Both you and her have probably spent more than half an hour of your lives getting worked up about this, posting on Mumsnet, phoning the school. If you want to do something about it, write to the headteacher and ask that the policy is changed to allow 3 lates per year or something, rather than fighting the detention.

spongedog · 05/10/2022 21:13

Call the (lovely) attendance team politely and explain. If your DD was late on a school bus, then others would probably be late too.

I say lovely - I am Data, not attendance but work in the same office. A good attendance team cares. They really do. They will listen when a parent cries down the phone that they cannot get a Year 11 lad out of their bedroom without physical violence; that a yr 7 child has such anxiety they cannot get out of the drive without being sick; that a student has had an operation (that no-one else at school knew about), that a grandparent has died etc etc.

There are attendance rules - there really are strict rules and enormous focus on attendance. But keep talking to the attendance team. Be polite though! Some of the calls from parents are foul. Really unpleasant. An attendance officer is probably not paid much more than minimum wage, term-time only. That's tough to live on at the moment.

HappyHappyHermit · 05/10/2022 20:35

Sorry that was not finished. I was going to say she isn't in control of the bus so doesn't deserve the detention, she could not and cannot correct her behaviour so what purpose does it serve. None.

HappyHappyHermit · 05/10/2022 20:33

Of course she isn't.

MsTSwift · 05/10/2022 20:26

That’s just mean.

TheOrigRights · 05/10/2022 20:25

I've never heard of children getting detentions when their bus is late.

QuietQuietBang · 05/10/2022 20:16

Krank · 05/10/2022 17:27

It's not a school bus, its public transport. There is no school bus here.

Then whether you are unreasonable or not depends on whether she’s getting a bus that would make her late 20% of the time or 2%.

If she’d be better off getting a bus ten minutes earlier but chooses not to then you are being unreasonable. If they are hourly and normally get her there twenty minutes early then you are not.

LincolnshireYellowBelly · 05/10/2022 20:12

As a teacher, as much I expect a parent’s support when I issue a detention for good reasons, I also expect parents to challenge (appropriately) if I’ve made a mistake.

Your child absolutely does not deserve this detention

TheTurn0fTheScrew · 05/10/2022 19:34

My DC's school cancels late marks if there is known heavy traffic.

Brealinr · 05/10/2022 19:33

Idyllicidealist · 05/10/2022 18:39

There's some petty and ridiculous people working in schools.

My experience too.
I’m convinced all common sense and reason departs their heads as they qualify. No other explanation for it apart from being dictatorial otherwise in cases like yours OP would they be happy for a child to be stood outside the school an hour early in case the bus they should be able to rely on does not turn up again - if you made your child do it they’d flag it up as an issue!

AMindNeedsBooks · 05/10/2022 19:32

User135792468 · 05/10/2022 18:29

This is not true.

And how is it not true exactly?

Bananaman123 · 05/10/2022 19:31

I remember my form teacher trying to make an example of me (never late apart from this day). She had a training teacher so was showing off giving me a lecture about being 10m late. I told her I had actually gone out 40min early to catch a bus and 2 buses went by but were full so didn’t stop. I was actually raging at standing at the bus stop for an hour so made it clear I wasn’t taking her pish lol

AsAnyFuleKno · 05/10/2022 19:27

reigatecastle · 05/10/2022 18:40

I would do the same. If it escalates the situation, well the governors would need to look at it. They have ultimate ability to review the discipline policy and hold staff to account for its implementation and interpretation.

There was a thread like this recently though and some MNers thought that the kids need to learn what it's like in the workplace. Forgetting of course that you can, to some extent, choose where to work and whether to rely on public transport. Kids do not have that autonomy and it is 100% wrong to blame them for public transport failings.

And added to that, if it was a one-off, you'd probably just make the time up and very little would be said about it.

WombatChocolate · 05/10/2022 19:23

The approach shouldn’t be ‘she’s not doing it’ - that’s the response of the parent who rejects all school discipline including perfectly reasonable discipline and is a pain in the arse.

The response should be ‘I think you’ll find the discipline policy has been unfairly applied in this case’. It’s a totally different approach, but the difference is really important.

It’s not that Op doesn’t support detentions for lateness or that she doesn’t support any discipline for her DD, but it’s about pointing out why 5is particular detention is unfair.

WombatChocolate · 05/10/2022 19:20

It’s the trouble with these inflexible discipline polices. They are unable to recognise the nuance in a situation or respond accordingly.

When you contact school, don’t just ask about this particular incident but also what they can do to ensure their policy doesn’t give lateness detentions to students who have had genuine public transport difficulties - it’s a regular thing.

This kind of thing happens when ‘the system’ issues detentions or they are issued centrally by someone who doesn’t know the individual circumstance. Better systems don’t just blanket-apply policies but can work with a policy and identify nuance to see who actually needs a detention for lateness.

Personally I would ring but also raise this wider issue in an email with Head of Year or Deputy in charge of discipline policy. You won’t have been the first to raise this kind of thing.

And in no way is this kind of communication akin to the parent who wants to wriggle their child out of a deserved detention - and you shouldn’t be seen as being equivalent to them, as this is totally different. However, initially you will probably be treated like this, because many people contacting school about detentions are in this category. School though, will know that in reality the very blunt instrument policy leads to errors being made, and like the tutor has already, acknowledges them….but not to the point of adjusting the system unfortunately!

Sh05 · 05/10/2022 19:19

Ds was given a same day 30 minute detention because he was at an appointment. I'd already called the school to let them know plus he had a pass from the office because I'd rang in the previous afternoon letting them know.
He's a generally well behaved child so didn't argue with the teacher although he did remind them he'd been at an appointment.
When I rang in the next morning at first they argued that he HAD been late so it was right that he got detention, they only apologised to him once I insisted she check the class pass that he had plus check with office staff in regards to my 2 phone calls.
He was in year 9, first time he'd ever had a detention and he was just really embarrassed more than anything else.

Namechanger965 · 05/10/2022 19:19

YANBU. I work in secondary and get the same bus as quite a few kids, one day it didn’t arrive and neither did the 3 after it. I ended up 40 minutes late for work (no taxis/uber were free) and the students were obviously also 40 minutes late. I explained to the member of staff on the late duty what had happened and they refused to waive the detention for the students, I had to go to each head of house and explain to them to get the detentions removed. Bloody stupid when they only needed to apply a bit of common sense. I’d worked there for 6 years as well, so they knew me well.

I would definitely speak to the head of house/year and explain she’s not doing it.

Dobbyismyabsolutefav · 05/10/2022 19:14

YANBU. My DD travelled to school by minibus and she never received a detention if she was late into school.

Swipe left for the next trending thread