Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Major Public Schools

115 replies

Izwizi · 05/10/2022 12:16

I myself went to a major public school (Cheltenham Ladies) and haven’t chosen to do the same for my own children for various reasons.

my SIL, who can be a bit highly strung, has two sons who currently attend a nice state primary. She has announced that she’ll be sending them to the (big name) boys public school about 15 minutes away. I have. A lot of experience with this school and I do not think her boys are the right fit. They are lovely boys who I adore but I don’t think they’d cope there. My SIL has hit the roof. IL’s tend to pander to her a bit and Have suggested to her that I was unreasonable in my advice.

DH and IL’s attended a good Grammar school and I just don’t think she appreciates how robust they’ll need to be to jump straight from a cosy village state primary to a major public school. Happy to be corrected if people feel I’m being unreasonable?

OP posts:
erinaceus · 05/10/2022 13:43

Did your SIL ask for your input? If so, I would say your piece once, a gently as you can, and then drop the matter entirely.

You wrote "She is choosing the wrong school for the personality of her children" which leaps out to me as massively overstepping. This is a matter for your DNephews' parents to decide. If the school were that poor of a fit for your DNephews they wouldn't have gotten through the admissions process.

Andante57 · 05/10/2022 13:40

A lot of experience with this school and I do not think her boys are the right fit

Surely a good school should be able to deal with a wide range of characters and interests etc. just as a good horse trainer should be able to deal with all different sorts of horses.

TrufflesForBreakfast · 05/10/2022 13:36

Op I understand your sentiments. There is often a huge social gulf in these schools between those who have and those who have not, often compounded by the boarders v day thing. Having been a day pupil at a boarding school I know how it feels to be automatically typecast on the outside by mere dint of my domestic situation. The day kids are apparently still seen as 'irrelevant' at the same school 30 years later! I actually opted for state for my dcs because I felt the environment was a lot less toxic. (They 'thrived' in their state schools btw.)

AloysiusBear · 05/10/2022 13:33

She is saying based on her knowledge of the school and the children , that the boys may well hate the school - anti bullying policies or none

She isnt a parent of a child at the school, or a teacher there, nor a recent attendee. She knows a handful of parents of pupils there. There will be hundreds of boys there. Some will be sensitive.

In any case, those sorts of public schools interview & select, they are spoiled for choice & are highly unlikely to offer a place to a boy who really will struggle to fit.

Often these descriptions are self fulfilling. The boys at the school maybe confident and robust because the school is good at instilling that confidence!

midgetastic · 05/10/2022 13:24

I don't see she's saying the boys aren't good enough

She is saying based on her knowledge of the school and the children , that the boys may well hate the school - anti bullying policies or none

But people will misinterpret and add meaning behind her simple statement

Littlebird43 · 05/10/2022 13:22

My DH went from a single entry village school (plus single parent, low income family) to a large public school, funded by a scholarship.
Sure he didn't get to go skiing and the other boys laughed at his mum's car, but he thrived. He found his own crowd of friends (often other geeky misfits) , he benefited from being pushed academically and socially and he developed a thick skin and sharp wits.
I think more people should be encouraged in breaking down the barriers of these old institutions rather than reinforcing the idea that there are right and wrong people of certain educations.

BirdinaHedge · 05/10/2022 13:19

I understand where you're coming from. But coming from you, it's going to sound a combination of patronising, and sour grapes.

Leave it. They'll find out (at least they can't be beaten any more).

AloysiusBear · 05/10/2022 13:17

Most of the major public schools have robust anti-bullying policies, and most of them accept children on bursaries. At my grandson's public school, there are children from all kinds of backgrounds, so I think your idea that your nephews wouldn't 'fit in' is rather dated.

This. It just sounds snobby to me, a thinly veiled way to close off certain prestigious schools to anyone not from the "right" background.

AloysiusBear · 05/10/2022 13:16

There are lovely schools in abundance that would be perfect for them.

Honestly, the (unconscious) implication here is that her boys aren't good enough for this school.

Not robust enough, not rich enough, not sporty enough.

Schools welcome and benefit from variety. Maybe all those rich robust boys will gain from all having to be tolerant of different personality types.

Its really none if your business. The fact that you think your own attendance at Cheltenham (vs your SiLs academic background) is in any way relevant to your ability to judge a school speaks volumes.

VestaTilley · 05/10/2022 13:15

I think you should have either worded it gently or not said anything. Have they passed the entrance exams? If so, they’ll presumably be able to keep up academically.

The time to speak up is if/when you see that DN’s are very unhappy. They might love it and thrive.

HappyHamsters · 05/10/2022 13:13

Which school is it, some dont accept day pupils. Like pp said entrance will be at 13.

AloysiusBear · 05/10/2022 13:11

She is choosing the wrong school for the personality of her children

And you know this how? A good school will cater for a range of personality types. They won't have 600 or so identical type kids.

Too much emphasise is made on matching of schools to personality. Its an important skill and character trait to learn to get along in different environments. No school should be so rigid that an NT child can't settle in their.

Oh and you absolutely do sound like you want her to "stay in her lane". Your own attendance at one school many years agp does not make you more qualified to judge a public school now, or the personalities of her boys.

Dorisbonson · 05/10/2022 13:07

My son is sweet, highly academic, very sporty but he is also quiet and lacks confidences. He could get into Eton or any grand school without issue. However as you say about your nephews he wouldn't be a good fit and probably wouldn't enjoy it.

I have friends whose parents sent them to Eton and it was a major mistake because it didn't suit them at all.

I am on the same page as you and think it is right to pick the schools sensitively based around fit rather than desire to have a child at a grand school.

chesirecat99 · 05/10/2022 13:06

to jump straight from a cosy village state primary to a major public school

None of the major public schools where the "vast majority of the boys board" start at 11, they start at 13, so they won't be going straight from primary school, will they@Izwizi?

Avidreader69 · 05/10/2022 13:00

Most of the major public schools have robust anti-bullying policies, and most of them accept children on bursaries. At my grandson's public school, there are children from all kinds of backgrounds, so I think your idea that your nephews wouldn't 'fit in' is rather dated.
In any case, the boys would have to pass the entrance exams, it's not just a case of the parents deciding where to send them.

ChnandlerBong · 05/10/2022 12:59

It's not really you're business though and surely your knowledge of the school is 20 years out of date?

Plus surely no one can go straight from a village primary to a big public school -where will they go for year 7 and year8?

BBBBMushroom · 05/10/2022 12:58

DH went to a major public school, he was very sporty and ended up in the rowing team for his Cambridge college his family were wealthy but his best mates Dad was CEO of a bank and lived in a Manor House with full staff DH family
had a big house with a housekeeper.

There will always be someone richer but I know the kind of school you mean because DH has talked about it in detail. DH said he would never send DS to a boys school. Our local mixed independent school is crap so we sent DS to the local comp because the closest decent mixed independent school is miles away. DH has always thought that he was on the back foot because he hadn’t mixed with girls much when at school.

LuciaPopp · 05/10/2022 12:52

I think you should massively back off. It's one thing to talk about your experience of a school (and it's not clear to me in what capacity you have this experience- if it's as a schoolgirl knowing boys 20 years ago, it's probably not very helpful), quite another to do so in terms that make other people "hit the roof". Why should you be the person to determine where your nephews should go to school rather than their own parents?

Plus, if you phrased it in terms of "I went to a major public school and therefore know more about it than a mere grammar school girl" I imagine you came across pretty poorly.

latetothefisting · 05/10/2022 12:51

It depends did she specifically ask you for your advice? In which case she can't complain. Or did she say she was thinking of x school and you jumped in?

The way you've worded the advice is that the boys are not the right fit for the school. She could have taken it as criticism of her kids. Might it have gone better if you'd instead criticised the school e.g. "oh really? I haven't heard great things about that school, my experience is that kids who don't board and can't afford to go on all the school trips are excluded. Plus you know it really focuses on sport - x is so good at music it would be a pity if he missed out."

But really its not your business. You've provided your view, she's the parent, it's her decision. Besides which the kids might not get in. If they do get in they might thrive - lots of kids who dont have all the private or grammar option you/she has go to a "lovely gentle primary" and then have to sink or swim in a giant, rough comp. If they really struggle they can always transfer to a different school.

Palmfrond · 05/10/2022 12:43

I went to a major public school, a long time ago now. I’m sure many many things are radically different, but coming from a middle middle class background (parents did not pay any where near full whack), yes the discrepancy between me and the fabulously rich, entitled and often either braying or snide wankers I went to school with was difficult. I did quite well socially during term time, but during the holidays they were partying together in Chelsea, Chamonix, the Bahamas, I was shopping for new undies with my mum in Brixton arcade.

BUT DONT WORRY IM NOT BITTER!! ha ha

Whatacarryonthisis · 05/10/2022 12:36

Doesn’t matter what we all think

You’ve said your piece of your sil doesn’t want to listen then that’s up to her

she can always move them at a later date if she realises her error

Anothermother3 · 05/10/2022 12:34

Your motives sound correct and your arguments are thoughtful and valid. Finding a school where a child thrives vs just about survives would be the obvious choice. Hopefully she will see your motives when she’s calmed down.

HappyHamsters · 05/10/2022 12:34

What reason does she have for wanting her boys to go to that school has she taken them for a visit, are they down for their prep school.

HappyHamsters · 05/10/2022 12:32

Its obviously better if they go to a school that offers their interests but they will need to pass exams for boarding and grammar schools and may not be offered a place in either. How old are they now. What does their dad and the boys, think is best.

iloveruby · 05/10/2022 12:30

Newusernameaug · 05/10/2022 12:28

This has zero to do with you - this is just your opinion and no one asked for it. In future I’d mind my own business!

This isn't a random person the OP met in the supermarket - this is her family, who presumably shared their plans with her.

What should the OP do, just say nothing and let her nephews suffer the consequences?

Swipe left for the next trending thread