Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Major Public Schools

115 replies

Izwizi · 05/10/2022 12:16

I myself went to a major public school (Cheltenham Ladies) and haven’t chosen to do the same for my own children for various reasons.

my SIL, who can be a bit highly strung, has two sons who currently attend a nice state primary. She has announced that she’ll be sending them to the (big name) boys public school about 15 minutes away. I have. A lot of experience with this school and I do not think her boys are the right fit. They are lovely boys who I adore but I don’t think they’d cope there. My SIL has hit the roof. IL’s tend to pander to her a bit and Have suggested to her that I was unreasonable in my advice.

DH and IL’s attended a good Grammar school and I just don’t think she appreciates how robust they’ll need to be to jump straight from a cosy village state primary to a major public school. Happy to be corrected if people feel I’m being unreasonable?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
mathanxiety · 05/10/2022 22:46

"What do you think?"
...is not an invitation to say what you think.

It's an invitation to make positive noises, non committal but still positive noises if you think it's a bad idea.

Above all, when someone's children are part of the topic, it's an invitation to be tactful while making your very general and vaguely positive remarks which focus on the qualities of the school, not the children.

notdaddycool · 05/10/2022 22:12

Do they not need two years at Oreo from 11-13, that might smooth the way.

Izwizi · 05/10/2022 22:10

latetothefisting · 05/10/2022 19:22

You still haven't clarified OP - did SIL generally "share her intention?" to the family (your 16:08 post) or "ask [your] opinion" specifically (your 12:08 post).
Very different things!

She explicitly asked for my opinion. To be clear: “what do you think?”. Well I told her what I thought.

OP posts:
XelaM · 05/10/2022 21:00

If she wants them to have a chance she needs to look up the entrance pre-fest now. I'm pretty sure they test in Year 6. I think other posters have mentioned this as well. They might never pass the assessment. Then the decision would have been made for them. If they pass both the assessments and the interview, they might surprise you and really fit in.

snowleveret · 05/10/2022 20:46

Both school and university, although the wealth at university was probably even more extreme. The school was very academic and you were much more likely not to fit in properly if you weren't up to their high academic standards.

Thepeopleversuswork · 05/10/2022 20:44

I can understand your reservations and they are not without foundation: a close friend of mine (from a normal middle class background) went to one of these schools and was absolutely miserable, failed her A Levels and had a breakdown. Your SIL should give this very serious thought and it’s not clear she has.

But there is also a whiff of “stay in your lane” in your post. It’s hard to know if your motives are genuine or not. I do think you need to tread very carefully in order not to create the impression that you think she’s got ahead of herself.

You can’t know for sure how these boys will cope (or not) and as others have said, the admissions process may well weed them out. But surely better for them to try (and possibly fail) than have their chances arbitrarily ruled out because someone who isn’t totally unbiased deemed them not to be quite comme il faut.

I would stay out of it. Describe your experiences there is it’s relevant but don’t try to sway her.

Palmfrond · 05/10/2022 20:24

snowleveret · 05/10/2022 19:32

I also studied alongside extremely wealthy students at a very prestigious academic establishment. My background was more modest but I was one of the most academic and that carried much more kudos than wealth.

Let me guess, this was a university, not a school for children, which is what this topic is about?

snowleveret · 05/10/2022 19:32

I also studied alongside extremely wealthy students at a very prestigious academic establishment. My background was more modest but I was one of the most academic and that carried much more kudos than wealth.

snowleveret · 05/10/2022 19:22

Surely the parents and the school itself are the best judges of whether the school is a good fit for the boys. OP your arrogance and lack of manners are really not a good advert for Cheltenham, for all its exclusivity.

latetothefisting · 05/10/2022 19:22

You still haven't clarified OP - did SIL generally "share her intention?" to the family (your 16:08 post) or "ask [your] opinion" specifically (your 12:08 post).
Very different things!

Blaggertyjibbet · 05/10/2022 19:05

AloysiusBear · 05/10/2022 13:16

There are lovely schools in abundance that would be perfect for them.

Honestly, the (unconscious) implication here is that her boys aren't good enough for this school.

Not robust enough, not rich enough, not sporty enough.

Schools welcome and benefit from variety. Maybe all those rich robust boys will gain from all having to be tolerant of different personality types.

Its really none if your business. The fact that you think your own attendance at Cheltenham (vs your SiLs academic background) is in any way relevant to your ability to judge a school speaks volumes.

Yes, this.

RIPQueen · 05/10/2022 18:53

VladmirsPoutine · 05/10/2022 18:49

Can someone describe to me what sort of boys would fit with the idea of a grand public school? Like essentially mini Boris Johnsons and David Camerons? Or is it more a case that some of the boys spend half term surfing in Hawaii whilst others are lucky to go to Skegness?

My brothers were children of divorce in a fairly standard house and sometimes no summer holidays. Some of their friends holiday’d in Mustique and had country estates. Real mixture!

VladmirsPoutine · 05/10/2022 18:49

Can someone describe to me what sort of boys would fit with the idea of a grand public school? Like essentially mini Boris Johnsons and David Camerons? Or is it more a case that some of the boys spend half term surfing in Hawaii whilst others are lucky to go to Skegness?

surreygirl1987 · 05/10/2022 18:41

Yes they are bright but they will be eaten alive there.

You know that for a fact, do you? As someone who has spent many years teaching in the independent sector, you honestly don't know. It is arrogant to assume that she hasn't done her research and I'm sure if she wanted advice from you she'd have asked for it. I imagine she feels patronised. And just because you went to CLC, it does not make you an expert on major public schools...!

XelaM · 05/10/2022 18:40

RIPQueen · 05/10/2022 18:30

I attended a “major” public school and I don’t really understand how you can have such a different opinion/experience of it to me! Certainly can’t understand you advising your SIL like this. I don’t think the social fit is as important as the academic fit tbh, because social disparity is, for the most part, a good thing. Having a child who can’t keep up and feels stupid isn’t, but that’s what common entrance should determine (and why common entrance tutors should be discouraged). There will be imbalances re money/power at the local comp too - are you saying that works for you because it’s in your nephews favour, as those who have “more”?

This.

My brother attended school with kids who had extreme wealth and one of his school friends is from a European Royal family. No one cared that my parents were very ordinary working middle class and he's still close friends with his mates from school now. Academic fit is what is really valued at those schools.

urgen · 05/10/2022 18:37

Has anyone mentioned the cost and can SIL afford this? Two children at a 'public' school and boarding is going to be hitting £90k per year. Most boarding schools have some day pupils but the fees are not much lower and as most other pupils would be boarding what would happen if the boys wanted to board?

Unless they are going to go for help with fees you cannot just sit the exam with no guidance, no preparation and expect to be welcomed with open arms.

I think this isnt well planned at all and seems a bit bonkers. My DS did go to one of the big 'public' schools and he was very well prepared for the Common Entrance and had interview practise. The boys took a coach arranged by his prep school to visit the school both pre and post exams.

RIPQueen · 05/10/2022 18:30

I attended a “major” public school and I don’t really understand how you can have such a different opinion/experience of it to me! Certainly can’t understand you advising your SIL like this. I don’t think the social fit is as important as the academic fit tbh, because social disparity is, for the most part, a good thing. Having a child who can’t keep up and feels stupid isn’t, but that’s what common entrance should determine (and why common entrance tutors should be discouraged). There will be imbalances re money/power at the local comp too - are you saying that works for you because it’s in your nephews favour, as those who have “more”?

mathanxiety · 05/10/2022 18:04

I think you need to read @latetothefisting's post again.

You also need to reconsider who exactly it is who instigated the 'drama' that has occurred. Your SIL asked a question, but it would appear that you opened your mouth and shoved your foot straight in, and intend to keep on doing so.

If I were you, I would tell your SIL you're sorry for being tactless and something of an overweening snob.

I would also leave your brother and his wife and their children to forge their own path.

Iusyje · 05/10/2022 17:42

Littlebird43 · 05/10/2022 13:22

My DH went from a single entry village school (plus single parent, low income family) to a large public school, funded by a scholarship.
Sure he didn't get to go skiing and the other boys laughed at his mum's car, but he thrived. He found his own crowd of friends (often other geeky misfits) , he benefited from being pushed academically and socially and he developed a thick skin and sharp wits.
I think more people should be encouraged in breaking down the barriers of these old institutions rather than reinforcing the idea that there are right and wrong people of certain educations.

This and also, the OP sounds as if she's saying she loves her nephews more than their mother loves them. Which ofcourse is rubbish. We all do what we "think" is best for our children. Sometimes we get it right and other times not.

FelicityFlops · 05/10/2022 17:08

To be brutally honest, if you are a parent today (not the same as when my siblings and I were growing up) you should really look at your child and how their personality fits with the school you are considering.
You should also bear in mind how committed you are to supporting this, not just from a cash point of view, but do you, as parents, mirror the education you expect your children to receive? For example, do you read books, take part or encourage sport, go to the cinema, theatre, concerts, ballet or opera regularly? Or even have an interest?
If you just want to abnegate your responsibility as a parent, then boarding school is an option, if not, there are other ways to go about it.
Should add that I went to a very "old" girls' school from the age of 4.5. My sister, who is a lot younger than I am, joined post 11+ and our brother got totally, educationally (thanks to the State system) messed around, but ended up at a minor public school.

AloysiusBear · 05/10/2022 17:05

Also if the reason she's targeting this school is because its prestigious, that's completely fine and logical.

There's a huge social capital gained from attending these schools, plain and simple. Dh attended one and now works in an industry absolutely dominated by their alumni and the network effect is massive.

AloysiusBear · 05/10/2022 17:00

The thing is OP, your opinion and desire to give it is stemming from a fundamental position of believing you know more about this than her.

That belief is arrogant. Sorry. She is an adult and the parent to her own children, she is perfectly competent to do her own research and form a view, she doesn't need your input.

Andante57 · 05/10/2022 16:58

Op I’ve only skimmed the thread but presumably this school has common entrance and probably a pre-test.
Does your nephew’s present school prepare children for common entrance? Or are they being tutored for it?

AloysiusBear · 05/10/2022 16:57

I don't understand why some people find is so difficult to grasp that you need to match the school to the child...

Because kids are extremely adaptable!

Mouriv · 05/10/2022 16:56

Isn't this all just hypothetical at the moment?

Most public schools conduct their entrance process in Year 6 (with pretests and interviews) or Year 7 (with exams and interviews). The earliest they would be offered conditional places after interview is Feb-March of Year 6, so at this point your nephews can't possibly even have places at the school in question.

In my (personal) experience, these schools are very good at spotting the sort of child that will be suited to a school. If your nephews were to be offered places, I'd assume that the school considered they would be a good fit. If they're not offered places, the whole argument is redundant.

If your SIL is serious about aiming for a particular public school, a prep school that sends boys there regularly would be more useful for Year 7 and 8 than the local state secondary school.