Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

In thinking DD is selfish for TTC

211 replies

Wheninrome62 · 05/10/2022 11:16

DD has told me that she and her fiancé have decided to initiate the process of having a baby. She already knows she cannot conceive naturally due to a health issue, so this involves IVF treatment and potentially a lot of money and disappointment. It is news to me, as DD had always previously said she categorically didn’t want any children and I fully supported this, as they have a lifestyle that doesn’t lend itself to parenthood (both professionals living in the city with pressured jobs and have only recently bought a large old Georgian flat which needs work AND is on the 3rd floor with no lift!), not to mention the fact that DD is very highly strung and I’m not sure she’d cope well with motherhood, particularly as they wouldn’t have any family living nearby to help and they are set on remaining in the city in the unsuitable flat.

DD is only 28 yet her rationale is that time is running out and she doesn’t want to regret it later down the line if she doesn’t go for it. I don’t think the gravity of such a decision has really been thought out, the fact their lives will be changed forever and professionally her hard earned career will suffer. I also can’t imagine how anyone would actively choose to bring another life into this world at the moment, given how depressing things our financially and environmentally. I dread to think how much worse the world will be in 20 years from now too.

I love DD dearly and only want what’s best for her. If I don’t at least try to talk her out of it I’m not sure I’ll ever be able to forgive myself, but at the same time I value our closeness and don’t want to ruin it. Any advice greatly appreciated

OP posts:
mam0918 · 05/10/2022 12:26

reigatecastle · 05/10/2022 12:11

Easy for people to tell you to mind your own business.

Once she has a baby she'll expect you to help with childcare.

And then you'll be the miserable granny for not agreeing to help and upend your life and fulfil your grandmotherly duties.

According to OP they live away from family in the city alone and no most people I know do not greatly have grandparents helping out (in fact a lot of my friends parents are either dead or sick/disabled).

The assumption that they would demand anything is just that an unfounded assumption that doesnt even fit in with what OP wrote.

shreddednips · 05/10/2022 12:26

You mustn't say anything OP! I can't understand why you would think that a) you get a say or b) your daughter wouldn't cope with motherhood. She sounds much more together than I was when I had my first and mine turned out alright.

Also, it's impossible to predict how people will be as parents. Bear in mind that she may not be 'highly strung' (!!!) in every aspect of her life. I don't mean to be harsh but you may well not see the best of her if you feel you're entitled to stick your beak in on deeply personal life choices, that would be enough to make most people feel highly strung.

Laurdo · 05/10/2022 12:26

Wheninrome62 · 05/10/2022 11:38

I’m disappointed that I’m being criticised for posting my honest views anonymously to seek advice. Of course I would never relay my feelings to DD in the same way I have worded them in this post. DD and I have a good relationship and I’m generally very supportive

You opened yourself up to criticism by posting in this section. I don't think there's any problem with constructive criticism and it can help us see things from another perspective ans grow as a person.

I learned the hard way never to start a thread in AIBU. Of course not everyone is going to agree with you and have every right to tell you YBU but loads of people on this section think it's perfectly fine to name call and be downright rude to a complete stranger.

shiningstar2 · 05/10/2022 12:24

There is nothing wrong with a woman of 28 wanting a child and she and her partner are the only people who should be involved in such a decision. Many people have children in accommodation which is not the ideal for kids ...especially in the city with prices the way they are. Some move out to the suburbs later to something more comfortable using profit from the original flat ...some don't. In any event their decision. If she has a well paid career she and partner are better placed to fund childcare so she and he can continue their careers if that is their wish ...again their decision.You seem over invested in their decisions ...especially as you are not in a position to provide childcare so any decision doesn't impact on your daily life. Be as supportive as you can. If you really can't support in any way best to say nothing.

PrincessScarlett · 05/10/2022 12:23

Wow. This is a heartbreaking post. In the kindest way, you are projecting your feelings/experience as a mother onto your daughter. You sound very critical and negative towards your daughter. And to already say you won't be offering childcare is very harsh and sounds uncaring. How do you know they will even want you to look after their child?

I know you won't say any of what you've said here to your daughter and that you wanted to just vent anonymously here but please be excited and supportive to her.

Meili04 · 05/10/2022 12:23

You don't get a say she's 28 support her. She's actually being very wise doing it at this age rather than waiting until her late 30s early 40s as lots do.

SnowBall86 · 05/10/2022 12:23

I would’ve rather ate my own poop than told my mum I was trying to conceive. Even though we always had close and good relationship. In fact, I told her all my life I don’t want any children at all (and then I told her I don’t want second one ever) and then went on to have 2 children. I’m what a lot of people would describe highly stung, prior to kids I used to live in a flat in London, indulge in expensive get always, designer clothes and high cuisine restaurants. Was never maternal really. … and I adore my kids! My life is absolutely pointless without them. They made me much better person. Even though we now moved out of London and struggle with one salary I wouldn’t change them for the world.

Splutteramo · 05/10/2022 12:22

Wow. Just wow.
it sounds as if she’s being sensible, if she has fertility issues then she should absolutely get in with it.
one of your issues is that they both have good jobs? Hopefully your DD professional job comes with decent maternity pay and her DPs. job should help cover the bills. Oh, and lots of kids grow up in cities…

Lillygolightly · 05/10/2022 12:22

At 28, good job, stable relationship, owns own home and with known fertility issues…I would say she is sensible to start now if this is what she feels she wants for her future.

What your perceive to be her struggles with motherhood are to do with your perception of how you see her as your daughter, and does not mean that she won’t make an excellent job of motherhood.

Who are any of us to know what kind of mother we will be before we are one, I am certainly not the mother I envisaged before I actually became one myself.

As for bringing a baby amid the current plights of the world, there will always be reasons not to have a baby, in fact there are always many more reasons against than for, and if we all traded on waiting until the conditions were perfect would never have babies at all!!

Your DD sees her circumstances and timing as perfect or as perfect as they are going to get for her. For the sake of your relationship with her and any future grandchildren I suggest you keep your opinions to yourself and support her. It’s not like she’s some wayward teen, with no job and a flakey boyfriend, she’s a competent adult with a job, a partner and a home. As a parent myself I would be happy for any child of mine to start a family in those circumstances.

mam0918 · 05/10/2022 12:19

You are being MASSIVELY unreasonable... what on earth makes you think your opinion matters at all?

Also you should seek help for your irrational views of the world instead of dumping your anxiety on your daughter... the world is better than ever for bringing children into, I mean 100 years ago an infected paper cut could easily mean death and winter smog litrally killed hundred, we live in the age of progression and its only getting better.

DisforDarkChocolate · 05/10/2022 12:18

Why are you treating you adult daughter as if she is an idiot?

Just keep out of it, or better still offer some support.

AryaStarkWolf · 05/10/2022 12:16

reigatecastle · 05/10/2022 12:11

Easy for people to tell you to mind your own business.

Once she has a baby she'll expect you to help with childcare.

And then you'll be the miserable granny for not agreeing to help and upend your life and fulfil your grandmotherly duties.

The OP has already said she won't expect that as they live far away from each other......

CheezePleeze · 05/10/2022 12:16

Wind your neck in OP

It wouldn't surprise me if your daughter ends up on MN at some time in the future, asking if she should go NC with her controlling mother.

imsureineverdo · 05/10/2022 12:15

"DD is very highly strung and I’m not sure she’d cope well with motherhood"

Wow. That's unkind.

tenbob · 05/10/2022 12:15

whynotwhatknot · 05/10/2022 12:02

You wont be allowed to say it here but i agree with you op-my dsis has never wanted children and hasnt got he right personality very immature -if she said she wanted a child now id talk her out of it

But her DD isnt ‘immature’

she has a high flying job, her own flat and is planning a wedding.
Nothing about that screams ‘immature’ to be

Btw, My dad would describe me as ‘highly strung’, which is just another way of saying ‘won’t put up with his bullying bullshit’ and ‘won’t roll over and do what he demands’

Given the rest of OPs post and description of her DD, I’m taking the ‘highly strung’ label with a pinch of salt, and wonder if it says more about OPs expectations than DDs personality

CallMeNutribullet · 05/10/2022 12:15

I wonder why she's highly strung? I'm betting you've expressed doubts about her capability since she was a child

pewtypie · 05/10/2022 12:14

Wheninrome62 · 05/10/2022 11:38

I’m disappointed that I’m being criticised for posting my honest views anonymously to seek advice. Of course I would never relay my feelings to DD in the same way I have worded them in this post. DD and I have a good relationship and I’m generally very supportive

I think you may need counselling to try and understand why you want to sabotage your own daughter and why you feel you have the right to interfere in their adult lives.

MrKlaw · 05/10/2022 12:13

voted YABU but has a 'depends' in it. If you genuinely think she's jumping without thinking it through then talk to her.

But ultimately not many of your points make a difference other than that one

  • if they're both professionals then they might financially be in a good position for one to take maternity leave and/or get a nanny/nursery
  • We lived in a 3rd floor flat with a baby for a couple of years it was fine - babies are small, get a lightweight buggy, no problem. If they can't make it work, they'll move
  • world is depressing - blimey thats their call not yours
Octomore · 05/10/2022 12:13

TheWolves · 05/10/2022 11:18

Eh? Is this for real? Because it sounds like something a dickhead would write.

So true! 😂

thenewduchessoflapland · 05/10/2022 12:13

Well it's just as well you live miles away;you have an excuse to visit once every 6 months and send cards and presents in the post then.

My friend has a highly strung mother like you who a opinion on everything in her life,criticises everything she does and make it quite obvious she doesn't really like being a grandmother and even more so a great grandmother now.

My friend is deeply hurt by her mums behaviour.My friend has also made a good mum and her circumstances were less than ideal when her eldest was born but she's managed well enough and her now eldest is a fully fledged adult and a credit to his mum.

Laurdo · 05/10/2022 12:13

Ultimately it's not your decision to make but I can understand your concerns. As her mother you only want the best for her.

I think it's fine to talk things through with her but this needs to be done in a supportive way without criticising her. Being a parent is hard and if she decided that's what she wants then she'll need and want her mothers support.

I was engaged to a guy years ago. When I told my mum she basically told me it was the worst mistake I'd ever make and listed several reasons why my then fiancé would make a terrible husband. All this did was push me away. Ultimately she was right about him and I discovered this for myself thankfully before any wedding. But really she went about things the wrong way.

I think some of the things in your post, although not ideal aren't end of the world. Plenty of people raise kids in the city or in flats. Plenty of professionals have kids and manage to maintain their careers. If they're both professionals they're likely more financially stable than a lot of families. If people waited for everything to be perfect before starting a family no one ever world.

MassiveSalad22 · 05/10/2022 12:13

None of your business and ‘her life will be changed forever’ - why is that automatically a bad thing? Very narrow minded.

Cornishclio · 05/10/2022 12:11

I don't think you should say anything. She is an adult, has a supportive partner and a good job and a home. It's their decision and quite frankly your opinions on whether new lives should be brought into the world could apply at any time including presumably the 90s when you had her. Just support her as a mother should.

reigatecastle · 05/10/2022 12:11

Easy for people to tell you to mind your own business.

Once she has a baby she'll expect you to help with childcare.

And then you'll be the miserable granny for not agreeing to help and upend your life and fulfil your grandmotherly duties.

Caiti19 · 05/10/2022 12:11

I get that you are anxious and worried for your daughter, and you feel she shouldn't rock the boat when they are both doing well.

Thing is though, you obviously did get to experience Motherhood, so you can't really lecture her that she shouldn't? I don't think you are a horrible Mother. I do think you are very anxious about the world, and should invest some energy into calming your mind down so you can embrace their decision and be as supportive as possible.