Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Grandparents helping

110 replies

Sparklybutold · 05/10/2022 00:29

In a nutshell - I have no family to help and my husbands side is pretty lacking, although his mum is trying and will have our daughter roughly once a week for a few hours. I was sat next to a grandma today who spoke at length about how her granddaughter lives at her house during the week as her mum (grandmas daughter) and dad work. She also cares for her daughters horses and has taken in her dog depaite the grandma advising her daughter to not get one owing to her work schedule. I was sat there feeling angry, shocked and slightly envious of how much support this family got in terms of childcare and how lucky this mum was to have such a selfless grandma. I couldn't help but think the daughter was incredibly selfish to expect and accept so much help from her mum. In the same conversation the grandma spoke about how she wished things were different and she would love her own time, but she's committed to her daughter. I just left aghast. I've had to make really hard decisions based on having very little family support so to hear this was incredibly difficult and shocking.

So aibu or not?

OP posts:
Gonnabegrandma · 05/10/2022 01:15

Our dgd lives with us with her parents and some of their siblings ! I provide care every day and it seems natural to me to help out at anytime . My friends think it’s mad !! Her parents are quite happy. Our parents didn’t help out that much when our children were growing up and I suffered horrifically from pnd so I was determined that our dil would have all the support she wanted , but each family is different and I’ve never had to juggle working with caring for my dc or dgd

meateatingveggie · 05/10/2022 01:03

@MadMadMadamMim I agree.

The idea that grandparents are lacking if they don't give up great chunks of their time is awful.

HoppingPavlova · 05/10/2022 01:03

Tbh I’m always gobsmacked when I hear people have parents/family living nearby to even be logistically feasible to assist. As with ourselves, most people I know have parents living in other countries, States or long distances away. How do people have situations where abundant/diverse/specialised work opportunities exist for both themselves and their spouse/partner around the corner from both sets of parents????

Thegreenballoon · 05/10/2022 01:02

I wouldn’t want that kind of “help”. My parents babysit occasionally and they’d be round like a shot in a crisis, otherwise they stick to grandparenting not childcare, which works well for all of us. I would absolutely hate to have my children live with my parents during the week (not that they’d ever agree to that, nor would my children be happy) - that’s not helping that’s practically being another parent. No thanks.

hellosunshineagainxxx · 05/10/2022 01:00

You have tons of help compared to me. My parents have never had my son and my husbands mum has had him once, on our wedding day 😂 count yourself lucky

MadMadMadamMim · 05/10/2022 00:58

I only every see this on Mumsnet. I'm obviously a different generations (I'm late 50s). I worked part time when children were small and then went back full time because I needed the money.

It would never have occurred to me that my parents should somehow chip in to help out with my kids. They worked too. The liked to see the GC if we dropped in for a coffe, and occasionally we arranged meals together, but I didn't expect 'help'. Both my parents were still working full time when I had DCs in my 20s.

I was left a single mum too - and you just get on and deal with it, mentally accepting that this is now your responsibility. I'm bemused by modern families that seem to think help is someone due to be offered by others. One of the things about becoming an adult and parent is that you weigh up whether you are prepared to sacrifice a lot of time/money and stress to starting and raising a family. Maybe I didn't have a Pollyanna relationship with my granny - but both my mother and my gran would have made sharp comments on my parenting and offered outdated, unwanted advice had they been involved in child care. I wouldn't have wanted to revert to the 'child' status whilst they took over my kids.

Sparklybutold · 05/10/2022 00:53

I think what it triggers in me is the fact I have zilch on my side. So to hear about this other woman's support structure was just mind boggling! Especially considering the fact serum looks after the horses and now her dog!

My DH mum is definitely trying, just a shame DH dad is unpleasant most of the time.

OP posts:
DoodlePug · 05/10/2022 00:43

All families are different.

Both me and DH spent a lot of time with grandparents when we were young - after school, lunchtimes, over nights and short holidays. My sis usually went on foreign holidays with my nan.

My parents have practically brought up my sis'sDC (single mum), providing wrap around care plus every school holiday, taking them abroad for weeks at a time .

We live near the in laws and whilst retired and obviously loving sending time with DS they were also very clear that they weren't 'support' as such. One sleep over a month (2pm-10am) plus an hour after school once a week and that's it. We needed them to do 10am-10am once for best friends wedding and they really weren't happy, I must stress that my DS is lovely!

It's fine really, i didn't expect anyone else to raise my child but given how much help they had from their own parents I find it very strange.

I do think it's unreasonable to expect the grandparents to alter their retirement plans or even give up work to care for their child, which some people seem to do.

LightDrizzle · 05/10/2022 00:43

How old is your daughter?

Having your MIL take her for a few hours roughly once a week is a big help in my book. I know some GPs provide loads of childcare but I think it’s still a minority and I wouldn’t expect it. It’s lovely for all if it’s what everyone wants but I have felt sorry for older colleagues in the past who were struggling with the amount of care they provided.

My only living grandma lived a few hours away and it was the same with my children and for my childhood best friend so I suppose it’s what I’m used to. My daughters had lovely relationships with their three surviving grandparents but they never provided regular childcare.

HeddaGarbled · 05/10/2022 00:40

I think you are really. The grandma was having a moan, as people sometimes do. You don’t know what’s really going on in her family.

What is it you want help with? A few hours childcare every week from your mother in law sounds pretty good to me.