Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Grandparents helping

110 replies

Sparklybutold · 05/10/2022 00:29

In a nutshell - I have no family to help and my husbands side is pretty lacking, although his mum is trying and will have our daughter roughly once a week for a few hours. I was sat next to a grandma today who spoke at length about how her granddaughter lives at her house during the week as her mum (grandmas daughter) and dad work. She also cares for her daughters horses and has taken in her dog depaite the grandma advising her daughter to not get one owing to her work schedule. I was sat there feeling angry, shocked and slightly envious of how much support this family got in terms of childcare and how lucky this mum was to have such a selfless grandma. I couldn't help but think the daughter was incredibly selfish to expect and accept so much help from her mum. In the same conversation the grandma spoke about how she wished things were different and she would love her own time, but she's committed to her daughter. I just left aghast. I've had to make really hard decisions based on having very little family support so to hear this was incredibly difficult and shocking.

So aibu or not?

OP posts:
UnagiForLife · 05/10/2022 08:02

Same here, both sets of grandmothers (granddads not an option unfortunately) weren’t happy to look after our DC as babies and toddlers so we did that bit all on our own. I didn’t go back to work until they were school age. We didn’t go out on our own together for seven years.

Now they’re school age my mum is willing to look after them on her own under very special circumstances but she worries herself silly about it so we’ve only asked her twice.

The school run is about 50/50 split grandparents and parents picking up. DCs friends have regular ‘sleepovers’ and days out with their grandparents, even aunts and uncles, which is just not an option for us.

I think it’s the natural way of things that grandparents are very involved in their children and grandchildren’s lives as they grow old and have more time on their hands. It takes a village and all that. I hope to be a helpful grandparent if I get the chance.

I think those who do help have a very special bond with their grandchildren, keep fit and active for longer and are ‘down with the kids’ which is great mentally! If you’ve got that help, enjoy it but don’t take advantage of it and realise how lucky you are.

Tomorrowisalatterday · 05/10/2022 07:58

What does piss me off is those people (and I've seen some on this thread) who chip in with 'I hardly have any support either, only picking the GC up from a school and giving them dinner once a week and a sleepover every other weekend, it's so hard', who don't seem to be at all grateful for the help they do get

Totally. And the OP is in this category too.

My SIL bangs on about how she only gets 6 weekends away a year without her kids even though she knows that I haven't even had one.

jannier · 05/10/2022 07:54

MadMadMadamMim · 05/10/2022 00:58

I only every see this on Mumsnet. I'm obviously a different generations (I'm late 50s). I worked part time when children were small and then went back full time because I needed the money.

It would never have occurred to me that my parents should somehow chip in to help out with my kids. They worked too. The liked to see the GC if we dropped in for a coffe, and occasionally we arranged meals together, but I didn't expect 'help'. Both my parents were still working full time when I had DCs in my 20s.

I was left a single mum too - and you just get on and deal with it, mentally accepting that this is now your responsibility. I'm bemused by modern families that seem to think help is someone due to be offered by others. One of the things about becoming an adult and parent is that you weigh up whether you are prepared to sacrifice a lot of time/money and stress to starting and raising a family. Maybe I didn't have a Pollyanna relationship with my granny - but both my mother and my gran would have made sharp comments on my parenting and offered outdated, unwanted advice had they been involved in child care. I wouldn't have wanted to revert to the 'child' status whilst they took over my kids.

Totally agree.
At one time people wanted to be independent adults now a lot is about getting me time etc.
I always thought having children was being grateful if you got the odd hour off but basically you choose to have a family so regular nights out, weekends only happen with children including weddings and paid childcare is normal any extra is lucky.
We seem to have a generation that often feel they are owed by their parents rather than now we are adults its our turn to be giving back. It's like grandparents have no right to a life and we want them to carry on being the parent until they drop.

RealBecca · 05/10/2022 07:49

Our family are great and happy to babysit so we feel lucky but we only take it up once every few months when we have something we need to do. DD goes to school and we work full time so we feel like we hardly see her anyway. So a few hours a week of not being switched on for work or parenting seems like a bit of a luxury! Perhaps the first daughter is unstable and the grandmother says she works full time as a bit of a cover. And what else can grandma really do? Leave the kid? Let the dog bark alone for hours? Report her to animal and child services?

MrsBennetsPoorNerves · 05/10/2022 07:49

YABVU to say that you get "zilch" and to imply that your DH's family are "lacking" when yoour MIL offers childcare for a few hours roughly once a week. That is actually quite a lot of airport, and certainly not nothing. How much do you expect?

It's weird because you have reacted angrily with regard to this other woman regarding the level of support that she gets, but equally, you don't seem to feel that the help you get is enough. What do you think would be an acceptable level of grandparent input?

You sound quite entitled to me, tbh. Also, I find it a bit weird to be envious of a situation in which children are barely even living with their parents...I would hate that arrangement and can't imagine that people would put it in place merely for convenience, I would assume that something else is probably going on.

Why not just focus on your own stuff and be grateful that your MIL is kind enough to help out as much as she does. Lots of people get a lot less support than you do.

hiredandsqueak · 05/10/2022 07:41

mountainsunsets · 05/10/2022 07:39

Everyone is different, all families are different.

We don't have children but my FIL provides "doggy daycare" for our dog while we work. He volunteered, refuses to take money and they have a wonderful relationship. We've said multiple times that we'll pay for daycare if he finds it too much/ to give him a break and he was genuinely offended at the idea Grin

Yes, we're incredibly lucky but he also volunteered to help and we never asked or pushed it on him.

Now I'd be very happy to provide doggy daycare free of charge every day as well. All the joys of a dog without the responsibility or expense sounds great Grin

Ponoka7 · 05/10/2022 07:40

@00100001
" I think this a symptom of having kids far later in life tbh"

The area I live in is deprived. The women have babies from eighteen usually into their twenties. Retail, cleaning and carework are the main jobs of the women who live here. The local employers will allow the established staff to leave and come in late by fifteen minutes. So many Mother/Daughter combos are working opposite shifts to manage the children in the family. A lot of men in their sixties also do childcare. My DD works afternoons and evenings. I'm planning on going back to work nights and early mornings in two years. Her children will be eight and ten and we will only need holiday club type provision.

mountainsunsets · 05/10/2022 07:39

Everyone is different, all families are different.

We don't have children but my FIL provides "doggy daycare" for our dog while we work. He volunteered, refuses to take money and they have a wonderful relationship. We've said multiple times that we'll pay for daycare if he finds it too much/ to give him a break and he was genuinely offended at the idea Grin

Yes, we're incredibly lucky but he also volunteered to help and we never asked or pushed it on him.

hiredandsqueak · 05/10/2022 07:37

I help my dd by doing childcare for dgs because I love her and wouldn't let her struggle but I'd be lying if I said that it's what I signed up for when I became a Granny. For me a few hours once a week would be the ideal for me so I think what your MIL offers is very generous.
I think though that when Grandparents are over involved it smacks of them not cutting the apron strings for their children and them enjoying that co-dependency. I would think I had done a pretty poor job if dd needed so much support outside childcare whilst she works tbh.

JessicaBrassica · 05/10/2022 07:37

I also think a few hours a week is good. I'm a bit envious of the level of support you get

So far we have been refused one night so we could go away for our 10th wedding anniversary, support when dh was ill in hospital for a couple of weeks with a septic infection, I was struggling with working ft and solo parenting a 2 and 4yo (and with no childcare I was unable to visit him), or to have Ds for an hour whilst we took DD to park run. We stopped asking after that.

We've also found that babysitting in areas where there is high gp involvement is hard. Wed offer to swap with friends - you baby sit for us and we'll look after yours next weekend kind of thing - and although we could find friends to look after ours, they never needed/wanted us to baby sit their kids. I then felt uncomfortable asking.

DrinkFeckArseBrick · 05/10/2022 07:32

When I read your post OP I didnt feel envious I just thought what a horrible lady to take advantage of her mum like that, why get a dog etc if you can't look after it. It sounds like her mum has no boundaries and that's not healthy.

A lot of people I know have families who live too far away to provide regular support or parents are ill etc, amongst my friends it's the norm to do it all yourself.

What does piss me off is those people (and I've seen some on this thread) who chip in with 'I hardly have any support either, only picking the GC up from a school and giving them dinner once a week and a sleepover every other weekend, it's so hard', who don't seem to be at all grateful for the help they do get

rookiemere · 05/10/2022 07:31

Your poor DMIL provides once a week childcare and all you can do is moan about your FIL and compare it to other families with more support.
I know this comes from a place of being upset about your own family l but honestly count your blessings.

Willbe2under2 · 05/10/2022 07:28

I think every family is different, when I was pregnant my MIL said she'd look after DD 5 days a week when I went back to work... I think she's glad we didn't take her up on that offer now she's remembered what 1 year olds are like! She does do 1 day a week though, as does my mum (again, her choice - we didn't ask, she offered) and she has 2 days in nursery.

My big thing was I didn't mind our parents doing a day or so but I didn't want either of them taking care of DD more than DH and I do and becoming 'parents' rather than 'grandparents' iyswim.

00100001 · 05/10/2022 07:28

I think this a symptom of having kids far later in life tbh.

Grandparents "should" be in their 40s and still working full time and therefore unable to provide regular childcare.

But my parents are in their 70s and retired and (very happily) spend time with my niece (2.5) 1 set spend every Friday afternoon from 12 - 3 and the other set have other Thursday for an hour after nursery. This wasn't possible when my lad was wee. They were still working, so we saw them all of a weekend, and evenings as DS got older etc.

However,I'm all for community and familial support, it's natural that the whole family spend time with each other in natural settings.

ImustLearn2Cook · 05/10/2022 07:27

ChillysWaterBottle · 05/10/2022 04:39

YABU calling the daughter 'incredibly selfish' just because you are envious of her set up. Surely it can't be THAT shocking to you?? Most people I know have significant family support, it's absolutely the norm here. No doubt you would accept it if it was available and offered too. It isn't a one way thing. Grandparents who do this often do it because they want to and love spending time with their grandchildren. Many people are raising children within a wider family unit where everyone helps each other out, not just siloed couples.

YANBU to bemoan your own lack of support though. Not everyone has family support available or the relationships to make support offered acceptable. That makes things a lot tougher. It can be hard to hear when someone has things that would make your own life easier. I've certainly fallen into this trap myself. But it ultimately isn't helpful. And it is more to do with you than them.

@ChillysWaterBottle Beautifully written.

Strawberrysundaeonamonday · 05/10/2022 07:27

I’ve had zero help from grandparents and extended family, not even a cup of tea after my DC were born. It sometimes makes me feel sad when I see how much love, support and care other people get, but at the same time our grandparents are totally different people to the kind grandparents others have so I wouldn’t really want their involvement anyway. In some ways it’s a blessing because as a pp said they get zero support and interest from me now they are getting older. They reap what they sow.

SirBlobby · 05/10/2022 07:26

My parents offer 2 days a week childcare. And help out with babysitting every 3/4 months for special nights out. They are constantly buying for our child and have paid for big house things that (we never asked for or even mentioned to them) they knew we needed such as repairs.

We are incredibly fortunate.

I have a friend who has 3 kids and who lost her parents at 10 years old. She has had nothing and no one to help her. Life has been incredibly hard. I have offered what I can (bits of money/babysitting here and there/cups of tea and food at mine) but I work full time and have a second job. Life is incredibly unfair and sometimes I sit and think how bloody lucky am I. I keep saying to myself, when I have more money, I'm going to treat my parents to something wonderful. They don't have to go over and above but they do out of love for me and DC.

Phos · 05/10/2022 07:25

My DD has a friend who lives in a similar situation. His mother works shifts and is a single mother so he lives with his grandparents for stints of up to a fortnight. It's not all rosy, the child struggles massively with never knowing if he's coming or going and as lovely as his grandma is, he needs his mum.

FrozenGhost · 05/10/2022 07:25

I think your post goes to show how easily people can fall in to these arrangements and not really appreciate them, after all you get help every week (that's 52x per year more help that most of us get) and you see it as you "get nothing" "zilch". Maybe this women in the story is also pissed because she gets no help from her in laws side. The moral of the story for you should be appreciate what you have.

Jaaxe · 05/10/2022 07:24

Some people are just more lucky than others and it depends on circumstances and their relatives, it sucks but it’s life.

My mum gave me so much support when I had my first daughter, had her once a week to help with childcare then on top of that where she could - she did this as she got no help from her relatives when we were little and knew the importance of having a balanced family life. Unfortunately, she passed away when my eldest was three and I lost all the support and help I was getting.

I now have 3 children and pregnant with a 4th. We get no family help now, our childcare bills are through the roof, we haven’t had a night away from the kids in 7 years and I’m wondering who will watch my kids whilst I go into hospital to have my csection and hoping DH will be able to be there. We have other family on both sides but neither offer any help.

I think you just have to choke it up to experience like my mum did and make the best of it…..my DH jokes that he can already tell we’re going to be the super involved grandparents that help with childcare all the time because have really struggled whilst ours are little not having any help and I don’t want that for my kids when they grow up and have families, similar to how my mum felt x

MinnieMountain · 05/10/2022 07:23

I wouldn’t want to be reliant on that level of support. What if the DGPs get ill and can no longer manage (as happened to a friend who works shifts).

MIL takes our DS after school twice a week because they both like it, but DS could easily go to after school club.

Ponoka7 · 05/10/2022 07:21

My GM and GD provided childcare. I'd go on holiday and trips away with them. I moved by my Mum when I was widowed. I did evenings/nights so my children slept at hers. All of us looked after my Mum before she died, for us that's how families work. I've now taken temporary early retirement to help out my DD. I sympathise over the dog because when I haven't got the children, I've still got one of the dogs. I've told both DD's no more dogs. I have one of her children over night every Friday and my eldest DD (no children) has the other. My eldest then has them both every Saturday. I do school pickup, after school care, Wednesday to Friday. My eldest takes them on weekends away and on holiday during the summer. I think that looking after your grandchildren is the best anti-aging thing that you can do. I've had health issues and they've stopped me wallowing. I'm on a fitness drive mainly because I want to do activities with them and I'm vain, wouldn't be happy going swimming over a certain size. My Mum used to like doing my shopping and ironing because it gave her something to do. She was a morning and night lollypop lady as well. There's health benefits to being busy.

notdaddycool · 05/10/2022 07:19

I think any grandparent support is a bonus and should be treated as such. Having none should be your expectation and what you get is what you should be grateful for. We got a morning a week, which saved a day at nursery pre pandemic but during that time they grew that bit older and whilst we might get a couple of nights a year that’s about it now. It wasn’t 100% reliable we’d miss at least 1 day a month, sometimes weeks at a time so I’d get a babysitter who was a lot cheaper than nursery. I could swallow that quite happily. Other grandparents are overseas and are virtually bribing a niece up, we’re more concerned how much they do than jealous.

Bootsandcat · 05/10/2022 07:16

As pp have said, a few hours a week is amazing already, you are so lucky. My family is overseas (20 hour plane ride away), my MIL lives 6 hours away and only seen the eldest (2.5 yo) 3 times and the youngest (6m) once. FIL never bothered to meet the kids… don’t compare, it’s the thieve of joy

Bestcatmum · 05/10/2022 07:15

And the funny thing is OP I was offloaded onto my own grandparents all of the time because my mother "couldn't cope". She's never worked. I dont understand what she couldn't cope with I was a very well behaved child who could amuse myself all day. Iearnt early on not to bother my mother. She was ways going off onions holidays leaving me with them. I got myself dressed and washed and walked .yself to school everyday a mile away at 5 years old while she stayed in bed. I find it quite astounding she expects me to sacrifice my owning now to be at her beck and call. She isn't infirm.

Swipe left for the next trending thread