Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Grandparents helping

110 replies

Sparklybutold · 05/10/2022 00:29

In a nutshell - I have no family to help and my husbands side is pretty lacking, although his mum is trying and will have our daughter roughly once a week for a few hours. I was sat next to a grandma today who spoke at length about how her granddaughter lives at her house during the week as her mum (grandmas daughter) and dad work. She also cares for her daughters horses and has taken in her dog depaite the grandma advising her daughter to not get one owing to her work schedule. I was sat there feeling angry, shocked and slightly envious of how much support this family got in terms of childcare and how lucky this mum was to have such a selfless grandma. I couldn't help but think the daughter was incredibly selfish to expect and accept so much help from her mum. In the same conversation the grandma spoke about how she wished things were different and she would love her own time, but she's committed to her daughter. I just left aghast. I've had to make really hard decisions based on having very little family support so to hear this was incredibly difficult and shocking.

So aibu or not?

OP posts:
FlyingPandas · 05/10/2022 11:48

Ragwort · 05/10/2022 10:05

I feel sorry for the grandma in your description - I am mid 60s and some of my friends are GPs and they nearly all say they feel taken advantage of by their adult DC and their demands and expectations around childcare. I think they are being too passive in not laying down boundaries but some of them seem scared of saying 'no' as they are threatened with not seeing their DGC or not being 'perfect' GPs. Many of my friends who are grandparents are still working, have elderly parents themselves, volunteering commitments, hobbies and interests etc but are expected to drop everything to be available for their grandchildren.

Yes this. I think there is a real modern 'expectation' that grandparents should adapt their lives to fit around their children's and grandchildren's needs, provide free childcare and be prepared to take on that load uncomplainingly.

As is shown by a couple of the posts on here, in a few cases some grandparents genuinely do relish being able to offer daily childcare and support, even if absorbs a significant chunk of their time. But I suspect they are in the minority, and I am sure many feel trapped/exhausted/frustrated/taken advantage of that they are having to do so much to look after grandchildren, but also feel they have no choice.

Every family is different but there should always be a balance and it's clear that many parents have unrealistic expectations of their own.

Beautiful3 · 05/10/2022 11:44

YABU. All families are different, people do what they want to. That grandma obviously wants to help, so does so. She's just venting to a stranger about it. If she didn't really want to do it, then she wouldn't. If it makes you feel better, I'm in the same position as you. Zero support here, and I care for an elderly parent. It sucks, big time. I too have been a little jealous of other mum's, who get lots of support. Just don't go down that path.

jannier · 05/10/2022 11:43

UnagiForLife · 05/10/2022 09:55

@jannier not sure why you’re quoting me, you make a good point but hope you’re not telling me to get a grip and adult. If you read my post I get very little help, don’t expect it but think it would be nice if grandparents wanted to and people who have that are lucky. Both my mum and MIL are retired, have a few hobbies but mostly complain that they are bored and lonely while my life is hectic and I’d love the occasional break.

Sorry wasn't meant to quote you its a nightmare on this app to say something without quotes coming in error.
I do think people underestimate the exhaustion of childcare when your older its hard to put yourself in the shoes of someone twice your age or more. A full day can be too much a few hours of an easy child is different to full days of a tantrums. Most grandparents haven't had young children for 20 years its a big shock if your not used to it.
I love my grandchildren and happily give up my day off to care for them but I appreciate its not for all I think the entitlement of some is awful.

hiredandsqueak · 05/10/2022 11:31

My children will always come first no matter how old they are so by helping out daily I am helping my daughter. I have my GD 4 days while DD works. Husband out of country at present. I walk my dogs at 6,30 am round to daughters by 7.40 come home at 4 ish, walk dogs again, have tea and back to help out until 9 pm. The days DD doesn’t work I do her ironing and study for an Open University degree and catch up on chores but still help out in the evening.

I would wonder how badly I had done raising my adult dd to be an independent adult if they needed that much support tbh and I say that with a daughter who has raised dgs singlehandedly since the day he was born and has been back at work since he was nine months old. That's not helping out that is doing it for them.

Brefugee · 05/10/2022 11:21

My children will always come first no matter how old they are so by helping out daily I am helping my daughter. I have my GD 4 days while DD works. Husband out of country at present. I walk my dogs at 6,30 am round to daughters by 7.40 come home at 4 ish, walk dogs again, have tea and back to help out until 9 pm. The days DD doesn’t work I do her ironing and study for an Open University degree and catch up on chores but still help out in the evening.

and others of this ilk: that is lovely and fine for you and your family. For others not so much, and these (often smug) posts are really just fanning the flames, as though other kinds of grandparenting are inferior and invalid.

FWIW, my DCs went to my parents every year for a couple of weeks in summer, to help us out and to foster a relationship. It worked for all of us, especially when one of us didn't have to fly over with them, and again to collect (or one of our parenty brought them back). Although that was always fun too.

rbmilliner · 05/10/2022 11:17

I have no childcare from GP on my side (DH's have both passed away and were basically too old too offer before they passed) and none is offered. I never expect it, even a couple of hours a week other than I'd have thought they'd actually want to spend time with their only granddaughter. I tried to broach the subject that DD might be able to come for a sleepover for my 20th wedding anniversary (fairly big milestone in my book) I've never asked before but the whole idea of providing any childcare was shut down fairly promptly.

looking after siblings pets seems ok though.
It breaks my heart if I'm honest for my daughter's sake as she's never so much as had a day out with them and she's starting to notice that other GP take an interest in their grandchildren's lives and hers don't.
The irony in the whole situation is that I have vivid memories of them complaining that my GP didn't do enough - to my mind they knocked spots off them!

55larry · 05/10/2022 11:02

I have looked after my Dgs since he was 1 and my dd went back to work after maternity leave. Before he started preschool I used to have him for up to a day and a half a week and he went to a childminder the other one and a half days that his mum works. The reason it was up to one and a half days was because his dad works shifts - 2 days, 2 nights on four days off.

Since he started school I have him up to three mornings and three afternoons a week and since my dd went back to full time he goes to breakfast club and after school club two days.

I am very happy to have him and Dh and I have a wonderful relationship with Dgs. The reason we offered to look after him even before he was conceived was because we are older grandparents and if we were going to be able to give time to him the sooner dd had a baby the easier for us.

Originally dd’s mil had offered as well but she unfortunately died of a brain tumour two months after Dgs was born at the age of 57 and we are so grateful to be given this opportunity.

dirtyasadustpanlid · 05/10/2022 10:48

It's the expectancy of it....Ohh but we couldn't work if my parents didn't take him, we don't earn enough to cover childcare, we have no choice, Mum just loves having him from 7-5 every day, Nahhh she wouldn't want money for it, it's what grandparents do, it's quality time with their grandchildren, My friend's Mum has her kids all week including nights, my Mum won't do that, it really bothers me Dad really enjoys the school run, kids are better behaved for My Mum than they are for me at home, My Mum is only 63 and full of life.

All the while you see downtrodden older people trying to wrestle a 2 year old into a shopping trolley in Tesco who are getting old before their time by being full time childminders after already bringing up their own kids.

Selfish, entitled and wrong.

MrsSkylerWhite · 05/10/2022 10:22

I love my little fella beyond words, we have such a lovely relationship, we have fun, we laugh so much, we get into mischief, its wonderful and I feel very much that some grandparents are just not aware of what they are missing out on by not having much to do with dgc“

all of the above but one day a week in sole charge is plenty 😁

SlouchingTowardsBethlehemAgain · 05/10/2022 10:20

I was an older mum so no GP support at all and really my generation did not expect it. Maybe childcare was more affordable then. I do sometimes feel sorry for some of the quite elderly women I see struggling with a couple of tots on the bus. Grandpa is rarely to be seen. I think family finances are so squeezed these days that GP care is the only way they can both work.

thebabessavedme · 05/10/2022 10:09

It all depends on attitudes, I am 60 (this year), I have one grandchild, I adore him! I have done quite a lot of 'looking after him' over the years because I was lucky enough to be in a position where I was able to and because I was happy to do so. I don't refer to it as 'childcare' because i am his Nana, not a nursery worker, teacher etc - my daughter has been able to work and we are very happy to have him if her and sil want to go out, provided me and DH have got a free diary!

I love my little fella beyond words, we have such a lovely relationship, we have fun, we laugh so much, we get into mischief, its wonderful and I feel very much that some grandparents are just not aware of what they are missing out on by not having much to do with dgc.

HOWEVER, I'm no doormat, I have my own life to live and enjoy, my own social life and my marriage is very important to me so I take care to have time with Dh.

That said, it is not compulsary that gps do what I do and parents should not simply expect them to.

Brefugee · 05/10/2022 10:07

I think what it triggers in me is the fact I have zilch on my side.

Frankly? when i hear this and similar i just roll my eyes. Part of being an adult is making adult decisions and choices. You have children and you have to work out how to handle childcare. And backup childcare. Nobody is obliged to help you out, they can if they want and they can cease at any time.

Harsh? yes. sorry.
What you need to do as a parent with little support, is to try to let the feelings of jealousy (because that's what it is) and regret go, and do what you can to mitigate it. It's hard we live in a different country to the entirety of our families, it was very very hard at the beginning. Hard and expensive. I get it. But you really have to try to be glass-half-full and i-can-do-it about this. Otherwise you just feel as though you want to get off the planet.

KermitlovesKeyLimePie · 05/10/2022 10:07

You are v.vfortunate to get what you do.

Both my parents passed away before my DS17 was born and DH's parents who are alive and well have not even had him once for 10 mins in all those years.

DS is severely disabled and as his full time carer, I would kill for what you get OP.

Ragwort · 05/10/2022 10:05

I feel sorry for the grandma in your description - I am mid 60s and some of my friends are GPs and they nearly all say they feel taken advantage of by their adult DC and their demands and expectations around childcare. I think they are being too passive in not laying down boundaries but some of them seem scared of saying 'no' as they are threatened with not seeing their DGC or not being 'perfect' GPs. Many of my friends who are grandparents are still working, have elderly parents themselves, volunteering commitments, hobbies and interests etc but are expected to drop everything to be available for their grandchildren.

WhenISnappedAndFarted · 05/10/2022 10:01

I think you're being unfair on your MIL, her having your DC a few hours a week is a great help.

MrsSkylerWhite · 05/10/2022 09:57

I think a few hours once a week is fine 🤷‍♀️

UnagiForLife · 05/10/2022 09:55

@jannier not sure why you’re quoting me, you make a good point but hope you’re not telling me to get a grip and adult. If you read my post I get very little help, don’t expect it but think it would be nice if grandparents wanted to and people who have that are lucky. Both my mum and MIL are retired, have a few hobbies but mostly complain that they are bored and lonely while my life is hectic and I’d love the occasional break.

Icanstillrecallourlastsummer · 05/10/2022 09:55

Having your daughter weekly isn't just "trying". That's a huge amount of help.

CloudPop · 05/10/2022 09:53

Why do people so desperately want their parents to look after their children? I've never understood it. Spend time together and have a good relationship yes, but this aching desire to palm your children off on your parents for great swathes of time absolutely baffles me.

Fraaahnces · 05/10/2022 09:48

Wow… comparison really IS the thief of joy. I would have loved a one day a week granny to look after my kid.

jannier · 05/10/2022 09:47

UnagiForLife · 05/10/2022 08:02

Same here, both sets of grandmothers (granddads not an option unfortunately) weren’t happy to look after our DC as babies and toddlers so we did that bit all on our own. I didn’t go back to work until they were school age. We didn’t go out on our own together for seven years.

Now they’re school age my mum is willing to look after them on her own under very special circumstances but she worries herself silly about it so we’ve only asked her twice.

The school run is about 50/50 split grandparents and parents picking up. DCs friends have regular ‘sleepovers’ and days out with their grandparents, even aunts and uncles, which is just not an option for us.

I think it’s the natural way of things that grandparents are very involved in their children and grandchildren’s lives as they grow old and have more time on their hands. It takes a village and all that. I hope to be a helpful grandparent if I get the chance.

I think those who do help have a very special bond with their grandchildren, keep fit and active for longer and are ‘down with the kids’ which is great mentally! If you’ve got that help, enjoy it but don’t take advantage of it and realise how lucky you are.

Most grandparents are working themselves nowadays and are expected by their children to give up any time they are not at work yet the parent moans about exhaustion and no time to themselves why isn't granny helping....they forget exhaustion is worse at 60 that painful joints etc are worse and most 60 year olds have health issues.
Grandchildren are a lovely special bond but we should be grateful that the child still has grandparents not moan they don't do free childcare. My children lost all 4 of their grandchildren in 6 months my daughter was 2 my son 5 all appeared fit and well just a year before.
Get a grip and adult

Phos · 05/10/2022 09:43

I think it's natural to feel envious when other people's set up sound better than yours but all families are different, all grandparents have different preferences in terms of how involved they want to be with childcare and that's ok. I don't think grandparents help should be taken as a given. My mum has my daughter two evenings a week, one is overnight and the other she comes home after tea. This is her choice. My grandmother used to look after me 5 days a week before I started school and in holidays. I don't think there was a lot of choice, my mother had to work, she was a single mum and would have struggled with childcare costs. I don't think my grandma minded but some would prefer not to start this role again in their retirement or indeed aren't yet retired themselves.

ehb102 · 05/10/2022 08:21

The only time I ever felt jealous was when I heard "His mum with have her on Mondays, my mum will have her on Tuesdays, she'll be at nursery Wednesdays and Thursdays and I won't work Fridays." We had no family support simply because we had no family nearby. Or grandparents able to visit and child care.

It's okay to be envious of what other people have for a bit. But comparison is the thief of joy. You have to start counting blessings and turn your attention to what you have got, or you'll be eaten alive by bad feelings.

Mommabear20 · 05/10/2022 08:20

Personally think YABU. Family support is lovely to have, but imo should never be expected. You made the decision to have children, why is it anyone else's responsibility to look after them?
My mum works during the week and my in laws aren't in the best of health, so while they do have the children occasionally for us, we work our work out between ourselves to ensure that one of us is always home with them (2&1y/o) and if we ever ask for help and they say no, for whatever reason, we would NEVER be annoyed by it because it's not their responsibility to drop everything for us.

Whatiswrongwithmyknee · 05/10/2022 08:09

A few hours support a week sounds loads to me - it's a few hours support a week more than we got. I think you know that your reaction is based on jealousy. Of course it would be nice to have more support, but instead of berating family for not doing more, appreciate what you've got.

Swipe left for the next trending thread