Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Return of women who were right about safeguarding

337 replies

RhannionKPSS · 04/10/2022 23:09

AIBU to think Mumsnet should allow women ( & men ) who were right about lack of safeguarding in certain places back on this site? ( if they wish to return) ?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
WarriorN · 08/10/2022 09:56

@ReneBumsWombats yes that thread is quite the eye opener.

Ripxnutmeg needs a medal.

AutumnLeavesAreABugger · 08/10/2022 03:23

Yes, get all men out of work for charities for women and children. So many men seem to prioritise their dicks.
And if any men feel personally insulted by this
Then get sorting your abusive men, and don't be violent or sexually aggressive to women and children.

BrrrGettingColder · 08/10/2022 02:36

Just get men out of involvement in women's spaces and charities and just get men out of involvement in child charities. So many of them are abusive. See oxfam.

RhannionKPSS · 08/10/2022 01:27

Have any of you seen the tweet about the “ magazine “ JB was involved with? Absolutely disgusting.
I think Mermaids either didn’t care or didn’t check up on JB, either way is just sickening. Mermaids must drown in the sewer of their own making.

OP posts:
OMG12 · 07/10/2022 20:37

Pink News. Claims Mermaids is “being targeted with a misinformation campaign” Breslow is now on Sabbatical until after Christmas Lse has launched an investigation

ReneBumsWombats · 07/10/2022 20:20

WarriorN · 07/10/2022 19:54

So many of us here have gone over and over and over "am I being unreasonable?" on this.

We've delved into the rights and wrongs, the be kinds, do pronouns really hurt; all roads lead back to the same core answers.

Those in the ideology we are criticising do not rigorously reflect. Won't accept debate or criticism. That's why it's become a safeguarding mess. The culture allows broken boundaries.

It's healthy to challenge one another and self reflect; I change my mind frequently on various opinions around the whole thing.

I'm sorry, I don't like JK's writing/ prose, could never read HP, but fully agree here.

Yes, that's it. I don't think Mermaids deliberately hired a paedophilia apologist. I don't think they intend to support paedophilia. But I do think they are so driven by ideology that they will sacrifice child safeguards to it, and see the inevitable results as something that could happen to any well-intentioned organisation. They simply refuse to see that by worshipping the ideology above all, they're a magnet and breeding ground for these people.

I mean, they have form.

OMG12 · 07/10/2022 20:04

LemonSwan · 05/10/2022 01:24

Oh so it’s all related? The plot has thickened.

I did only pop on here to see what the gossip was as dailymail have an article atm about a Surrey mum who’s married to a priest who was arrested during Sunday lunch for making malicious posts on kiwi farms and it all sounded so insane I had to see what was going on.

So are you saying it’s: pedo group - man - mermaids - man resigned - malicious reports to police - throw Kiki farms in for good measure - Surrey mum arrested and here we are?

Yep all related, a group of people all interested in perversely sexualising young children, group together shocker!

but yes let’s welcome them into schools etc because otherwise you’re a bigot!

WarriorN · 07/10/2022 19:54

So many of us here have gone over and over and over "am I being unreasonable?" on this.

We've delved into the rights and wrongs, the be kinds, do pronouns really hurt; all roads lead back to the same core answers.

Those in the ideology we are criticising do not rigorously reflect. Won't accept debate or criticism. That's why it's become a safeguarding mess. The culture allows broken boundaries.

It's healthy to challenge one another and self reflect; I change my mind frequently on various opinions around the whole thing.

I'm sorry, I don't like JK's writing/ prose, could never read HP, but fully agree here.

Return of women who were right about safeguarding
WarriorN · 07/10/2022 19:01

Fully agree with all your points.

Yes, there was a lot of noise. It would take me too long to find the specific film and will now bug me.

BitossiBlues · 07/10/2022 18:06

Some of the things KD came out with in terms of children with additional needs and then also a child with a dsd (in order to support Ex?) to me were very odd given her profession.

I don't remember this happening, so can't comment. There was so much noise at the time! I agree though that nobody is beyond reproach, and nobody in the GC camp is a saint. I think everyone does their bit the way they believe is best, and like tectonic plates, they'll sometimes rub up against one another and cause a tremor. However, my line (and it's mine and might not be that of others) is that one cannot be simultaneously gender critical and supportive of the life goals of an AGP; and cheer them on while they centre themselves in the discussion as representing the interests of women.

WarriorN · 07/10/2022 17:42

I know it was mostly Exulansic. But if that's true, that KD had no opinion about the children with medical conditions Ex was referring to and many disagreed with, but was supported Ex fully, that's a issue.

Some of the things KD came out with in terms of children with additional needs and then also a child with a dsd (in order to support Ex?) to me were very odd given her profession. It was so long ago I cant remember exactly what it was. At the same time both have made excellent points on the issues of the ideology.

To me as soon as any of these people, including Genspect et al believe they're beyond reproach and cannot be criticised, there's an issue. Within safeguarding, its a culture issue.

pattihews · 07/10/2022 16:34

For the avoidance of doubt, the interview I was referring to was with Stella O'Malley and an American women and is, I'm pretty sure, Gender A Wider Lens. And RB was very waffly, hence me wanting to be very clear that what I think I heard him say may not be accurate. I also struggle with Stella O'Malley, who from my pov asks either ver obvious or quite off-the-wall questions which make me wonder how on-the-ball she is. I don't feel at all confident that she and I would agree about much.

I haven't heard the Arty/ Glinner interview and have no wish to. I'm as 'really?' about Debbie Hayton as the rest of them, but I find all this background bickering and bitching a total turn-off. I'll be so glad when it's over and I can walk away from the drama queens.

BitossiBlues · 07/10/2022 15:15

I don't believe KD had views over people with DSDs. She did have a loyalty to Exulansic, who had a problem with CAIS and would not put a lid on it. Somehow, by defending a friend against cancellation (not Ex's content, but her right to speak freely on YT), KD became more culpable in some peoples' minds than Exulansic over that particular debacle.

WarriorN · 07/10/2022 14:46

Thanks I don't know some of those details.

It's all difficult to evaluate sometimes; I have issues with KD over her ideas about some people with DSDs.

It's useful to see things from all perspectives.

AguaFiestaFeminista · 07/10/2022 14:43

God. I really do wish sometimes that ALL the men attached to this issue would fuck right off.

BitossiBlues · 07/10/2022 14:23

@AryaStarkWolf The photo saga in a nutshell:

The Mess video with Blanchard was part of an ongoing issue many GC women and trans widows in particular have with Arty and his defence of AGP (which included some "drunken" tweeting on his part saying some pretty nasty stuff to feminists). (And this is not over - even last night's unrelated Glinner missive had
women in the live chat commenting negatively about Hayton).

Sometime last year, there was a AGP conference held on zoom by Benji, a former ftm and formerly part of The Mess team. In it, a group of trans widows were trying to tell Stella O'Malley (of Genspect) how they felt about Arty and anyone on the GC side defending of AGPs - these men being the widows' tormentors and abusers in many cases. S O'M was having none of it and was pretty rude to them. You can hear it all in the video I referred to above (Can I Get A Witness Voices "AGP Discussion")

The photo was at the end of a detrainsitioner conference held earlier this year in Ireland by Genspect. A photo was published of a group of people including Stella O'Malley and Glinner in a pub. At the centre was Hayton. Now, bear in mind that this was a conference trying to give voice to detransitioners, and let kids know that transition wasn't the only answer, centring a bloke who does woman face and has had a lot of success and accolades while doing so (and who wrote the school's guidance on pronoun use and toilets and was, IMO, a TRA until he realised he's get a lot more validation on the GC side). That photo was plastered online by another GC TW (I think called Fionne), and captioned "We Are The Movement." It was goady to say the least.

Now, Jenny, a trans widow who had formerly been interviewed by Glinner, and was often times referred to by him, was invited by S O'M to that pub gathering where DH was present and centred. You can hear how this made her feel in the Can I Get A Witness Voices video "IN CONVERSATION: Jenny & Ayesha, Transwidows PART 2". When Jenny complained, Glinner all but disowned her.

The photo pissed off a lot of hardworking female activists who have done a lot more for the GC cause than anyone in it claiming to be "The Movement". A bunch of activists in the US got together at a protest, including KAren Davies (who had taken apart The Mess/Blanchard interview and had a running online battle with Arty and various Genspect people) and Poise Parker, who was out there on a visit,. They did a piss take of the "Movement" photo, having their own group photo taken in a bar. Glinner told Posie off for being in a photo with Karen.

The whole photo thing was incredibly childish and goady. But here was/is an underlying issue about treatment of AGPs (socially, legally and medically) and how making exceptions for "the nice ones" is compatible at all with GC's fundamental principles and concerns.

Farmageddon · 07/10/2022 13:53

endofthelinefinally · 07/10/2022 12:17

I vaguely recall that there was a big fallout from that Mess video and an apology from Glinner. I don't know. Later, when I have a bit of time, I will search.

I haven't heard of the apology, but I would hope to fuck he acknowledged the ridiculousness of that interview. Him and Arty fawned over RB a ridiculous amount, just because he was some sort of 'expert', I'm not sure why - maybe it's awkward to have a guest on your show and then criticise their work. Maybe they didn't want to rock the boat or insult him by questioning his methods. Either way it came off as pandering bullshit.
As previous posters have stated, they failed to ask proper questions, or push back on some of the ridiculous stuff he has come out with.

I'm glad that Blanchard has done this research because it allows us some sort of insight into the reasons behind these men's behaviour (which would probably have never been allowed to be conducted today), but I think he is guilty of some sort of researchers bias in believing that these men are always victims and never perpetrators of something. In wanting to understand them, he has fallen into the trap of trying to excuse them, and has failed to acknowledge the impact that AGP has on the families of these men, and on women in general who are expected to facilitate this against our own wishes.

endofthelinefinally · 07/10/2022 13:33

AryaStarkWolf · 07/10/2022 12:20

Oh I did miss a video then? How was it responsible for his marriage breaking down and his relationship with his children being affected though?

No, no! nothing to do with Glinner's marriage/children. It was the conduct of Ray Blanchard and Arty Morty on the video that was the problem and the fact that they didn't appear to take seriously the affect of the behaviour of the men being discussed on wives and children.
The thing is, those Mess videos are completely informal, often pretty disorganised and usually very good natured and interesting. That particular one got out of control and I don't think it was planned or expected, to be fair.
I started watching them comparatively recently. I find them very good and I think GL is very brave.

AryaStarkWolf · 07/10/2022 12:40

BitossiBlues · 07/10/2022 12:28

I'm not talking about Glinner's marriage and children at all @AryaStarkWolf . I'm talking about transwidows (and their children) as a group and AGPs as a group. And my distrust of anyone wishing for sympathy for the latter over the feelings and experience of the former. There's been a lot written about Hayton, and I've heard enough from him myself to know I would I would not trust him in a million years. Are you not aware of the "We are the Movement" photo?

Ahhh I see, sorry I misunderstood what you were saying there.

No I'm not aware of that, what is it?

BitossiBlues · 07/10/2022 12:28

I'm not talking about Glinner's marriage and children at all @AryaStarkWolf . I'm talking about transwidows (and their children) as a group and AGPs as a group. And my distrust of anyone wishing for sympathy for the latter over the feelings and experience of the former. There's been a lot written about Hayton, and I've heard enough from him myself to know I would I would not trust him in a million years. Are you not aware of the "We are the Movement" photo?

AryaStarkWolf · 07/10/2022 12:20

endofthelinefinally · 07/10/2022 12:17

I vaguely recall that there was a big fallout from that Mess video and an apology from Glinner. I don't know. Later, when I have a bit of time, I will search.

Oh I did miss a video then? How was it responsible for his marriage breaking down and his relationship with his children being affected though?

AryaStarkWolf · 07/10/2022 12:19

BitossiBlues · 07/10/2022 12:14

I mean that certain GC commentators have appealed to transwidows to "be kind" to the exact class of fetishist males that have abused them, and have given these males a voice over and above the trans widows.

Glinner has? I have a lot of time for him and have watched/read a lot of his commenting on the topic. I know he's friends with Debbie hayton but i don't think that makes him against trans widows and I still don't see how that part of his involvement is responsible for his marriage break up (unless I have missed something specific?)

endofthelinefinally · 07/10/2022 12:17

I vaguely recall that there was a big fallout from that Mess video and an apology from Glinner. I don't know. Later, when I have a bit of time, I will search.

BitossiBlues · 07/10/2022 12:14

I mean that certain GC commentators have appealed to transwidows to "be kind" to the exact class of fetishist males that have abused them, and have given these males a voice over and above the trans widows.

AryaStarkWolf · 07/10/2022 12:00

@BitossiBlues how do you mean he prioritsed a fetishists feelings over his wife & Children?