Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Is this boiler engineer U, or am I?

65 replies

PeeAche2 · 04/10/2022 21:18

Today it was my boiler’s annual service and a British Gas engineer arrived as planned.
He was immediately so mardy with me that I thought I must be dreaming!!

2 things he said:

  1. He legitimately told me off for having my thermostat set at 17. He said it was “irresponsible” with kids. I have a 10yo, an 8yo and I was holding my 4mo at the time. He said babies need 21 degrees. Straight up cannot afford 21 degrees right now. Always kept it more like 18 anyway, and it’s never done any of my kids any harm. So I’ve knocked off a degree. Like, isn’t everyone making hard choices like this at the moment? Bought the kids a second hand Oodie each for extra 🔥
  2. He said we should get a newer boiler. Our old one has passed the service just fine but it is old. (20 years). We aren’t planning on getting a new one until it’s on last legs. Engineer pointed at my baby and said “if I were you, for the sake of her, I’d have bought a new boiler over getting that extension done”

We are in the midst of adding a granny flat for my MIL who has suffered a stroke and now needs to move in. It’s not like we’re putting in a bloody home gym or something!!

My husband who WFH overheard the second comment and came and threw the man out!!

Currently a like-for-like boiler replacement for our size house would be about £8k. So, although it would be more energy efficient, we’d like to wait.

We aren’t rich or poor. Just middle. Have zero leftover income each month at the moment and don’t know who TF he thinks he is telling me how to spend my money and care for my kids. Please vindicate me by telling me you think he’s an unreasonable tosser!!!

OP posts:
Ffsmakeitstop · 05/10/2022 10:47

We had a boiler that old and when it started breaking down it was awful. Especially 4 adults wanting showers. We had to coordinate going in one after the other to make sure there was enough hot water.

We eventually went with a company called boxt and just replaced the boiler as the radiators are okay. We pay £67.00 a month for 3 years BG wanted £7000.00.

They are online so probably everywhere. It's a bit ironic that now we have an efficient boiler we still have to be careful using it.

ifonly4 · 05/10/2022 10:39

It's none of his business what temperature you have your heating set at, unless it affects your boiler working.

The second point about a new boiler - he's probably on commission for any new boilers installed with an introduction from him. On that point though, you'll get a boiler when your present one is on it's last legs, I would just say you don't know when that's going to be. Ours packed up at 10 years old, our old engineer and the one who ended up installing a new one couldn't find the cause, and manufacturer refused an emergency call out. By the time we'd had boiler double checked, got quotes in and had it installed it was five weeks - obviously not pleasant in winter. If you do go down the route of a new boiler sometime, get a couple of quotes in before approaching British Gas as their quotes will be the highest and you'd want to make sure they're the right organisation for the job.

GasPanic · 05/10/2022 10:36

Thing is even if the new boiler is 20% more efficient, it still takes years to recover the install cost. Efficiency improvements are a nice bonus, but unless you are using truly horrific amounts of gas even at today's prices it's going to take a very long time to recover your money based on efficiency savings alone.

Re replacement costs, I think the market is problematic. Mine was about 3K, they tried to sell me some extra widgets as well that I researched and pushed back on. I thought that was expensive. Then I spoke to a mate of mine down south who got quoted 12K for a system a bit more complex, but still nowhere close to justifying the extra cost - and it was from an independent.

So I think the market is having a lot of problems with price discovery at the moment, with the availability of boilers and the cost of the install absolutely all over the place. It pays to shop around.

PutThatDownNow · 05/10/2022 10:32

We had a very old boiler in our previous house, already old when we moved in. Every year for 15 years BG came to service it and told me it should be replaced. Apart from the year that one of them told me it was the best boiler he would see all week... When we did eventually replace it the cost was a fraction of what BG had been quoting me.

dementedpixie · 05/10/2022 10:32

andtheweedonkey · 05/10/2022 10:07

If you've more than one bathroom you'd be better with a system boiler not a condensing combi anyway. We did this with our (old BF boiler) and it's been fabulous.

When the time comes, ask @PigletJohn for some advice. He's a Star

You get condensing boilers that aren't combi boilers. It's a new condensing boiler we got but we still have a hot water cylinder and feeder tanks in the loft

worriedniece · 05/10/2022 10:29

Wow- he totally over stepped the mark. It's been 15°c in my 8 month baby room and he has been fine and still slept through OK. He has a thick sleeping bag and layers

dementedpixie · 05/10/2022 10:28

YellowTreeHouse · 05/10/2022 10:13

He’s right - 17 is far too low for a baby.

My thermostat is currently still set well below 17⁰C as its not that cold yet (I'm in Scotland). When it is colder I will put it up to 19⁰C.

We recently got a new boiler as ours was 20+ years old. Our BG guy had said for quite a few years that it would be hard to get parts but it never actually ever broke down. He never tried to pressurise us to replace it as it was still working even if it was inefficient.

Lindy2 · 05/10/2022 10:25

He has no right to comment on your thermostat temperature. 17 is lower than average however, plenty of people haven't turned their heating on yet. We haven't. The house temperature is OK and if we're a little chilly in the evening a blanket and hot water bottle makes it perfectly comfortable.

A 20 year old boiler is at risk of starting to have some issues. A new boiler is probably something you need to start to think about. However, I'd be amazed if it cost as much as £8K. I work for a gas engineer and we're based in an area with a large number of truly very large houses. New boilers in those houses don't cost anything like £8K and my boss always uses top quality parts and does very thorough work.

Campervangirl · 05/10/2022 10:22

Engineer was a twat but I'm fan girling on your DH for chucking him out!
My oh would have hidden whilst I chucked him out 🫣😂

Svalberg · 05/10/2022 10:19

YellowTreeHouse · 05/10/2022 10:13

He’s right - 17 is far too low for a baby.

Unless you've done a survey of OP's house, you have no idea whether it is or not. It depends upon the sensor location what a sensible setting is. I would guess that the baby doesn't sit under the sensor all day!

queenofthewild · 05/10/2022 10:18

Sounds like the BG idiot who serviced my mum's boiler.

Despite passing the safety checks he told her "I wouldn't sleep in a house with a 30 year old boiler". My mum replied "you won't have to. I've not invited you to stay". She promptly cancelled her BG contract and found a lovely independent engineer instead.

YellowTreeHouse · 05/10/2022 10:13

He’s right - 17 is far too low for a baby.

Newnamefor2021 · 05/10/2022 10:12

That’s crazy. He had absolutely no reason right to say that to you. My husband is a BG engineer. He says most people 19-22C. But equally years ago people didn’t have heating and just wore more clothes. He says it’s low but it’s nothing to do with him regarding what temp you chose to hear your home.

the boiler thing is that it’s a fire-able offence to not offer “best advice”. Which generally comes in the form of sales. The argument from the company would be that if your boiler fails and they can’t source parts then you will be without any form of hearing until they source parts or a boiler is replaced. A 20 year old boiler is likely to not have all parts available. Which plenty of customers do complain about if they weren’t warned. So I get that point. The reality is though it’s absolutely is about sales.

id certainly complain, you can request to not have that engineer again. And what temp you choose to heat your home is your business and nothing to do with him.

LadyDanburysHat · 05/10/2022 10:07

I agree on the thermostat comments. Ours is in the hall by the door so is set to 16-17 and that means 21 ish in the other rooms.

I'm glad your DH chucked him out. He was incredibly rude.

andtheweedonkey · 05/10/2022 10:07

If you've more than one bathroom you'd be better with a system boiler not a condensing combi anyway. We did this with our (old BF boiler) and it's been fabulous.

When the time comes, ask @PigletJohn for some advice. He's a Star

Thatiswild · 05/10/2022 10:06

Thermostat setting totally depends on where it is, I really feel the cold but ours is usually on 18 and that’s fine, my dh and kids are always boiling!

BG pricing for our new boiler was at least 25% higher than the next most expensive.

He was very rude, your dh is great for getting him to leave and definitely complain, that’s so inappropriate. I’m really sorry about your MIL, it’s lovely what you’re doing for her.

GasPanic · 05/10/2022 10:03

Re changing the boiler, provided that one is ok and you can get spares for it OK and it is not in danger of breaking down any time soon then I wouldn't replace it. If he has serviced it must have checked out OK.

The problem is if it breaks down at an inconvenient time (say middle of winter) and you need to get a new one. It is better to be proactive if this is likely to happen. I think the reason they pressurise people is because they get huge queues of people in the middle of winter trying to get their boiler replaced urgently (like me for example!) and all of a sudden your problem becomes their emergency. Remember waiting in a 6 week queue for a boiler in the middle of winter is no fun.

Re should you prioritise the boiler rather than the extension - well you probably should, but that is really non of his business and to be honest his comments seem inflammatory. I would have told him where to go (provided I didn't anticipate needing to call him out on Xmas eve to fix a broken boiler).

Re house being heated at a specific temperature to help babies I have no clue.

Re British Gas in general, I had my boiler replaced by them 1 year ago, and I found them very good, but a bit expensive.

MrsSkylerWhite · 05/10/2022 10:00

I think he came to our house 😁
I’d call in. Your thermostat setting is none of his business and he needs to be told by his manager to keep his opinions to himself.
If your boiler is working it doesn’t need replacing. They’ve probably been told to drum up business.

Interestingmauve · 05/10/2022 10:00

You're really very unreasonable to be using British Gas to service your boiler 😆

Their "engineers" have targets to sell you a new boiler and will use any tactics to meet them. My parents' boiler has apparently needed replacing for the last 20 years. I wonder how long the new one BG wanted to sell them would have lasted.

billyt · 05/10/2022 09:58

BG Engineers are pushed to flog over-priced boiler replacements.

He had no right to question the temp your house is set at, no right at all.

No point complaining though, BG won't do a bloody thing.

We use a local company for our boiler servicing. If I could be arsed to sort my suppliers out I wouldn't let BG supply our gas.

GimmeSleep · 05/10/2022 09:56

Ah BG still at it with their overpriced new boilers. They quoted us something ridiculous years ago, local indie gas safe plumber fitted a new one for about £1600

Getoff · 05/10/2022 09:55

My boiler is 20 years old. British gas engineers have been telling me to replace it since it was 10 years old. Except for the most recent one, who implied it probably had a good few years left in it.

Getoff · 05/10/2022 09:54

Shouldn't cost 8k either, if it's just swapping the boiler out.

If it's that old, it will be a swap to a condensing boiler, which might require hugely expensive work to lay a waste pipe.

WireSkills · 05/10/2022 09:39

Keep your thermostat where it is. 17 degrees on ours translates to 21 degrees in some rooms as the stat is in a cold spot.

Most importantly, continue doing what you're doing (with the knowledge in the back of your mind that your boiler won't be fixable if it breaks), but mostly, make a complaint about the engineer!

He has no right to be offering personal opinions. If he's said that to you, he'll have said similar to others and he deserves a bollocking from his bosses!

mamabear715 · 05/10/2022 09:00

WT actual F???

Swipe left for the next trending thread