Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Is this boiler engineer U, or am I?

65 replies

PeeAche2 · 04/10/2022 21:18

Today it was my boiler’s annual service and a British Gas engineer arrived as planned.
He was immediately so mardy with me that I thought I must be dreaming!!

2 things he said:

  1. He legitimately told me off for having my thermostat set at 17. He said it was “irresponsible” with kids. I have a 10yo, an 8yo and I was holding my 4mo at the time. He said babies need 21 degrees. Straight up cannot afford 21 degrees right now. Always kept it more like 18 anyway, and it’s never done any of my kids any harm. So I’ve knocked off a degree. Like, isn’t everyone making hard choices like this at the moment? Bought the kids a second hand Oodie each for extra 🔥
  2. He said we should get a newer boiler. Our old one has passed the service just fine but it is old. (20 years). We aren’t planning on getting a new one until it’s on last legs. Engineer pointed at my baby and said “if I were you, for the sake of her, I’d have bought a new boiler over getting that extension done”

We are in the midst of adding a granny flat for my MIL who has suffered a stroke and now needs to move in. It’s not like we’re putting in a bloody home gym or something!!

My husband who WFH overheard the second comment and came and threw the man out!!

Currently a like-for-like boiler replacement for our size house would be about £8k. So, although it would be more energy efficient, we’d like to wait.

We aren’t rich or poor. Just middle. Have zero leftover income each month at the moment and don’t know who TF he thinks he is telling me how to spend my money and care for my kids. Please vindicate me by telling me you think he’s an unreasonable tosser!!!

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Carlycat · 05/10/2022 21:41

Definitely complain to BG. He really overstepped the mark there. Prize wanker and CF

PeeAche2 · 05/10/2022 14:03

Ooh. Lots to digest here.

Forget the temp in my house, it’ll be a cool day in hell before I pay £8k for a new boiler. 😂 When he said that amount, I thought he must have been choking my chain.

17 degrees in my house translates to around 18-19 degrees in most rooms apart from the dodgy little room off the kitchen and the downstairs loo. I admit, I have a preference for cooler temps and I’m always telling my kids to just put a jumper on. But it’s not unreasonably cold.

We do also use log burners throughout the house.

I've turned it down a degree, that’s the truth. I hold my hands up to. But heaven help me, if you saw the bills I’m getting. I’m not made of bloody money. Everyone is just going to have to get used to a slightly cooler environment. Including the baby - who is nicely layered up and bonny as you like.

Lullaby trust advise 16-20 degrees and I’m happily within that target. Plus, she still shares a room with us, which means she’s toasty in with mum and dad. And besides, we have an open fire in the bedroom, if required.

Apart from during the boiler service, my heating hasn’t even been on yet. It’s positively balmy here in PeeAche-ville.

It’s unlikely I’ll complain. I have fantasised about it, but I have 3 kids and I don’t even get to take a shit on my own.

OP posts:
altmember · 05/10/2022 13:46

roarfeckingroarr · 05/10/2022 12:57

He's right on the heating. Not ok about the extension.

No he isn't. You can't just walk into a house and declare what the thermostat needs to be set at. It depends where in the house the stat is, the layout of the house, the quality of the insulation. If the stat is located in the coldest part of the house then 17 degrees should be fine. My stat never goes above that, 21 degrees would feel like being in a furnace to me. Obviously you keep a baby warm with appropriate layers of clothing.

Elphame · 05/10/2022 13:35

Getoff · 05/10/2022 09:54

Shouldn't cost 8k either, if it's just swapping the boiler out.

If it's that old, it will be a swap to a condensing boiler, which might require hugely expensive work to lay a waste pipe.

Not necessarily. I replaced my 1970s boiler a year ago as it was finally clearly on its way out.

It cost about £5K mainly because it had to be resited as the old boiler location wasn't permitted any more and we had thermostatic valves fitted to all 19 radiators.

We went for a traditional boiler and kept the hot water tank.

Irridescantshimmmer · 05/10/2022 13:27

Well that engineer was having a bad dogs' day.

KittyEmK · 05/10/2022 13:17

YANBU!! What a prick. Will you complain?

PixiesFeet · 05/10/2022 13:15

I would make a complaint to British gas. We had an incident with a British gas engineer. When my non verbal DC did not answer a question he asked DC he pointed at him and said whats wrong with him why can't he talk!

Tbf BG were very apologetic and refunded us for the bill for the boiler service.

Blossomtoes · 05/10/2022 13:07

Shouldn't cost 8k either, if it's just swapping the boiler out. Should be able to get a whole new system for that sort of money

This. We’ve just had a state of the art new boiler fitted and all (13 of) the radiators replaced. That cost just over £6k, the boiler was about £2.5k.

BigWoollyJumpers · 05/10/2022 13:03

Setting aside the BG man, who obviously is a tosspot.

We just got a new boiler to replace our 25 year old one. It wasn't broken, but it was coming to the end of it's life. We paid 2.5k all in for a new Worcester boiler, and my god the difference in efficiency. It's on for so much less time, and the rads heat up very quickly, and the hot water is steaming. We live is a large 5 bed as well, so it's a fairly large boiler.

roarfeckingroarr · 05/10/2022 12:57

He's right on the heating. Not ok about the extension.

ChocolateCroissantCafe · 05/10/2022 11:59

I'll try again... the rudeness would have lost this engineer a sale.

ChocolateCroissantCafe · 05/10/2022 11:59

Lullaby Trust advice is 16-20 degrees for babies, or it used to be? So your 17 degrees setting would be in the right bracket.

I'd not be keen to change a boiler that was safe and working well. To be honest, even if I was considering it, the rudeness woul

GasPanic · 05/10/2022 11:55

Lol.

I had the normal to condensing replacement. Two independents just wanted to drain the waste water into the soakaway outside.

BG wanted to fit a pump which would have been - I don't remember exactly - £500 quid extra. I didn't want the extra moving parts and cost, so I insisted they moved it onto another wall so the condensate drained into the same as the washing machine drain. It works fine.

One of the independents insisted the main gas feed pipe wasn't wide enough (it was) and quoted me an extra 2K to have a new pipe fitted (nuts).

BG did the most thorough job on scoping out the install, seeing what was necessary to do by some margin. As I said, more expensive but ultimately their people were a lot better.

I had a gas fire replaced by an independent in another house and had a terrible time getting the certification. I know someone who had a load of work done and it turned out the guy didn't have the proper qualis or certification.

So yeah, you can get Bob to fit you that new boiler for £4.50 and a six pack of beer, but don't be surprised if that comes with some baggage.

GreenFingersWouldBeHandy · 05/10/2022 11:50

Report to BG. And then forget about it.

Jmaho · 05/10/2022 11:50

Report him, ignore him then when you have the cash to buy a new boiler then don't go with BG! Get a local independent firm out
We bought our house 4 years ago it was built approx 24 years ago and still has original boiler
Had BG in for a quote they said it needed replacing immediately and quoted over 6 grand for a like for like, keeping hot water tank in loft. Not being moved very straight forward easy job 2 days max. I looked up the boiler they recommended and I could buy it for 2k I expect they get it cheaper so £4k ish labour bill
Has two other local firms in and they both quoted about half of BG but both said we were mad to replace the current one and described it as "bomb proof" said not to replace it until it goes wrong and that it would take years to recoup the cost of a new one with the energy we'd save so we haven't replaced it!

BiddyPop · 05/10/2022 11:47

We had a boiler that was17 years old when we bought our house, with engineers sucking their teeth on each annual visit. It failed literally the friday of the weekend that the builders were coming on the monday morning to build an extension which included replacing boiler - 5 years later.

That one last us another 15 years, but happened to blow the week before christmas in 2019 (again yearly servicing and had been getting the teeth sucking for a couple of years) - but we got a local company to replace it that week (I think it below on 19th and we got replacement on 23rd) at a fraction of that price. And we have a wood stove so would have managed if we had to wait.

altmember · 05/10/2022 11:43

Getoff · 05/10/2022 09:54

Shouldn't cost 8k either, if it's just swapping the boiler out.

If it's that old, it will be a swap to a condensing boiler, which might require hugely expensive work to lay a waste pipe.

Maybe if it needs half a mile of condensate pipe plumbing! 2k for the boiler, 6k for the waste pipe?

Speedweed · 05/10/2022 11:36

In my acquaintance everyone who has had a boiler service recently has had a conversation where the recommendation is that they get a new boiler. It's like the last hurrah before boilers are out and boiler engineers are demoted to plumbers...

GenExer · 05/10/2022 11:36

You're definitely not being unreasonable OP.

We recently had a similar situation with a British Gas engineer trying to dictate temperatures to us whilst carrying out our annual boiler service. This instance was to do with our hot water.
Ours was set at 55c by last year's engineer which we've been happy with as 65c was too hot for our shower.
DH caught this year's engineer fiddling with the thermostat and asked him what he was doing. Engineer claimed our temperature was too low and should be at 65c 'because of Legionnaires disease' DH replied no, that occurs at temperatures less than 50c and ours was at 55c. Switching it to 65c would be far too hot hence why it was changed last year.

He also identified a slight leak in a filter that had self sealed but didn't want to touch it because in his words 'Something's bound to go wrong and it's a Friday afternoon'.

The whole process of getting an engineer here was peppered with them consistently not showing up for the arranged visits and not hearing why.
We'd go elsewhere but for the fact we're tied into a 5 year contract with BG as they replaced our boiler 2 years ago and that was the T's & C's.
As soon as that guarantee is up we'll go with someone else!

ancientgran · 05/10/2022 11:21

I think it really depends on where the thermostat is. My thermostat is at 21 but it isn't triggering the boiler, if I put it at 17 or 18 the heating would never come on even in the depths of a bad winter.

I don't think they put the thermostat in a good place but we just know we have to allow for that.

So unless he knows the circumstances of your house he's talking rubbish.

bigbluebus · 05/10/2022 11:16

I'd have told him to keep his opinions to himself and get on with the job he was employed to do - as he's not paying your bills.
My thermostat is currently set at 16°c. I'm wearing a t-shirt and a thin fleece. It's not cold today in the Midlands.

blobby10 · 05/10/2022 11:15

PeeAche2 it would be worth getting a quote from a local heating engineer (depending on how much of a contract you are in with BG). When I had my boiler serviced, I asked the engineer how long it had left and he said although it was 20 years old it could last another 10 or 15 years or it might only last 1! But that old boilers often last longer than the new ones these days o not to panic and replace immediately. As it turned out, the next year I replaced it anyway as there was a screw that hadn't returned to its setting properly and it might have caused the whole thing to fail. It was a large 4 bed detached house and the boiler and installation cost around £4k.

cultkid · 05/10/2022 11:10

Wtf??
Also why 8k? What do you have?

My husband never ever ever would talk to any clients like this

Report him to his boss

perenniallymessy · 05/10/2022 11:09

queenofthewild · 05/10/2022 10:18

Sounds like the BG idiot who serviced my mum's boiler.

Despite passing the safety checks he told her "I wouldn't sleep in a house with a 30 year old boiler". My mum replied "you won't have to. I've not invited you to stay". She promptly cancelled her BG contract and found a lovely independent engineer instead.

Your DM sounds ace!

Unfortunately, if you report to BG it won't do much- he would be in more trouble with them for not recommending a new boiler than for recommending one. He has probably got a target to meet and has moved to hard sell.

Ffsmakeitstop · 05/10/2022 10:50

To answer your question yes he was a twat. You probably do need a new boiler but presumably you know that don't need a mansplaining twat telling you. Well done your DH.