Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

MIL asking for gift back

193 replies

hattiez · 04/10/2022 13:44

My MIL knitted / crocheted some cardigans / jumpers/ outfits and a couple of blankets for my son when he was born. They where given to us in a gift bag / wrapped in tissue paper and with a card with the usual congratulations on. One of the blankets had his name on and the other in colours/ design to match the nursery we planned.
A distant member of my husbands family related by marriage is due a baby shortly, my MIL has asked for the items she made for my son to be returned so she can give them to the family member.
My son is a young toddler and we hope to have another child shortly so we haven't passed on any of the baby things yet as hope to be able to use them again.
I'm not a hoarder and will happily pass things on once no longer needed and I appreciate that perhaps my MIL just wants to see the things she made in use again or that it may have been poorly worded and will of course return the items she made and gifted but AIBU unreasonable to be a bit upset / shocked that she's asked for them back to regift particularly as one has his name on and were quite personalised?
The cardigans and outfits obviously no longer fit so have been stored with his other clothes hopefully for a sibling and the blanket is on the chair in his room.
I appreciate families / friends hand things down / pass things on and we benefitted from friends giving us things however I would have kept the hand kitted things regardless in appreciation of the love and work gone into them.
I will return the items I think as it would seem she wants them back and I respect that she made them but it makes me feel a bit upset and weird that she has asked for what I thought was a gift back to pass on and wary of accepting future "gifts" in case they are also removed but perhaps its just me being unreasonable

OP posts:
GertrudePerkinsPaperyThing · 06/10/2022 09:11

You can also say "MIL, when you give people gifts, you can't have them back at any random time in the future. That's not how gifts works. Obviously I'm not going to give my sons personalised blanket to you to give to someone else!

I think you can happily say this, and you’d be right.

Personalised items can also have sentimental value

Musti · 06/10/2022 09:08

Have you spoken to her and told her about still using the blanket and wanting to keep the rest for a future child?

I have 4 kids and have some stuff and got it back. It makes sense for people to pass on baby stuff and get it back if needed again. So many items only used for such a short time!

TootsAtOwls · 06/10/2022 08:59

Don't give them back for the sake of "keeping the peace". That will just encourage her to think it's a normal request instead of deeply weird.

I'd "forget" until she asks again then act incredulous. "What? You want x, y and z back? But I thought they were gifts! They belong to ds, I can't take them off him!"

She's obviously being tight and not wanting to buy more presents

Schulte · 06/10/2022 08:25

Interesting. This reminds me of a lovely soft blanket that MIL bought for my DD. We were also asked to pass it on to SIL when her baby arrived. It wasn’t handmade by MIL though so slightly different to your situation!

PearlyShamps · 06/10/2022 08:04

I find flattery is a big softener in situations like this. Could you explain to your MIL how much you appreciated and really liked the gift, and would find it hard to part with these items now - especially as you'd love your 2nd DC (her future grandchild) to have the opportunity to use them? She might not realise how much you do actually like and want to keep these items.

donkeymcdonkface · 06/10/2022 07:44

My MIL did exactly the same - so I gave them back. But I did find it very odd at the time as thought they were made for my baby/future babies.

AdobeWanKenobi · 05/10/2022 23:00

SalviaOfficinalis · 05/10/2022 20:52

And yet you used it anyway…

I did wonder when I read it if the poster knew it was a slur why the fuck include it.
Its very much “I’m not racist but….” Isn’t it?

sashadjas · 05/10/2022 21:38

Ohh god love you sweetheart, your MIL is odd! Being me I'd be tempted to refuse all future gifts from her and to say "Just keep it, saves me returning it" but I think I'm rather more abrasive than you! I do hope this gets resolved xx

AiryFairyLights · 05/10/2022 21:36

@hattiez Could you compromise - decide on a few items to keep (the personalised and blanket etc) and give her a couple of items back and tell her you are keeping the rest as you are hoping to use them or pass them onto your son when he is older as a keepsake.
You could explain that you really want him to have these items as they will be something he has that was made by his grandmother especially for him - hopefully she’ll back down but good luck x

SalviaOfficinalis · 05/10/2022 20:52

bluesapphire48 · 05/10/2022 20:51

I clearly said it was a slur. Can't you read?

And yet you used it anyway…

bluesapphire48 · 05/10/2022 20:51

I clearly said it was a slur. Can't you read?

Springtimeshowers · 05/10/2022 20:45

what did you give her for christmas? .... ask for it back 🤣

RobertaFirmino · 05/10/2022 20:43

@bluesapphire48 You know that word that begins with 'R' and ends with 'acist'?

bluesapphire48 · 05/10/2022 20:37

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

Toomuchtrouble4me · 05/10/2022 20:36

Boil wash them then return.

MamaBearof4 · 05/10/2022 19:37

I'd say to her straight - "I had thought they were gifts, not loans. After all you'd personalised them." If you want to keep them, either as a memory item or for the next bubba, tell her firmly that you will not be returning them.

Gifts are gifts, you don't go asking for them back when you want to give to another person. A loan of a piece of equipment or special heirloom garment is different, and the give tells you up front.

Maryminx · 05/10/2022 18:58

A gift is a gift!
Ask her to clarify as u may have it wrong
Tell her how beautiful the gifts are and that they are treasured.
u don’t have to give any other reasons or explain that u are thinking of having another child.

cherish123 · 05/10/2022 18:57

As I see it, it was a gift. There is also a certain amount of sentimentality as his GM made it.

MIL is just being mean. She does not want to have to buy or make another present.

RIPQueen · 05/10/2022 18:47

Is this a bizarre PA way of her trying to find out if you are planning on having another baby

Vapeyvapevape · 05/10/2022 18:44

For the sake of world peace , I would return them , it is a bit weird but there are lots of strange people about.

Brigante9 · 05/10/2022 18:39

LookItsMeAgain · 04/10/2022 16:34

Could you buy some plain cardigans that look like they were knitted by your MiL and give her those? Does she remember what the ones she knitted for you look like? If she doesn't, then this might be a way to get around actually handing back the gift she gave you.

www.marksandspencer.com/peter-rabbit-knitted-cardigan-0-3-yrs-/p/clp60567311
www.next.co.uk/style/st918079/a29108#a29108
www.next.co.uk/style/st916284/t06842#t06842
www.next.co.uk/style/st457422/430370#430370

Why should the OP fork out for different items? What a bizarre suggestion!

YorkshireRog · 05/10/2022 18:27

Just explain how feeing and that would love to give to him when grown up etc x

Madamum18 · 05/10/2022 18:21

IsAinmDummm · 04/10/2022 13:51

Can't you just say to her that your hoping to need them again for no.2 DC?

Simples!!

Pumpkinpatchlookinggood · 05/10/2022 09:59

What about
Hi mil, that scarf I bought you for last Christmas can you post it back aspa as Joan down the Road is feeling the pinch and I said she could have it..
Cfery has no age limits does it?

hattiez · 04/10/2022 22:12

Thank you again for your replies.
I am going to let my husband handle this however I think he was also shocked at the request.
It is as much about the principal as the actual items and I agree with the poster who said about what will be next will they request my sons birthday present etc back on a whim or to gift to other distant family members.
As far as I could tell the items where nee when given to ourselves and my sister in laws received similar knitted gifts from my MIL when they had their children although they are older now, as far as I'm aware they where not asked to return them / pass them on and one sister definitely still has the items as she showed me them when pregnant in her children's boxes

OP posts: