Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask what you think about ‘work for dole’ idea?

518 replies

WakeUpAndBe · 04/10/2022 10:24

Is it reasonable or unreasonable?

Pros: on the surface it sounds reasonable. Means the public won’t view it as “free money” if people are working 30 hours a week for a lot less than the national living wage.

Cons: risks of exploitation and returning to Charles Dickens’ style workhouses for the poor.

Chris Philp said UC claimants should be forced to ‘work for dole’

“In his paper, Philp suggested those claiming universal credit should, after a certain time, have to work for their benefits if they were employed for less than 30 hours a week. He suggested those claiming benefits for a disability should be given work that they were physically able to do.
^^
“Philp said they could be asked to complete community work such as cleaning graffiti or clearing parks, charity work, supervised job searching or recognised training to top up their hours to 30 a week. He said a referral to the “work for the dole” scheme would be triggered between three months and two years after first claiming depending on previous national insurance contributions.
^^
“If anyone is not compliant with work for the dole activity requirements, they should automatically have all their universal credit payments suspended as long as the person is not working for the dole,” he wrote at the time. “Although the complete suspension of universal credit benefit payments may seem an extreme sanction, the evidence from the US suggests that this is required to make the scheme fully effective.”

Number crunching

The National Living Wage is currently £9.50 x 30 hours x 4 weeks = £1,140 for 4 weeks

According to the website, monthly UC is £265.31 for single and under 25,
£334.91 for single over 25,
£416.45 for couples under 25
and
£525.72 for couples over 25.

OP posts:
reallyisthisallthereis · 04/10/2022 16:45

FrankTheThunderbird · 04/10/2022 10:27

If there's 30 hours of work to do then pay someone to do it. As in a real wage.

This

WakeUpAndBe · 04/10/2022 16:44

Pinkcadillac · 04/10/2022 15:54

So this is fake news.

Trump would be proud of us 🙄

How is this fake news?! OP references an article in Guardian published recently.

Live on BBC right now:

www.bbc.co.uk/news/live/uk-politics-63114183

Braverman: Benefits system 'needs more stick'
There's more from Suella Braverman on benefits, the hot topic on Day Three of the Tory party conference.
^^
The home secretary claimed there is a "stubborn core of our population that sees welfare as the go-to option [and] is not motivated... to get out and work", adding that the system needed to add "a bit more stick" to make sure it paid for people to get themselves into work.
^^
Speaking at the conference, Braverman told The Telegraph's Christopher Hope there are "far too many people" who are able to work but don't. Instead, she said, "they choose to top up their salaries with tax credits or whatever".
^^
Referencing the popular Channel 4 TV series - which aired in the mid-2010s - Braverman said she believed that the "Benefits Street kind of culture is a feature of modern Britain".
^^
As we've reported, there's been some in-government fighting today after PM Liz Truss refused to commit to increasing benefits in line with inflation. Cabinet minister Penny Mordaunt swiftly broke ranks to call for the increase - promised under Boris Johnson - to be honoured.

OP posts:
MarshaBradyo · 04/10/2022 16:43

GeorgeorRuth · 04/10/2022 16:42

The company I used to work for signed up for the old workfare, the first and last chap who they took on lasted one morning after telling a customer to fuck themselves, he wasn't paid to help, he was only there because he had to be and it was shit.... it may not have been the result they wanted 😂

i can imagine it..

Thats the thing you can make people turn up to a charity role or sweep leaves if that’s all you think they can do but you may not get the results you want.

GeorgeorRuth · 04/10/2022 16:42

The company I used to work for signed up for the old workfare, the first and last chap who they took on lasted one morning after telling a customer to fuck themselves, he wasn't paid to help, he was only there because he had to be and it was shit.... it may not have been the result they wanted 😂

GeorgeorRuth · 04/10/2022 16:42

The company I used to work for signed up for the old workfare, the first and last chap who they took on lasted one morning after telling a customer to fuck themselves, he wasn't paid to help, he was only there because he had to be and it was shit.... it may not have been the result they wanted 😂

WakeUpAndBe · 04/10/2022 16:32

marmaladepop · 04/10/2022 16:30

Felt enraged at the word 'dole'. We've moved on since the 80's. Unworkable idea.

Currently still used in Australia

Work for the Dole: A Workforce Australia Program

OP posts:
marmaladepop · 04/10/2022 16:30

Florelei · 04/10/2022 10:30

Horrendous. Especially the part about forcing disabled people to work.

I’m seriously considering leaving the U.K.

This.

marmaladepop · 04/10/2022 16:30

Felt enraged at the word 'dole'. We've moved on since the 80's. Unworkable idea.

WakeUpAndBe · 04/10/2022 16:23

123ROLO · 04/10/2022 16:19

Wouldn't work

For one, those jobs should be employee jobs anyway.

Working out a system on what jobs would be suitable for people with disabilities would be very complicated, there would likely need to be PIP style assessments, multiple risk assessments, it would just get contested endlessly.

Also the whole process would be pretty degrading.

I do think however there should be more training courses available, including things like workshops on resilience, communication skills, how to present yourself and more skill based ones.

They could fill gaps in STEM jobs with re-training programs.

OP posts:
123ROLO · 04/10/2022 16:19

Wouldn't work

For one, those jobs should be employee jobs anyway.

Working out a system on what jobs would be suitable for people with disabilities would be very complicated, there would likely need to be PIP style assessments, multiple risk assessments, it would just get contested endlessly.

Also the whole process would be pretty degrading.

I do think however there should be more training courses available, including things like workshops on resilience, communication skills, how to present yourself and more skill based ones.

WakeUpAndBe · 04/10/2022 16:13

Unforgettablefire · 04/10/2022 13:38

@WakeUpAndBe but this is all from a decade ago, has he mentioned starting it up again since he was appointed?

He is also one of the ones accused of having the idea for the tax cuts for the richest in society that was later u-turned. Whoever thought that tax cut was a good idea during a cost of living crisis is clearly someone to keep an eye on.

Tory U-Turn On Tax Cuts Is Causing Chaos – So Who Is Blaming Who?
Liz Truss, Kwasi Kwarteng, Chris Philp and the government's advisers are all being roped into the debate.

OP posts:
SamphirethePogoingStickerist · 04/10/2022 16:13

Octomore · 04/10/2022 14:58

If a local job exists and nobody local has the skill to do it, what then?

Back in the olden days, the business would take on an apprentice and train them up while paying them a fair wage for the work they did while training.

This applies to all kinds of role. E.g. Big 4 accounting firms take on unqualified people and spending 3 years training them to be accountants.

The fact that companies would rather not pay to train people is not something the government should be condoning.

As I explained, we also has companies who is d not have vacancies who donated their staff time and skill.

It isn't one sided and can work well. It should not be derided and avoided just because national schemes are bought by the usual suspects and turned into money making machines.

Local solutions can work well.

mrsjohnnylawrence · 04/10/2022 16:10

@Pinkcadillac what's fake about this concept? It wasn't written about? It's not something that's been done? (it has)

@OnlyOpenMouthToChangeFeet I don't need to be told all this. I know many people on benefits, some it IS totally the life of riley, others struggle horrendously, and I've also had both personally. I've gone days without eating on benefits when I hadn't been paid on time. I've also been quite well off as a single mother in a sweet spot having my wages topped up.

PIP is brilliant, it's elevated so many lives and I think that's great.

My point was a bit tongue in cheek; it's a "good" idea in that it will benefit the wealthy. It's not good if you're at the bottom, but that's where they want to keep you. And by they I don't mean the Tories, the packaging of whatever policy is being enacted at the time. The people in charge don't care about you, and they don't make policies with you in mind.

People seem to think they do but are just always somehow off the mark. Absurd people can think this.

WakeUpAndBe · 04/10/2022 16:06

PearlclutchersInc · 04/10/2022 14:22

Its an appalling concept, along with all the other bright ideas which have effectively been labour on the cheap and abused left, right and centre.

Every time a Tory minister opens his/her/its mouth the unadulterated crap that's spouted beggars belief.

Well, they’re coming from a position of privilege aren’t they?

They don’t recognise the help they receive through inheritance and help from their already wealthy families.

OP posts:
AuntSalli · 04/10/2022 15:57

OneTC · 04/10/2022 15:49

You say that but we used to get loads of people coming for a job with us, and the job is really not very hard, and there's no way knowing that a significant number of them would be able to do it, and no way I'm finding out. The jobcentre people we used to get sent were unemployable. They needed help not just jobs

So that is their reason, not excuse for being unemployed.

some people‘s lives are just so chaotic if the government wanted to reduce the amount of service users they have for social services and NHS employing an army of Nanas to go and help these people manage their lives, put in systems in place, teach them how to cook, oh hang on a minute we had that was called sure start.

Pinkcadillac · 04/10/2022 15:54

So this is fake news.

Trump would be proud of us 🙄

AnchorWHAT · 04/10/2022 15:49

I trained for years to do my job, had years of experience and a high salary, when i was made redundant i claimed jsa, no way in hell would i be cleaning graffiti or picking litter. That is not what i trained to do! I was patronised a lot by job centre staff and told i had to apply for supermarket and care jobs, i applied but did not even get an interview because i was overqualified. Fortunately i stepped into another well paid role using my hard worked for qualifications, skills and experience within a year.
Jobs at basic level should be paid a proper living wage and resources to encourage people into work via skill enhancing, and training should be focused on long term unemployed. Not everyone needs it and as well as being patronising to people who are highly skilled sending them ( or trying to) on courses to look at how to use a computer or learn how to write a cv is a colossal waste of resources.
it feels as if the belief is that every claimant is work shy, many more would be in full time work if paid a proper living wage that allows for childcare or other care out of their salary. It is a nonsense to expect people who genuinely want a real job to take on community service or other created roles, as has been said multiple times if the work needs doing pay people a living wage to do it and save all the resources to support those with real barriers to employment.

OneTC · 04/10/2022 15:49

Florenz · 04/10/2022 15:39

I think all benefits should be contribution based. No-one should be able to stay on benefits indefinitely with no expectation of them finding a job. There are jobs everywhere nowadays, no excuse for being unemployed unless you have a severe disability.

You say that but we used to get loads of people coming for a job with us, and the job is really not very hard, and there's no way knowing that a significant number of them would be able to do it, and no way I'm finding out. The jobcentre people we used to get sent were unemployable. They needed help not just jobs

Shortjanet · 04/10/2022 15:45

FrankTheThunderbird · 04/10/2022 10:27

If there's 30 hours of work to do then pay someone to do it. As in a real wage.

This. It's really very simple.

OnlyOpenMouthToChangeFeet · 04/10/2022 15:44

mrsjohnnylawrence · 04/10/2022 13:55

Great idea for company owners who can sack existing staff, recommend themselves for this scheme, and then go 'well I do believe you have a few people already qualified for this work' then get them back at a fraction of the cost.

And if I can work that out so have they. It's on purpose. It's to scare or torture people off benefits, which it will do, and the aim will be achieved. There are plenty who take benefits over working because why work when you can claim benefits for a similar amount? Why clean toilets when you can do nothing instead for the same money?

So I can claim benefits for a similar amount as working? Please let me know where?!

I am severely disabled and bed bound. As a result, I qualify (not an easy thing to do by the way!) for maximum amounts of Universal Credit and PIP.

After my rent and council tax contribution have been paid, I have £589 per month to survive on. Bearing in mind the estimate is households with a disabled occupant have expenses roughly £583 higher than the average household, this isn't much. My energy bill alone is now £400 per month, and due to my conditions this is non negotiable.

I am also supposed to receive care of 30 hours per week, however social care contributions have been slashed. I now receive just £289 4 weekly from social care, which covers just 4 hours per week. So I can either pay for a little more care and not eat at all, or do what I'm doing and go without care. So currently I'm often dirty, unwashed, in soiled bedding. And still hungry.

Before ANY of you claim living on benefits is the life of Riley, take a walk in my shoes. (Would love to be able to go for a walk...)

OneTC · 04/10/2022 15:44

Aprilx · 04/10/2022 14:53

No it isn’t a Tory thing being rolled out. It is just a made up thing that no party is suggesting.

Well, it comes from a paper written by the treasury minister, albeit a while ago. The policy itself was introduced under a previous Tory administration and the Cameron era onwards have tried to introduce it and reintroduce it under a number of guises since 2010. It is definitely not "made up"

I don't think any of them are currently angling for it, just that the article is seeking to highlight the ideological attitude of someone who is currently deciding how stuff gets spent

WakeUpAndBe · 04/10/2022 15:43

paintitallover · 04/10/2022 14:42

I think that constantly setting up Mumsnet threads to test out Tory ideas without admitting who you you are is a form of trolling. There used to be so much on Mumsnet. Now there's threads daily from some corner of the Tory policy outfit or other. Mumsnet should do something about it. Nobody is fooled anymore.

No party doing this is making any headway with their image as an honest party. Say who you are, then we can respond or not, and the threads can be put with other sponsored threads. No need to be underhand about it.

I literally saw an article in the Guardian yesterday and was curious. That’s it.

I am not affiliated to anything political.

Why can’t people be interested in politics and want to discuss things they see in the news?

OP posts:
Florenz · 04/10/2022 15:39

I think all benefits should be contribution based. No-one should be able to stay on benefits indefinitely with no expectation of them finding a job. There are jobs everywhere nowadays, no excuse for being unemployed unless you have a severe disability.

WakeUpAndBe · 04/10/2022 15:36

Unforgettablefire · 04/10/2022 13:38

@WakeUpAndBe but this is all from a decade ago, has he mentioned starting it up again since he was appointed?

The Guardian reported on it yesterday. I hadn’t heard of it before, so it was new to me (and many others in here too).

Worth being informed about his previous ideas. Isn’t it?

OP posts:
Shortname · 04/10/2022 15:12

Uurgh hideous, especially the bit about disabled. What have we become when we won't look after the most vulnerable in society.