Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask what you think about ‘work for dole’ idea?

518 replies

WakeUpAndBe · 04/10/2022 10:24

Is it reasonable or unreasonable?

Pros: on the surface it sounds reasonable. Means the public won’t view it as “free money” if people are working 30 hours a week for a lot less than the national living wage.

Cons: risks of exploitation and returning to Charles Dickens’ style workhouses for the poor.

Chris Philp said UC claimants should be forced to ‘work for dole’

“In his paper, Philp suggested those claiming universal credit should, after a certain time, have to work for their benefits if they were employed for less than 30 hours a week. He suggested those claiming benefits for a disability should be given work that they were physically able to do.
^^
“Philp said they could be asked to complete community work such as cleaning graffiti or clearing parks, charity work, supervised job searching or recognised training to top up their hours to 30 a week. He said a referral to the “work for the dole” scheme would be triggered between three months and two years after first claiming depending on previous national insurance contributions.
^^
“If anyone is not compliant with work for the dole activity requirements, they should automatically have all their universal credit payments suspended as long as the person is not working for the dole,” he wrote at the time. “Although the complete suspension of universal credit benefit payments may seem an extreme sanction, the evidence from the US suggests that this is required to make the scheme fully effective.”

Number crunching

The National Living Wage is currently £9.50 x 30 hours x 4 weeks = £1,140 for 4 weeks

According to the website, monthly UC is £265.31 for single and under 25,
£334.91 for single over 25,
£416.45 for couples under 25
and
£525.72 for couples over 25.

OP posts:
Kissingfrogs25 · 06/10/2022 07:34

okytdvhuoo · 06/10/2022 07:29

If there are 30 hours of work available do you think these hours should be paid at minimum wage (or indeed the going rate?)

NB I think the PP is using ‘nothing’ in the sense of ‘pittance’..

I am happy to support any scheme that gets people into jobs - full stop.

It is highly unhealthy to be languishing every day without direction or purpose and relying on other people to pay your bills. It’s not good for anyone and a terrible example to their children.

Kissingfrogs25 · 06/10/2022 07:31

Mumofsend · 06/10/2022 07:22

"The real world' aka the crap the tories and Channel 5 poverty porn portrays?

Or actual real world based on evidence?

Don’t be preposterous. Most people that work for a living and pay taxes are strangely not keen propping up those that can’t be bothered to get a job ( unless it is people with real disability of course)
It is not exactly breaking news! 😂

okytdvhuoo · 06/10/2022 07:29

Kissingfrogs25 · 06/10/2022 07:21

People are not ‘working for nothing’ they are working for benefits being paid to them.

I entirely support this idea. It would encourage healthy able bodied people to get a better paid job and to start getting used to the idea. We can’t have millions languishing on the dole endlessly. It’s not good for the country or them.

You will find plenty of opposition on here. Plenty of people that are on benefits object obviously and Labour devotees but in the real world most working people want something done about it the huge volume of people on benefits as the jobs are plentiful.

If there are 30 hours of work available do you think these hours should be paid at minimum wage (or indeed the going rate?)

NB I think the PP is using ‘nothing’ in the sense of ‘pittance’..

Mumofsend · 06/10/2022 07:22

Kissingfrogs25 · 06/10/2022 07:21

People are not ‘working for nothing’ they are working for benefits being paid to them.

I entirely support this idea. It would encourage healthy able bodied people to get a better paid job and to start getting used to the idea. We can’t have millions languishing on the dole endlessly. It’s not good for the country or them.

You will find plenty of opposition on here. Plenty of people that are on benefits object obviously and Labour devotees but in the real world most working people want something done about it the huge volume of people on benefits as the jobs are plentiful.

"The real world' aka the crap the tories and Channel 5 poverty porn portrays?

Or actual real world based on evidence?

Kissingfrogs25 · 06/10/2022 07:21

limitedperiodonly · 04/10/2022 22:23

You can't be expected to work 30 hours for the dole that is absurd. But what about 10 hours a week for those who've never had a job before? so you have something to put on a cv, show you can turn up for work etc

@Choconut if you accept the concept that people should work for nothing what is the difference between 10 hours or 30 hours?

You clearly think it''s okay for people to work for nothing as long as it's for a certain period of time. What is the cut off point for you - 29 hours 59 minutes? Or an infinite number of people working for nothing for the same company in 10 hour shifts? When you give an answer would you show your working in the margin because I don't get your reasoning.

If you have a full CV as many people who claim unemployment benefit to which they are entitled do, what would you pay them? Would you reject them in favour of a school leaver who you can pay a handful of magic beans they can put on their CV? Again, why would that be?

If a job needs doing then you pay someone to do it and negotiate the rate according to employment law. If someone is less experienced you pay them less than someone more experienced and accept they might not do as good a job. But you still pay them don't you? Or is getting paid a fair day's money for a fair day's work absurd to you?

I don't think you've thought this through, have you?

People are not ‘working for nothing’ they are working for benefits being paid to them.

I entirely support this idea. It would encourage healthy able bodied people to get a better paid job and to start getting used to the idea. We can’t have millions languishing on the dole endlessly. It’s not good for the country or them.

You will find plenty of opposition on here. Plenty of people that are on benefits object obviously and Labour devotees but in the real world most working people want something done about it the huge volume of people on benefits as the jobs are plentiful.

purplehair1 · 06/10/2022 06:47

Evidence from the US? You mean where there exist whole shanty towns/no go areas of homeless people? Frankly I don’t think we should copy the US on any policy at the moment although Biden is a lot better than the angry hateful orange blob.

ancientgran · 05/10/2022 20:50

Octomore · 04/10/2022 12:21

Exactly! Why not provide the hospital with sufficient funding that they can pay enough staff to cover this work?

Because people already moan about NHS money being used for management and admin so having more admin staff would cause uproar.

Zilla1 · 05/10/2022 11:18

Who might benefit from a workforce requiring nil payment? The same group who benefit from the 40% of benefit recipients already in the workforce as paid employees who are paid so little that their wages requiring topping up at the taxpayer's expense? Privatise the gains and socialise the costs?

NumberTheory · 05/10/2022 11:17

I don’t have much of a problem with the idea of benefits being provided as guaranteed work at the living wage of x hours a week. (With other provision for those who aren’t able to work). I think expecting people to work for less than the living wage is where it becomes exploitative and Othering.

However, it would probably be significantly more expensive to provide work schemes (even at less than the living wage) than it currently is to provide UC. And the government’s track record with work and training schemes isn’t encouraging (I remember YTS too and while a few people did well out of it, there were plenty of abuses and pointless make work projects. One near me famously had a group of YTS digging holes, then a month later another group came along and filled them in.). Though I do think if it was set up as a way to benefit the community with work being community and charity related, rather than a way to subsidise businesses or be a deterrent/punishment/“moral corrective” for those on benefits, it might work.

Maverickess · 05/10/2022 10:57

SarahSissions · Yesterday 11:07
Work 30 hours a week- I’m on board. For those “on benefits who are already working” if they are only doing 15 hours they can make up the other 15 working for the state before they get any money. for those not working then they can do the full 30.

And for those already working full time but in receipt of some benefits due to being a single parent, and on a low wage, and where the other parent pays and does fuck all? Because it won't stop that particular problem of men walking away without a care in the world from their responsibilities leaving it to someone else and the state to fill the gap. What do they do to 'get their free money?' let me guess 'get a better job'.

And those who can only work 15 hours because that's all that's available, because they're on a zero hour contract and that's all they were given this week because the employer wants to keep their staffing costs low but have a workforce available at the drop of a hat? They can't work today because they've got to do their state mandated hours but the needs of the business mean they're needed and if they're not available they're then unreliable and not given even 15 minutes the following week?

And those who are caring for disabled/elderly relatives around that 15 hours or in fact full time, who cares for them the rest of the time? Is the state going to fund that? (Far more than they'd be paying in benefits to that person - but hey at least the tax payer knows that anyone on benefits is having to do something they approve of right?)

Those that are disabled or sick themselves, where are these jobs that they can suddenly do going to come from? Who's going to be paying for the reasonable adjustments needed for them to be able to do something state approved for their benefits? And why if it can be done so that a section of society can feel superior and like their tax isn't going to lazy scroungers, can't it be done to empower people now?

nothing in this life is free…apart from benefits it seems.
Or work when employers are getting it for free. Are we going to start calling businesses lazy scroungers when they've got a large part of their workforce made up from benefit claimants, paid for by the tax payer and then pocketing the difference? I doubt it. And as for doing work directly for the state, so, so many things supposedly run by the state are in private hands anyway, so someone other than the state is going to benefit financially, be that a contracted company or a manager who's saved a fortune on wages and then gets a nice fat bonus.

I don’t know why some people find the idea of work so offensive“

I don't think many find the idea of work offensive, a great many find the idea of exploitation offensive, but then I guess if you're one of the ones exploiting and you stand to gain from it, or already do, you won't be offended.

If this work exists then it should be paid at at least nmw, not benefit claimants used to do all the shit jobs in the country that no one wants to do because they're shit, wages and conditions appalling and in some cases exploitative. It's just going backwards with this idea.

Endlesssummer2022 · 05/10/2022 09:16

Terrible idea. It’s either a job or not a job. If an employer can find 30 hours of work then they should create a real position.

MrsSkylerWhite · 05/10/2022 08:57

SarahSissions · Yesterday 11:07
Work 30 hours a week- I’m on board. For those “on benefits who are already working” if they are only doing 15 hours they can make up the other 15 working for the state before they get any money. for those not working then they can do the full 30.

nothing in this life is free…apart from benefits it seems.

I don’t know why some people find the idea of work so offensive“

I sincerely hope that you never find yourself in circumstances you could never have imagined and reliant on benefits through no fault of your own.
(we are reasonably well off, I have never received benefits but I am very, very glad that they are there.)

Trinity65 · 05/10/2022 01:40

FarmerRefuted · 04/10/2022 10:42

It's a shit idea.

As a PP said, if this work exists for benefits claimants to be able to do for "free" then it should exist as a paid job for at least NMW, if not more. And know they're not strictly working for "free" because they would receive UC in exchange however UC is below NMW and its money they should be getting regardless if this proposed scheme didn't exist therefore they would, in effect, be working for free and against their will. There is a name for people forced to work for free and against their will.

People claiming benefits are just as entitled to dignity and fair treatment as people who aren't claiming benefits. Forcing them into modern slavery is not the answer, creates a two tier "us vs them" culture which will widen the divisions in society, and creates further inequality. More people would be pushed into poverty, you'd have people literally foregoing the support they're entitled to simply to avoid the indignity of it. I don't want to live in a country where we have an underclass of "undesirables", out picking litter or cleaning graffiti in their DWP branded hi-vis so that we can all see that they're dirty benefit scum.

(And don't @ me about me implying that litter picking or graffiti cleaning are shameful jobs, they're not shameful jobs when they're properly contracted, paid, and being carried out by people who have chosen to be there).

👏👏👏
Absolutely well said

blubberyboo · 04/10/2022 23:51

No… whilst I believe people on benefits should have the option to top up their benefits with paid hours. if they can find some casual work or whatever there shouldn’t be a barrier to them taking on the work as it maybe fulfils a seasonal or short term urgent need and helps build their skills. But they should be paid at least min wage for the hours they do.

forcing people to work on benefits for no extra money is demoralising, criminal as they won’t get minimum wage and actually would take more jobs out of the workforce as employers would opt for the cheap labour causing a poor cycle of being people being trapped

mathanxiety · 04/10/2022 23:28

YYY @missprism

Or since the Tories are so taken by all things American, why not bring in some good old fashioned Southern peonage.

gnilliwdog · 04/10/2022 22:29

@LikeTearsInRain We volunteer for our local litter picking group, and have helped with some gardening. Everyone should be encouraged to take care of their neighbourhood, rather than getting a group to do it for them, under duress. Where the job can't be done by local good will, it should be paid work.

Isahlo · 04/10/2022 22:28

crosbystillsandmash · 04/10/2022 10:28

What do I think of it?

You do realise the vast majority of people on benefits are already working? Or 'working' as unpaid carers for family members with woefully inadequate or non existent local authority help.
Educate yourself before you climb on that high horse op.

How about as a nation we focus on raising wages, providing better, cheaper childcare for working parents and more help for the millions of unpaid carers?

This exactly
also those people who aren’t working or aren’t working enough are in work search groups. I was placed in work search for taking two weeks unpaid leave in the summer holidays last year because I couldn’t afford childcare all through
so the following month I then had to work search work f/t in the hospital look after DH with a chronic illness manage my home and support a sen preschool child.
it’s grim already it doesn’t need to be harder

limitedperiodonly · 04/10/2022 22:23

You can't be expected to work 30 hours for the dole that is absurd. But what about 10 hours a week for those who've never had a job before? so you have something to put on a cv, show you can turn up for work etc

@Choconut if you accept the concept that people should work for nothing what is the difference between 10 hours or 30 hours?

You clearly think it''s okay for people to work for nothing as long as it's for a certain period of time. What is the cut off point for you - 29 hours 59 minutes? Or an infinite number of people working for nothing for the same company in 10 hour shifts? When you give an answer would you show your working in the margin because I don't get your reasoning.

If you have a full CV as many people who claim unemployment benefit to which they are entitled do, what would you pay them? Would you reject them in favour of a school leaver who you can pay a handful of magic beans they can put on their CV? Again, why would that be?

If a job needs doing then you pay someone to do it and negotiate the rate according to employment law. If someone is less experienced you pay them less than someone more experienced and accept they might not do as good a job. But you still pay them don't you? Or is getting paid a fair day's money for a fair day's work absurd to you?

I don't think you've thought this through, have you?

missprism · 04/10/2022 22:22

Why not just get all claimants into chain gangs and be done with it? Tory wankers.

Discovereads · 04/10/2022 22:20

LikeTearsInRain · 04/10/2022 22:12

So huge council tax rise is preferred then rather than having a group of 20 people doing some work for 2 weeks then being left to claim as normal?

Who do you think these 20 JSA claimants are exactly? And how does litter picking actually help them find another job? And why would there be a huge council tax rise when your idea involves sacking council employees who already do this job….creating more people on JSA?

LaurenM87 · 04/10/2022 22:13

An absolute disgrace from the most vile PM and chancellor in my lifetime. 30 hours per week for a few hundred quid a month?! It's tantamount to slave labour!

LikeTearsInRain · 04/10/2022 22:12

JustLyra · 04/10/2022 22:09

It would be far more helpful if councils just had enough funding to employ the number of staff they need.

So huge council tax rise is preferred then rather than having a group of 20 people doing some work for 2 weeks then being left to claim as normal?

XenoBitch · 04/10/2022 22:10

LikeTearsInRain · 04/10/2022 22:08

It would be really helpful if they could do jobs that have a community impact like litter picking, gardening/landscaping in public parks, emptying public bins, washing off graffiti etc. It could be organised through local councils too and they would save a fortune on the labour as they would only need a small team of employed supervisors to coordinate and oversee the work. There are probably enough people on JSA they’d only have to do a couple weeks a year if they stayed employed long term - you’d just rotate through a different squad of claimants every two weeks. Councils are short on funds at the moment as we all know and the last thing we need is a big council tax increase next year.

Councils already have people employed to do those jobs. And where it is done for nothing, it is by people who have committed a crime.
Being unemployed is not a crime.

JustLyra · 04/10/2022 22:09

LikeTearsInRain · 04/10/2022 22:08

It would be really helpful if they could do jobs that have a community impact like litter picking, gardening/landscaping in public parks, emptying public bins, washing off graffiti etc. It could be organised through local councils too and they would save a fortune on the labour as they would only need a small team of employed supervisors to coordinate and oversee the work. There are probably enough people on JSA they’d only have to do a couple weeks a year if they stayed employed long term - you’d just rotate through a different squad of claimants every two weeks. Councils are short on funds at the moment as we all know and the last thing we need is a big council tax increase next year.

It would be far more helpful if councils just had enough funding to employ the number of staff they need.

LikeTearsInRain · 04/10/2022 22:08

It would be really helpful if they could do jobs that have a community impact like litter picking, gardening/landscaping in public parks, emptying public bins, washing off graffiti etc. It could be organised through local councils too and they would save a fortune on the labour as they would only need a small team of employed supervisors to coordinate and oversee the work. There are probably enough people on JSA they’d only have to do a couple weeks a year if they stayed employed long term - you’d just rotate through a different squad of claimants every two weeks. Councils are short on funds at the moment as we all know and the last thing we need is a big council tax increase next year.

Swipe left for the next trending thread