Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask what you think about ‘work for dole’ idea?

518 replies

WakeUpAndBe · 04/10/2022 10:24

Is it reasonable or unreasonable?

Pros: on the surface it sounds reasonable. Means the public won’t view it as “free money” if people are working 30 hours a week for a lot less than the national living wage.

Cons: risks of exploitation and returning to Charles Dickens’ style workhouses for the poor.

Chris Philp said UC claimants should be forced to ‘work for dole’

“In his paper, Philp suggested those claiming universal credit should, after a certain time, have to work for their benefits if they were employed for less than 30 hours a week. He suggested those claiming benefits for a disability should be given work that they were physically able to do.
^^
“Philp said they could be asked to complete community work such as cleaning graffiti or clearing parks, charity work, supervised job searching or recognised training to top up their hours to 30 a week. He said a referral to the “work for the dole” scheme would be triggered between three months and two years after first claiming depending on previous national insurance contributions.
^^
“If anyone is not compliant with work for the dole activity requirements, they should automatically have all their universal credit payments suspended as long as the person is not working for the dole,” he wrote at the time. “Although the complete suspension of universal credit benefit payments may seem an extreme sanction, the evidence from the US suggests that this is required to make the scheme fully effective.”

Number crunching

The National Living Wage is currently £9.50 x 30 hours x 4 weeks = £1,140 for 4 weeks

According to the website, monthly UC is £265.31 for single and under 25,
£334.91 for single over 25,
£416.45 for couples under 25
and
£525.72 for couples over 25.

OP posts:
antelopevalley · 06/10/2022 12:12

@Thisismynamenow then they should be paid for the work.
But a healthy person who uses a wheelchair is pretty uncommon. Most disabled people have multiple issues or mental health problems.

Thisismynamenow · 06/10/2022 12:09

antelopevalley · 06/10/2022 11:56

Evidence from US suggests only way to make this work is to take away all benefits if people do not comply.
So disabled and ill people drag themselves along to litter picking so they do not starve to death. Or carers with the severely disabled people they are caring for.

This will not work. It would be very expensive to provide work disabled people can do. It is why the previous scheme just shoved people into unpaid supermarket jobs. Unless you exploit people, it will be extremely expensive.

You would have to match the person to the role. A wheelchair bound person couldn't do a heavily manual job, but they could work in an office based role with reasonable adjustments.

Thisismynamenow · 06/10/2022 12:08

I think its completely fair. HOWEVER the benefits must rise to NMW to cover and they must get all other working benefits.

So unemployed people get matched with a job, work FT/PT and get paid correctly by the state.

It's ridiculous to say they won't have time to find another job, all other working people manage. It may even help people find alternative employment as its easier to find a job when you have a job.

It will never happen as it would cost too much in time and money, and it is open to becoming a workhouse very quickly!

Gremlinsateit · 06/10/2022 12:01

Octomore · 06/10/2022 11:35

If there is school time only work that needs doing, the relevant employers should advertise those jobs for a fair wage and people will apply.

Also, here parents of children over 9 months and under school age who receive parenting payment, with some exceptions, have obligations - less onerous than full work for the dole, but still involving meetings, reporting and “activities”.

Once the youngest child is school age, again with some exceptions, there is no more parenting payment and no different treatment - ie work for the dole is not limited to school hours for primary caregivers.

I would say, be very cautious about embracing this.

antelopevalley · 06/10/2022 11:56

Evidence from US suggests only way to make this work is to take away all benefits if people do not comply.
So disabled and ill people drag themselves along to litter picking so they do not starve to death. Or carers with the severely disabled people they are caring for.

This will not work. It would be very expensive to provide work disabled people can do. It is why the previous scheme just shoved people into unpaid supermarket jobs. Unless you exploit people, it will be extremely expensive.

Grrrrdarling · 06/10/2022 11:47

WakeUpAndBe · 04/10/2022 10:24

Is it reasonable or unreasonable?

Pros: on the surface it sounds reasonable. Means the public won’t view it as “free money” if people are working 30 hours a week for a lot less than the national living wage.

Cons: risks of exploitation and returning to Charles Dickens’ style workhouses for the poor.

Chris Philp said UC claimants should be forced to ‘work for dole’

“In his paper, Philp suggested those claiming universal credit should, after a certain time, have to work for their benefits if they were employed for less than 30 hours a week. He suggested those claiming benefits for a disability should be given work that they were physically able to do.
^^
“Philp said they could be asked to complete community work such as cleaning graffiti or clearing parks, charity work, supervised job searching or recognised training to top up their hours to 30 a week. He said a referral to the “work for the dole” scheme would be triggered between three months and two years after first claiming depending on previous national insurance contributions.
^^
“If anyone is not compliant with work for the dole activity requirements, they should automatically have all their universal credit payments suspended as long as the person is not working for the dole,” he wrote at the time. “Although the complete suspension of universal credit benefit payments may seem an extreme sanction, the evidence from the US suggests that this is required to make the scheme fully effective.”

Number crunching

The National Living Wage is currently £9.50 x 30 hours x 4 weeks = £1,140 for 4 weeks

According to the website, monthly UC is £265.31 for single and under 25,
£334.91 for single over 25,
£416.45 for couples under 25
and
£525.72 for couples over 25.

They are so out of touch they don’t realise that many on UC work part time for childcare reasons. They literally can’t afford to pay someone else to look after their children so they can work more hours. Also some do work 30+ hours a week yet their wage is so low or they are on 0 hour contracts so that working week is not guaranteed.
Our government are so out of touch it is u real & statements like this are disgusting, derogatory & uncalled for.
I’d like to see him work full time, while running a home & caring for children full time😡

Octomore · 06/10/2022 11:35

JulieMarooley · 06/10/2022 11:31

One good thing about this plan could be that school-time-only work could be made available for those with childcare needs.

Single parents with kids under school age would need to be exempt.

If there is school time only work that needs doing, the relevant employers should advertise those jobs for a fair wage and people will apply.

JulieMarooley · 06/10/2022 11:31

One good thing about this plan could be that school-time-only work could be made available for those with childcare needs.

Single parents with kids under school age would need to be exempt.

JulieMarooley · 06/10/2022 11:23

It would be a decent idea for the civil service to expand to employ everyone who is capable to work.

I think it would cost more overall to do this, than to just pay people to do nothing, because there would need to be managers to oversee, organise, shift the workers from removing graffiti one day to clearing bins the next etc.

It would perhaps be worth it for the benefits to the workers who would otherwise be sat at home, and the benefits to society of the extra work in the community.

TwinMama88 · 06/10/2022 10:53

Some of these replies have made me so angry. We can see why our country is in this mess when people like you support this absolute crap. Are you walking around with your head up your arse?

I'm in benefits for the first time in my life.
I've worked since a teenager, at one point having multiple jobs at once. I worked hard.
Then I had children and my ex left.
I can't afford to work right now, as childcare is so extortionate that there's no job I'm able to do that would pay for full time childcare plus my bills and feeding us.
So please tell me, what am I supposed to do?
I want to work, I don't want to be looked down upon as a scrounger because I've fell on hard times, and am struggling for a way out.
I'm being pressured to find work, and when I ask for help about what I can do regarding childcare, I'm told its my problem.
I'm a single mother, I can't work nights, I can't work weekends, unless I bend over and shove my kids up my arse.
They're not near school age yet.

So some of you are happy for me to be forced to work for my universal credit, in which I'd have to somehow pay for childcare, leaving me with no money then for my bills so I'll get into debt.
Or I can just refuse and have my money stopped and I can either have sex with strangers or sit and watch my children slowly starve to death?
But you think that's acceptable because you know, nobody should get free money right? Which isn't technically free money when I've paid tax and NI for many many years until this point.

It's a shocking idea and will see even more people falling unemployed or without the means to feed themselves and their children.

Lifelessordinary1 · 06/10/2022 08:39

The number of universal credits claimants include 41% already working and the 1/4 million working age people living in care homes and hospital - who are so disabled they cannot be left alone.

It also includes all those who are less disabled living in supported living which means they are so disabled they can manage some aspects of looking after themselves but not others.

It also includes the people who are very long term ill - say going through Chemo - who i personally feel may not be able to work. Jesus wept did i actually have to say that!

It also includes carers of the above people who may be very disabled or ill - and some carers are caring for more than 1 person.

It includes some parents of very young babies who are on a maternity leave type situation.

It also includes the many people who have so many barriers to getting a job, more minor disabilities, lack of transport, childcare, caring for sick or elderly relatives, criminal records - i could go on listing them for hours.

It also includes people who are between jobs - one job has finished, and they are going through the process of getting another one.

I am sure i can think of more categories of people on Universal Credit - I love the comment about local councillors knowing these people who have never known anything, but benefits exist - really i do not know anyone who actually knows their local counsellors!

Gremlinsateit · 06/10/2022 08:14

R2G · 06/10/2022 08:07

Ooh yes what a good idea, can we make them wear bright orange boiler suits with 'poor but grateful' written on the back too?

😂

America12 · 06/10/2022 08:13

Would childcare be provided ? If so why can't they provide it now ? People (women) would be back to work in droves if they didn't have unaffordable childcare costs.

R2G · 06/10/2022 08:07

Ooh yes what a good idea, can we make them wear bright orange boiler suits with 'poor but grateful' written on the back too?

FriedasCarLoad · 06/10/2022 08:06

That would be too many hours, considering that their main job should be job applications. And simply counter-productive for those who are genuinely desperate to work.

But for that very small minority who haven't worked in years and don't want to, maybe something along these lines might give them the push they need.

I'm not sure how the process of identifying those people could be made fair though, and how the safeguarding could be good enough.

Gremlinsateit · 06/10/2022 08:04

We have work for the dole in Australia. It’s shameful. If the job is there, it can pay minimum wage.

The task of finding the placements has been outsourced to non-government agencies which scam the system to reap higher placement fees. Participants are referred to placements which don’t match their skills or needs, and are provided with inadequate training and safety gear, leading to injury.

Studies have shown that many sites don’t meet safety standards and that participants’ employment prospects do not increase significantly.

Because of the moral hazard, so to speak, of the placement fees, agencies are motivated to apply the work obligations to people who are exempt, like students who meet the exemption requirements.

Anecdotal reports also suggest that agencies falsely rated participants as having a more severe disability or lower educational achievement than was the case, because they received higher payments for participants who were rated as more difficult to place. Substantial amounts have had to be repaid by agencies after audits.

celticprincess · 06/10/2022 08:03

Definitely not!!
No such thing as dole now. Jobseekers is either no longer, or phased out. Universal credits is the thing people looking for work claim alongside people who work claiming it as they need the top up from bad wages to survive.
If a job is available the pay someone properly to do that job.
would agency work count? Many qualified teachers graduate without an immediate job and are already paid very poorly to work on supply through an agency. Not all are even eligible to claim UC.
Job applications and job searches take ages. Yes, if people don’t seem to have found a job within a decent time frame they should be expected to take any job - this was expected of me when I was made redundant from a job, am a qualified teacher and was given 3 months to find a teaching specific job or I’d have to take any job. Job centre accepted they’re not equipped to deal with professionals. I took agency work as I’d still earn more than a minimum wage cleaning/waitress type job and it would give me ongoing experience for applying for a teaching job and sometimes my name known in some schools. It would have been extremely hard to get another teaching job if I’d been expected to work full time for jobseekers money in a cleaning/retail job whilst trying to pay childcare for my kids and also write lengthy applications/look round schools etc.

GreyBlossom · 06/10/2022 07:57

Kissingfrogs25 · 06/10/2022 07:51

I am talking about the people that do zero work and have no intention of getting a job, or those doing the absolute bare minimum and exploiting the system. I am certainly NOT talking about those on low pay that work hard, I completely support anyone working.

I don’t feel I share any values whatsoever with someone that takes no responsibility for themselves or their lives. I can’t abide laziness either.

How many of those people exist? How do you decide which ones they are? And if they do what work are you going to make them do and how do you make sure they do it? Managing the whole thing would be hugely expensive.

Kissingfrogs25 · 06/10/2022 07:51

okytdvhuoo · 06/10/2022 07:42

Well… those claiming benefits often are long-time taxpayers. Interesting that you perceive it to be ‘us vs. them’

I am talking about the people that do zero work and have no intention of getting a job, or those doing the absolute bare minimum and exploiting the system. I am certainly NOT talking about those on low pay that work hard, I completely support anyone working.

I don’t feel I share any values whatsoever with someone that takes no responsibility for themselves or their lives. I can’t abide laziness either.

GreyBlossom · 06/10/2022 07:44

What work are they going to do and who for? Especially at the moment, if they're willing and able to be a half way decent employee, there's plenty of unskilled work available.

It's not the same thing, but I have worked with teams of people doing community service and it's really hard work to get any actual work done. If people don't want to be there, they're more of a liability than a help.

That's not to say all unemployed people don't want to work and there might be one or two success stories where they get into a routine, apply themselves and it's a way into work for them, but on the whole, finding them things to do and then monitoring attendance and performance will be more expensive the the benefits IMO.

okytdvhuoo · 06/10/2022 07:42

Kissingfrogs25 · 06/10/2022 07:31

Don’t be preposterous. Most people that work for a living and pay taxes are strangely not keen propping up those that can’t be bothered to get a job ( unless it is people with real disability of course)
It is not exactly breaking news! 😂

Well… those claiming benefits often are long-time taxpayers. Interesting that you perceive it to be ‘us vs. them’

okytdvhuoo · 06/10/2022 07:40

Kissingfrogs25 · 06/10/2022 07:34

I am happy to support any scheme that gets people into jobs - full stop.

It is highly unhealthy to be languishing every day without direction or purpose and relying on other people to pay your bills. It’s not good for anyone and a terrible example to their children.

I agree that it’s not good for your mental health to have nothing to do every day and people do lose confidence when they become unemployed/ get made redundant etc.

So when people get back into these jobs should they be at least paid minimum wage, in your opinion?

rageapplied · 06/10/2022 07:39

Define "real disability" please.

Mumofsend · 06/10/2022 07:38

Kissingfrogs25 · 06/10/2022 07:31

Don’t be preposterous. Most people that work for a living and pay taxes are strangely not keen propping up those that can’t be bothered to get a job ( unless it is people with real disability of course)
It is not exactly breaking news! 😂

You have missed the point. The numbers who fall into that category are minimal yet presented by the tories and media as significant numbers. Funny how they never break the figures down?

In the real world the vast majority on benefits are either disabled, carers or working.

Kissingfrogs25 · 06/10/2022 07:38

It’s ridiculous how some pp on here find the vey idea of working so offensive. Everyone should be working, period.