Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask what you think about ‘work for dole’ idea?

518 replies

WakeUpAndBe · 04/10/2022 10:24

Is it reasonable or unreasonable?

Pros: on the surface it sounds reasonable. Means the public won’t view it as “free money” if people are working 30 hours a week for a lot less than the national living wage.

Cons: risks of exploitation and returning to Charles Dickens’ style workhouses for the poor.

Chris Philp said UC claimants should be forced to ‘work for dole’

“In his paper, Philp suggested those claiming universal credit should, after a certain time, have to work for their benefits if they were employed for less than 30 hours a week. He suggested those claiming benefits for a disability should be given work that they were physically able to do.
^^
“Philp said they could be asked to complete community work such as cleaning graffiti or clearing parks, charity work, supervised job searching or recognised training to top up their hours to 30 a week. He said a referral to the “work for the dole” scheme would be triggered between three months and two years after first claiming depending on previous national insurance contributions.
^^
“If anyone is not compliant with work for the dole activity requirements, they should automatically have all their universal credit payments suspended as long as the person is not working for the dole,” he wrote at the time. “Although the complete suspension of universal credit benefit payments may seem an extreme sanction, the evidence from the US suggests that this is required to make the scheme fully effective.”

Number crunching

The National Living Wage is currently £9.50 x 30 hours x 4 weeks = £1,140 for 4 weeks

According to the website, monthly UC is £265.31 for single and under 25,
£334.91 for single over 25,
£416.45 for couples under 25
and
£525.72 for couples over 25.

OP posts:
Rosehugger · 04/10/2022 11:09

No. If work exists they should be paid at least minimum wage for it. If it's temporary work then she should get paid properly for the hours they worked work then be able to go back straight onto unemployment benefit/UC without this being affected.

WakeUpAndBe · 04/10/2022 11:09

KitchiHuritAngeni · 04/10/2022 11:06

I have a disability, I had to leave my job because of it.

The jobcentre was absolutely horrific. They said I was fully capable of working in my previous, physical role. Despite the fact I had cancer, despite the fact I couldn't move my head, despite the fact I can't move my left arm at all, despite the fact my left leg goes numb and I collapse regularly. They sanctioned me for having hospital appointments a hundred miles away which coincided with the day they wanted to see me, even though I gave them plenty of notice I couldn't attend. They didn't take the side effects of my medication into account and told me if I stopped taking them I would be capable for work so it was my choice. I had numerous letters, evidence and reports from physios, surgeons, doctors and neurologists too but none were accepted as evidence.

They decided I was fully capable of work because I can move one arm above my head. I asked them to tell me what job I could do that entailed me merely lifting one arm and they said that was up to me to find one.

It took a year of tribunals for them to finally acknowledge I couldn't work (that's when I finally got an independent tribunal with a doctor present) Another 6 months after that to finally sort out my money.

During the time it took them to finally acknowledge I couldn't work they would have made me do these jobs.

That system is barbaric and not fit for purpose and this scheme would make it a million times worse.

I’m so sorry that happened to you. Hope you’re ok now xxx 💐

OP posts:
FarmerRefuted · 04/10/2022 11:09

SarahSissions · 04/10/2022 11:07

Work 30 hours a week- I’m on board. For those “on benefits who are already working” if they are only doing 15 hours they can make up the other 15 working for the state before they get any money. for those not working then they can do the full 30.
nothing in this life is free…apart from benefits it seems.
I don’t know why some people find the idea of work so offensive

Because its not work, its forced labour.

PeekAtYou · 04/10/2022 11:07

They've done this before (Workfare) Employers sacked full time MW workers and replaced them with Workfare people then let them go after 6 months and replaced them with a new batch of people.
All work should be paid at least NMW. Tax payer money shouldn't be used to lower wage bills at profitable companies like Tesco. It's bad enough that UC is in effect a subsidy for employers and that MW isn't set at a level that full time workers don't need to claim.

SarahSissions · 04/10/2022 11:07

Work 30 hours a week- I’m on board. For those “on benefits who are already working” if they are only doing 15 hours they can make up the other 15 working for the state before they get any money. for those not working then they can do the full 30.
nothing in this life is free…apart from benefits it seems.
I don’t know why some people find the idea of work so offensive

Getoff · 04/10/2022 11:07

So let's say background unemployment due to job turnover is usually 5%. If unemployment in a particular area temporarily hits 10%, the government could offer a subsidy to employers in that area who expanded the number of minimum-wage employees they have. If people who work have 60% of their UC clawed back for each pound they earn, the government could refund employers half of what they pay out, and still come out ahead. The economy would benefit from the extra economic output, at no overall cost to the government. If/when excess unemployment disappeared in the area, the subsidy scheme would be phased out again.

KitchiHuritAngeni · 04/10/2022 11:06

I have a disability, I had to leave my job because of it.

The jobcentre was absolutely horrific. They said I was fully capable of working in my previous, physical role. Despite the fact I had cancer, despite the fact I couldn't move my head, despite the fact I can't move my left arm at all, despite the fact my left leg goes numb and I collapse regularly. They sanctioned me for having hospital appointments a hundred miles away which coincided with the day they wanted to see me, even though I gave them plenty of notice I couldn't attend. They didn't take the side effects of my medication into account and told me if I stopped taking them I would be capable for work so it was my choice. I had numerous letters, evidence and reports from physios, surgeons, doctors and neurologists too but none were accepted as evidence.

They decided I was fully capable of work because I can move one arm above my head. I asked them to tell me what job I could do that entailed me merely lifting one arm and they said that was up to me to find one.

It took a year of tribunals for them to finally acknowledge I couldn't work (that's when I finally got an independent tribunal with a doctor present) Another 6 months after that to finally sort out my money.

During the time it took them to finally acknowledge I couldn't work they would have made me do these jobs.

That system is barbaric and not fit for purpose and this scheme would make it a million times worse.

FlorettaB · 04/10/2022 11:06

The deserving and undeserving poor. I can’t help but feel that the Tories read A Christmas Carol as a horror story.

OneTC · 04/10/2022 11:05

Let's take viable paid jobs out of the work market and give them to people that don't want them or can't do them.

Those people we just made unemployed to clear the spaces, should they go the front of indentured servitude queue or the back? I mean these are formerly working people so deserve less punishment than the evasive doleys...

FarmerRefuted · 04/10/2022 11:04

TooMuchToDoTooLittleInclination · 04/10/2022 10:54

What is the reality if claiming benefits now?

say you're a 26 year old male, no childcare responsibilities, able bodied, no MH issues.

How much would you get & for how long? What expectations are there of job seeking, taking A job, rather than waiting for a CEO job to come up?

I have just realise that I have absolutely no idea.

Based on a 26yr old man:

recently fallen out of work
living in a rented flat for £400 a month (cheapest private let in my area according to RightMove)
no dependants or partner
no savings
band A council tax

He would be entitled to £170 a week/£680 four weekly.

This is made up of:

£74 universal credit
£77 new style Jobseekers
£19 council tax support

He needs to pay his rent from that, his utilities, his food, clothing, transport, etc.

To ask what you think about ‘work for dole’ idea?
the80sweregreat · 04/10/2022 11:04

Even the most basic online applications need around half a day to fill them in.
If the government know that they can't do both easily , it might work , but many people do have restrictions in place and can't work 30 hours that easily. It has to be fair to each individual
It won't be though :(

BurnDownTheDiscoHangTheDJ · 04/10/2022 11:02

A cynical person might say what a cheap way to get people to do the low paid jobs (eg fruit picking) that no one wants and we used to have immigrant labour for (before freedom of movement was abolished!) But I'm deeply in uncynical so wouldn't say that.

PerkingFaintly · 04/10/2022 11:00

FarmerRefuted · 04/10/2022 10:48

I think one of the pound shops (Pound world?) and Tesco, possibly s couple of other companies too, did this during the days of Workfare. They laid a load of paid staff off and then got the the same staff back for free via Workfare. There were also lots of reports of Workfare staff being treated like shit by companies - not allowed proper breaks, banned from using facilities for "real staff" such as staff rooms and toilets (think it was the pound shop again who were sending Workfare staff to public toilets around the corner because shop toilets were "staff only"), being given all of the shit hours and shit tasks, nd basically being treated like lower class citizens.

Yes, I remember Tesco doing this.

People working for Tesco under Workfare were deemed not employees, and not covered by Health and Safety legislation or Employment legislation.

It got particularly nasty when they Workfared people with poor health – eg a heart condition. For an employee, Tesco would have to do a risk assessment before asking them to run up and down stairs or hump boxes. For a coerced "volunteer" no one took responsibility: not Tesco; not the JobCentre. But the person was threatened with sanctions if they failed to "volunteer".

Awwlookatmybabyspider · 04/10/2022 11:00

OurChristmasMiracle · 04/10/2022 10:57

So if people are expected to be working 30hours a week how are they supposed to job search, complete applications and attend interviews and travel to interviews for paid employment?

Exactly. The powers that be can't have it both ways

Mrsmch123 · 04/10/2022 10:59

I don't think it's the worse idea. Would certainly help weed out the people who take the piss with benefits as they would go and get a "proper" job and be paid for it. The problem is how you figure out who those people are without sending someone who genuinely needs to be on benefits out to do that job

WakeUpAndBe · 04/10/2022 10:59

cawfeee · 04/10/2022 10:46

Pensioners are the largest expense, get them lazy bastards out cleaning graffiti, litter picking for their money.
My dads still working in his 70s, why should his peers not have to do the same.
Wonder why that ones not been suggested.

Pensioners will be protected because they’re statistically more likely to vote Tory.

But you are right… What Chris Philip said about disabled people can also be applied to the elderly too. So, pensions are potentially at risk here too.

OP posts:
Getoff · 04/10/2022 10:58

FrankTheThunderbird · 04/10/2022 10:27

If there's 30 hours of work to do then pay someone to do it. As in a real wage.

I agree with creating work if/when there is a shortage of jobs, but the work must be genuine jobs, even if they are jobs that would only exist temporarily to keep unemployment down. I think the way to do it is by incentivising employers regardless of whether they are public or private sector to create extra jobs. I don't think there's any need to explicitly link these jobs to the benefits system. That already contains mechanisms to persuade people to take available jobs.

OurChristmasMiracle · 04/10/2022 10:57

So if people are expected to be working 30hours a week how are they supposed to job search, complete applications and attend interviews and travel to interviews for paid employment?

Lilyhatesjaz · 04/10/2022 10:56

A lot of these jobs should be done by people paid proper wages.
Time spent completing job applications with someone who can help them, or time training may be more useful, but this needs to be proper useful training eg gaining an IT certificate not like YTS where trainees were used as cheap labour.
A lot of people work part time due to caring responsibilities not because they don't want full-time work and should not be penalised.
I think tax credits are not always a good thing though as they allow big employers to pay low wages and workers are topped up by the tax payer they should have to pay proper wages.

Blueberrywitch · 04/10/2022 10:54

Completely awful idea and a waste of time and resources for the government and people needing income support. Much cheaper and more effective to have a universal basic income rather that all this outdated, stigmatising bullshit.

I say this as someone has been very lucky to have not needed income support yet in my life, but very happy to live in a society that provides a social safety net to all who need it.

walkingonsunshinekat · 04/10/2022 10:54

Icanstillrecallourlastsummer · 04/10/2022 10:51

If it is 30 hrs work they should be paid for 30 hrs work.

I think it some circumstances it's ok. My brother has MH issues and lives in another country where he is in receipt of disability benefits. There they encourage suitable, unpaid work. It's not a condition to the benefits being paid but highly encouraged. It has been great for him, it's given him a purpose, social interaction. work experience and made him feel useful. In return he benefitted those employing him (he worked on a farm for quite a while, where he looked after animals and helped with landscaping type activities).

I don't know if schemes like that exist here, and if they do how widely used they are. But I think they could probably be beneficial to lots of people, especially if applied on a carrot rather than stick basis.

Yes schemes for the disabled to find therapy in work used to exist and Cameron shut them down.

TooMuchToDoTooLittleInclination · 04/10/2022 10:54

What is the reality if claiming benefits now?

say you're a 26 year old male, no childcare responsibilities, able bodied, no MH issues.

How much would you get & for how long? What expectations are there of job seeking, taking A job, rather than waiting for a CEO job to come up?

I have just realise that I have absolutely no idea.

Octomore · 04/10/2022 10:54

OneTC · 04/10/2022 10:37

I don't see why not

Because it's a stupid, corrupt and immoral solution to a problem that only exists in the eyes of morons

Well said

AuntSalli · 04/10/2022 10:53

MsPincher · 04/10/2022 10:43

I think one of the most notable things last time was that large number of people stopped claiming when asked to work. This indicated they were working cash in hand.

I wouldn’t object to some suitable work for people not working and assessed as able to work. Being out of work long term is not good for people.

So what exactly do you think you could do for a living that would be cash in hand ?

and reliably provide you with £1000 a month income which is what you would need to not be on benefits.

my deep concern following the case of in Liverpool of that poor little girl that was shot in her own home is the most lucrative cash in hand job I can think of is drug running. My sister works in social services and I’m reliably told that provides about £30 a go, three or four of those a day and you’re laughing providing you don’t need to use the gun you’ve been issued with.

walkingonsunshinekat · 04/10/2022 10:53

Funny how this proposal is from multi millionaire Chris Philp, the same Philp that came up with the idea of the cut to higher rate income tax.

The whole leadership of the Tory party is in the hands of the Tax Payers Alliance, a far right unelected think tank, that makes people like Meloni or Le Pen look like Corbynites.

He wouldn't work for a few pence an hour, so why should anyone else who finds themselves unemployed?

Swipe left for the next trending thread