Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask what you think about ‘work for dole’ idea?

518 replies

WakeUpAndBe · 04/10/2022 10:24

Is it reasonable or unreasonable?

Pros: on the surface it sounds reasonable. Means the public won’t view it as “free money” if people are working 30 hours a week for a lot less than the national living wage.

Cons: risks of exploitation and returning to Charles Dickens’ style workhouses for the poor.

Chris Philp said UC claimants should be forced to ‘work for dole’

“In his paper, Philp suggested those claiming universal credit should, after a certain time, have to work for their benefits if they were employed for less than 30 hours a week. He suggested those claiming benefits for a disability should be given work that they were physically able to do.
^^
“Philp said they could be asked to complete community work such as cleaning graffiti or clearing parks, charity work, supervised job searching or recognised training to top up their hours to 30 a week. He said a referral to the “work for the dole” scheme would be triggered between three months and two years after first claiming depending on previous national insurance contributions.
^^
“If anyone is not compliant with work for the dole activity requirements, they should automatically have all their universal credit payments suspended as long as the person is not working for the dole,” he wrote at the time. “Although the complete suspension of universal credit benefit payments may seem an extreme sanction, the evidence from the US suggests that this is required to make the scheme fully effective.”

Number crunching

The National Living Wage is currently £9.50 x 30 hours x 4 weeks = £1,140 for 4 weeks

According to the website, monthly UC is £265.31 for single and under 25,
£334.91 for single over 25,
£416.45 for couples under 25
and
£525.72 for couples over 25.

OP posts:
CosyDarkNights · 04/10/2022 12:08

Why not pay people properly to do those jobs so that the people doing them can afford to live? Taking benefits from people unless they agree to be exploited is gross. Some people probably are workshy if they see little financial benefit in working. That doesn't give permission to exploit them though. Up the minimum wage, make people want to work their way out of poverty that way. Some people will no doubt be judged fit to work when they can't and plunged into even more poverty, this increases ill health and then just costs more in healthcare on the NHS...

It's a no from me.

Floydthebarber · 04/10/2022 12:08

He is being unreasonable for referring to 'dole'. Does he think people still queue up for their giros each week?

itbemay · 04/10/2022 12:08

FrankTheThunderbird · 04/10/2022 10:27

If there's 30 hours of work to do then pay someone to do it. As in a real wage.

This!

ancientgran · 04/10/2022 12:08

I don't think it is a good idea or workable. The only exception I think might work is for teenagers who've never had a job. A suitable work experience position where the company they are working for puts in some real support might be a good idea. They'd get some experience, a reference and they might get a job if they do well. I think they should get an extra payment on top of benefits though because going to work costs money, travel/appropriate clothing etc.

WatchoRulo · 04/10/2022 12:08

Octomore · 04/10/2022 12:04

But also 100% predictable.

What a normal person sees as an unintended disadvantage of the scheme was in fact the whole purpose of it. It was primarily a tory bung to large corporates which had the additional 'advantage' of being acceptable to the Daily Mail hate crowd.

Exactly - it's win-win for nasty people with or without brainpower.

VickyEadieofThigh · 04/10/2022 12:07

Dotjones · 04/10/2022 10:35

People who can work should be made to work in return for benefit payments. However, they should be paid the living wage. If a job needs doing, pay someone properly to do it.

That would be giving them a job, therefore.

I've been around many decades and have seen Tory goverments trot these kind of 'appeal to the hard of thinking' "ideas" out on many occasions.

Anyone who cannot see that this kind of "idea" actually leads to more unemployment, not less, is deluded.

WatchoRulo · 04/10/2022 12:07

Doesn't anyone else find ironic that it's a Tory idea to introduce communist-style full employment?

Octomore · 04/10/2022 12:04

okytdvhuoo · 04/10/2022 11:58

Wow this is utterly disgusting. Ethically bankrupt.

But also 100% predictable.

What a normal person sees as an unintended disadvantage of the scheme was in fact the whole purpose of it. It was primarily a tory bung to large corporates which had the additional 'advantage' of being acceptable to the Daily Mail hate crowd.

WahineToa · 04/10/2022 12:04

They had this in NZ & Australia. The NZ Labour government have something called ‘ Mana in Mahi’ ( mahi means work ) and they subsidise jobs and apprenticeships for young people on the dole. You may think the employer is getting too much for free, but not every business owner is rich and the government helps both business growth and the young person training. You obviously only get to be part of the scheme, both as the unemployed person or business, if you meet certain criteria.
when I was on the dole in NZ I was made to go to job workshops that lasted all day every day or work in jobs they had to fill. To be honest, it made me push myself into something I wanted to do rather than feeling like I was being punished because I had abusive parents and got kicked out at 16! I didn’t like the scheme but tbh I was not putting enough effort into sorting myself out before they made me.

JustLyra · 04/10/2022 12:02

Given that most people on UC already work and just don’t get paid enough it amazes me that anyone could fail to see this for what it is.

It’s another way to funnel money to businesses.

Why does anyone think it’s a good idea for taxpayers to pay more for Tesco/Poundland/YMCA/Others to have staff they’re more than capable of affording themselves?

RC1234 · 04/10/2022 12:01

It sounds dodgy as hell. How can you justify forcing people to work for less than the minimum wage (because 30 hours a week for the equivalent of JSA or whatever it is called now is not minimum wage)? What will happen is that we all get laid off and forced to work for pennies by unscrupelous employers (the decent employers will go out of business because they can't compete).

OneTC · 04/10/2022 12:01

WakeUpAndBe · 04/10/2022 11:58

This is the biggest problem. It’ll have knock on effects to workers who will lose their jobs to freebie workers on benefits.

From a business viewpoint it is genius. Just think how much can be saved in salaries?

Swerving on the employer contributions is the really attractive part. The reality is these companies could pay nmw out of their own pocket and the taxpayer could pick up the benefits part and they'd still be quids in.

And people support them getting an even better deal than that

JustLyra · 04/10/2022 12:01

roarfeckingroarr · 04/10/2022 11:59

@FlorettaB it's just a name. Community work, community service, community contribution - call it what you like. If the logistics could be sorted so it wasn't a burden on charities, I think expecting people to make a contribution for the money and housing benefit they receive (10 hrs or so each week) is reasonable in principle.

The contribution they should make is full time job hunting and being on said benefits for as short a time as possible.

AsAnyFuleKno · 04/10/2022 12:00

If the job exists, pay someone a proper wage to do it

This - nothing more to be said.

roarfeckingroarr · 04/10/2022 11:59

@FlorettaB it's just a name. Community work, community service, community contribution - call it what you like. If the logistics could be sorted so it wasn't a burden on charities, I think expecting people to make a contribution for the money and housing benefit they receive (10 hrs or so each week) is reasonable in principle.

okytdvhuoo · 04/10/2022 11:58

JustLyra · 04/10/2022 11:56

Exactly. It was massively exploited by big companies.

And it did people no favours in terms of references as they had to come up with an issue to show why they hadn’t employed them after the six months.

Wow this is utterly disgusting. Ethically bankrupt.

IncompleteSenten · 04/10/2022 11:58

No fucking way.

Either there is a job, in which case the company should hire someone and pay them fairly or there is no job and any 'work' being undertaken in return for benefits should be living wage, something benefitting the community not a company, a reasonable travelling distance, suitable for the person's skills and abilities and with exemptions for certain groups of people.

WakeUpAndBe · 04/10/2022 11:58

Kendodd · 04/10/2022 11:55

I bet employers love it.
The Tory party pitches itself as the party for business, donors have their ear. I'm sure they'd be delighted to have a supply of labour that they don't even have to pay.

This is the biggest problem. It’ll have knock on effects to workers who will lose their jobs to freebie workers on benefits.

From a business viewpoint it is genius. Just think how much can be saved in salaries?

OP posts:
MsPincher · 04/10/2022 11:57

roarfeckingroarr · 04/10/2022 11:50

I support it for those who are not working at least 20 hours per week IF ABLE, no small children etc. But for, say, 10 hours a week so it's not exploitative for the money (keeping in mind that many on UC will get housing benefit on top of that, plus discounts on CT) and doing things to support the community like mowing the lawn, volunteering, helping out at a food bank, rather than for private companies.

Yes I agree with this. I don’t think anything wrong with people claiming being asked to volunteer in certain circumstances.

caringcarer · 04/10/2022 11:57

@WakeUpAndBe, I think Truss has said Pensions, Disability payments and Carers Allowance will go up in line with inflation but other benefits have not been decided upon yet. Many single working people working 50 hours a week have only got a 2 percent pay rise this year. These people may not be happy to see their taxes go to give those we other not working or only working up to 12 hours a week a 10 percent pay increase. I heard this argument made on radio this morning by a single working man working 50 hours each week to pay his bills.

victoriacrosshairs · 04/10/2022 11:57

Nothing about being given work you can't mentally cope with if you're disabled I see.

And as others have said. It was done before. Workfare.

If the job exists, pay someone a proper wage to do it

JustLyra · 04/10/2022 11:56

FlorettaB · 04/10/2022 11:54

*’My niece worked full time hours in an out of school care setting. Mornings and after school. For £60ish a week. Twice she was sanctioned for taking a day off (with advance notice) to attend interviews. For five months she was given glowing reviews. Then, unsurprisingly, in the last month they decided she wasn’t a good fit in their team. So “regretfully” didn’t offer her the job full time at the end of the six months. Instead they got a new freebie from the scheme for another six month trial.

Less than a month after she was deemed unsuitable she got a call from them when someone unexpectedly quit. She was back to being a superb worker again and they wanted her full time.’*

Now you’ve sad that JustLyra I’m remembering a company that usually took on hundreds of extra workers every year over the Christmas period that didn’t need to bother under that scheme. If there’s an hour’s work that needs doing and you have to pay a normal worker £9.50 an hour and a ‘Welfare to Work’ person can’t get more than £60 a week, who will the company choose?

Exactly. It was massively exploited by big companies.

And it did people no favours in terms of references as they had to come up with an issue to show why they hadn’t employed them after the six months.

roarfeckingroarr · 04/10/2022 11:55

Private companies * not customers

FlorettaB · 04/10/2022 11:55

Heilalala · 04/10/2022 11:53

Community Service is for people who done crimes.

Wrong. Lots of people in full time employment volunteer in all kind of community roles for no payment. These are the kind of activities people can participate in - providing benefit to the community. Plenty of time to search for jobs around that.

That’s volunteering. When you have to do the work or face legal sanction, that’s Community Service.

OneTC · 04/10/2022 11:55

I mean let's be honest community service already takes away paid roles