Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Should I report this dog for biting DH?

119 replies

heldinadream · 04/10/2022 10:17

Posting in AIBU for full range of opinions.
We live in a village. We’re having our bathroom done so are temporarily without a bath or shower, and some people we know (but not well) very kindly said we could use one of theirs, we’ve got a key and freedom to come and go.
All good and lovely. Incredibly kind of them.

They have a very large garden and a dog that runs free in the garden.
I went a couple of times to use the shower and I wasn’t comfortable with the dog, who looked at me suspiciously and followed me, so I stopped going and I’ve managed without and also spent time away so I can shower elsewhere (yes it’s taking a ridiculously long time but that’s another story!).
Anyway long story short my DH, who has happily gone there probably a good 20 times now, was chatting to one of the parents of one of the owners a couple of days ago and the dog approached him and bit him, through his trousers, unprovoked in any way as far as I can tell, skin not really broken but a massive blood clot thing just under the skin and a bruise.

Obviously DH – completely unfazed, because that’s him – has told them, they are upset and apologetic but also were concerned that we don’t report it, AND have admitted it’s not the first time dog has bitten. Second time IF they are being straight with us. DH not only happy to let it go but fully intends to go shower again and just says he’ll avoid the dog if necessary! I’m like – how? What if the dog follows you?

The people themselves are almost never there when we go, by the way.
The more I think about it, the more inclined I am to want to report the dog. But – it is in its own garden. And I really don’t want to upset these people, who are both nice but also pretty kind of powerful locally – unlike me, I’m an invisible sort. But I’m cross they think it’s ok to have the dog run free and yet gaily say to people to just come in, and presumably people who deliver stuff have to run the gamut of the dog, too.
AIBU to even consider reporting the dog?

OP posts:
Littleheart5 · 04/10/2022 14:04

These people have been exceptionally good to you and you’re considering reporting them. Honestly, stop going over for showers, have a chat with them and leave it there. Do not report to authorities FFS

Tha · 04/10/2022 13:38

Dog lovers are quite honestly not right in the head.

I don't love dogs, don't even like them really, but I wouldn't ever have a dog put down because it bit me once in his own garden not even hard enough to break the skin. And I ESPECIALLY would not if their owners had been kind enough to offer me their bathroom for months on end.

A dangerous out of control dog attacking unprovoked is a different thing entirely.

2bazookas · 04/10/2022 13:35

That would be an incredibly rude and unkind thing to do to such generous neighbours.

YellowTreeHouse · 04/10/2022 13:32

Grandeur · 04/10/2022 13:18

Seeing as you own a dog yourself, you should know that training and/or a dog behavioural expert can be perfectly sufficient then?

I await your response.

I don’t own a dog.

This dog has bitten twice. It is dangerous and should be put down before it does it again.

cindyhove · 04/10/2022 13:29

No!

Grandeur · 04/10/2022 13:18

YellowTreeHouse · 04/10/2022 13:11

Yes we do, it’s a German Shepard.

The dog was not caught off guard and the DH is not a stranger - he’s been going there since May. Stop making excuses.

Seeing as you own a dog yourself, you should know that training and/or a dog behavioural expert can be perfectly sufficient then?

I await your response.

YellowTreeHouse · 04/10/2022 13:11

coffeeandpoetry · 04/10/2022 13:06

Honestly it's YOU being ridiculous here. The dog was in its own home, minding its own business and was caught off guard by stranger invading their space. Of course it shouldn't be reported and immediately destroyed. We don't even know what the breed is Hmm
If you knew anything about dogs then you'd know overly territorial/protective behaviour can be quite common. Training and a dog behavioural expert can be perfectly sufficient.
Your post is extremely ignorant.

Yes we do, it’s a German Shepard.

The dog was not caught off guard and the DH is not a stranger - he’s been going there since May. Stop making excuses.

Yack02 · 04/10/2022 13:11

I think you've all acted irresponsibly to be honest. Show me a dog who wouldn't be wary of two strangers entering its home when the owners aren't present.

This was a silly arrangement, the only one who isn't at fault is the dog imo! Who had no choice in it in the first place!

I can't believe you would consider reporting it either. To who? The police? As if they're going to do anything. There is major crime happening that isn't even being dealt with, never mind a completely preventable situation.

The only decent thing to do is say, thanks very much for letting us use your shower, but as the dog is clearly uncomfortable with us being there, as it bit my husband, we won't be coming over any more.

TooMuchToDoTooLittleInclination · 04/10/2022 13:07

Octomore · 04/10/2022 11:27

This dig snapped at your oh. It was his home, a stranger showing up, his owners not there.

The owners' parents were there.

So? They're not his owners/the home owners.

people are in his house, he didn't attack anyone.

the owners aren't being responsible, they shouldn't allow people who can't sort their own lives out, to use their home because it's stressing their dog out.

but the dog nipped your DH, you weren't there, he doesn't want to report it....I think you should keep your nose out.

coffeeandpoetry · 04/10/2022 13:06

YellowTreeHouse · 04/10/2022 12:57

Oh don’t be so ridiculous. You cannot compare humans and animals. The dog is an animal. It is dangerous and should be destroyed.

Dog lovers are quite honestly not right in the head.

Honestly it's YOU being ridiculous here. The dog was in its own home, minding its own business and was caught off guard by stranger invading their space. Of course it shouldn't be reported and immediately destroyed. We don't even know what the breed is Hmm
If you knew anything about dogs then you'd know overly territorial/protective behaviour can be quite common. Training and a dog behavioural expert can be perfectly sufficient.
Your post is extremely ignorant.

mountainsunsets · 04/10/2022 12:58

vivainsomnia · 04/10/2022 12:54

The fact that the dog has bitten before makes it 100 times worse
The dog didn't bite, it nipped. Not even blood! Don't you think that if the German shepherd meant to be aggressive, he wouldn't have done more damage going for a real bite!

It doesn't matter whether there was blood or not. It still bit someone, and it bit them hard enough to leave a mark and a bruise.

The owners also know the dog has bitten before and they knew that OP and her husband were going to be coming in and out of their home.

And yet they still chose to have the dog free-roaming and in areas where it could get to them and bite them. That's incredibly irresponsible behaviour. Either you shut the dog away or only allow visitors into the home when you're around to hold and control the dog.

According to the law, any dog that bites a human on public or private property is classed as out of control. In fact, dogs don't even need to bite to be considered a danger anymore.

YellowTreeHouse · 04/10/2022 12:57

vivainsomnia · 04/10/2022 12:52

It is violent, aggressive, unpredictable and needs to be put down
Dies this apply to humans? Ifa friend of your husband came to you, in your garden, when your back is turned, and when they come to touch, you turn around abruptly and doing so punch them in the nose.

Does this make you a violent, aggressive, unpredictable person who should be sent to jail forever!

Total over dramatisation!

Oh don’t be so ridiculous. You cannot compare humans and animals. The dog is an animal. It is dangerous and should be destroyed.

Dog lovers are quite honestly not right in the head.

Ylvamoon · 04/10/2022 12:55

If this dog wanted to bite, OP'S DH would have a chunk of his leg missing.

I also think that we should know about the breed/ type of dog. Any guard dog breeds will be prone to nipping if they feel their home is threatened.

The dog was clearly guarding the home, and reacted on instinct.

I'd stop going as to not provoke the dog any further.

vivainsomnia · 04/10/2022 12:54

The fact that the dog has bitten before makes it 100 times worse
The dog didn't bite, it nipped. Not even blood! Don't you think that if the German shepherd meant to be aggressive, he wouldn't have done more damage going for a real bite!

FlorettaB · 04/10/2022 12:53

I wouldn’t report it but I would have a serious word with the owners about keeping the dog away from people and muzzle training it for out of the house.

TooHotToTangoToo · 04/10/2022 12:52

It's your dh decision if he wants to take it further or not.
If you feel that strongly about it talk to the owners before you report. (Personally I'd not report)

vivainsomnia · 04/10/2022 12:52

It is violent, aggressive, unpredictable and needs to be put down
Dies this apply to humans? Ifa friend of your husband came to you, in your garden, when your back is turned, and when they come to touch, you turn around abruptly and doing so punch them in the nose.

Does this make you a violent, aggressive, unpredictable person who should be sent to jail forever!

Total over dramatisation!

YouSirNeighMmmm · 04/10/2022 12:51

Random789 · 04/10/2022 12:46

And the 'what if he attacked a child' always seems to come from a complete failure to understand that each dog is an individual and presents his/her own particular range of risks. This dog bit an adult man who repeatedly (from the dog's point of view) 'invades' its property. That is a very specific set of circumstances. If I panicked and bopped a man that I mistakenly thought was following me, for example, would it mean that I might attack a child?

What if the next person to invade is a small child retrieving a ball? The dog is dangerous and needs destroying.

YouSirNeighMmmm · 04/10/2022 12:50

Octomore · 04/10/2022 10:28

I would report it. It's not the first time it has bitten, and it could be a child next. I wouldn't want that on my conscience.

100%. The owners should never have given you a key to their home unless they were 100% sure that the dog was safe. It is irrelevant it is in their house, they have allowed their dog to bite someone.

What would people say if they've given them a key and not mentioned that the gas was leaking and the house could explode at any minute? What if OP was saying "it was kind of them to let us use their house, but now my husband is dead due to a massive explosion". Would people say "they are kind, it's their hosue, chill out"? No. Just because you are doing someone a favour doesn't mean you can ignore basic health and safety.

The fact that the dog has bitten before makes it 100 times worse.

Unforgettablefire · 04/10/2022 12:49

Random789 · 04/10/2022 12:46

And the 'what if he attacked a child' always seems to come from a complete failure to understand that each dog is an individual and presents his/her own particular range of risks. This dog bit an adult man who repeatedly (from the dog's point of view) 'invades' its property. That is a very specific set of circumstances. If I panicked and bopped a man that I mistakenly thought was following me, for example, would it mean that I might attack a child?

This.

vivainsomnia · 04/10/2022 12:49

Oops! Or other animals, pin them down, attack them, causing serious damage or worse do get put down, not those who just nip a stranger in their house.

vivainsomnia · 04/10/2022 12:47

Bitey dog gets put to sleep
No they certainly don't. Aggressive dogs, who jump on people or o

Random789 · 04/10/2022 12:46

And the 'what if he attacked a child' always seems to come from a complete failure to understand that each dog is an individual and presents his/her own particular range of risks. This dog bit an adult man who repeatedly (from the dog's point of view) 'invades' its property. That is a very specific set of circumstances. If I panicked and bopped a man that I mistakenly thought was following me, for example, would it mean that I might attack a child?

Mammed · 04/10/2022 12:44

Not the same thing at all but...
We adopted a dog when I was a teenager from the local dogs home, he was a very large breed and after a few months became very protective of our house and especially of my younger brother and I.
He was muzzled whenever we went out, and we didn't have visitors without putting him in his crate first.

The woman who lived next door (terraced houses) had a son who was a drug addict, one day when I was 16, I was alone in the house, her son came stumbling into our house by mistake, our dog attacked him quite badly, luckily he managed to get back outside and close the door but he was in hospital for a while and was physically scarred for life.
His mum did everything to try and get our dog put down but the police wouldn't even entertain the idea, because essentially her son was trespassing.

I do remember them warning us though that if our dog went on to attack a family member or any other visitor we'd invited into the house then it was pretty much dead certain that he'd be destroyed and my parents could be prosecuted.

YellowTreeHouse · 04/10/2022 12:41

Mercurial123 · 04/10/2022 12:37

Great everyone's happy. The OP's husband was willing to go back so he's not concerned.

Well no, I’m sure they wouldn’t be so happy about having to give up their dangerous dog.

If the OP doesn’t report it and a child gets bitten they would be equally as responsible for knowing there’s a dangerous dog and not acting upon it.

If the dog owners cared so much they would have addressed the situation already given the previous bite. They haven’t, so they only have themselves to blame.