Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

See all MNHQ comments on this thread

Have people forgotten "Be Kind"

141 replies

Steppymum · 04/10/2022 08:29

I only joined mumsnet recently. I've been a stepmum for around 2 years so relatively new to the role. I thought joining mumsnet would be good for getting advice and tips as well as venting about some of the stresses of parenting amd everyday life.

I've started 2 threads about 2 separate topics and commented on others posts. Of course eveyone is entitled to their opinions and it's always good to get another perspective. But within a week I've been called a cunt, an arsehole, told I don't deserve friends, I'm too involved with my DSD, my DSDs care is non of my business, I sounds like an nightmare etc. etc.

Of course there have been some positive comments as well but it's the negative ones that always stick. If people think I'm being unreasonable I'm happy to hear their reason but I think calling a stranger a cunt etc is unnecessary. People seem to read part of the post, miss out a chunk, make assumptions and twist every word you say. And it seems as a stepmum I'm already public enemy number one. 🤣

How have other people found the site? Am I just being too soft? Is it worth sticking around?

OP posts:
InCheesusWeTrust · 04/10/2022 10:40

You need to post in correct topics much calmer outside aibu

Steppymum · 04/10/2022 10:38

AmaryllisNightAndDay · 04/10/2022 09:18

should I just expect to be called names from total strangers?

Yes you should expect it, this is the InterNet. Some strategies:

  1. See what the general tone is on the MN board you want to post to. The boards are very different here. e.g. AIBU is very combative, Behaviour & Development more thoughtful and supportive.
  2. See which topics, opinions and wordings from other people have already led to flames on the board that you want to post to.
  3. Do not start "light-hearted" threads unless you are prepared to manage flames. What is"light-hearted" to one person easily comes across as dismissive or insulting to another.
  4. Remember that you are not just talking to the people you can "see" as posters, there will be far more people just reading and your light-hearted post that goes down well among the usual posters may offend the others. You may or may not care what they think!
  5. Be especially careful what you say about sensitive topics like step-parenting. It's up to you but I wouldn't make jokes or light-hearted remarks about it online.
  6. Apologise if you accidentally caused offence. And not a defensive "I was only joking can't you take a joke how could you take it to heart" type non-apology. That only feeds the flames.
  7. Don't respond to name-calling and personal abuse. Ignore the post. Any response to name-calling just feeds the flames.
  8. Report all posts with name-calling and personal abuse. MumsNet will delete them but someone has to report and that someone is probably going to have to be you.
I hope this helps, good luck!

Thank you. Some great advice 😊

OP posts:
TheGoodFighter · 04/10/2022 10:37

HRTQueen · 04/10/2022 10:34

There are some nasty bullies on MN they are like sheep one starts and others follow

often quite manipulative with their responses

it will get defended as well this is AIBU and if you can’t handle the truth. It’s all about honesty here nonsense

as we have already seen today …..

There are no bullies. You cant bully via anonymous words on a screen to other anonymous words on a screen.
Anyone who feels bullied needs to grow up and close the site until they get over themselves.

MayThe4th · 04/10/2022 10:37

There’s no way a comment calling someone a cunt would be left to stand by MNHQ.

So did you report it OP? Did someone else? A comment like that would 100% have been deleted.

While I don’t believe that personal attacks are ok, and there absolutely are threads where people are rounded on, it’s impossible to say whether your situation is one which merited some straight talking rather than hugs and unconditional support.

If you’ve posted 2 threads on here and have had a hard time on both, and have had a hard time when replying to other threads, then I’d suggest there is more here which you’re not saying.

And while it doesn’t justify calling you a cunt (if that actually happened), then the truth is that you can’t expect all agreement all of the time.

FWIW I don’t subscribe to the view that posting on AIBU makes you ripe for a kicking either. AIBU should be got rid of IMO. But there are definitely threads where people post the most outragious things and then cry “bullying” when people don’t agree with them.

Doingprettywellthanks · 04/10/2022 10:36

Steppymum · 04/10/2022 08:51

I'm not expecting them too like I explained. But should I just expect to be called names from total strangers?

It would be interesting to have links to the threads you started…

HRTQueen · 04/10/2022 10:34

There are some nasty bullies on MN they are like sheep one starts and others follow

often quite manipulative with their responses

it will get defended as well this is AIBU and if you can’t handle the truth. It’s all about honesty here nonsense

as we have already seen today …..

BamBamBilla · 04/10/2022 10:33

I think BeKind is as enraging as the 'Keep Calm and..' or the 'Smile love, it might never happen'.

Bullshit aggressive sayings used to keep, usually women, quiet and in their place.

Hoppinggreen · 04/10/2022 10:23

Doingprettywellthanks · 04/10/2022 08:36

I certainly hope the “Be Kind” nonsense has died a death.

Same here
I will be kind to people who deserve it, I won’t let people get away with shit just because it’s “kind” to do so

AmaryllisNightAndDay · 04/10/2022 10:22

I've been on social media since before it was called social media and I've seen that anyone can go on the attack or get sucked into a flame war or a pile-on. There will be some topic that is personally painful, some wording that irritates, some day when we're feeling reactive. It's not usually a personality thing.

And you can't expect to have a mature argument and vent your feelings. If you vent yours then other people will vent theirs back at you. And it will probably escalate.

Harridan1981 · 04/10/2022 10:11

Depends. Were you being a cunt?

Context is everything.

WeBuiltThisBuffetOnSausageRoll · 04/10/2022 10:07

You get Be Kind bollocks anywhere.Some of us appreciate a site that you can be a fully fledged adult and speak like one. Of you're being a total cunt, sometimes you need to be told, simple as that.

Yes, a fully fledged adult, but that isn't the same as a fully-fledged arsehole.

I've no problem at all with strong words and criticisms when merited, but if somebody's whole repertoire of human communication is going for the jugular, without any range or nuance of expression and conveying differing emotions and feelings, they just become the linguistic equivalent of the boy who cried wolf; like those people who use swear words instead of punctuation, every other word, and you quickly just give up on trying to filter out what they're actually trying to say.

I think the same about parents who never speak to their kids, but only ever shout at them. Maybe they think it's an ongoing demonstration of their parental authority (personally, I find it abusive); but if it's your default, what do you have left when you DO need to shout/berate/discipline them?

GonnaGetGoingReturns · 04/10/2022 09:53

I find 'Be Kind' to be honest works both ways. You get people using it as a phrase when you know they're not really that way in real life.

I can't stand the phrase now. Either follow it up with a 'Be Kind' action and mean it or just bugger off.

Steppymum · 04/10/2022 09:53

LadyVic · 04/10/2022 09:43

Yes, everyone has stopped using #bekind, and everyone seems to have forgotten the reason it started in the first place. People seem to have forgotten that words said, words typed hurt. No one knows why someone has posted on MN, or on any social media platform. Sometimes its not as clear as it might seem. Yet the ones who take delight in being abusive, 'taking someone down a peg' or however they want to explain just nastiness and bullying. I have been subject to some very nasty comments, not just here but on other platforms aswell as my opinion wasnt the same as others, and calling out bullies, and bullying behaviour is likely to lose me a role I love and have done for years. I do wonder how many deaths it will take to make people think about what they are typing

I mean it's absolutely impossible sometimes to give the full backstory without writing a novel so you try to summarise and folk jump to conclusions and fill in any gaps themselves. Even when you try to go into more detail to explain, it's not good enough as they've already made up their mind.

OP posts:
TheGoodFighter · 04/10/2022 09:52

You get Be Kind bollocks anywhere.Some of us appreciate a site that you can be a fully fledged adult and speak like one. Of you're being a total cunt, sometimes you need to be told, simple as that.

Rainbowbaby13 · 04/10/2022 09:52

Keyboard warriors are the worst I bet they wouldn't have the balls to be that rude to your face. Some people just love being rude/mean must get some sort of kick out of it.

Karma is a bitch though so I'm sure they'll get there's at some point we can but hope

As previous posters have said step mums get a bad response on here no matter how good your relationship with step child

Pretty sure there's lots of bitter and twisted people say behind these keyboards

Steppymum · 04/10/2022 09:49

ArcaneWireless · 04/10/2022 09:40

Know that you will get some fabulous advice here. Over the years I’ve had tremendous help and support.

You just have to filter out those who are here for the drama. Don’t give up yet.

Thanks that's reassuring to know. 😊

OP posts:
Bettyboop3 · 04/10/2022 09:49

Shoxfordian · 04/10/2022 08:39

If you’re going to start a thread then not everyone is going to agree with you op

Big difference between not agreeing and calling someone a cunt that deserves no friends.

WalkthisWayUK · 04/10/2022 09:47

If it’s about being a step mum, it’s brutal on here!

I was a step mum going through hell, with some really awful experiences but they weigh in heavily here on mumsnet on certain topics.

On the other hand - I used it as a way of growing a thicker skin in some ways - and got some absolutely amazing advice when I learned to ignore the horrible comments. It can be done and there are ways of phrasing the original posts to stop a lot of the unkind comments. But yeah, some people here are arseholes frankly. Really nasty in a way that I hope to god they aren’t in real life.

LadyVic · 04/10/2022 09:43

Yes, everyone has stopped using #bekind, and everyone seems to have forgotten the reason it started in the first place. People seem to have forgotten that words said, words typed hurt. No one knows why someone has posted on MN, or on any social media platform. Sometimes its not as clear as it might seem. Yet the ones who take delight in being abusive, 'taking someone down a peg' or however they want to explain just nastiness and bullying. I have been subject to some very nasty comments, not just here but on other platforms aswell as my opinion wasnt the same as others, and calling out bullies, and bullying behaviour is likely to lose me a role I love and have done for years. I do wonder how many deaths it will take to make people think about what they are typing

ArcaneWireless · 04/10/2022 09:40

Know that you will get some fabulous advice here. Over the years I’ve had tremendous help and support.

You just have to filter out those who are here for the drama. Don’t give up yet.

Steppymum · 04/10/2022 09:40

WeBuiltThisBuffetOnSausageRoll · 04/10/2022 09:33

I agree with you, OP - the actual being kind, respectful and genuine rather than just the hashtag.

I left and became a lurker for a couple of months earlier this year, as I just got so irritated with certain people waiting to start an argument and be nasty over nothing. Like most people on here, I relish a proper discussion, and I'm more than happy to be challenged by views that are very different from my own. We're also not children on here, so fair criticism and huge disagreement is par for the course.

It's just the people - probably former school bullies - who are not interested in thoughtful, intelligent discussion and interaction, but just dominating, gratuitous ad hominem attacks and the online equivalent of a punch-up behind the bike-sheds.

It's a shame they can't all set up their own forum where they can all just call each other names and shout "Your mum", believing it to be hilarious; and leave MN for the many people, from all backgrounds and with all kinds of perspectives, who genuinely want a discussion forum for grown-ups.

It's the sheer numer of people who behave like this that has shocked me. Like "there's always one" but jeezo it's rife on here!

Even the response to basically asking if it's too much to ask not to be called a cunt by strangers has an overwhelming vote for yes. I don't think this is the forum for me to be honest.

OP posts:
WeBuiltThisBuffetOnSausageRoll · 04/10/2022 09:38

I also think the word 'kind' is widely misused as a synonym for 'doormat'. It's perfectly possible to be kind but totally unyielding to pressure to ignore/hide your own beliefs and standpoints.

Often, it's not what you say, but how you convey it.

Steppymum · 04/10/2022 09:35

ArcaneWireless · 04/10/2022 09:23

I don’t subscribe to ‘be kind’ either. It is a mealie mouthed way of shutting people down. There is a reason why people have honed in on that phrase OP.

I’m happier with ‘don’t be an absolute cunt’ rather than ‘be kind’.

I’ve been called left right and centre on here lately for something that didn’t actually happen the way the bandwagon jumpers have decided it did. And they won’t let it drop because they are high on the drama.

It says more about them than it ever will about me.

Folk will be forthright in their opinions. And that is appreciated by a lot of folk. But if some chose to be arseholes and personal? Try to let it slide past you. Gobshites are going to gobshite.

Gaspanic’s pub description is pretty much bob on.

Agreed, maybe "Don't be an absolute cunt" would have been more suitable but then I didn't really want to be calling people cunts either.

I'm sorry you've been treated like this. It seems that all it takes is for one person to be rude and all the others pile on.

I probably should have done some research before I joined. I've been a member of other forums before but never seen comments quite like the ones on mumsnet.

OP posts:
WeBuiltThisBuffetOnSausageRoll · 04/10/2022 09:33

I agree with you, OP - the actual being kind, respectful and genuine rather than just the hashtag.

I left and became a lurker for a couple of months earlier this year, as I just got so irritated with certain people waiting to start an argument and be nasty over nothing. Like most people on here, I relish a proper discussion, and I'm more than happy to be challenged by views that are very different from my own. We're also not children on here, so fair criticism and huge disagreement is par for the course.

It's just the people - probably former school bullies - who are not interested in thoughtful, intelligent discussion and interaction, but just dominating, gratuitous ad hominem attacks and the online equivalent of a punch-up behind the bike-sheds.

It's a shame they can't all set up their own forum where they can all just call each other names and shout "Your mum", believing it to be hilarious; and leave MN for the many people, from all backgrounds and with all kinds of perspectives, who genuinely want a discussion forum for grown-ups.

Octomore · 04/10/2022 09:28

butterfliedtwo · 04/10/2022 08:44

Be Kind is a load of bollocks quoting a domestic abuser. It’s brainless and used to shut down discussion and silence women..

This is it.

100%

There are occasions where kindness is the required thing. And other occasions where straight talking (not abusive, but blunt if necessary) is more appropriate.

You see it in many environments. For example, women have higher expectations of 'kindness' (essentially subservience) placed upon them than men do in the workplace. A woman who is direct and assertive at work will be called 'bossy' or 'strident' and treated as if her behaviour is a problem. Whereas men can be outright aggressive without anyone raising an eyebrow

The expectation of kindness from women can do one.