Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Mixed sex toilets

87 replies

Wichit · 04/10/2022 01:15

I work for an organisation that employs about 250 people. We have high staff turnover and a lot of us work hybrid.

A few months ago all our toilets at work got changed to mixed sex. They are self contained individual cubicles. We didn't get consulted or anything, just got to work on Monday and every toilet had a joint man and woman sign.

About a month ago I went to use the loo, opened the door and there was a bloke already in there with his back to me. He turned around when I opened the door. He was semi undressed and I could clearly see his lad etc.

Lots of apologies, swift door close etc. I hadn't actually met him previously due to hybrid and high turnover.

It made me feel uncomfortable. I don't know the guy.

I raised with my line manager that this new toilet policy is potentially putting staff in tricky situations and he told me to take it to HR. Which I did and their response is that he probably forgot to close the door.

Well I mean yeah hopefully so, but nobody has any way of knowing that and anyway that is not the issue. The issue is that my employer should not be facilitating a set-up where such ambiguous encounters can happen. I think, anyway. AIBU?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Brefugee · 05/10/2022 09:17

They have introduced some mixed sex loos at my dc's school. I have advised my dd not to use them. I have advised my younger ds, who is in year 7 and feels intimidated by the older boys in the single sex loos, to use the mixed sex. So I have mixed feelings about them, but the bottom line is that the kids still have the choice of using single sex loos and I think that this is crucial in every environment.

so... girls have to be responsible for keeping your DS safe from the other boys? and girls have to responsible for keeping themselves safe? Stop passing the buck and say something.

Forgetting to lock the door? Give him the benefit of the doubt, OP, and ask HR to send a company wide email reminding people to close and lock the doors. If the same thing happens again shout, loudly, "FGS SHUT THE DOOR" so everyone knows? or contact HR again. Every time. Also you could get them to remind everyone to close lid before flushing. (but then people have to lift the lid to check they don't need to brush, so swings and roundabouts)

Personally? I have no issues around mixed sex if they are self contained units. Not so worried about sharing a washbasin although i can see how they are useful and discreet on occasions.

AlecTrevelyan006 · 05/10/2022 09:03

Man here :)

it is very common in mens toilets for cubicle doors not to be locked - especially if the bloke is simply using at as a urinal.

so I think some blokes just get into the habit of not locking the door behind them.

p.s. I don’t like mixed sex toilets either

jewishmum · 05/10/2022 08:57

Nobody 'forgets' to lock a public toilet cubicle door! This just doesn't happen.

lifeturnsonadime · 05/10/2022 08:50

This thread brings me to mind of something that happened last year when I was out with my family in Birmingham.

I went to the ladies toilets in Pret, (and they were single sex) , as I was washing my hands a Muslim lady wearing a beautiful dress came out of a cubical and asked me for help. Her period had started and she wanted to check if she'd bled in a noticeable way on her dress, she had.

I helped her as best I could to remove the stain.

This is what we lose by making toilets mixed sex. This isn't a frequent occurrence but it can and does happen, as as someone mentioned upthread, women miscarry on public toilets.

This woman wouldn't have been able to ask for help if it was a self contained cubical and she probably wouldn't have entered at all if it had been mixed sex.

Why on earth we would happily give this away to appease males I have no idea!

No benefit to women at all that I can see.

allboysherebutme · 04/10/2022 22:38

I don't like them and think they could be dangerous.

cbatopainttheshed · 04/10/2022 21:09

@Jedsnewstar hilarious you assume I'm naive, if anything the total opposite. I work with sexual offenders. You're naive if you think men aren't 'getting off' on a whole host of daily things. Mixed sex toilets are the least of your worries if you're going to try and find something perverse and assume that the majority of men get their kicks from leaving a loo door unlocked!

Iliveonahill · 04/10/2022 20:45

I was on a course last week which was held in a hotel that had mixed sex toilets. There was a main door that went into a small lobby, another door and then self contained cubicles. As I walked into the lobby part a man closely followed me in. I was immediately on my guard as I’ve never been in that situation before, I felt very vulnerable as I didn’t know him. The lobby was isolated. I was not happy.

Jedsnewstar · 04/10/2022 20:38

cbatopainttheshed · 04/10/2022 11:14

YABU.

The cubicles are self contained, the bloke in there was an idiot for not locking the door but that doesn't mean mixed toilets in general are bad.

We've had them at work for about 6 months now. I like them as the sink and mirror is in the cubicle so I can do my business completely in private.

How naive. Lots of men get off on this.

Lcb123 · 04/10/2022 20:35

I’d personally just think that was an accident, unless it’s happened more than once. I prefer the mixed sex cubicles - saves the big ladies queue and it’s fairer to everyone

DdraigGoch · 04/10/2022 20:26

I notice that the OP hasn't been back

cbatopainttheshed · 04/10/2022 17:27

334bu · 04/10/2022 15:32

How is the disabled toilet any different to the mixed sex toilet the OP has described?

The OP said individual cubicles not a separate room like a disabled toilet . Are there gaps at the top and bottom of the doors, does each individual cubicle have a sink and sanitary bin? If the only change is the signage, then the employer is putting their female staff at risk of voyeurism etc.

Op said 'self contained cubicles', which I read to mean contains the toilet and sink like a disabled toilet

KimberleyClark · 04/10/2022 16:09

mrsjohnnylawrence · 04/10/2022 12:12

I have never seen a shared area for a toilet on a train or plane @KimberleyClark
Have you? That would be a mixed sex toilets.

I think on trains they are single use toilets, which are not mixed sex, but single use. No shared area.

The toilet in my house is not mixed sex, it's single use; one at a time.

No shared area in the OP’s work toilet either.

autumn1610 · 04/10/2022 16:06

Firstly it would be good to clarify what the OP means by mixed sex toilets….
By the sounds of it it is a self contained toilet/sink etc however not totally clear

If as above then YABU it doesn’t affect you as this is the same for accessible toilets and no one has an issue with users having to share mixed in these. Total privacy apart from the guy purposely/or not leaving the door unlocked which is an entirely different issue.

if on the other had its individual cubicles not self contained and it’s shared hand washing facilities then YANBU everyone should have the right to feel safe in the toilets both female and male and those in between.

I’m all for 3 options exclusively male/exclusively female/non gendered plus accessible. Same for changing rooms. Some males won’t feel comfortable either sharing with women. I don’t agree with it being the female toilets that are typically converted and still having an exclusively male toilet

334bu · 04/10/2022 15:32

How is the disabled toilet any different to the mixed sex toilet the OP has described?

The OP said individual cubicles not a separate room like a disabled toilet . Are there gaps at the top and bottom of the doors, does each individual cubicle have a sink and sanitary bin? If the only change is the signage, then the employer is putting their female staff at risk of voyeurism etc.

bythere · 04/10/2022 15:16

Whatwouldscullydo · 04/10/2022 14:30

I think it shows just what mentality is behind mixed sex toilets.

They are painted as quicker, cleaner, safer, more inclusive, easier for dads etc

But when you think about it the same men who apparently piss all over the seats and make the mens so disgusting will be in the mixed.

The same men who apparently the children shouldn't be around in the mens are also in the mixed.

The same men so dangerous they bear up non comformjng males in the mens will be in the mixed.

Etc

So what makes anyone think its going to be cleaner amd safer ?

Why when men could keep their spaces clean so children can use them, is the answer to bring these same filthy men into the mixed ? I mean its done on purpose in that case surely? I mean unless they undergo a personality transplant when they go through the door effectively all men are doing is using women as behaviour management in mixed toilets. It makes no sense. Unless you realise that perhaps men are just lying to you and/or deliberately maintaining the situation where mens spaces are so unsafe/unclean as an excuse to either be able to override womens boundaries while we all cheer on "such a considerate dad" or to ensure women have nothing.

I mean in spaces where there's a separate room for urinals that leaves it so thaT men have the mens and men have the mixed and women have no where. We should not be encouraging this.

Why women allow themselves to be conned into believing that this is beneficial to women i don't know. I mean theoretically it would be possible to have these lovely enclosed clean spaces as a single sex provision? Women could petition/fight for that of they so desire?

Why haven't we up until now? Could it be the real reason mixed sex spaces are suddenly apparently cleaner /safer/more private is not because anywhere wants to create sone lovely environment in which both sexes can be in states of vulnerability in safety. The doors are floor to ceiling so you cant put a camera phone under the door. The reason cleaners pop by more often is a safety precaution and because mixed sex toilets frequently have urine in the seats. Is ther a reason why this is necessary/happening ? Have we forgotten why we had separate spaces to begin with.

Its bad enough males have basically fought to make it so women have no where we can go where males can't also follow us. But we have been manipulated into thinking its all such a wonderful idea and we become thankful for it. I dont get it.

Well, for what it's worth my DH will take our DD(4 at the end of the month) into either the men's or a family facility depending on what's available. He says he'd feel very infringing on women and girls privacy by going into theirs. We've told her she can use either since she's just a little girl but "mummy and daddy have to use the one for them."

Good post, by the way.

HermioneWeasley · 04/10/2022 14:58

Nobody at work should be exposed to a colleague’s genitals. HR need to think about how they are going to stop that happening

cbatopainttheshed · 04/10/2022 14:56

mrsjohnnylawrence · 04/10/2022 12:10

but @cbatopainttheshed what you describe are not mixed sex toilets, you describe single cubicle toilets and I am assuming from the post, perhaps wrongly? that there is a shared mixed sex area in the OP's case?

The op describes them as self contained cubicles which to me spends like they have the sink and toilet with the cubicle so I think that's exactly as I was thinking them to be.

ByTheGrace · 04/10/2022 14:53

Mixed feelings, but I prefer single sex. I used to clean the public toilets at the end of the day in a large store. They were single sex and whilst both sexes could be filthy, the mens were worse, stank of piss, the floors were sticky in front of the urinals and I had to wipe stuff off the walls that could have been semen or phlegm. The staff toilets weren't much better and the male staff constantly had to be given talks about it.

On the other hand, the self contained cubicles with sink and bin are quite convenient if you are using a Mooncup etc. But a few weeks ago I went into the unisex toilets in a large burger chain in Liverpool, there was piss all over the seat and the wall behind the toilet, it stank of male piss. There were a few toilets and they were all the same.

Thelnebriati · 04/10/2022 14:40

@Wichit Do all of the toilets contain a sanitary waste bin? If not, they aren't suitable for use by women. The bins are expensive so I don't see how they are saving any money.

Did they perform an equality impact assessment?

user278654 · 04/10/2022 14:37

I think that they are totally unsuitable and mixed sex toilets not cubicles leave all open to allegations and abuse. Not for me call me old fashioned stuck in the mud!

Whatwouldscullydo · 04/10/2022 14:30

bythere · 04/10/2022 14:10

@Whatwouldscullydo "Theres also a disturbing number of men who either decide to take their girls into the women's, or offload the care to women because the mens is apparently so disgusting and they refuse to take the kids in the mens toilets."

That's what I can't figure out, how someone can't see the separation is much more important from adults rather than from young children.

I think it shows just what mentality is behind mixed sex toilets.

They are painted as quicker, cleaner, safer, more inclusive, easier for dads etc

But when you think about it the same men who apparently piss all over the seats and make the mens so disgusting will be in the mixed.

The same men who apparently the children shouldn't be around in the mens are also in the mixed.

The same men so dangerous they bear up non comformjng males in the mens will be in the mixed.

Etc

So what makes anyone think its going to be cleaner amd safer ?

Why when men could keep their spaces clean so children can use them, is the answer to bring these same filthy men into the mixed ? I mean its done on purpose in that case surely? I mean unless they undergo a personality transplant when they go through the door effectively all men are doing is using women as behaviour management in mixed toilets. It makes no sense. Unless you realise that perhaps men are just lying to you and/or deliberately maintaining the situation where mens spaces are so unsafe/unclean as an excuse to either be able to override womens boundaries while we all cheer on "such a considerate dad" or to ensure women have nothing.

I mean in spaces where there's a separate room for urinals that leaves it so thaT men have the mens and men have the mixed and women have no where. We should not be encouraging this.

Why women allow themselves to be conned into believing that this is beneficial to women i don't know. I mean theoretically it would be possible to have these lovely enclosed clean spaces as a single sex provision? Women could petition/fight for that of they so desire?

Why haven't we up until now? Could it be the real reason mixed sex spaces are suddenly apparently cleaner /safer/more private is not because anywhere wants to create sone lovely environment in which both sexes can be in states of vulnerability in safety. The doors are floor to ceiling so you cant put a camera phone under the door. The reason cleaners pop by more often is a safety precaution and because mixed sex toilets frequently have urine in the seats. Is ther a reason why this is necessary/happening ? Have we forgotten why we had separate spaces to begin with.

Its bad enough males have basically fought to make it so women have no where we can go where males can't also follow us. But we have been manipulated into thinking its all such a wonderful idea and we become thankful for it. I dont get it.

ColonelCarter · 04/10/2022 14:17

cabansunset · 04/10/2022 12:58

I hate mixed sex toilets I feel vulnerable. I would use the disabled toilet if were you in this instance. I absolutely do it feel comfortable.

How is the disabled toilet any different to the mixed sex toilet the OP has described?

ColonelCarter · 04/10/2022 14:16

We have these at work and they're so much better than when we had single sex group toilets, much more private. One lock doesn't work as well as others though, so you do occasionally get walked in on, those who care about that don't use it.

bythere · 04/10/2022 14:10

@Whatwouldscullydo "Theres also a disturbing number of men who either decide to take their girls into the women's, or offload the care to women because the mens is apparently so disgusting and they refuse to take the kids in the mens toilets."

That's what I can't figure out, how someone can't see the separation is much more important from adults rather than from young children.

quietnightmare · 04/10/2022 13:10

It's a no from me when there is space for both male and female toilets. I don't fancy having a bad belly or cramping and having to rush out because a man is waiting. A woman I would feel comfortable to shout and say having problems and know she will understand if that makes sense

Swipe left for the next trending thread